← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3440/2024disposed of

Mandeep Kumar v. Vijay Kumar And Others

2026-01-29Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal15 pages



       

   

   !"   

## $% $&' !" ("  )*           +"

",+-("!. /."(

##

"0" " !". /.""  1 222    

  3(

#(4 """ 4'(

###!

    !"  56 (!  !

 7"

 /  7"

  

  4' ( "   8#! 3"4 #. 1" # "("9 83:

 3( .  !6 "! (  " 45. " ( ( 

##  #!   "-

( "$(# . ;; " (" 9 $ : 56 !

  *  #5(   & " " 4'(

##!"/( #"  7((5 #; < ;  3((

##7(; < ;.(#67( -!"-6(=4 >#766"!/##6 "? "  !"'#  3( !"'# 7 46 "/ 4' -!" -6(   ! "    !"7(#(

##7" 6 ## @(('"( $##6-  "("(+"#+ !

." 54"6 *610*AA3 AA (""""" B( 6/(#C !(6(  ."( 6#6!" ((!"'#.   " #  7((. ( 

## ## 7  ( "     

 ! # # 6"/ & "( ".7("-!"-6(## (!## 4"!(" 3( 6/(#746 "/ 4' "   1 $&'  !". 7( #  "! (   #/6 (  6/(#4( 3( 77 4'-!"-6( (" /##6"   3( 

## 7 " 5  D/"! 0 #. 1" #4'(/##6"."!7(".(7""" ("( #"  "(""!3(

##7(5#(0 #.=(""  " '.(7( "0 #.D " 6"!.7("( "!  ! "/"#!(  E*1

;.   < ;  "- < <E+8 7"6" +#- A E7/"" (( ( 5 #  ("( 6#6 "/6( 6/(#4'"  1 E7/"" ((!( .(

##7;'"#   7 66   !

"6   4  6 ( "  6" # "# !7"5 7"6* . % "!(E 7/"" (  ".(!7#5#'"4   (& " " ( .(4! "!#' 4#  (  ""67"/"#'!

 

 *   1

"/"  (  6 /(# #  (  " 7" !    (  !  (    E 7 /"" (#E*76"6" 4'(

#### 7( ( # < *   1 7"  (  6 /(#   

"  "/ 7 " 6F " ; *  1 G E E "8!

'> #  "7"! 5  # 3( !(

   7    E 7 /""  ( ( "6"  !4"  ( !"'#7#   "!( # 6( ".##76 7""!    

           

     

  

     !

"#  $  $$#  

 "

"  !

"  !

 %&'((')'**( +,  %-.$$  / %  !  ! 

 



        - 0   !  "!

   " !

  !

"

   

   -.$ 1 

2    +"# ("" //     1.7(# (( ( 4      ( "(   6#6 "/6  (  6 /(# 4' "  1      1 .  H  !  !

. ( 83 7"

(##76!

 E! *< %I* ;; % "!( -"1 0  ! *  0 #?%! %   * .

.< A

>!% 4#' * .;;.

 %  +%- "6% ""6 +"  * . . % 3" " *A. % A - # *A. % 3# * A.A. A%  66"/ 4'(6" H !

.( " 

#7 """   E(/("

#"  #"( " A >"   # " ( 

##  4! ( ( 83 "" #'   (#  ( #   !    



"# F . 7(". 46  & "'    # ! (/64 .(!74  E( "("4  4! ((6(#!7#'<J'"(!(    (!

.(!""6 " (/4 "  0 "(" 4!((

##(##(/  "6   "6"(7(#(#.7((4! " !"' "!   >"   #  4! (  H  !

 H   ("6.!""6 "    "676"   "(".F 7" "#'7"

"("6 G " (" !.#"  # 4!((!

 "/ 4 4#'( *"(4! (& 6!( 0:4# F8 "(3 +,#

 4 

! 5 6  #    1 #77 .

 #7 0*8     & 6!  ( 8 "(

   !  # "  9:6.'

