Lalit Goel & ANR. v. Jai Singh
!"#$%&'
*+## , )%&'
(
*+## , )%&'
!"#$%&'
( !"
#$%&' "()*(+,!'"'-# ,++& "'-# ,++&.) -$" ,"))"(
# /
( ''" 2) ".-"0/ )%3 ./
$""$ 4 -"0/ )4,$ 01'.(
"$ 0
" " /"
/
01 " !"#$ " . & $"'/)
5 ()
$ 0
") "& , "#& $"') " 6 '
"#6788
,$
$ 0
") 01" / "!"#$
5"#
'.(
" " / $ )) 0 4 ') 4 ,$
"& , "# & $"') ,/) 0 4
4 '& "
"( )(
)
( '
/(01 % # &")) 9$
.
"
$"'8 .()1
"#
.
"
% $ )# ,"
$ ." 2$ '
0 '5
.
"" !
'
"
$ " .
( ) ,5
0/ :
%$
.3 ./ 5/ '$ . $"' ) " ; .
,$") %< )"
= )8 ( ,$") "&"#6 '
"#6788 $)1% #)"# )1
$"#$(
'
.0 $" $"
$". /) %$ )),
/
./) "() " /"
$" "')/"# $" 6 /''"/ ,
2"&") 6("
)% $ " . ,$
= 6("
./ ."
/( >
# ""# ''"/ %$ )# ;7
/ !
"
;"
) 2 " ( 6 '.(
/ 7 %%:8 )#,"
$"
( "
") " ()1 " / "
"
/
" /"
/ $ #)"# "&"# "#& $"') 01 ( < )"
= ) ;
'
/ 01
( ,$") "&"# '
0/ ) "&)/'
#"
()"'
" $". ' & 10
) ."#"/ (/'
"( > , ."
/'
"/((
" ( '
" " !"#$8')
" ,"
0? "
!"#$%2"." )$).
%@7
$= #%A1 !/# B8%@7 &" !"#$="))%7 ")#" B8>%.
"
!"#$% : " "'
"'
) !
B8% @ +7 9 ) B8 % @ * % "'
)"'
%= 6("
)B8 -$
'/.
A?C 3 - 0/ %< )"
=
,"
0?
$ &"# $
'/ ) ( " )"#$
"
) '% -"0/ , "/ " &/ $ $ ) '.(
"7 % / 7%:801 '""#"/ "$" &/ 2/ ) $ ""# -"0/ )"/ 01'
"#
(/'
" 1./'$) '# '&"'"#
0)"$$"()
/
" /"
" . & $"'/) / $ #)"# "&"# 6 '
6788 01 < )"
= )% $/0 !.
!
#"
= )% #"
, & $"') "D/ " -0"#$.
$"'
"%$ ("
/ , )"'"
'
" "!"#$,$ 01$ ."
/.0 & $"')
( $ $
"&
> $"')
( ;
" #/ ,"
$&
" " / $
/.0 "#& $"')
"&"# & $"')
".1 " !"#$ "
)) /"'"
' & $"') "D/ ","
''/ ./'$)
0)"$
/) $ #)"# "&"# "& $"') 01< )"
= ) 2/ ) ( "# ') % $ % $ /((
""# )"/ ,"
/0.""
".1
/
" /"
" . & $"'/)
/ $ #)"# "&"# "#& $"') 01< )"
= )#
/))1'0
. "& "#
"'/'
()"'
" ;7 #"
01 " !"#$ 0 " ,$ ( / !
22, /0."
2/ "
)< )"
= )D/ (/"$ / !
"
% ;2% (& 01 "
!"#$% 2"." ) $).
B8 ;
" / #/
-"0/ )% 0 " .
"
) '% $ "#$ )1 $ )
< )"
= )" / $ ,$") "&"# "& $"') , $" ," $ ,$ $"
" / $("
" .
"') ) ( A?< )"
=
,"
0?0/ ?() " '"'/.
/ ,$"'$$
''.( "
"!"#$ $("
),$ "#
, )0
,"
$ $ "#& '(1.
"') ) ( 2/ ) ') ( '.(
"01'
"#
" / $ 0
"
E% %$ " )/
"#01 (()1"# ./) "()"
.
