High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27671/2013dismissed

Jaswant And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2015-10-08Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron9 pages

# $% &% '%( )%* $% & +, % -%-.)$%/0 ,10%$+% -23-40 0%*0%%+, 0!0" 5 - 33$)#$*0 ,10%%+,607 8 -% 91 ,0 ,10%%+,: -%)9*'90 ,10%%+, " -%-(3(2 44%#20 ,10%%+,

/3% $% &% '%( )%* $% & +, % -%-.)$%/0 ,10%$+% -23-40 0%*0%%+, 0!0" 5 - 33$)#$*0 ,10%%+,607 8 -% 91 ,0 ,10%%+,: -%)9*'90 ,10%%+, " -%-(3(2 44%#20 ,10%%+,

-;)$1%*/+<1., &% '%( )%* $% & +, % -%-.)$%/0 ,10%$+% -23-40 0%*0%%+, 0!0" 5 - 33$)#$*0 ,10%%+,607 8 -% 91 ,0 ,10%%+,

! -%)9*'90 ,10%%+, 5 -%-(3(2 44%#20 ,10%%+, !

/$,% $% &% '%( )%* $% & +, % -%-.)$%/0 ,10%$+% -23-40 0%*0%%+, 0!0" 5 - 33$)#$*0 ,10%%+,607 8 -% 91 ,0 ,10%%+,: -%)9*'90 ,10%%+, " -%-(3(2 44%#20 ,10%%+,

!! !

" $ %,% $22 ,+ %/, (% #% + = !858 !

6> !8 5 !

6> !

!7 !

6 !

7 " !

60 $2244 $ ?( 2, % +(@2 +(%+ /2* A% $ ,12+/ , (2B 2, @* $ %* %@ 12+/

($%*%+%)% ,@#)% !;

"0 7;

"0:!;++ B0:!;:60:7;:"(%4+%12+/2%(%4-% %@ /+2< C !

6 D $(4$ ,% $1 @ (, %+ 2, (, ,% '2240 @( $ +(%+ ?( /#224%(,$224$?(2,$+%0 $%%0%$2*%%0$%3%/=!858 !

60 #$% $ 2, $ +% /(%4 6EF7- (, $ %1('224)3,%+(% ,$0$2-%0%(%4 $(@9/%?(

6 ',,,!

6G <(%F 8H(,%)7 $ ., ?( 0 :7 G% $% A$ DH0 2, /(%4 6 67

%'224=B%+(%>675!" %'224$%3 :!7!" % '224 )3,%+(% ,$ # ,, @ ?(%, % +(@2 +(%+ /2* A% $ ,12+/ , (2B 2, @* $ %* %@ 12+/ ($%*%+%)% ,@#)% !;

"0 7;

"0 :!;+ + B0 :!;:60 :7;:" (%4 +% 12+/ 2 % (%4-%%@/+2<C!

6 D$+%2,$%@9 (,%)"

$ 0%20+4($$*$1%,$% /,$(2+,($$%2,'224)$ #$$@(2,%0$,2,$@?(%,$(0$2,?( $ @ ?(%, 1 $ 2, $ @(2,% % ,%4 $ @92,0,2%(,%)5$ #(, 6 !!

6 <(%F :H0$%%0$+%+$@2,$2244 ($?(+%,4 $ 4%1 $ +% $ $* % #% 2, /(%4 6EF7-(,$%1('224)3,%+(% ,$0 $2 -%0 % (%40 #$% $* $1 %, %( $ $(,%%,4$%0#$%20/1, /2, (%1$@+(%,%?(%$$($+%,21$ 12,$+%1%+, $ ,0 $ #% / 2, @* $ % # 2%0 (%4 @$2 %+, ! "0$$ %,0 (@9 /%?(0+%$I212+/2F! 6 +(@2$, " !

!(,%$(9@)$,(2, ,,%22, % % %4(2,12+/ 0 :56+,($$24/ $%,)% 7 "#$4,0,$12+/2C !

!"0 $ @ %//, $ // $,, @* $

,/%%0 0(%4$%F24/$%,#%+%, $ I2 12+/ 2 C !

6 , " !

!0 #$$ # /(2(2* %+%, $ )%2 +2 )% 70 "0

: @%4,%#4GH!

8!;!

!,,!

