High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24306/2015dismissed

Haryana Power Generation Corporation Ltd v. Haryana State Micro And Small Enterprises Facilitation Council And ANR

2016-08-30Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi20 pages

!" #"$%&%'(

)

*( + ,***,- ."&"'!( !

"

#$ !

" %& **,-/ 0. 12 '

#

&()&*(+, - .)/ 0

," 1

2/

0

0

0

"

#

"&

"

0

"

0

!

(4"

&**)," 1

"&**)2/

(5,6/"

"

$ &**4," 1

"

&**47/ " #

0

.0 & . %

"

" 0

""

# %& "

"

0

0

#

, - .&/0

.( !

3

"&

"

" "

#

0

"

0

!

"&**) "

0

&

!8

!

(5"

"&**4 ' "

"

$ 9 3# " 90

!" # $"%& -

# , - .)/ 0

"

3

0 0

" :

#

# , - .)/ 0 #

" & !

" !

#

# 0

"

"& . 0

%(

-

3

#

#

0

3

"

( . 0!

#

, - .4/

0 ( . " #

!8

3

"

" "

!

#

"

0 #

"

" "

"

#

#

"

!

"

8

# !

" "

# 0 (

. 0

"" #3

"

!

0

;

0

"

!

0

"

0 0 "

" #

"

"

"<0 2

&,/"

"&**4

=.

&

"

"

1 2

&,/"

"&**4

=.

" # $ %

% & '() '()

# $ * % #

+

% & '() '()

#

0

&

#$

0

# #

"#

0

0 & >

" 8

.&

& .

.( 0 "

!8 #

3

"

.

"&**4 . "

. %&

"

0 .

# 0 #

8

;

3

"

#

!

"

(5&?"

"

&**4 ( . "

"

"

!

#0

#

"

"

!

#0

"

. "

#0

"

0

"

0

!

(4"

"&**)

(5,6/"

"&**4

"

0 "

# "

"

"03 "

"&**4

=.

&&

, -./0/&# 1

+

$ * 0 & '(

&"*-./0/&# 1

2/ 3 4 5 0 $6

'$( #

2

$ * 0 & '(,# '

2 &

1

, /1

1 7 8

,9 /1

%

%

7 ,/

,:

, &

1

, :

$

7,&

, , $

2

7

"2 9 # 9 /

7

7

; & %

% <

7

7

0

27 $

% # <

9

% <

4 4

7

* 3 # # & $ +

7& ''= 7

, =,: 2

7 > ,

"

"&**4

"

& .

0 !

0

. "

0

"

8

"

# 0

&

#

(+ &?

"

"&**4 !

" 0

(5&?"

"&**4 '

0

" "

=.

)"&

*

) "

?

7

9 # /

4%, @

%

7

7

)( & %& ''))'')

3 $$$ &, =-

%

7

& %& ''))'')

? &, A"

9 # /

4%

> & %

>

$, (/

7

,

+, ',-,!: (=

,

9 #"

(5

"

"

#0

8 #

(5

.0

'"

# "

0 "

&?"

"&**4 8 " !

#

"

"

"

!

"

"

"&**4

(+ &6"

"&**4 !

""

#

#

"

# "

#

!

"

"&**4 !

!

#

""

"

"

0!

.

03 "

"&**4;

!

"

""

"

"

"

8

!

03 "

03 "

"

0

'!

" 0

0!

0 "

# 0

"

#

0!

. 03 "

"&**4

!

"

"

!

# !

# ""

;

0

"

!

#0

"

'"

"

: 0

"

#

"

# "

# 03 "

!

"

"

0

#

"

'

#

# - "

#

0!

.

3# "90

"

, #

3# 0

"

0

0 !

"

3# 8

"

0

#

# 0 " '

"

" " 0 -

"

0 " # "

3#

""

"

" 8

" ""

0

70

#5 &6'# . 0" #27&! !" 5%1 #6 '#!8".&/

0 2

@ - "

"

"

!

"

"

"&**4 "

"

0 " $ 9 "

"

#"'9:.!&5: ';7&'%' '#% '#!8".&/ 032 0%<%12 "

#

(+ &? A "

3#

$ 9

!

"

"

"&**4 0

#

! 3# "

20

!

"

!

"

"&**403

"

$ 9 " (6 (+"

3# #"'9:.!&5: ';=& ,/

=.

