High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23406/2016allowed

Rajinder Kumar Malhotra v. Registrar Cooperative Societies Punjab And ORS

2024-05-03Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mrs. Justice Sukhvinder Kaur14 pages

! "#$$

%$ &'( )* ! +!$!$

, -*.$! /

0 !$1 #$!$/'

% 2 !*+0

4 1'5*1$ .* +!$!$

, 1! ! "'

% 2 !* +0

! * (,$1* ( /1 6 # !7$!* 1*$ $1* ( /6 # !

% 8 /6 # !"

!*0!$!$

1*$ ( )$5/6 # ! 97 6'.'!$ : . $*/6 # ! "

!*0!$!$

6%'

1* /6:/'

% 2 ;

, *$!/6 # !"

2 !*# <<<

= 1 '

) 00 $

2* )" "!*0!$!$

'2($!!* !!* ( !( $ !*'

% 21! !

0 !$>$

#$ ?

1$# ((

')/

* !@!*')/

!*'2B' ! #!$

! 5

!*2 $

'#* ( ! $ $)). ) #

! E !

!* 0

" !* '

% 2

0 !$1 #$!$6#!/ "

* !@!*6#!/ A !*'

% 2

0 !$ 1 #$!$ ')/ "

* ! @!* ')/ / " ( !*'

= # '

) '2($! !* ! 1#!$

3 6 " !* 6#!/ (0 7 !* 0F 2 E !

!$!'! # ((

# !

( 5 ') "

.') !$

" #'$!( #

$!$

" $# " '#*(0) E '2($!!* !!* 0F2 E "!*2 5$

! # (($!! "!*

0 !$ #$!E2'!$!

$ !( "F0) !$

00 !

1#!$

6 "!*6#!/

?!$'2($!!!* !!*$(0'.

( !( $

!$"$# !$

2E!*.$! $$)). ) '

%'!$"$ -*.$! /

0 !$1 #$!$/'

% 2/* 00 !*$()" 6($ $! !

"!*'

% 21! !

0 !$ 5$ 7*$) #!$ .

6($ $! !

/*0 )'!$

( $ .!* ')

2/ 2/ 2/ #/ 32/ 3#/ 4 / 4# ')

"!*')/

!* "!7*$)* )$ .!*

""$# .$! / * 00 *$ 0 ) !*2E ( $ . !* ')/

/2E$'$ .)!! !4

= # '

)'2($!!* !!*'/** 2# ( G'. "*$

# ' !* ! 0 !*'2($!!* !!* H)!! !4

/ ')

!* 2 $'

')# ')* 2 ( 2E$ 5$ !*0

"1#!$

36 "!*6#!/ ')3 "!*')/

= # '

) '2($! !* ! !* $(0'.

#!$

$ 7$!* '! %'$$#!$

!* $

'!* $!E $) 2) 7$!* !* 6($ $! !

!*')

# ')** ( # (( !$

( $ .!* ') ?!$"'!*'2($!!!* !!* ( !( $ !*')/

/* ')!$ ! 5$ . 7 E0 7 "!*6($ $! !$ (($!! !*2 5 (0 7$ .!* .$ .$#!

" ))!*0 7) !$ .!

!*(0) E "!*2 5$ #)'$ . 00 !( !/0 ( !$

( ) !* (0) E # ((

# = # '

) * ) )$

!* %'.( "

A2)!*1'0( '!$ # "& 1* !* %

!* = ; . % !* 1

= # '

)* ! 5 !*$ '!!

!* $ '0

"!*6#!/ !*')/

7*$#*7* ))"!

) !/$ '00 ! "!*$'2($$

= # '

) 00 $ .$ !*#

#!0!$!$

) $ $! !! !$

!*0

"!*6#! '2($!!* !$!' ))E!* ( $ "!*2E ) 7 "!* '#* ( !$ !*2E ) 7 !* #$!E # ') *

)E 2

$ !( " ') 4 " !* ')/

/ ) # '

) 00 $ . "

!* 1! ! * '00 !!* 0 '2($!!!* !!* " ( !2E!* .$! $$ #

($!E7$!*!*0

"1#!$

36 1#!$

3 FFF$$$ " !* 6#!/ 7)) ') 3 " !* ')/

% ! $ "1#!$

3FFF$$$ ')3/7 ')")#!!* ! !* .$! $ (0 7 !

#$ !($ !* B' )$"$# !$

$!$

"$#'2%#!!