!2+,( $$//%//,,%F24/$%,,(F@2* $4%(,%$%$$$32*@(2(+%0#$$#+221% ++(2 1224 @, '224 )3,%+(% ,$ # /4 $ %2%+%+,%,24/)% 7 "/34$%,24/ F@2 2+2,(+42/4,$+%)%2+2 )% 7 "1%%,$$%,24/#$4,1$ $32*@(2(+%((%,#$*?(%$%(, $($+% $+%,4$-4,,

0%%%,$ #%/0$1@++,, <(% F!;6$%21<% $+%,4(,% J

#$%&'()(*(+,-*" #$%&./01#+ 1-$#

//,%2%// )%F:!0(%4,(%41//(,$$ %1( '224 $%30 2, 1224 /+2 <4 3$% 65;;: / , %9 <4 +%22* E$% 65;;!6 #%,%@$$3$%#$$/4 %, 24/ * (, 1 $ %, , /,%0%%,,@%24,+%/$% $$%(65;;!6+%,2*$2%0@($ +2$32(/@%%22,%9 : 6(,%!

%4%//0$$3$%,@3+(?( $$%,$%%,G+%I-F! ! , -F!

!"H $% + + 2#4 4%0 $ $ %24/ #22 2 * 2, ++2,;4%, % //#$+$24/%,$(2,@/,, ($/%$@$$+3/*@,

//,#//

" $//4%#$$+%+2%2%//, %//,++%12$%24/$#$$,+2

#$%&'()(*(+,-*" #$%& . 01#+21-$#

//,%2%// )% ,(%410//(,$2,$ $/-%E$<43$%!:;; /, ! /$%1('224.3$(20#%,#$$* (, /9% +% $ 2, ,$ /4 $ %, 24/0+%I-F!

!! ,1$$$ 24/$%%,,@%F24,($/%0$ #22 //(/ <4 %((% %( <4 +%</*$$$12@$#$$,+2#$$ 2%2* $# $ +%+, %F24/ //(/ <4 %((%

//,;(44#// $//4%#$$+%+2%2%//, %//,++%12$%F24/$#$$,+2 +% / $% $ / $ /, @1 -%E$(22*/,%$,E$

#$%&'()(*(+,-*" #$%&/"/"/0/

//,%2%// (%4+%,$%2+2)%:!!0:60:7 :"@%$//%/,$@(77

/24$ . ++2+4@$$+%+,%,1,4%,)% :!F:6 :7F:" (%$% %/, $ $ . ($%* 2* 22#,%4$++22@**%,%%%4$42, #2222#$++2%(@$$+%+,%,$# $)%22$+%@2//2%(%$$ ,,(%4$%(%,1,4%,)%5!F5", 56F57=$%$ ($%*,.,4$%(#%3 ++,,3, $4$24/$%,$ //%//,,%F24$%,$#$$, +2

//,;(44#// $ // %1# $ 24/ 1BFF1B 2 ++2*;4%,%$1*0($12+/2,$ . ++ 2 24/ , 4% #$ $ +%+2 %2% //,%//,++%1$%24/$#$ $,+2

#$%&'()(*(+,-*" #$%&0

//,%2%// $//+,$%,1,4%,)%

7F " , (, $ $ %$ $ %, +4 @* $ 1224 )3,%+(% ,$ @, @2 $ 4%(, @( $ $32*@(2(+%0#$$+221%++(2'2240/4 #*0#,,,%F24$%,@*4142+ G%%%2+2H1,$$32*@(2(+%#222, @(2,40<+@,,4,#$,#$$.#4%, $ *% !

$ // @%1, $ $ %((% 2*4 ,(0 #$$ @ ?(%, % /34 $ %, @2 $ 4%(, ,0 $ // 2 +, ( $ $ /,, 24/ + $%(4$ $ 2, 4%, -; 2@2

2$1.,%%(+(4,-;'3., .,% 4(+%,2+2,2*$#$2,%2 +2 %/(%4 5%4%(+$(4, 7

% +2, 2* 22 $ +%+, %F24/ +% /$%$@$$%2*41

//,;(44#// %/,@*0(%4$%24/+%+,@*$ %2% // # +4 $%(4$ 2, 2, -; '3 .,@ -; 2@2 2$1., +%,%K0 # ?(%, , (, $ -; '3 .,@ $ %, * $%,+%*%4$$2,2,,@*$%24/0@(-;