00'

8

 (;     . #"   # " ( "   " !

'( 4! (("##6#'(7"

 4'(

83 ("((!E.(76"  5## 7"5"7"*;<% "!( * % "!( < E(/ " ( 4!! 4'#"  #" ( " ; E(3 +,#

 4 

! 5 6 # 

  1 #77 .

 #7 0*8 . ( 0:4#  F 8 " 7  "6 (    6"  !

     '" #  6"#   & " " !"/( #" 3( 6(.(  (  7" ". ( " #  !  !6 

"#& "'7((7"   4'(0:4#- "!8 "

A E 7 # "!(!3(0:4# F8 "F! ( "#7  !  !6  "# & "'    3(   67 # 4#4" "   0 / 

 +,  

9$' ;   

  "  +  

, +

  ! !

  

/  +,    

    +

          

     ! "  +     (

'0 

<'  +    

 +  

 1 /  

 +  

      !

   =  

> 9$'0; != +

,7  

   >  , 6 

   

 

  (?  +

,       

 

  )  +

,   

 +,  '

 "  !/      

   

   

   #+

  &   "   

 

   

     

           /

" @ 1 

@ 10 ( /      ,= 

> 9$'0; 

      

     "

, +  

 !  #  <7

   

  

 !

 ,:   



 !  ,    !   "  3

!  ,



    

, "  

"  

  ) 

  A ! ,

 !

       ,'' ,

 ) 

  

 A     

   

"+, 





  * = 

> 9$'0; 

  

  +    

"     , +   &!     +

,         

  

    )  7   

   

 9 ;      , 

  

  



/



 "

9 

; "  

+

 



)

  ! ,   A      

   B   

  +

,/   +

  / , 

  ! , /@ ! 



  

+  ! ,

!  ,    &  +

, +  

?

   ) 7  



   + 

   

   "

     !+ 

 7     "   



 7   

 B



+ 



  "  /  +    

 "

"





C /$

!EF# 

 ,7G$

 ! E F #   

 , 7 GEH ( @3= 976;H:

>

 "  "+

A  C9@3=8; D I

   

  +

"

    "

   + ,  + " ,    + 

+  ,

 ,  

     ,

   

+ "

!)

 

!  "

  I !   "

!      

 &      "        "         ,



  "

!  

 

            D 3   ) +

 

 , +          "

 

 D  +      + !     ,    ,    ! D 8 / 

 /  G

 /  G8

H 67 0 9&E;;E &

+ , 967*'; D.    "

 A ,  "  B    ,I! ,

!

,  , 

    ,

 "

!  "J !       , 

 

    ,         ,

+"

!     "

)

  

   ,

   ,+,    

 " , -%+,

"" ,

+, ,





  +

  B

 ,       " 

 "     "+,  

/ /   +! , " +  ,     +      "      "    ,

 + 

  "     - 3 !  

  "        " ,+"

!D

<   ) 

 " + !

  E         &F#E!# G&F#E! # G8*1H670 *G8*0H E0(89&E;H ! ,   C96701*; D ,  , +       "  "

+  , +      

  "    

       +  ,    3 ,

  ,

   ++     6

 >"  

        + "

  "

!

"   + 

 /   + !          ,   "

  

 

3,    +   + 

+   :        , 

+        +  

+ 

  +  +, 

+   D / 

E =!

+ !9 0(;      

    +          

 ,

, + 

   

 " D    "  "+ 

  ,     !

        

  "-D     +     +,       "

   

 ,

  E = "



" 7 6

 !> G !> G8**H@3 0CG8*(H E 1((CG8*(H6

K(*0976;H



 "  + 

+

  



C9@3 88'

; D:

  +

,C /

  "

! / ,  +,  

 +

 ,  ! ,        

   ,        +

,+ ! 

 "   !   B        



+ 

#  ,   ,C)  +         ,      



 "

! 

