High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1516/2019dismissed

Punjab State Electricity Board, Patiala (Now Power State Power Corporation Limited) Pspcl v. Jagjit Singh And Others

2021-04-05Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri11 pages

!" # $%&' (&) % * !" # *& +&,& ,,%% -

$& ./!# /0 0&

& - # (0&*!)2)

&0,,%% & 3 # # )2)

&0& 1 (0&).

5&0&

6 0,,% ) 6 %%* %' 7'

% / 0,,%

& & ,,% %/

0! /6 ,

"'0%& # /%. / + &)*0&"'

, +8 9:7 % "' 0 , & &

0& 0 %%* & 0 /2 0,,%% /& 0" 6" ,' %) ,&0 06)*00*

6,%6 * 7 *0%%

; %, &'"

% /*0 & < =,&

6 3&)%&

% &0,& &

% &0,,%% , /02 && 9

> & )0,,%% & *0%#$(

&6 % 06 /& 6 " ,&6 %

6,%' * 7 5 &0&) 2 && 9

> &9).

&$ / & ).$??)*0*&

9 *&/& 0,' 79 & 6" % &6,% '& &2 0,'

9 6 " % &6,% '& &2 1%2 &&

> &9 &,&

+,*/%& #-+,.$4& *#5& $44#(&, $'*&" !

3&$")#'

)&"6/.& " # $%&#'#(&)* +,-.*/#+0#)* *1"#-21,/"&.* "&."-/*%&+*

$3).$4&)

/")**/%& #-+,.$4& *#5& $44#(&, $'*&"3&$") #')&"6/.&

&%$"7)

7 *0 &

9 6

9 &6 % @2 &6 % #% 79 .$?

#% .$??$%&% 79

9 A0 6 0/0&

*%% " %%* .$??

; % 0 $ & A0 % # "& 0&* 0*%%",% 0 6 "

9: .$??+2% 79

9 & & 0& *&/& 0,'

79 & 6" % &6,% '& *00

0 0, .$ 1

9 *00 0

$ / & & '&

&2 80&/&0 6" %)*00* " %%* & '& &2) 6 6 * 62&&

> & ) *0&"' %

$ / & *

/& 0.$?? &6,% / '& 1%2 >& 0 && " /&,& B A0 !"#$%&'(& ,% &&0/&

$ / & 1

7 : 9 *0 0 % &

0 /& . $ $; % %/"% &0, $ &0 #$( $ / &

$% @+2% 1/ %

)

$%&%@+2%@A /@+66 @?

%% # " # 6,% '& &2 &60 ! / 0 , .$?? &6 @ :@5?@1+77

9 C # 0"! /2 /" ,&6 % ) ,&

06 9

> & )* &620 /

0 .$ )*0 /,&6 )0 & %/& .$ )

,&#0 %?)* 79 &'& &2 A0'*& "/& 0

6" % & '& )*00* 0,

$ / & *0%&62 /0 6%'2%&@&& 7

> & )0 , %%' 00

$ / & 0 /& ,& % 0&&

> & 7

> & %&

0*0%/& /0

$ / &)0&* ! 6,

9@ &61

:@1 9@ 0 * & %

#0 %) & &&"2 A0 * 6%')*00* &62 2&& 7

> & 0%& # /%. / 0 &/0%' %%* 0 , 0 0 * 6%') *00 *

&62 "' 0,&6 % 0 "6,%6 *

7 A0 %'/& D "'0,,%% * 0" &&2 / 0 2 && 7

> & ) 0& *

/&6 "* 0+ % 0.

&$ / & 0,,%% "&00&&& * %"/2 06* 9 3*2&)

0/&6 0 ,% && ? 0 0,,%% 0 ,& 06@&& 9

> & ) , & & *& % 0 % 0 ,

$ / & 3*2&)*0%,

/0&& 9

> & )0&* 6 D && /0 0

$ / &

0 &&)0&* 6 &/& /! 6, 9@ &6

:@1 9@ 0 6%'* &622&&

> & 3 ) &%% , &, ), & & *&/2 0&&/0 %%6 ,&*00

$ / & &6,% / '& &2 ,&&/ %

06 9

> & *& /&6 0

,% &&"'0,,%% % /*00 %

2 0* 00+ % .

&$ / & 0/& &/0&&&&

A0'02,% && %',' 0

/ ( )0

"D " /&6 &2&)0

6 ' / 0 ,' ) " &62 / 0 6%'

1 & )0 /) "6! /6 ,

"'2

( 0 + &

9 #+A)*0& 0 "

&2 B &

& /06& % % /0&/ 6

% &"00,& )*& 02*0,& *

6%' ?

* D /2 "&,' %0& 0& ?

