Union Of India And Others v. No 6361403 A Ex Havildar Pritam Chand And Another
!"#$
!
" # ## $
!
" # # $ # '
&()* #+ ,- . / 0$
0 ,% 1 ## $
%
", ',,
3 % /,% ,
& /%) , ' &,&&&4 5 6
7
8/ %
& () , 0 & .& " (
0 &6, ,00& ," (
08/3,() , 0 . ,' & ( 0 )%
3
003& &'()&*
&'+,-.)/0 9 &.)+ $% 6
%%0)8
: :4; && ,'&35
:<; ",/ 3 00& + $% 54 :<< & '5<) ;. , &5&) + /,3 & ,'&
.$35 , .& ,'. + / && ( 0 )=#> > "
/ ,&', && ( 0 )3
&?5@0 (), 0 #& 0A& 5 ", & ( 0 ) 0. 0 . , 3
9&(),$.% , )+ &&&& 5;/
,'
&,,
%& ( 0 )3 , ( (0 ( ''+&() . 0 ) + 0 ''' +&/ 0&/(, 0 & .& " (
0 &/ 3,() , ,00 ', &9 &", &/(. 003&+ &&&&4 5",% +%, & & 7&,
!"
#
$ #
%
& ' ( ) )*
+,
- .
/ 0*
2*
(
3
)
,2.)4 )
!+#
5
6 ; 0 ''' +&., && %
&
,6
%8/(),0 &.& " (
0 &/, % & , 0&,'
,
3 %
(, $ /23-3/'34 .2 (564 .)-( 4 A%& '.B +&9 &
,% 3 % /
0
&.
'3,, ,(00. )& +
)..(,& %
0/( % , ( ' 00& ,.)/& % , 0
'/ , (.
' &/ ..(,.( & (0 ,. /,, ..
'
&&/), %% % /,
% . , ( '
(0( , ' 0( '
(0(.''+&( ( (0. 0 ) + /,
D &/./,% %0 , ,9 &'. &&(), =(0%7$ / 0&
/%& ", 0+ %'%, , & +& 7& , 7* %
8
9 :;<
1
#
=
0
) 3
*
7+ >
*
?1..:0 @$; :;*
.
A0 ",0 :;B :;2 :
;
*
:0 7; :;.
A0 :;B :;.
C
C
A :;B :;.
?
D E
A :;BF :;. D E
) 1.. >G D :D
;
H >=
9 G
3
> @ + 7
$ I
< +& '6 8,(+7&% %0 / , ',% &0)&0/,3, & ( 0 )(. 0&
)..(,.( & (0 ,. / &3, , , 7 @ +/ , / , ', )
, & (0& ..( &( +0 &&.,.)/( ),
D &(
&,( & ( 0 )%
E ,0
/,
. & ( 0 )%
) ..(,.( & (0 ,. /3,(. 0& 3 ,& ( 0 ) D .@./( .% +0) D &0 . , #& 0 A&/ , & &0) %
',, & && ( 0 )( ' ( (0 (.
'''+&(). 0 ) + ", &&0 (.
9 &(),=
0
) 3
*
7+ > *
?1..:0 @$; : ,./, ',,
%
.%
&
,
&%,) 0 &. 0,0, )..(, & (0 ,. &/ % 00)3, , ',
(.
' 00&/, &( , (.
'( 3 , )& #+/, ',,
, 0 , %
.% / , 3, ) & , / ,
( 0)/ ,() , & ,%%
' & 8
)& /, (%
.&( 0,
& ' + ..( , & (0 ,. .% +0)/,
%+ ', &3. D (
%8+
, &/( & ,.%0)/ &
/, &
.
,'&/, /,0 . (. 0& +& ( 0 )%
#+/00,
& .
& , + () , &/(0 0) F&/,
&0 '3,,,
)& +
, &/ 0D
. 0 ) + &1 , . ( ' ''+& () ( ( (0. 0 ) +
A, .)/,
(. 0 , , % %06 8,), (& 0& ( 0 )%
, &/( 0) * 8, .% , & . 0 )
+ / . (.
'&&(),#& 0 A& +
, ( ' ( 3 , & 3, , ,3+/(. 0 &&() & ', .
(. & (8 ) , & , / .) 0
( 0)(. 0 &&(),#& 0A&/
. . 0 ) + ( ( (0. 0 ) + /,, .( ' ' 0&
,/ ,.& 0% ,0& ,,& 0&
,+( && .& 07.
, &( .&/,
% , (.