$
"#0 "
/ (( ;
"/
#/
'.(
/ & "/$
" ), "
2/ ) ( "# $ /
'
"
') '.(
" ;
#/
/'
#"0) (&
)
,"
$/ 1 ''/ /
""#" /"
" )"'.
"'/.
A?3 ;$
'/ ) %( / ( 805
' -"0/ )%
'"
" 0 '/.
1 '/() ,"
$ " , 0 "
"
) '%$ "#$ )1 "&
'')/"
/ / $ #)"# "&"# '
" D/ " 01 < )"
= ) -$ -"0/ ) " ( "'
()
(
/'$ '
/ " 0 )"
/ ( <7A?%"
"')
"
( ,$ # " / ."
=& .
6("
)% $ "6 ( $ #"& 1 ?()
,$1 / ,$
'"'/.
$ # " / :') ."
$("
)6" ,"
, )) " &"
A?7B : ") 0/ $" ( .
/ ) A? ,"
$ ,/)
"#
<7 , )) ,"
" &"
A?7B : (,
" < )"
= );
/ 0
$ )
/'$
B "$"'
"& '
" $ )1 1 ' D/ -$ -"0/ ) $ )
& &"
, " < )"
= )$ ."
'"# '"." "
) "# $ .
1 '.() (
" "# $" ) ".()"'
" " '"." -$ )$ )"
/( /#.
$"2/
!"# $%&&'() %*& +
,-+ !./)**0$)( $1( 223 $)
/ 01< )"
= ) '"'/.
" '"
""
0
'
/ 01 ( ,$") "&"# '
")
" $". $" ," $ ""."'
, ( / $ )
"
".()"'
.
"& & $"') ) )1% $ ,/) '$ & $"') "/ ,"
"/ '.( 1 2/ ) $ .
1/0.""
") / )""# ' )"( ,"
" / 0 "# $"
=& .
6("
) 01 < )"
= "#
< )"
= ) .
"') ) ( '(1,$"'$ " A? -$ & "/ '"'/.
" '"
" 01 -"0/ '""# " ))/ -$ ('
"#0 /..
1"
."
"'
("'"() ) , -$ /. 0 '" " 0 (0 " (0 1
/0 D/" '"." "
)-$ / )""# ' 01 ) / . ./'$) ")) )"
1, "#
& " ''"#)1% ""# -"0/ ) "/ )"
0 ".
''"#)1
-$"0"# 2/ ()
'.(
" $ 0
"'
$ "0 -"0/ ) $
'.(
"7 % :8/ 7%:8
/ 8 "'
?( 7 >% :8 " / "# 7 %:8 A?( '& %
( '"
)"
7 %:8 2.(
"D/ " 7%:8 <"'.
F. $ G7% :8( . $ 7 % :8 @* % "'
)"'
%= 6("
)%3 ./ B8 (
" !"#$ , ."
" = 6("
) ,"
$" 1 " 6" <7
"2"&")6("
)% $ "
$ &"#$
" /1%"#$ " /1% -"0"
) " 6"2-!'
$
0"
)%
)0 .$ #"' ' /" ,"
( /.'
($ )/,"
$
)0 % )0
", )) ) .
?")) 1"/,"
$'
)($
.
-$
"'$ # . $("
) -$ ') @ 7 &" !"#$ ="))% 7 ")#" @ +7 9 ) @ +7 9 ) A1 = )6("
)% )-,%3 ./ (&
" /"
%
( "$("
)"H
'-$ " / /
" /"
/
" (
")) " " 0/ 1-$ )$ ".0/
.
"'
?( "0")): "(
'.
5 ?$"0"
" $"# ' /##
/0 D/ $" "'$ # . $("
)% " / /
"'/ .
"'
?( ; #"& '"'/.
% '.(
),"
$ .
"'
?( " 0
".
./ 7 %:8 , ( "
/ "# @ * ?() /.0
" /"
/
&"'
". 9
("#"&"
,
" /"
/
'/() ,"
$ ( "
" (
% "
/ "'
,/) 0 & " '.(
" ( " / "# "
7%:8 "
" 7%:8 -$ -"0/ ) $
./ 7 %:8 ?( (
"%( '"
"
'$ # ;&"
, 0& %'.(
"/
"$
" 7 %:8 "
"7%:8 @7
$= #%A1 !/# %2"&")6("
)%3 ./ (&
" , )) " ""'
A? 6 (
" !"#$ / E &"/ " 1 / "#$ '$"' .