& ,&&2

& )&2 %0& *

@ *00 * /2 0 & *0

&6 : 3*2&)0'*&6 /"&&6 0/& 0 0&,' % 0 /&0%& 0 %"0 6 A0 /0 0 &; * ,&%%',&%&"'&2 /0,' %

@*0

&6 7)0& & 0&&, 6 )0 &0&&2 : @*

/2 9 A0 *& B 6%'C 0 " 8"

&E * A* 0 + &' &' 6 B"

&6%'F &&/ %&'F 2 &6 0 &/ %& && /6 ) / &% & % & 0 % 60C # 0 ,& *0& & 0,'

,' &2 ) ,& &* , & "% *0 * %

6%' ? 0 "

"'0 + & # G ( ,& B*0& 0& %

6% 6 0 6,%'

&2 ,' C?

>)*/&*00%/%,

0&& ,

"'0H2& 6

3&' *0* %

I 6%'E 0 2

/2 0& *00%&'02" >&"2 80 ""& 6 00

2%2 ,'

&2 6& &>&6%'6,%> ?0 &,%'0%"'

0,> &00 "" >6

&"'0 >,&" ) 0 )'+66

) 0 ); %'

*&D) & &

"%' 2& , &; & ,0 %'

A0 ,& ,% /& *$*&#' 2 1$-"$)/$8 9:

>6,% &0& 0

&."&*$"3; /+$+.& &0$"*%&+* 6) <&)* &+2$4 &2/)*"$*/#+ &"6/.&)))#./$*/#+;

$2 *0 0>,& 66%D'+66

/ 0& /00 >& /2

&66

)*0%6,%6 /0 &66

/2 / 6 2& /& 6,%' ) 6% D

,% A0#H2& 6 0

,' 6%'66

0,& +

; %')*0%&66 /0,' : @)0'+66

&2 ' , 6%' 00&0 ) 00,%6 / & .

&$ / & 0% /,%6 0 %""& /0,&*00 /&0%& 0 * 0& && / &0&&2

% 0 / , 06&&%D )* 0* &62% 6%')" /&

&0&&2 )0& &)0#00,&&/2 >0 : 7 &6*000 &2 * D

C ?

0 & ! /6 ) 0 " 0% 0 *0

6%' &2 ,' % &62)0 "D &60

6*0 0,'&2 D ,% &60*0

D &620 6%'%& ?

,& 0 ! /6 )0 0%

80 2&&2 ,' D ,%)*0%D / 0 )0H2& 6 > 0 &6*000,'&2

D,% 80%/2 /

0&66

+66

) ,"'0H2& 6 )6 '6 6%

% & ? % ,&@,& &,"'0H2& 6 ,, 6%'66 %D 0, &,& 6%

*00 & , $>& *00 "' 0 6%'

66 *00&0& %%' 6%' 0 6,%6 ,& %&/&' ?

)0 6%'66&66 /2 / ,,&,&,' %"'

&62 /0 6%' 6%' ,

D &620 6)0 " &60 6*0 0 ,'&2 D ,% &60*0 D

&620 6%'%& A0& % "

*0 0,'* &/0%'&2 && /0,&&2 ,'

%) "

& 2& 0& & 0 &66

6%' 66 & 6 0& >,& 66)0H2& 6 D 0 &"&,'

% &*00!

&& 0&&

)*00 &62% 6% ) &0&&2

D,% &6%& 0 " >"'0

: H2& 6 *006'

&%'" *00/ &% &2 ,' %0D ,% A0 & ,& ,%

0 *$*&#' $=$)*1$+6)#0$4,$); 8:

> 0 %%* /*&

J: A01 % ,&2 / &0&2 ,' *&6"'

0#H2& 6 & % 0&66 0 '+66

*00* 0"'& ( (&) &6& +0 .

01! 0 3/0+ & ?

0,&

& 0&66

0'+66

6,%6 )0%D%0 2& 6% 6

"& % 6% +66

&6%%',, &/0 0 &, %*0 0 6

*00 6/0 6 0 0 H2& 6 &0 %,&

,'&2 A0 *

,& %'*0* "'0# 1! 0 "'

&% /

& ,&6

*0& &0&2 ,'

)*00 % " %

&01 % )*&,&2

& # & 0

5"& &' 9)7 &% /0K+

& )* *02*&62 ' 6%'&6D ',&2 &/&'*00*

% 01 % ?*

& % 0 , 06 0K+ 0 "&

& /& 0/0& ,'

% *00 * /2 0& &,& 0 #&& A0 3/0 + & % ,,&00 %" &

/0 . &' 9)7 0 &

&% , "'

03/0+ &* &%'

& % %" *0 0 . &'

9) 7 0 # H2& 6 * !