7*$#* E0

( E2(0) E2E

0 !$ 1 * 7 ')/ !*"

/ ) 2 (0 7 !

( 5 ! $ !* $ B' )$"$# !$

$!$

" $# -* 0 2E!*.$! $(0'.

$ !*0 !0!$!$

/!*"

7 !$ !" #

* #

$!*'2($$

7 !!

!*" #! "!*# /$!7 ')2 00 $!!

!#! $ 0

"!*6#!/ !* ( '

1#!$

"$ $!$

2 I# (($!!J ( !* .

. 2 E " #

0 !$ #$!E/2E7* ! (# ))/!

7*$#*!*( .( !* "" $ "!* #$!E$ !'!K #I#

0 !$ #$!EI( #$!E.$! ( 2.$!'

!*$6#!

1#!$

6 !$#!$

$ $$' ) $ 2# ($ . ((2 #! $ #

0 !$ #$!$ ;

$ $$' )* ))2 ($!! ((2 " # ! ) 0F #$!E '

) '#* #$!E * 2 F(0! 2E !* .$! $ !*$2* )"/2E . ) 0#$ ) -* ! ) 0F #$!$ * $ . $ $$' ) ((2

!* ! " # (( #( " !* '

% 2

0 !$ 1 #$!$ 6( ! 6#!/ 4 4/ * )) !$ !* * "'#*$ $$' )7$!*$ 0$ "!*E "'#* (( #( !$ !*0#$2(

> !*0'0 "!*$#!$

/#!$

/ #!$

#!$

3 6 L0$( E #$!EJ( #

0 !$ #$!E7* ((2*$0#

$!F#)'$)E "$ $$' )K 2L# ! ) #$!EJ( #

0 !$ #$!E7* ((2*$0$ #)'0$( E #$!$K

# L 0F #$!EJ ( #

0 !$ #$!E 7* ((2*$0$ #)'# ! ) #$!$ "#$ >$ ) '!* $!E$ #

0 !$ #$!E -*"$ ) '!* $!E$ #

0 !$ #$!E* ))!$ !* . )2 E "((2K

D C

!7$!*!

$ E!*$ .$ '2 #!$

/7* #

0 !$ #$!E#

!)!*

!* ' '#* . ! '(2 " ((2 ( E 2 0#$2/ !* ( E 0 $ $ $! 2E ) 7 "

!* #

" ( )) . )2 E$.

! !*0 ! !$. )2 E/!

2$.

! !*0 ! !$. )2 E/!

2)#!$ !* 0#$2 (

!( !* "$ E /

$!$ " '#* '(2 " ((2 " !* !

F#$ )) '#* "!*0 7 "!*. )2 E ( E2 0#$"$$ !*2E ) 7 !*'0

E" #$ !*$6#! !*. )2 E (!$ .!* "* ))2#

!' " #!

!*0 ! !$. )2 E $!(!$ . $!* !!*0 ! !$. )2 E* ))

! )! E 0

$ !*2E ) 7) !$ .* ))

! )! E0

$ !*2E) 7) !$ .!

$!#

0 7 $ "'!* !* !

! ) !* !7 !E 0# " !* !

! ) ((2 "!*#

0 !$ #$!E( EB'$$!$

(!$

" !* . ) 2 E "

" !* ( )) . ) E #$0! "'#*B'$$!$

/!*# (($!!* ))# ))

C D

(!$ "!*. )2 E

!) !!*

(

!*" (!* ! "#$0! "'#*B'$$!$

?"$ '#* (!$ "!* . )2 E/$!$#$2E ( % $!E "((20 !$ .!

!$!'!( % $!E "((20 !$ .!

!$!'!!*( )). )2 E/!* !*)#!$

'#* ( )). )2 E* ))2*)7$!*$ "

!E"$ E!* "

1#!$

9)#!$

($ !$

"((2 "# (($!!

* E # (($!! * # !

* ) ""$#

(($!! * 2 #

!$!'! $ ## # 7$!* !* 0

"!*$6#! ') 2E ) 7( !*'

/ !*.$! ( E/2E $ 7$!$ . 00 ! :

(0) E 6($ $! !

'#*0$ ( E/" (!$( !$(/ 2 0#$"$ $ !* !* 6($ $! !

* ))/ 2"

!*F0$E "!*0$ "*$ 00 !( !/ ."

!* #

7 # (($!! $ ## # 7$!* !* 0

"!*$6#! ') 2E ) 7( !*'

9 -*0

"'2 #!$

'2 #!$

"#!$

* )) 00)E!

