High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23241/2016dismissed

Sangita v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2020-03-05Mr. Justice B.S. Walia7 pages

! "!#$%$&'( )%*&+$ ,! $ $&!- .!-%/% * ! -0&&"-% ,!%1&"!& %

-!%!& ' )-!!12*&23"4# ! - 5!1! $ $&!- )-"62& 7$4!"$3"4# ! - 5!-!%1&"!& % 888 : -0!-$& 5!1! $ $&/&"!-- $#;! 5! &% $ / $& &"$$% - 5!$%%/&#! 7-$ #!- $--$ -%! $&+%$"!# $& 5! -!%1&"!& %$&11$& $&+ 5!1! $ $&!-%!&$! ;%%.1% $&% !"

;%%< 1% % 5! 1! $ $&!- 7% /;;0 !;$+$=;! - 11$& 6!&

;%%<1% $&4$!7 1;$#0>+/$"!;$&!%&&!?/-!> " !" 9: -$!

# % 5!#%!;!"$&+ 5! $;$&+ 5!1! $ $&-! 5 & &&/&#!6!& 7% 6"! =0 5! 5$!

)$&$% !-3 -0& & @ @ 5 &!6!6=!- !#5 6$;075%!6$&$6/6#-!% ;&" 5" =!!& #A/$-!"3 7/;" =! +$4!& !61;06!& +$&% ;%%< &"

;%%.1% %%1!-A/;$ $# $&1%%!%%!"=0 5! 6!6=!- 5!;&" /% !!% 6$;0 & /- 5!-&#! 5! %$" &&/&#!6!& 3 5! 1! $ $&!- %/=6$ !" 11;$# $& -6 &&!?/-! > & ( 6!& $&$&+ 5!- A/;$ $# $&%%/&"!-'<

" #

9: B!-&!"#/&%!;#& !&"% 5 %1!-"!#$%$& 2!&1/-%/& 1-1%; > &&/&#!6!& 5! 5$!

)$&$% !-3 -0&3 #&"$" !% 75 7!-! 6 -$# - C 7!-! =! -!+/;-$D!" !- #61;! $&+ -$&$&+ #/-%! =! %1&%-!" =0 -4;$ 7!- 61&0 -$4 ! B$6$ !" B75!-!%#&"$" !%757!-!+-"/ !%7!-! =!#&%$"!-!" - 11$& 6!& %B &"%1!-;$#0

B3&;0 5%!;&"/% !!% 757!-!"6$ !"$& =/ $;!" #61;! ! 5!#/-%!7$ 5$& 5! $6!

-6!%1!- 5!$&% -/# $&% 5! !1- 6!& 7/;"=!#&%$"!-!" - 5!1% !&> !;1!-! #&" ;%%.# !+-0!;!4& !? -# 5! "!#$%$&$&&&!?/-!> $%-!1-"/#!"%/&"!-'< $ %%& '( " ')) *(

!!'

" ' ,' ,(

-'. "

, # ' '(* (. "

# /%&0' '(

' 1 , '

,'"

2 ,

" ' # ) ,'+!

* 454

* ,'( 0 ,

!'' ".#%%&6 $2

"'(

"+ " ' .()

','+!

454,'(

+ ) + !

(, ' ') 454

+ '( " .

,' "

" )' +!

'#+ )' !' ') % '7

849 , *'# .# !

, (

9: 9: 5!!1/ 0 66$%%$&!- 5!#&#!-&!"$% -$# 1-!1-!" ;$% #&"$" !%757!-! =!

!-!"11$& 6!& &"$&#;/"!" 5!&6! 5!1! $ $&!-$&;$% #&"$" !%757!-! =!

!-!"11$& 6!& % B &##/& 5!-=!$&++-"/ !$! &&!?/-!> 75!-!% %1!-11;$# $& -6-$+$&; 75$#55%=!!&%57&=0;!-&!"#/&%!;