/& / &2 # 0 & 0&K+ "&

&65"& &')7 ,&0"2 ! /6 )&&& %'"& & ) &0&&2 & 0&66

0 6%' +66 & 6 0& >,& 66) 0 H2& 6 D /& "&,' % & 6 0& &

7 ?

! " #$ % &

! " #$ % & ' " ( #+A 7)02 ( 0 + &*

& / &2 ,' % ?* 0% 0 0& 6%' )" &", &60 &62% 6%' & % &"&&' " > &/& ?

)! !

9#+A ) 0 2 ( 0 0 + & *

& / ) *0& 0 , &* ,, 8& 6,,&&* 7

*&D0&/" 3* 6& %*0?A?*'& ,%6 6& 60 )*000,

0'&77 A0,' *&&2 * 7 , &L 0& &* ,

# "

; %') 0 % 0 % , ) *00 *& &&' /6 6 6 %; % & % ,%6

?A?&?A?& @,%'0 * &0&&2

* H&2 0, &0& *

0 0 ,' % 1 * &; & D

&6 7 *0 0&2 ,' 06,%' *&/2

; # ), &00 ; % &*0?A?& )0* 0% %0 &2 ,' * 7 ?

,& 0! /6 )*

6&,& % 06 ) 0*

"2) 00,' 0 &2 0 %, &&' /0; %

6&*0? A ? +& @%'0 *0& &00 % *0006 6 6; % ?A?& @,%6

&6%'0 *0

&),' %0

6 1 ? "'0& 00 , &0 0; % &*0?A?& 00

" > 0 " &2 ,' % 1 ) 0*2&) * &6 7 ?

0 & 6 ) *0 0& "' 0 6, / && %'

6 0 ,' % &%& /& * 7 ) 0 6 0 &%0 6 "

; C 5 &0&)& & "6! /6 ,

"'02

( 0 + & * $ !

+ ,

79#+A 9)*0&"' 0 && ) &&62 / 6%')0" &62% ,' %* /& *

?* 0%00 %

"6" '06 0&&& A0

>*0%&62 /0 6%'* ; 0 ?

,& )* "

&2 B A0 /0 %

& 2%&& & > /

& /& " " 0 ,& ) 0& 0 & 0/2 ' & , %

& &

0 %

& " &%2 *0 6%' 0 ,

&'" /0"&62 ?

%%0&&&

H2& 6 ?

02/0" &2 ,

0 *0'

0%* & D &65& 02" ,&20"

&2 ,

# 6%' /0"&62 , & 0&66

0H& , & )(1* %" % &2 ,

&6 0 0& 6,%' 0 + &%H2& 6 02/0&2 ,

&'" A0,% %

& 0 & & , %* , 6,%' 0 &6 5& ) *0 %% 0& /&

6,%' % / &2 02 " /2 0 " # 0 &6 &'&6 *0%%'&"&&'

#2/+,&"/+21$/+/).$)&8)-0"$:; 0+ &0%0 02 /,0 6 6%' 02 /D &620 6)0H2& 6

&"&&%' >0*0

&6*000" &2 ,' % "/2 0 , & ?

$"(/+,&"/+21).$)&8)-0"$:; 0 &2 0

, &* &/ %& 0 /090&,&

*&/2 0 " ?* 0 ,,&2%0 /0)0 6 *%%&%"D0 0&/ % ?

)0 0& * %& % 2 &6 ?

$/$"$3$+$71$").$)&8)-0"$:;2 ( 0 + & 0%0 %%* /

B32 /0&0%&

% &0,& )*& 0 , 00 0& 00, & % 0 " &62% 6%' 0 '

+66

*0%%' !

? * & / 0 6,%6 0'+66

&,&)* "'

0& 00& 6%' 0 6%' /0"&62 0 0 " &62 &6 0 6,%6 0 &66 0'+66

A0& >,% *0'0 6%' /0" &62 &6 : ?

'>,%

&62% 6%' &6 :)* 0

0& > / 0 !

; %') *0%00, & %0&2 ,'

7@* A0 0, & 0%% " %0&&%" 0 ,' % ?

0 0 ,& ) 0& * 6%' *0% /& /0" 6" ,&6 % 0, & )

0& * 6 *0 &/& 0 ! 6, 1 9@ &6

:@1 9@ 0 6%'* &622&&

> & & /%')0, && *& &/0%' /2 0 ,' ,& *0 0

$ / & & 6,% / '& &2 ,&&/ % 06 9

> & 5 &0&6&) /&6 0 ,% &&"'

0,,%% 0*00+ % .

&$ / & 0 &/ 0& %6 / /0,' * 7 3 )D, / 2* 0"2

) /& 6 & & 0! /6

"'0%& # /%. / + & 6& 6

1?AK(31? .KH$ 1+3K1? .KH$ !,

M @ "#

M @