!*6($ $! !

00 !'

'2 #!$

$" !* 6($ $! !

* 2 00 ! '

!* ! #!$

1#!$

( ) '0 $

"# (($!! ((2!* "

?"/$ !* 0$

"!*.$! / # (($!! E((2 # (($!! 0$! !)E ( 5 " ')! $ .)$. ! $ !* 0"

( # "!*'!$$(0

$! *$(2E!*$6#! !* ') 2E ) 7( !*'

/ # (($! E #!7*$#*$ 0%'$#$ )!

$ !! "!* $!((2/ ( 5 " ')! $ !* $(0)( ! !$

" 0 '#!$

) 0( 0 . (('

! 5 2E!*#

0 !$ #$!E/ !*$ ! )( ! $ !* #

#!$

" !* # (($!! !* .$! ( E/ "!.$$ .!*# (($!! !*((2/ !* # ( E 2/

2) !'

$!E !

! ! $! *$

2%#!$

/$" E/2E $ 7$!$ ./ ( !*# (($!!/ 00 ! :

! ($ $! !

( .!* "" $ "!* "

!F#$ .$F(

!* !* #$!E"

!F#$ .$F(

!*/ ( E20#$"$$ !* K 2 ( !*((2 .!!* # #E"$))'0!* '.* )#!$

!*( $ .0$ "!* '!.

.((2/ ## $ . !

!* 0

" !*$/ ## $ . !

!* 0

"!*$6#! ') 2E ) 7( !* '

$ !* ! !* # (($!! E '#* #

0 !$ * ))

!2'0 50!'

'0 $

7*!*$

!* * )$ )

#$ ) $!

E.' !.$ 2E!*:

C3D

$"'!*!* !$ # " #

0 !$ #$!E# E$

!* 2'$ " 2 5$ ./ !* 0

" !* 5$ .') !$

6#!/ 44 44* )) ) 00)E $"'!*!* !$ # " #

0 !$ #$!E# E$

!*2'$ "2 5$ ./!*0$ "$F(

!*( !$

$ #) ' * ))2

E 1#!$

3 3

" # ((

# " (0) E " #! $ #$!$ 6 0F #$!E( E'

( / 7* B'$!

2E !* .$! / * )) #

!$!'! # ((

# " )) 0#$"$#) "(0) E$ !*$# "!* ! $ !* $# " !* # ! ) #$!$ 7*$#* ((2 " !* 0F $ !*$# "!*0$( E #$!$7*$#* ((2 "!* 0F !* "

$ #$!$ * # ((

# $#

!$!'!'

'2 #!$

!* 0F #$!E * )) ( 5 ') "

!* .') !$

#'$!( !* #

$!$

" $# " '#* (0) E 7$!*!*0$ 00 ) "!*.$! ') -*:

!( E/"

0 !$ #)

"'#* #$!$/ ( 5') !

# E '! !* 0'0 "!*$ 6#!0'0 "!*$6#!

0 !$#') / 7$!* '!0%'$#!

!*. )$!E "!* "

.0 7/'#*')( E0 $"

)) E "!* "

)) 7$ .( !!/ ()EM

C4D

3FFF$$$ N' )$"$# !$

((2 "!*# (($!! (0) E " #) " #$!$ !*#

$!$

"$#'2%#! 7*$#*0

( E2(0) E2E #$!$ ?!$ ) 00 0$ !!

! () !') "!*')/

/7*$#* '

%&'

6( "E = 7 1'2%#! !

!* 0

" #!$

') 3

#$!E( E" (!$(!

!$( ( $!2E ) 7

%&() )'!$

> 6( ! ;

( ! '

') 4 * )) 2 # $ '! $ ## #7$!* )'!$

0 ! . )(!$ "!*

0 !$ " 7*$#* '

!$# " !* $ ! !$

$#'!* ( !* 2 .$ K $!* !

'#* )'!$

* ))2 )$'

)$!$0 2E ( % $!E " ((2 0 ! ! !* . ) (!$ . ! 7*$#*

!)!* !7

!*$ "((2"

!*!$(2$ !*#

0 !$ #$!E 0 $ "'!* !* ! ( ) 2E ) 7 "

( ! 0$ ')E 00 2E !* .$! 2E ( % $!E !

$ E. )(!$ .

%&(( 600)$# !$

.$! "

.$! !$

"6( !

