← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2125/2011allowed

(O&M) Amit Sharma & ORS. v. Ruldu Singh & ORS.

2017-12-15Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan16 pages

      !    

"#$%  

       

 

  

"#$%           

 



&' '()) * '('+,'-

.   $*/01$ 2   22      

     !!" 

# $%

 &'

( 

 %)** +'

,  

-  ( ...

/,#01,#'/,0/"

! 2

  &



3   (    3  )  (  



&(    

45654667  

3  

 3

 &

 

# / 68-97:;$ 

  2

3&

&(  

3  

 3

  



< (

,2,- 3

     &    

# ) $=95>8$&

&(  

 

(

 

 



 

  

 

 *  

     

*     ?, # $7=

4:54667



48;9==89=65 ,-3

  



- 

  

    

3



 2    



@ 

   

@3

&(   A&

B

 

#  



(

 

  

 

2

 



@      @3

&(   

 

*  

&(

 ,3 9   

  3

& =:(   

 3  (

3 ,

2  -  ( #  

 

3   

$ 6669  (  4668 4667?

6$654667  (3

;:669  

,3 

3

  (



 (  (

    -   *

      3  56  (        

 3  3 2  -  ( #  

 

   ( $6 6669  :6669 

 /



 3  *  

 $ 6669 3

  3 3

  46 6669 3 



 

 

 # $

4



  

 



  3 3



C    3 

  

 * 



3  ( 

 '2

  3



  &



 



*  

&( 2

3



3 



 2  2 &  

 3      

      

 

      

  

 

 

 !"#$% &' ( ) *  

 

 

) 

 +   ,     -  +  .

*  

/0  .

    

*         

 ' 





 1 

 



/ 0 !    

  





 



    



 '

 /0(     

    & /0( 2     

  &

 &'      

   

    ( 

   .

 

 /0( $ (  3

 4

 



   

<$ * '<4  

,

2  -  (  

    ( 

  1D=    

  <= !3   -   -!  



?,$7=

4:54667948;9==89==7

=65 ,-

468 E   @ /

   

 

3D



4>$$466;/ 

-

# ) $= 5>8$A

  B 3 3   



-9  &

 3(

 

  0   2 ,  

 (

3

3  476$4667 486$466; 

  

3

D

<$3

 

3    / 

  3



C <  ( 

 '2   3 

   





*  

 

 / 

3

 3

 2 

2 &  

3

  

,3

( 



&



2 2 & 







  3



 

   * 

3

  '2 2 3



 '2

3

 

3



2 2 &  3



 

  

3 (  3

3



 

 3  (

3 



  

3

 

>

8 2   





$6 

 

   





88

87    $;=;2

 





 $ 4 



            



*    ,

           ' 



 ,

     &

    ' 

       '

    % 4 



        

*

        

  *

 '           *   '

 

 '   

   

   

 3 ,3

 



 (







3(





3(    

  

 ,  3

   

3



3   



  &



2 2 &  

 < $     

 



 



'2

3





,3 3 

&



&(

 

 

 



'2

 3 (   

 3 



3  & 

2 

3

&( (&

&(

3 

  

 5



  2 

&( 

 

?, 



     3& 



&(

2 & &( &



 

?,

C









&



2 &  /

 # $         2 & 



  

(   

3



  

   

 

2 & 

(







3 ((



   

3 



/  

  1D >  (

 3







 

 

&(





3





 3 /  

  &

 

 &(  <$       

    

    



D 

&(<$  

2  /  

 



3





3

 



&(

C ( 3

2     &  '

(  

 

  ,  

 (







2 & 

 

  

>

8 3 (



 3  

3 

3(





  /

 

  3 (



/  





   $62 (7'8 )('$)9982+&

:

.

466=A$B- -  - :74AG/B.  

8) '-;

<-

&7'-8  -=

2& &'



&7'-466$-!>=:.

> &2) ?7



&7'-8 2<,'2) ?7

&7'- $;;:-!>8;

 

+;

-

8@)9'2) ?7 466$A=B  -A- B  :74   )&  27 -+  8 

 7

 $;;8A5B -A- B;7.2'(-'& -=.++< )( &) $) )&-=.8'- +'

& ) . 'A -&+'

& #.'> '97)

&7'-8

+-  9)

+ 

&7'-$;;$-!487 /  -    



    1D >

  

  @@, 

'2  

#   

 3 

   3   2 3 & 0  

3 



A  

 3  B2   3

   * 

2 

 E@

,2,



 

 '2 2

 

  

'2  

 * 





'2 A

B

  ,2,

2

 

 (



 3



 (3 

 



 



3 ,3 



 D 

< $

3

 



     , '        &  25 " 4 

      

 

 

 

      .4. 6    

  .

    

  



  74      

  4   8

  

- &   

9  (

  

   

 &  

 

 .     

  



 74     

  .    

  .       

  .     

   74   .       8

         

52 ' .  

      8

 

   

'

  .  

 

     

 * * :

:

*    &

 

  74    

     ' 

  .   

   

         ;.( 

 

    

3A 

B 2

  

 D 

  



 .   & '

     

  )

 !#-

.6  ;.(

 !  2 .     . 

  

    .    

          



    .  '

   



 4 

      *    . 

    

    

  

  





+    .    

     

  &

'   

 

    .  



     &

 

  .     ' 4-4-#< 

 &'

   &  2 '

   .   



  .  

