← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24122/2015dismissed

Amit Gupta v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2015-12-11Mr. Justice S.C. Datta20 pages

 

    

  

 !

" "#$ %"#& '



        

   

() % *+,- (./01 -)() .--102      

  

 

  !

" #        !

$         % !

 

        

  !

"

 

       



  !   "  

"  #  $ %

&'

&&

 &(

 )     #

* "   +     &&,-&&.



 



 *  

  "   

   / 



   ( (& &( 1! -2  



&,

  #  &((0 1  

  452 

  &6 (. &(

1! -72  +#   &

+ 9 

 ::

  #    

  # 

+ 9 ; 132 ; "+#



  +#     

 1! -2  +  < 

     = >?

 ;

< > "  

"

   # + 

%

&07-

 %

( @ ? 9 %  ? >  ;   

"  +   ?

     #  = >?

 "

    + %

&,6 

, ('

 %

6(0 

,

   + - %

3:

&- :( -'

1%>





#2   # + 

      

 < >   

   #   

"  +   ?

 +

"

  #   "

   

  



     

  #   



     6( $

  

    #    +   

#  #



- 

 

       #     #  # +

   # *   

  # 9  #  

#   





<





  > * "



 &1

      

  

  A

& &( &  

    "     

 " ) +#   

 3  13  % &2 ;   

   



   "  

# ,( 0( $ "   

 "  

76 ,& $ * "           "            

  "   #  "   % >

 # 1%>   

 

 "        



&,

     B 

   * 

    

'0,



.

& &( & 1! -&2 "  

   "+#   



 

"  # 

 

 > ' (,&-:

"  

+ #+ +#   

 

  B 

 #  

 

 

  "   " 

#





*          

  % >

 #      

 

   +#    " 



     - +? 



&,102

   

  3! 3   :

  '

/  

  

 #

  



 3! 3   

 1! -'2 ?   - +?

     



  ( (& &( 1! -2  +   

 1! -2       # 





&.

   +   

  # :

  & "  +  

  &6 (. &(

1! -72 =  "  *  

 

    ; 

     #         "



 &1

   ; 

             

 

" #   = >?



 < > *     



  #   6( $ 

# + 76 ,& $   

 " 

 +    +    

  



      

   + "

#   

     



# #

 

"

) = " 

 

#  

 *    

 #

  "   

   

  +#     :

)

*  + "

#   +#     "

 

  #    "  B # 

   

  

     

  

   

 #   



&,

   "  *      +#

 

        

<  * 

"    +#

 

     "

 +   

 



&,

   "    & '

!$%%%%()*  

  

     

+ ,  ,  ,   -

    



     ,     

    

             ,  

   



             .

    

,    

 -

                   

  

     

!

     

)" #   -    

 -     

        

        

)$ #   ,      

 -  

)"



 



,  ,      -           



, 

,        

 

      ,               -

    -    

  

  

)/        -            -

  , ,

       

    



  -   -

  -       

)0 *     





          

     1   

,  

  

            .



  1 

 ,

- ,         

     1   

     

  ,       

              

-      



    

)2 #     



      +    

          

    

- 

 -



 &

)0

34   &5    

,&

"

)  '    

6       

      

 -   7 



,   ,          -  8 ) '   

6  

( )      8 )      

     



8 )       8 )-       

    8 )-             

   .

= C+



   

 &   '()*+ ' $+%,%-)..

#--+. !##  !  





&,

&.



      +) 

  

           :

'09  : - 

     -

+       ,

 

 







      

;&   - 



 



       

,       

 -          

 

 

    





,

/

 <     =    

 

"2 ">>$  "

# 4    <  .

    

=    

"2 ">>$  4  

     

    -

  

   

 4

    

1

  

         #    

 

  





  

 34   ))- 

"2

">>$ ,    -

  9"    >2                

 

 $ *-   

"? ">>$  ,

         

"2)$    

 

"?  

& & -     

 

"2)"  

/ #,    :   @       

 

            

   

  

"2)$

">>$     

""2 @  * #  :   @       

                    

A -        "0B

,

">>C  :

- ,    :   @               

  -

    

-      D



              

 - 

# : @  - 

 

 ,    

  -

         



 

  

 

, ,   

       

  "2)$   +                    

   

"2)0 ">>$ 

 



6 ; 

      

   ? 



    

      

 

 

        "   



 < >  "         "

    

          A #          "   % :>

 #  

   "   

+   )    "  

  

#

 

 3!  12 



&,

    #         #   

   " 



 # "  B  "

 "  

  B 

 #

 # < >  "       "     %>

 +    "        

   +#  "    

   "  

 #  "  B < >   

   "  ?+

  "

  ;  %>

   #  B 

 #      

 

       "   %>



 " +   )    "  

   

  /   



# 

 

 

        

  %>



    

 

  "

  #

 

    +

 # 

    

 



          

B *    "

 +   

 

      -)..%1%)%%*2:

'$  #   .