' & + /,
/,
.3 00 (&.&,+ & ' + /) ,
6
%8/,#& 0A& & ,
0 '
#+/ 0 &0&
%/, . &) ,#& 0A&003,'
&0 0 &&3 $,%
,GH &#& 06# 0 )
8/IG
0. * H 0 %0 G
5 ",/ , ( 3&.
&3,, .
,(+% %0 /3,,, . . ,% ,.)/,
%0 .
).& 07.
( '.&+
, ,0,/,
(.&&(
. & ( ' , . &1 3,, . (. %% &&,, && 3 &. '#+/
0 D &(&.
&/., , &/3,,,
0 7
, % ,& / &1,
, / , % /,
% , 00. ,% B ' %0/ +
, +
() , . . 0 ) + /3,() /, $ .) 0 &,,
,& ( ,3 0, & ' + ,.) &
,3 ( (0(.''+&(), & . 0 ) +
&& / 0 D &(',&., & /3,,,#& 0A&/& & 00)%&.B & 0& + & 0,B/% 00)%%
', &+ ,& /, ',.%0). .& 0 , / ,
+ 0 ' , (0B , '
/ 3,.
/,,& (. &#+/ , & .%0). 0
0 0)/,() .)(. 0 &&D %
,/,
( ,%% . B
%0/,3 ' 0( 3& '
. 0 ) + ( ( ' ( (0(.
'''+& ()%. . 0 ) + $ 0)/ ,
%.%0)& , , '%% . B '%0/,
(), #& 0A& &/0& 0
/,,, &. & )& /( ), &&. & %, ( ', . )%
0 ,.)/ +)
0 0),
( +& 1 % , / ', . 0 ) + /( 3 0& 00) 0&300 0
(),#& 0A&/, + %
( (. & . +
0 '
3,() ,3 0&(& 0& ( 0 )%
; 3+/ 3 , & &+ , $ & (7 ', ,% / (.&&(), 0 .& 0(& , &'&0+ 7%'%, , .% &&/ 7&, *
JK ? E
JJJ6
4 & ',& +0 ,, ., %% . B '%0, (..& .
,% %0 6
%8&0&(), =(0%7$ 0&
(),#& 0 A&/, .& 3, ,,3+/& & ( &,%
/(. & ,.)/& &.B %0 .
)
/ , &0 03 9 &'. 6
%8 , ,() , %
.% ,, ', && 3 0 + / &(+ (0) &3&+
, ", ', , &%
.%
( (0( ,
0&+ & ( , &%
.%
(. , % 3+/ , & + & && '& ,'
'
+
, /,' 0) ( ', &%
.% /( 00)0 & &
)0 ,#& 0A&/ '' 0 , &+
, '/ , ', .%0). , (0B ,
'
0
, 6 8/ 3,() .) (.
+0&,,
',& ,.)%
0/ (. &. & 0' . 0), )#+/ ,() 3 0 D &( & ,.& 0% /, ,& ( 300.& ,3 ' 0& &(. ,''+&() (. ( (0. 0 )
+
< 3+/& '% 6
%8/& 0 , ,
( && )%& . &
,+ (
&&,7 6
%8 &0)/
+ & ( ,%
.% 6
%8, ( 0&(),% /,() /,
$
&' + 3 ',',% ,.& 0 (&/ 7&6
%8$
%
0)/,() & (
&,
% 00 .& /( ,() ,
,&
( &( 0 & 0' . 0), )$ 0)/ &(&0& .
. 0 ) + && / &(&0& ( ( (0(.
'''+&() . 0 ) + (),%
E ,/
.
,9 &'. &&(), %7$ / 0&
!"C # $ % & '
3,
/&0 .&, 7 /,,(
'/,, (. &3& , &
0 0)0 ,
& & (0 ', (. + & , % , B ' D , %%
( '.& , +
:
+ ,3
, &0 03 .&
+& 6
%8.B , &&0 ( 7% 0 03
./,() /,7% 0 03 ./ .& +&
%80 .B ,,
& &( +
, & %
0 &/ / / 0 0 , &/,
) . B,' ', &3.
.&,
& / &,/ , 00 .%0. / %0 ,
& /( % +,(/ )/&0) &0, ",/ , ' ' , ( , %%
/ .
,+& 6
%8 &&()," (
0
&/0 &
. ) 00'0 ) & &(
%,0& 6/&*
-03- .2 (564 .)-( .,/, $ . ,3 %
&3 ,( +
(+/, . & .
& ", .% &&/ %
&(),0 &" (
0 &/ . & & .& 5 &0 '3 ,00% '%%0 8/ )
## $ $ #
., . 53(534:3&+6/,;-3&4./30
34;.
53(53- -3:.-(&<*3
34;.