M/S Surindera Malleables Private Limited And Another v. Small Industries Development Bank Of India

  
    
 

 !"

#$% &%'()(*+, 


  



  

      

   

     




!+ - .!/
/  .

- .!/
0 /.. 1%)%*$+ !1/2#(3%*&%14#)25#67&8'#$% 1$2%6%$($(*%1) !1 %%6%*&%1/(*927&8'#$% 1$2%1%)6*&%*$  #:%)2 (*&#3 2%6%$($(*%12#)#661#'2%&$2()';1$(<6;9*(*9$2% 1&%1  &#$%&   

  6#))%&  =5 
2(%  ;&('(#3  !#9()$1#$%7  #1(&#=#& 618(&(*9  63('%  2%36  $  $2%  1%)6*&%*$  1  $#>(*9  6))%))(*    $2% <1$9#9%&616%1$5 $2%6%$($(*%1) *?

@

7$2()';1$6#))%&$2% 33A(*91&%1+ B2;92  $2%1%  <(92$  =%  )<%  );=)$#*'%  (*  $2% '*$%*$(*$2#$$2%
(8(3;&9%/%*(1 (8()(*"7#1(&#=#& ';3&*$%*$%1$#(*$2%#663('#$(*;*&%1/%'$(*C $2% /%';1($(D#$(*  #*&  %'*)$1;'$(*    (*#*'(#3  ))%$)  #*& * 1'%<%*$  $2%/%';1($5*$%1%)$ '$7

=;$ 2#8(*9 1%9#1&$$2% #'$$2#$$2%;$)$#*&(*93#*#<;*$#9#(*)$$2%

  6%$($(*%1()8%1)@

'11%)7A%#1% $2%$%*$#$(8%8(%A $2#$$2()()# ($'#)% 1$2()';1$$(*8>%($)&()'1%$(*#15 :;1()&('$(*#*&&(1%'$$2%2#*&(*9E8%1 625)('#36))%))(*  ($))%';1%&#))%$)$$2%(*#*'(#3*)$($;$(*);*3%))$2% 6%$($(*%1)2A)($)
#*&);=<($#$(<%E=;*&6#5<%*$ 63#* )61#5%& 173()$*, 

 .%$ 

  1%+6))%))(*=%<#(*$#(*%& 1*% A%%>$%*#=3%$2%6%$($(*%1$);=<($$2%616)#3F *$2%#

(&#8($ (3%&=5/;1(*&%1/(*9223;A#3(#7 (1%'$1

6%$($(*%172%);92$$21%%A%%>)<1%$(<%$ (*&;$$2%6$%*$$(#3 =;5%1#*&

%1%&$6#5


3#')6%1<*$2(*$2%#'';*$2%#<;*$ &;%#9#(*)$$2%6%$($(*%1)7#)*$('%&(*$2%1&%1&#$%&? @

7()8%1
@'11%) .%#1*%&';*)%3 1$2%1%)6*&%*$E #*>6(*$%&;$$2#$$2% 6%$($(*%1)  2#&  *%8%1  #&2%1%&  $  $2%  )$#$%<%*$  <#&%  *  $2%(1  =%2#3

1%9#1&(*96#5<%*$ $2%#<;*$&;%#13(%12%2#&;*&%1$#>%*=% 1%

%=$)%'8%151(=;*#37
2#*&(9#12$2#$$2%%*$(1%3#*#<;*$)2#33=% '3%#1%&=5??

72A%8%17*$2(*9A#)6#(&
*)(&%1(*9$2%# 1%)#(& #'$;#3<#$1(G $2%'#)%#*&$2% '*&;'$ $2%6%$($(*%1)=%(*9*$=*# (&%7$2()';1$&%)*$ (*&#*5 1%#)*$(*$%1 %1%(*$2%61%)%*$6%$($(*7A2%1%$2%());%);92$$=% 1#()%&=5$2%6%$($(*%1)()1%9#1&(*9$2%<#$$%12#8(*9=%%*&%'(&%&=5 &&($(*#3
(8(3;&9%/%*(1 (8()(*"7#1(&#=#&A2('27#''1&(*9$ $2%<7  A#)  *$  '<6%$%*$  2%1%  =%(*9  *%  ;33  %*'2  :;&9<%*$  

%3#*9#*##*& *&21#1#&%)2  (92 
;1$ (* !H) %A%33%157 #

? 6161(%$#15'*'%1*%6=5($)161(%$12(1(8%%&2(/;1%)2 #=;#*& #*$2%18!H)/$#$% #*> *&(#70%&#5#6#3%< 1#*'27%331%#*& #*$2%17

,5&%1#=#&

7#9#(*)$$2%6%$($(*%1)7A2%1%#)!#&1#) (92
;1$(* 41'>(5#1#:#*& $2%1)8
2(% ;&('(#3 !#9()$1#$%7 /1(8(33(6;$2;170(1;&2;*#9#1 ()$1('$#*&$2%1)7

C"

(8(3"

=%(*9(*$2%(1 #8;17$2%3%9#3());%()3% $6%* 2%A1($6%$($(*()7#''1&(*9357&()<())%& #:%)2 (*&#3"

;&9% ;18(*&%1/(*92(33"

;&9% , 

 <> 2%$2%1)6%#>(*9H1%#)*%&+

%)H 2%$2%11%61$#=3%+

%)H