    

  



    <

    =   

 

"2 ">>$ # 







        

                                  

 

 -     -  

"2

">>$ /"

# 4  < =,<  

 =  <

 

 =  4    

      

      E            4   

,  -     

- 1

   

   4          

   -      

 

# 

, E     -  &    4      



4  *   , 34    

"2   < =

   <



 = A <  

 = # 

-        -   E       



           

     - /$ F   

      

   4      -      

-  -

    /C 

     

          -       ">>$     -      

<F       

=  

      4 

   ,    , 1 





-  

   

  

 *             

4      

     4   *  

 



 

    



 

  

,      -  ">>$ # +    

 

       

   



                  

  *     

 

, 

 





 



     

   

  ,    

#

D 3

 @  ,   

 

9)"),)-,) )4 

* ">>$ ,D 3

  , CC0 

0>

      ,    -   

 



     

 ,  , 

,    

      



        

 A         

 

#

  <D  3

 

@    %   )@      

  @ , ">>/)       <@   

-

   "G ,">>/ #  

 



    

  #   

     

#



   @  )"  



@   

*   

  

      

 @    D E ) @    

 , CC0, 



   

1  -   

 

    4 

   

 #    

   < 

= @  )

       0   

   

     

  ; H#   

 





  

      

   A





 ""I   -  

 >I  

   

  .

      -

H // G          

-   

<

   =        

  #

   



     





 

  A





 



    -    

   A





#   

 



     >  I      







   ,

  

     <   = <  = 

-     

/0 @  ** @   

 

     -   

        #

 -     ,E#* , E#A:#  * ,  E   * ,  :

-  *   

* - * ,

*   9>,  

 E#A:#

,

 

     

    ""I   - 

>I :

- ,

 <   =     9>)> 

 



    

   >I   - 

"0,>>>I D

        

  

-



,   

 

    

  #



   



   9"    

  

   





  

   

     

 

 

   

# @   

- 

 

  



-

 0$

  >2 @   

  ; HJ

 

 1  





  - 

     

              

 

  

 

 

 



=  H /2 D    -            

     

,  

  

   

 

     -  ">>$ ,  -        

    

    

 

        A 



 

  

    <    =

  

"2  ">>$    #,              

- 

   

  

 

    

 ,    -       

,  1

    

 ,       

,  

   -    -

      *      

  

,

  

 

  





 

 

0/

  

 

 $)   

 7  





  -

-       

  

,@ 

      

  

- 

    

 , @  7 

KD -

3

7 KD L)">>$?@@90M,

   ; H" #   &7 , , 

    



   





 -     

  

  

  4 





 

    

!

 

     

,



   

       



 7 

  

 

 

     

4 

 -

   @  + 

, 

  

    

 #



, ,   

  

 H /C #    

    

 4    - 

  

 

       *       ,   

,   

      

          

 /"I

  

   

# 

 ,     

  



     

   

"2 )$   

 : @  E  

  

 ,



 



    - ,

   

  

- 

    @  

  

 -

-      0? 

 

   

             F 34   ))-,<   

=  

         

    34   ))-,, 

-  

  

 

   

, 

"

    

   

   



,



  -      

    







 ""I  >I #   -   

 



      

             

 

 

  4

     

J 

,    9"

>2    

   4

  1  



   - 

   

     

 

 <   

=  , 

  @   -      

  34   ))- 

"2 



 



       ,

    

    

      -  

"2 ">>$ #

   

  -           

  ,



      

#





  



#        

 , ,

 





  -         -   4   34   

  "2       -                      

      

/  - 

      - 

    ">>$          - -    

   ,

   

  -

  -

 

@  

* 

  0C* 3

F  -   

KD L)">>"$@@ ?M,@ , 

4   4   

    

 

   -

#

  -  4        

 -





   

  4   

# @  

 

     

"2        3

       

  

-

    

  

    

   

  

 



   

 

 =

 

 ,



  

   ,    



 +   

 &        

    

 

     

  

  

#       

-    -       ">>$         

- 

   

 #,  



 + 

2>   ,   

#  , , 



    ,  

       



   -



 

,     3

-  @  7  -  E L)">>/ @@0$CM,@   

 

+              -  

       

      .      .

 

           

-  

  + 



, @ 

  ; H#          

 

     



 

 "0/9I

 & -          

      9G

 22I  ,  #  ,E       

    

  

       

 F

,    +     ,

@ 3 

   





4    

 0>>I,

   



  /9 2$?

I              .

  

H * "

  *

 

    " 

  

   

 #

        "  

  "   )

   " 

"  

 

 * "



 





&.

   



 



 



&,102

    

  + 



&.

A  



    +#   A    "

" =

   / 

      ? 

     / #  +#    " +#  = C+



  ,%-)..1%)%%*2

        :)

   

 

#    "  

 

 #   

   "  

 # "  B     3!  1+212 



&,

         #  

       

   

 # A #

 

  # +

 

            "  +    



+?       +  #

* "

  *

  # 

 #

#    

 9 "#& '

3 &0 4 )

.