=, : B

>

#

% ./ ,#

0.1

, 2 334% !! 54 !!5:

#

%

& 3 .% %,&,",((''

()C)CC ,

&,3,:

9#9/*&, : 9#9/*& & 3 &

& A %$

,:

3 ; / ==D $$$

/ '?D $

# %,:

> .8 #

%

$ * 0 &

4 # & 1

E +$,:

.8 #

%

,

A, $

#

%

, 9

B # ? 9#9/*&

4%

>

, (, %

?(F

# ' 9#9/*&

B

#

% % ,: .8 #

% ., , 6,

0 !"!15

5+

, :

G

.% 7 / ,8 ' 0 !"!1"7/93 % :

$;

- ,2 $$0.1 !""<5<= 9 9:

E

# '

9#9/*& ,

;

$ 9 "

0

"

!

"

(5"

"&**40 !

&("

3# =.

,&

7

,$ # = A

4%% & , &

4% % & , :

>

, :

% &

,& B

9#9/*&

)( & %&

# C 4%

,4

#

%

,70"4&91+

35%

,@

4% >

& ) %$

, '"

$ 9

#

#

3# 0

# B# "

;

$ 9

"

3

!

0

#

0

# "

#

! 3# "

20

!

"

$ " &6 &+"

3# #"'

9:.!&5: ';=& ,/

=.

=, % ;

4 %

B ,: E

4% 7 B9

4 % ,- 4% :

& == &== 2 % B9

%

7 , .

, %

% E% %

% <

9

> 7 , A, % -,3,",?='

?

CC ='

? C( =A (C)( (?== C

4 % C,',CC C,',CC

',?,CC =,?,CC ?,,C ',A,C ',=,C

,: -&,",''CC

& -,3,", ) CC ',?,CC %

,-,3,",A='?CC'

CC'

% ,C,CC , .

B , (, $

E

& E4% ;

% , $

9#9/*&

%

H #

&

& % & ''), 9

E

& E4%

# = & %&,# ( 3 $ & & 1 >

,$

3 $ >

1

3 , : .8 #

% . :( ( ,. , : ( 0 !!!1 +

354 >

,

> 9#9/*& # ( & % & '')

>

9#9/* &,

$ 9 " 0 *>&

8 . !" <;1"$!.%$ 1&,%5%!"#7&! !" '#!8".&/ 0 20%<%12

"

0 #

=.

(,

%

)( & %&

''), -

%

7

,# A#

,+

A %

> & %

>

$, ), : &

A#

, ?, $

% I

, , $

;

%

,:

% &,:

# A

4 % & ,9

A & ( =

,

# - "

"

0 "

"1&:6'.:,%5%!"#7&8"*%$. '#5 11/*"#%65

3 '!".:.%&"& $%1%! !%'6'$%1/6'? @ '#!8".&/ 02 0%<%12

" "1&:6'.:,%5%!"#=&

,/"

#

!

(5&?"

"&**4

4A"

3# "1&:6'

.:,%5%!"#=& ,/

=.

), $

& '')

%

&

# =,$

# =

# =

& ''),@

# = & '')

%

,# =

6

7

,$ % 7

,$

%

7

,$

& ''),$ 1

%

) & ,#

# =

,$

7 6 J$# & CC)

% >

&

'') > %

# = & CC)

, : &

& CC)

,J ', :

( ,:

; 7

:

& # #

%

# &, :

.8 #

%

, $>-

, , 7 7 - "443091

+& > #

%

- 2 %

# & & % & '') # &, $>.

($ ,:

2?

- "449051 0 , 1 9"@"449031

+""> #

%

/ & & ''), :

,:

4 1 %

& '') ,$

& CC)& 3

,,,,,

0 # "

0!

. 0 !

0 $ 9 " #"'9:.!&5: ';=&

,/ $ 9 " 0 *>& 8 . !" <;

1"$!.%$ 1&,%5%!"#2 ,/0

"1&:6'.: ,%5%!"#=& ,/ !

"0

" '"

'

"

" 0 "

# 0

"

.

"

#

0

"

0

!

(4"

"&**)

(5,6/"

"&**4

!

0

"

"

0

"0

.

'

"

#

0

3

0

0!

" "

# 0

"

8

& 0

#

"

# "

0

"

'

0

"

!

0

"

!

"

"&**4

'"

"

0 " 0

"

# ;

# , -

.)/ 0

. 0

"""

#"

#

!

"

8 " 3

!

0

0 #

#

"

"

- #

3

&&4C&&)"

"' %

# #

" "

0!

"

"

!

.

"

#

#

!

0

'

0 "

"

0

" % "

"

0

0!

. 0 !

)

0**,-2 5A& >

8 #C =D C% >

0

=D C%