- 5! -!%1&"!& %3 5! 1! $ $&!- 5" !& !-!" 5!- A/;$ $# $& % 53

C &" 11!-!" % 0!- & $;/-! 5! 1! $ $&!- %/=6$ 1- =!$&++-"/ !3 5!1! $ $&!-7%

!-!"11$& 6!& %!& 4$"! ;! !- )!6 (> 5>

B> > <@>.; " !" $!&&!?/-!> 9(: 7/;"=!-!;!4& 6!& $&5!-! 5 ;!-&!"#/&%!; - 5! -!%1&"!& %5%#&#!"!" 5 $&#%! #&"$" !%757!-! 5- C 1%%3;;%/#5#&"$" !%&6!%7!-!$&#;/"!"$& 5!;$% #&"$" !%75 7!-! =!+$4!&11$& 6!& %%%$% & B$&!6&7$ 5 5!#&"$ $& 5 5!$-%!-4$#!%7/;"=!-!+/;-$D!"&;0& 5!$-%/##!%% /;#61;! $& B!-&!"#/&%!; - 5!-!%1&"!& %#& !&"% 5 5!1! $ $&!-& =!$&+

!-!"11$& 6!& %!&E$&!"%!-4$#!& 75!-! !- %5!%/=6$ !"&11;$# $&" !"@@ -!A/!% $&+ -1!-6$%%$& #& $&/!% /"0$& 5! #/-%!%%5!7%"$&+ =!

-!E$&$&+$& 5!!1- 6!& &"7& !" #& $&/!5!-% /"0%$ 7%5!- $&;0!- 5! -!A/!% 7% ##!1 !" 4$"! ;! !- " !" F@ 7/;" ;% =! -!;!4& 6!& $&5!-! 5 &! 5!#&"$ $&% -##!1 $&+ 5!-!A/!% 7% 5 5!1!-6$%%$&7/;"& #& !-&0"$-!# -$&"$-!# #&%!& 5!!1- 6!& --!#+&$ $& 5!!?6$& $&>A/;$ $# $&5 #10 5!11;$# $&%7!;;% 5!1!-6$%%$&+-& !"-! 2!&&-!#-"

9: : B!-&!"#/&%!; - 5!-!%1&"!& %#& !&"% 5 5!1! $ $&!- #& $&/!"5!-% /"0$& 5! #/-%!&"#61;! !" 5!%6!$& 5!0!- (&"-!E$&!" 5!"!1- 6!& !-54$&+4$;!"% /"0;!4!$&/;0 (%$&#! #/-%!7%75;! $6!#/-%!B!-&!"#/&%!; /- 5!- #& !&"% 5 $ $%&;0 !-A/;$ 0$&+5!- 5 5!1! $ $&!-&!0!- 5!-!

!- 6"! -!A/!% 4$"! &&!?/-! > " !" F

- #&%$"!- $& 5!-&6! -11$& 6!& & ;%%<1% &" 5 $& 5! #$-#/6% &#!%$ 7%#;!- 5 5!-!%&750 5!1! $ $&!-"$"& +$ ! #;$6 - 11$& 6!& & ;%%< 1% 5! $6! =!$&+

!-!"

;%%<.11$& 6!& %!&37% 5 %5!7& !" #61;! !5!-

/-%!&"7/;"& 54!=!!&=;! #61;! ! 5!%6!35"%5!6"! -!A/!% - 11$& 6!& & ;%% 1% %$&#! $& 5 !4!& /;$ 0 %5! 7/;" 54! =!!& -!A/$-!" 2! "6$%%$& $& #/-%! 75$#5 $% - "/- $& 70!-%&"7/;" 5!-!

-!& 54!=!!&=;! #61;! ! 5!- /-%! B!-&!" #/&%!; #& !&"% 5 1!-/%; 5! -!1-!%!& $&3&&!?/-!>-!4!;%=!0&"&$ "/= 5 $ $%& 5!% &" 5!1! $ $&!- 5 %5!7%& 7-! !;$+$=$;$ 0 5&"

C#;%%#&"$" !% =!

!-!"11$& 6!& ;%%<1% %$& 5! 11;$# $&3&&!?/-!> 5!1! $ $&!-5%% !" 5 %5!7%&!4!-+$4!& & 11- /&$ 0 - 11$& 6!& +$&% ;%%< 1% =/ %5! &!4!- 6!& $&!"$& 5!11;$# $&3&&!?/-!> 5 %5!7%& 7-! 5! %$"1%$ $&!%1!#$;;0$& 5!=#2+-/&" 5! # 5 %5!7%7-! 5 5! E= 7% =! 1-4$"!" /% !!% 6$;$!% 75%! ;&" 5" =!!& #A/$-!" $& !-6% &&/&#!6!& 5! 5$!