2@2 2$1.,$,4$@(2,4+2++%1,,%, $%,+%*%4$%F24/$%(4$$2,2,-;

2@2 2$ #22 % 242 /+2 1# $ # %/0//$+$$+%+,%24/ %2%//#22@(%$%/,,($/%$#22 + $%(4$ 2, 2, -; 2@2 2$ 1 ., $ +%+,%24/#22#%((%G@,,.H 4%,#%$(,$%A D2%,2$(H$# $ $, +2 $ // %//,, ++%1 $ %24/ $ // 2 $ + $ /9%* 22 $ %%,)%C :"2%,*,?(%,,%( #%3(22#40$%24//*@++%1,$%2 ,?(%,$%,#%3)% :"#22@/+2,L

8 =$1$%,2%,(2%$+%24$,, /%$+%#%+$+(%+?(2*4 $ %, $ D@2 )(+%/ (% )(@ )4$ $% ' ) %* $% G!

H8)"7" $ %(3 ,# $2 $ %(%,A D0A D AD$2,$$2,0#$$%?(%,% %(%,%$+20@?(%, 4,$$,') %*G!

"H ) 5!0$D@2)(+%/(%$2,$$,% </+%((%%/?(#22/$#*($% %?(%,%$+(%+%,,$+2,$%1/$ @$2,$22#4 J 1##$,@10#,,*4,% #$*,%41$ )(@)4$1)%*0 G!

H8)"7"$(2,@41$#220(@9 %%%3%$+2, ,12+/$%

%,42*0 $ /+(4, 9(,4/ % , , $ ++2 % 22#,$22#4%/ $)%%*0%@+%/0)%* ,%,,%$@9$++222*% %2 <2( $ 2, $ < (+, @* $ %((% , ++%+% + % %(, $ %((% % $ @2 9*/ $ ++22 #1%0 $ ,% $22 / $ #* $ ($% %/14 $ %((%0%?(%,%$+(%+%,0$+2,$% 1/ ! $ )%%*0 %@ +%/ $22 ,, 2* $ < $ %((% +%% ) 7G H % (@?

+$+%+2,(/%/%2(++% $% :=<+$%+@20$%+,$22%*%$ %((%0 (2 @/ ,(2 % $/ $1 +2, ,12+/#$(%/14$/1##$,@1L %/ $ %, 9(,4/0 $ 2, ?( @4?(%,%%,0$(%%(($2,22$ +%92*4$%,,;%$22%*%1 #1%0$?(0#$$%,,%?

(%,@</, 0 #$$% $ 24/ $ %, $ @ $4, @ $ +%1 @(2,%%$2,F#%,%/%*,%@%%*/% %+2$1@+%,(,@*$+% +%(2+2 <(%F H$#$,94$@,'224)3,%+(% ,$0 $%%%(,%,2$($2%,24/1%, %(,+%#1%0$%F24/$%,<2(,($2%42* %(,+%,$2*#%$%/22%(,+%/4 $ %1, 2* ( +2 $ %1, +20 %, +2, 1% $ +2,2*/2*-;'3., .,0@(($$2,4%(+ $(4-; 2@2 2$1.

,2*/22%,$14F $,%(%/4$24/($%,/4G <(% !;6H%/42%$$#/(2+2%($%%42%, 24/0#$%$%1,2*(+20$%$%,2**%( =$1%$%?(0@(,($%,$+$ +%#$2,(@9/%($?(#1%0$, 2*%,+2%$$%0$%(/142%4(/@% %( % # %21 ,% 4 2%4 (/@% ,#224(@4?(%,0/$/22,(,%! %4%//0 ?

: (,%,0 $ $%,$+0 #$$ $ +% /* (% ( ?($%2,0@(($,1,(2%$41#*$+(@2 %)$2%4%+(@2%@+%%%,4$,1,(2 %0$%%0#,$$4%,24/#$1# ?(%*+%(2%2,0@(1$32*++(2,%%/?( 0 $ +%+, %F24/ 1% $ +% $ 2, 2* +%1@(2,%#22 1#$@10#,,*/%$+% #%+?(2*022$#%+%,/, 3!

3 !!4 '/2