J   

+ "     

    ,   

         )  ,   +

,C$  + +       



,  

,+  

 

 +,  



+ 

; 

+ , + "    "! ,  +

"D9   "

;  )    "   

 ,



"     /  , ! ,



  , )  +   



"   6  + 

 

  +  0  4 " L )    = " 1 K  $

(  "      "   

 ,

  C D)   ,

,    ,  !  +    

,   ' 

, .    

,   !    

  !

5     "    "

    

     !       +

  

 B           ,      ! +'

 !

' 

,   

" !

5

  "     

   B 

D 1 / 7    /

 /  7 E ! %

=!

 G7    /

 /  7 E ! %

 =!

 988;1#770*(C88#7797 ;88*C8

67>((H 7   C9#770**

 ; D        A   +

+

 ""

 , 

!





+

   , " 

D ( / = &  "

  ! $ 7   9/

; 9$; E G=&  "

 !$7  9/

;9$;E988(;#77 ((C 88( #77 97 ; ( H 

"         

  / ,

 7  C9#77((*

8; D8 3   , 

" 

  "   

   , +    !

 

   "  !  +  

 ,   

,  "  

  " $ 

,  "      !

  



,     



+   + "



     ,J    ' 

,  "     

+   + "  +,





 /      

     

,  " ,

 B   +, 

 9;

 

 J9

;  "      

J 9

;    

 #   '

 

,  "     ,  ,

 9;  "   

 ,

 

 

 "

,  

,+    J 9

;  "        

 

   ,

 !

,  



  ,

 ,+ +  

   J9

; "  B 

 

  , 

"!

,        J 9 !; !              

 

D * /     ! 6 ,   G    ! 6 ,  9 ;#770109 ;#7797 !;*19 ;#77 ; *H   7 

        

  +    

 C9#7701 

*; D* )         

   

/ ,

 

 "C $ 

, "9#

 "; 9;KB 

"  

 

  

       " B  

; E   " 9    "

;   

     !       +  

 "C ;E " "   J 9+; E     " 

     +

,

;: 

B %' 

, "94

 "; !;= " 

 "   

A    9!;E  9 <    

"; 9!

; E  B  

 9  "   

"!

,; /   

 ,

  

+   ,  9 ;9

;9 ; 9 !;/  ,

 

  ,   

 

!

   + "!

 

 

  

  

 + "

   ,    

;9+;9

;9!; 9!

; 

"   " 

      +

,   

B     9 <       

"; B 

D  /  #  ! % /

 6  7 E G #  ! % /

 6  7 E 9  ;   #77 1 0; #7797 !; 8C9 0;1#7797 ;*0 H 7  



C9#77 *

 ; D  ) 

 +



   

"          

  +

 ) A 

,

  "  

 

      +   

  



 B  )   #  *      M

6 8

9 + !

,D6 D; 

      + "

  D  D )  + 

"   

  D

 D     + 5    



   , +   D 8 ) 7  



    

!

        " B 

      

" 

  "       

"    

  N  , 7  

    +,  & " 7     ( ( <'   *  

<'

 /  

      6, 9 ;   7   

 

 



+, (', ' !

  

 

"        +,  ) +

  /



6,    

"

      

& B +,  &  +  !+  "     ,   " ,

  +   + 6,  " +( ,       

      

 +

  9;       )  7    



  , "   

   

9 ;                "   +

, 



B  

 B 

  "      

"      " !,  " )  7       

    01*

(<'1880

<'

  0   , 7  

#

 9 ;

+      

 9 

, 



;   D

 "D  / + !

  

 "

"





C D1 /    L

  "L

    +

,   

? ,  

  7 C' 1/=&  "

 !$7  9/

;9$;E/  + !C D )

   #  % *   L

 "L     

 # %  

 ' 

, ) 

 

  0





     ) & " 7   

  



"



*



    +   L

 "L   , 



 

 ! + 

 



 "   "  

 !

               

 )       '

 

,   ,  +       

  !+

 

   6

  "     

  

!

 !