)$&$% !-3 =!%$"!% G 6!6=!-% "$

!-!& 6$;$!% ;&"/% !!% 5!4$;;+! 5!1! $ $&!- $ %!;

757!-! 5- C#;%%1%%7!-!11$& !"%%%$% & B$&!6& &"7!-!"6$ !"$& /-%!%+$&% % $1!&"75$#57%1$" 5!6

9(: &"&%/##!%% /;#61;! $& 5!$- #/-%!3 5!07!-!-!+/;-$D!"$& %!-4$#! 9@: 54! #&%$"!-!" 5! %/=6$%%$&% ;!-&!" #/&%!; - 5! 1- $!%%7!;;% 5!-!#-" 9F: "6$ !";03 5! &6! 5! 1! $ $&!- /+5 54! =!!& $&#;/"!" $& 5! ;$% #&"$" !% 75 7!-! 5 - C #;%% 1%% &" ##-"$&+;03 5! 1! $ $&!- /+5 54! =!!&

!-!" 11$& 6!& % %%$% & B$&!6&$! ;%%<1% &"-!+/;-$D!"=! $& #/-%!$&75$#5%5!7%-!A/$-!" 2!"6$%%$&&=!$&++$4!&&

!- 11$& 6!& % %%$% & B$&!6& $& !-6% "!#$%$&3 &&!?/-! >

7!4!-3 # % 5!#%!-!4!; 5 5!1! $ $&!-%/=6$ !"&11;$# $&

-11$& 6!& 3&&!?/-!> - 5!1% ;!-275$;!6!& $&$&+ 5 %5!7% 5&" C#;%%1%%&"5";%11!-!"$& $-% 0!- "/= 3 5!!1/ 0 66$%%$&!- 5!#&#!-&!"$% -$# 1-!1-!" ;$% &"$&#;/"!" 5!&6! 5!1! $ $&!-$&;$% #&"$" !%757!-! =!

!-!"11$& 6!& %B &##/& 5!-=!$&++-"/ !$! &&!?/-!> 75!-!%%1!-11;$# $& -6-$+$&; 75$#55%=!!& %57&=0;!-&!"#/&%!; - 5!-!%1&"!& %3 5!1! $ $&!-5"!& !-!"5!- A/;$ $# $&% 53 C&" 11!-!" % 0!- 7!4!-3& $;/-! 5! 1! $ $&!- %/=6$ 1- =!$&+ +-"/ !3 5! 1! $ $&!- 7%

!-!" 11$& 6!& % !& 4$"! ;! !- )!6 (> 5>

B> > <@>.; " !" $! &&!?/-! > 5!1! $ $&!-E$&!"%!&& 75!-! !-&@@ %5! %/=6$ !" & 11;$# $& -1!-6$%%$& #& $&/!5!- /-%! !-6$%%$&7%+-& !" 5!1! $ $&!-& F@ &"%5!1-#!!"!" & ;!4! - 1!-$" #;%! &! 0!- $& -"!- #61;! ! 5!

/-%! /-$&+ 5$% !& $-! 1!-$"3 %5! 6$& $&!" % $# %$;!&#! 7$ 5

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

!-!"E=%1!&3 5!1! $ $&!- #/;"& =!"6$ !"$& 4!& 5!-7$%! 5!1! $ $&!- 2;!4! - #61;! $&+5!- #/-%!&"$ $%&;0 !-#61;! $&+%$"#/-%! 5

9@: %5!6"!#;$6 -#;%%1% &#!54$&+##!1 !" 5!1% !&$& 5!#$-#/6% &#!%%& !"=4!3$ 7%& 1!& 5!1! $ $&!- 54! 6"!#;$6 -11$& 6!& & ;%%1% : ##-"$&+;03 " & $&" &0 6!-$ $& 5! 7-$ 1! $ $& 7--& $&+ $& !- !-!&#! 7$ 5 5! "!#$%$& 5! -!%1&"!& % -!

/%$&+ 11$& 6!& 5!1! $ $&!-+$&% ;%%1% 5!7-$ 1! $ $&$% =!-!

6!-$ &"$%##-"$&+;0"$%6$%%!"

6$ 5! 5!-%1!2$&+>-!%&!"' !%> 5! 5!--!1- =;! ' !%>