-* # 0$ " !* ( ! 0! 2E !* #

0 !$ #$!E '

') / $.

2E !7 ""$# " !* #

#$!E ')E '!* $O 2E !* . ) (!$ . $ !*$ 2* )"/ * ))2'2($!!!

!*.$! )

7$!* 00)$# !$

.$! !$

')E $.

$ 1'#* # 0$ " !* !* ))2 ## (0 $2E!*#!$"$# !$.

"!* 2 !7 ""$# "!*#

0 !$ #$!E!

!* ""#! !* ! !* 0

" ') * 2 # (0)$ 7$!*

%&#* N' )$"$# !$

$!$

"1$#"9(0) E -* B' )$"$# !$

$!$

" $# '2%#! !

7*$#* E0

( E2(0) E2E #

0 !$ #) "

0 !$ #$!$ * )) 2 '#* ( E 2 !($ 2E!*.$! " (!$(!

!$( *!*.$! $ "!* 0$

!* !$!$ # E F0$ ! !

/*( E2E /"

2# 7$!$ .) F!*0

"!*$')7$!*0#!!

0 !$ #$!$ !

'#* F! ! * ( E #

$ 0 0 J

> ( !* 0' ) " !* "

$ 0

" !* 6#!/

!*')/ /$!$ 00 !!* !!*0 7#

! $ $ ')3 6 $ ""

($ . # ((

# " )) 0#$"$#) "(0) E

( 5$ .')H.') !$

#'$!( #

$!$

"$# "!* (0) E/ ! 7$!* !* 0F " !* 2 5 !* ( * )) 2 2 '.*!$ "

#7$!*!*0$ 00 ) "!*.$!

($ $! !

# 2 00 !7* E (($!! "!* 0F #$!E# !

* ) ""$# '#*6($ $! !

7* $ 2 .

!(0) E/7 ')2 00 !2E!*.$! "

'#* 0$ !* 6($ $! !

* )) . "

" 7 (($!!$ !( "!*') 2E ) 7 !*6($ $! !

7 ')

!2 !$!)!

#!$

! '( !*

E *7 ')* !*0 7 !* ! "!* (($!!$ !( "1#!$

9 "!*6#!/

-* 0F #$!E * 2 "$ #

0 !$ #$!E 7* ((2*$0 $ #)' # ! ) #$!$ !* "$ ) '!* $!E $

0 !$ #$!E ! 7$!* !* . ) 2 E " !* ((2 -*'/

% ! $ " )) !* 0

7 ')/ !*"

/ ')!

)E $

#)'$

!* !!* 0F2 E0 !!*. )2 E "!*((2

$ ( !* # (($!!H2 " !* #$!E ?

# 7* 6($ $! !

* 2 00 ! $ 0) # " 2 H# (($!!/ '#* 6($ $! !

7 ')

! * !* 0 7 5$ !

!* ! 0F #$!E -*"

/ !* 6($ $! !

# ')

! 2 (0 7 $!* !

( !* 2E ) 7 " (')"

!*.') !$

"#'$!( ! #

$!$

$#$ !( "1#!$

3 6 "!*6#!/

!* 0 ! # / 7 "$ '

$B' $!' !$

/ 7*$ / !* .$! 00 ! *$()" 6($ $! !

" !* 2 5 $ ' ) # 0 #$!E"$!)E*# (( !* ( !$ !*') !* "! #!$ . .$! / * 00 !* (/ 7*$) !* #*( " !* 6#! (0 7!*.$! !

2!*"$ ) 00 $ . '!* $!E ')3

"!*')/(0 7!*.$! !

00 !*')7*$#* " ( 2E!* 0F #$!E$ !( "1#!$

3 6 "!*6#!/ /* 7/ !*#*(

7* )) 7!*.$! *$()"!

" ( ( !*')

" !*

' 0$

/ '#* # ' 0! 2E !* .$! $ )$ !

!*0

"!*6#!/ ')/

?!$ # "# ) ' 2)F#$ "0 72E!*.$! ) "$ !* !!* !0 00 2E!*.$! * ')!$ 7!$ 7 E !* 0 7 $) 2) 7$!* !* 0F *$"!$ . $! !

!* .$ .$#!

/7* $ ?61""$#

-* E !* " !* #

0 !$ ( ( ! $ 2

$) "!* ) "((2 "!* #$!E$ ( .$ .!*$ "" $ -* 0!$!$

/7* $

"!*((2 "!* #$!E* /!*"

/$.*!)E ! 5 '0!*( !!#* )) .$ .!* $F#$ "0 72E!*.$!