'  .        .    

   

    

 3 A 

 <$  A  

B 



D 



 



   & 

3





'2

 B

 

 <$  

2 

 ( 

 D 





 3 





 





     2



   



& 



2   

3   (







 

&(

 





 3  /

  

 

 2 & 

3 





(&

  

2

  (

 





 

2 *  3 



&( '

(

&

  

& (

&



   &  2   







 

    

3   

( *

 

 

 )

  (



C (





  (



 

,



 

 (



  



  

(

 

 

( 

 (







(  

 

?,(

& &  



&



      32

  )-7 -)1 98

7'=27= +

&7'-. BB3" % B &



 === === === 4      (' )'

   &     

  

 

&'

 -

 6  >  "

    )  (' )' 4*               

  

 

(' )'        

 ,  === === ===3 , $ ++ 8 :)

&7'-. 4 35   /-  3

  

2 & 







  4

*     * . 

   

   4 &   ' 

    

          

  

   

 





 

     ;

  #    

            



    '

   &

     & 

   

   3 , 7' )&' )  <-

('1&8 ''A C'9

&7'-.$

 6 5.

456$46$5 3 



 /

@&   -   3 &

&( 0  /-  

 === === === .  

    



*     & 

 &'

  &  &   

      &     &

 



* &    

 &

  "

 -  6 4 &*  



 &     8    

       

  ? &'*  8 ' &

  4 &   

' 8 ' * 

*     8    

& ' 

*   *  ;.(    *  #

   '

    

       

 '

  *      

 &

  

  &      







  

 

       '       &

   &

   4 & 4*     

 



 







 3 2   2 &    

    (      

 

 

?,  

 2  

?,   



    



  



( 

 &

&(

 2 

  2 & 







,





2    3 





2 &  





 

 (  (

&



2 &  

 

  



-  





/



  (  4667

 (





  

    

&

  ! 

02F  *&

3  3  D

   <$  &(      

 (     



D 





  

3

 /

6567466: 6=6746672  



   

<=!3   -   -!  

 



# ) $= 5>8$3 3   





  &  3( 

  0     3 3

3    ?,# $7=

4:54667    / 

 

 (

  

  

3    47$4667 486$466;2

 45654667

    

  

/

3 



 /

             

 

 

 (& &(

  

 ( /  &

,

3

 

 

3

 

 

/ 

* 2 3

&(   A&

B

  

#   





 

  

 ,&

&(

       # $ ?F # 487$    46$$ 

             

 $76546$4 2



-# 48$55 -,, 46$53

  

  

&  

 

#  A 

   B   2   

3 

656446$:2  

3

C  

#   

  2  

   

   

    

D

* '  

,

2  -  (< 4/ 

 

 33  3,

2  -  (

3 #  

 (  (  $ 6669 /  (3

;

:669  

  4667/  

 (

 1D =3  &



&(

&

  , 

 D 



,

2  -  (3 

 



 D 







  3

 

 

 

&

2

3

$4 $=  (

   2  

 (    (  (

     #  (  3 

&(    F ( (



 

 

&  2   ( 

  

 &(  <4   

    

 &

3  3    (  , (  4668 67 3   (;

6669  

 )

2 &  

 

 (

 

  

&(,

2  -  (3 3

 @H@2 (

 (   466$  4667,

  

6$65466$ =$=4664  ::669  

3

&

3   (

 

  ?

  6$654664 =$6=466=  (  >6669 



?

6$65466= =$6=4665  (  > >669 

?

(  6$654665 =$6=466:  ( 

8 4669  

?

(  6$65466: =$6=466>  ( 8 7669  

?

(  6$65466> =$6=4668  ( 7 5669  

?

(  6$654668 =$6=4667  (

4  ;

6669  

?

6$654667 45654667  &

 8 >669  2



& 

 (

3  &

 

 

  &



( 

&

3 3  ( ;

:669  

 

    

3=:

(  < $   

 



3=:(  

( 

 =:(   ,  &

 

(&  



  

 @ .

 @(<2 

A **5# 

@

B

&

 @ A  &      @   !2 'A (C2$ D 2<$5# @

5!

@

A     =

  @'          -  +      '

 A (2<$#2! D *$*5#  

@



     

$   ($ = $ D %5# @ 

 

(*5# @



F (2*5# @

; F= (2*5#  (%*%*5# 2        3

 

  $8

(& &(

%  

3

   8:I

    

 

  2

 

 

&  9   C     / 

* 2   A

B 



      

  *        

  

       

$ 6669 

   / 3  (

3'

2  -  (#  

# 30 

( ( $6 6669 



/ 3  

 :

6669  

 



 



 

 





3

 & ( 

 / 

  

 

  $:

6669 



2  

 

/ ( #  / 



$5  



  (  

&   



&

& 

  2 

 A%1D:

J (  1D 8B

       2 

 &1D $6  :5  $7 :$49 

 (

  2  -  (

( 



&

3  3 -  (   (  

3  $6 =4:9  



  &

D&

  J 2 



 

 

* &





(

&   

&  

 

  

   

$76546$4/

 

( (&

&(  -

5

 

( 

 D 

(& 

&

&  $7 :$49 

 2 

 

46 6669 3

3  (& 3 

 

#  A  B C 2  &  

3

K8:I    

 

 

(    3     2 &        

 

  

&



& $:

46$8  "   22 % 

   <   9

L <  & L 9#