""

       +

  

    +

 

!  ,  

  & " 7     !

 ( 

  

  L

 "L ( 

   

  

     ,   0



9  

  ,; "

 

   *



      DD

  "D DE  

D 9K #

; 1 ) >"    ,  +, 7 

#  !N /

/ 7 ,E    

 

#)7! !

#,9  !     "   +

,    + !

 

  !;   + !C D 6  ,   

 

+

   +,

  

  "   

  

"  !           

 



   ,  

    

 

 

 "   

 " 

       

  "

 

 

  !

     

   

 !+ 

D 10 /  

 ! > "  7   " 

  

 

? +

,

+ "+  

  

" + "     ''   

  !" ! B    D!  

"  !

!!

     , +     L

  "L   

 +  (



<'D 11/6,!

4

/   , "  

 9 ;      L

  "L        



 )

      

  !,   7  

"

   C D6     "   

  

   + !+  "     ,

  " ,   +  

+ ) 

  " +(,    

    



      D 1(/E

9 ;

+,

'



 ) +

   0 

<'         

<' +,  & " 7  7  "  

   



        B ! +

 ,  

    L

  "L     0



<'D  3(0:4# F8 "( (!

  " /"  (   3( 8 " # !4"5  ( ! F"  3( !

  "/" ( .("".   "    ! "#$%&'&()#"#* $(+($",- (  ( & &. /- ,0&  3( #" 83   ( ! " 

6   " "  

#'6(! # #"* .<<.

; % 07/".  A K  "#F 

   (#!* .;;.

 %E( "  (8 ". ( 7"H " 4 ! & "' 7("#!746   3( #  ! 7 #  ("" !  *

.<<.

; % 4 &."$(12+&# &  3( ! # F  7" "6(#'    *.;

.< A  ,,&#.(#,0()*&   - ( 

##  "7 !

  ( #6"!(! ".(7 #   (" 6( ( #/ "!(7"

.(!! !76" 5## "("#/!7"*. % "!( 3( #("6" 7 # .("".! *. ;. % 

#'6  ! # #"  9;:. (   ("67 # !*.. %



3,3)&%&."$(1&2+&# &  3( 6(  /  7 #   ( . ( 

##7##  "(#6 !'(/  "6 /"    " "! 3( 8 ". ("". !  

" "7"

* #5(H   "! #F  

("#(#. 3!!&)"#* 1 !   !

 7 #  4   " ( !       "6 ( ( ' 6 4' 7## (/  "6"("(#"

6#'.5 6 /7 ( " # # 7  (/- (4 0" )&1(5  

 ".(!

H    "6 

  *A#5(  ())"(*&+) +&$,  3(!""6 " (

##(/4 "   ( 0#(#6  ( "(   6#6 "/6  (  6 /(# 4' 

"/"  *( "/"    "  ( !

#  H (""( 6#6 "/6L 6 #/"46   /"'

' "" E (6(!(75"! "6 ( " G "(" !.(!

 # !""6 "  *A#5(

 E /7  ( 4/. ( !

    4' ( 8 " (( 834 #   "   -" 1 0   4'(

83 M( 4' (8 "  >!%"6  ' * .;;.

 %

"  NA K * .<<.

; %

 



#F  *.;

.< A% *.;

.< A

(6   8("6

#  7((" ("6 *.. %    " #MF  1("6 * . . % A +  "6 * . . % *A. . %



""6+" 

#  7((" ("6 *A. . % 3# * A.A. A% *<A. ;. A%

 3( # !

  (  4' ( 8 ". ("". !  *<A. ;. A% " 6   !  * A.A. A%   4'( 83.(4#!

!*.

.

 % 3( !  7 # 4 '4#  

( !    4' (

A  #" 83#67("N< " ##'3(#4#'

'(!7 # 4 "(7"



 3( "

#"

6#'    + 6

# .'.(###          

         (#3()-67 6869 /6"6 @((" 56%"  L%1 @(("" "4# L%1