-* #!$ #$!$ 7 ') *

00)$# !$

$ !* " #! "!*0 !# 6($ $! !

!2 )) 7!

! 50 )$#E #$$

1 !#*$ .!*0 7 " 0F2 E ! "$ .!* (!

!* .$ .$#!

7$!*. !

" ($ .') "!*#

0 !$ ( '

! !

! 5$ . 0 )$#E #$$

?! $ 5

!* ! !* .$! !* .$ .$#!

?61""$#7*$)!*0 7* 2 0 $!

!* #

0 !$ #$!E $!)" !* '.* $! 0F 2 E !

! 5 #$$

" (')) !$ .!

$!(0) E

-* 0

! 2

!*$ . 2'! 0 ! " !*

) 0

$ . '

6!$#) P= ?! 7 ') 2 $! !

! !* 0

" 6!$#) P= " !*

7*$#*0 $ '

L6!$#) P= L?

# "'0$

" 2 /!* ($ $! !

00 ! ( .!* "" $ "'#*#

0 !$ #$!E* )) . "

'#! ")#!$

7$!*$ !*0$ 0#$"$ #) '

* !*( .( !!

!*)#!$

2 J

& 1* !* %A# '0 /

A2)!*1'0( '!7 F ($ .!*%'.( !0 2E!*$$$

#* "!*& ! 5 $.* '! 2!* !!*6($ $! !

)EF#$ )) E "!* "'

#!$

"!*# (($!! #

)EF#$0 7!

'#!)#!$

! !$!)!

))

7((2

-*'/ 7 "$ !* ! !* #

#0! $ . 2E

A2) !* 1'0( '!$ & 1* !* %A# '0 * 2 $ 0 !$ !*

-*.$! /!*"

/# ')

!* !$ *$()"!* 7 "!*

0 !$ 5 7$!*!* .$ .$#!

= # '

) "

!* 0

! * )$

%'.( 0 2E

$ ! #*$ .* *$ 1$ .* 1! ! "'

% 2/

4431- /$ '00 ! "*$#

! !$

!* !!*.$! * 0 7 ( 5 ( ! $ !* ')

!* # (( !$

" !* 6($ $! !

"!*2

7/7"$ !* !$ !*0 !# /!*.$! *$()" 2# (!*6($ $! !

( # (( !$

!* (0

7*$)* )$ .!*0 ! ".$! /* 00 !* $ ( * ) E*)'#*0 7 "F#$ # ) ' 2)F#$

" #!!* '!*

$!*"$ $!$

" !*"$ $!$

"@ "$ '

F0) !$

1#!$

6 1#!$

20#!$)E -*@ (

)E!*.

E !

7* ( !* #$!E !'! !* ( .( " !* "" $ " !* !* @ (

0 !$ 1 #$!E 7* ((2*$0$ #)'# ! ) #$!$ -*'/$!$ #

.) ( ! " $ ' #$!$/ !*"

)E!*. )2 E "'#*#

.) ( !# ! 5 #$$

" (2E ) 7 ')7*$#* "# '* !

2 00

2E !* .$! -* .

! ! 7* $ 00 ! 6($ $! !

!2 )) 7!

( 5 ( !$ !*')/( /

" !'7*$#*! 5 7 E!*E#

#0! "#

0 !$( ( !/ 0 $ '

6!$#) P 7$!* ! ?Q $ ! 2E !*

;$ !E !*6( !6#!/ /7 "

$7 '"$ $ ./7B' *!* ( !( $ !* ')2E!*6($ $! !

00 2E!*.$! /7* 7

!* (0

7/!*#* )) .( 2E!*0#!$0!$!$

7$!* . !

0 !( ! ) #!$

! 5 2E !* 0

!/ !* ( *

F ($ / ) # '

!*0!$!$

!0!* ( 0 E !

)) 7 !* 0!$!$

( 5 #* )) . !

!* ( 2"

!* ) 1$ .)G'./$" $

-* 7$! 0!$!$

## $ .)E )) 7 $ 0 !

-* 0!$!$

7 ')2 !)$2!E!

$)). )($ $) 2)!

!*(7$!* . !

0 !( ! ) #!$

! 5 2E!*0

! 6))0 $ .($# 00)$# !$

) !

$0 "

*!*0 5$ .H

R 8 *!*0 ! 2)R 8