'/) ,"
$ ) $" 1
/.
@" 1 '
""'
.
5 A? -$ -"0/ ) $
/'
" ) "
E 01
5"# "
0 : D/ ,$) 01 ./ 7%:8
7%:8( ( '
01 )1"#/( /#.
$"2/ !.!"# #,-+ !"# /$)**2() %3'
D/
'
)) '"
" " ,$
" '.(
"D/ " 101 (()1"#./) "()"
$ /
"# 0 "
/ (( $ 0
'
01'/ )
" !"#$8 " /
" $" " &"
A?B :01, 1
""'$"
;( > " &"
%$
.()1 - '$"'"
=/ " "), 1% $" B5$(% 3 ./ $ 0
"# 7%:8( . $ @/ ( .
" 1% $ / ,5 D/"
>$/$" 1,5 "") "$" 0 - '$"'"
=/ " 7 "), 1% $" B5$( " #/) :( .
," $"# $ 0
.
,$ $ ,/)
" . 7 "), $" B5$( 3 ./ 6, % ')
" '/.
A?C 3 01 , 1
' ,$ 01$ ') $" @'/.
A?C.
I $ &"# # ( 8.
" " !
(
.0 -$ " ,"
. $" ( (& '/.
A?C 3 !
') ' " @ .0 01, 1 " &"
A?B : .
$"$ &"# 1)
/.$"$ &"## ( 8.
" 2/ ) & 1 #/.
.
$"# " ') ' "/ " &"'
("
" /1 $" "#$""
ED/
" 1" '
1$" " "#$" &"'
.()1
" ,5$( 7 "), 1 ') )
')
% '# '&"'"# ,"
$ ,$
$" 0 ,"
7 "), 1% "
" ""'/) ''
( '
"
" / )"'.
01 (()1"#./) "()"
$ " 1 ("'
"A?3./'$) 01
"#
"
/ (( , )) ' 1%" ' "/ " &"'
7 "), 1 ("
" 1E % "D/ "') &"#/ )/ "'.
"0/
" 1E ( 01@7
$= # -$" ( %@7
$= #"$"
""'$"
$ (
" 1 .
1 0 / " /"
/
; $" '
"%$ ( )),"#
8 J;'
)) /
" " /1;'
$,
/ " /"
$" J B$ ( ,"
"$"
"" '$"
'
" ' /'
"% "
" ""'/) '')/
&"/ ) "
E " "#$
/ ))1 /) " /1/
''/ "D/ "; $" &"
, .
%'.(
"D/ " / "1 )$ ./ 7 % :8 , )"'.
"F. $
7% :8( . $ " !"#$ " $"
$ $ (
0 ./ 1 "'/) /.0 1 ''/
<
$
" '/.
A?C% (()"'
(/(
0 ") "!"#$"
5 ( ,"
$
)
01$".-$ (()"'
"A?C ).
( 8.
" -$ " / $("
)"H
")) ( A?C% $ )
"))
" .
"'
" / , &"
"'$ # . $("
)6, % 2/ '
/"'"
) "'
" / ,/) $
.
'& . $" '"
"'$ # . $("
) ; " / /#$ &)/
1
" )D/ " 0 ./ 1, "D/ " " / 0 "#
)"'.
D/ )
" "'/.
A?3;
$" &"
, .
% ) "'.
D/ ( "
'& 1 )), )" ".
" / $ / &"/ )"
E ; &"
, "'/" .
"0 % "
" & 1 ')
" " 1" ''/ " /1/
''/ "D/ " - 5"# 1.(
"'
&"
,% ') '.(
"7 %:8 , ) "
)" ''/ " 1-$ "
" ./ 7%:8$ ))0 ,"
E ( /. .
(
"))
)"H
" #"#
%
" "." 6, % ") "( )1
)), "
. ' 4)'/)*%0 -4( K@=/)
"I B$
(
5"#:
: B$
(
: