High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18240/2018disposed of

Ashu Hooda v. Union Territory Chandigarh And ORS

2018-08-31Mr. Justice Kuldip Singh,Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa27 pages

!" !!

#$%

!" " #$

!" $$

()#

!" $ !

!&'

!" %&' '()*)+" *!)+*(,%-.)!/ & 0.).&1!* .!

*(,%-.)!/ & 0.)%0!&0(1&0(2

+3 )1 4&56 ) 7#)0%674 5 "

48 9:;

;

) 7#45 " ;

)1'& 4&56 )!&%45 " 99

)&'/45

4 ) 1"45 )=)74 5 "

) 6#45 %&.

;:8 9

)!75'!'4&56 )7"'!'

)=%4&56 )'"& 45 )&77& 45 ";:

8 9

)! 51#45 )!&%45

)%!1"45 ";

8 9

)&=1"45 " 84>49;4?8 9

)%#45 " ?

)545 )1& 45 ) =45

"??

)245 " 8 9

)&@45- ## ">

8 9

)=#45 "9

> 8 9

)!2 45 )!&#6#45 )!&'45

:8 9

)&#1 45 ">

:8 9

)A545 ">> 8 9

) $'&'45 "

8 9

) 245 "; 8 9

)&%45 , - . %66##" 56"@

;48 94 99 ;

5#5''# ''" B)%%&15')### "#4&> ,)### 4 , "5""' '&'6'"#C @'"#"@4"5 5 'C'' ##"#"5B# #''.C'6 @'# (# .# @#. ,(..

,## '

5 ""# )# ## 4 6 "5 " '= 6#"#

"5 #' C'"5 ##0 C@ '@@ 5#C'4' 5& B ## 0 C' " @ 6=@# ## 46#@""" ' "5 0 '%## (..

6 5 "#"+3 #% &. 6##(#.# @#'.

' )%%&<%2&

38?)4

& • "@# %&.#' 4 # #"5 ## 0!=21# #&54) # E'# # 4 15' 0 ## 9F##0 G &4 2'

5<# 5<& .&0:E)# % :

) "5 # & ## ' 0 • # (..

1 ' @ #H @ #<& 15'

'""6 # • ## # 9F##0G 4 2' 5<#

5<& .&0 : E) # % : ) 6## @ @ )<11& ## ' # &< 5<0##@

" "# @ • 2 ## 4 # @# 4 # 3#4 5 '4 # @# ## @ 5 " ' " @ "5 )#<2# ## /0)**)*&%11*'%&* ,2,3)114'/'&56785 999 ,

5'6'%6' 113)8;7&%*'%&*%<%)1%41'+3 ##0G& &15'G& #0< 5<2'

5 5 &<) '<(!0G&5 )#<2### 5 5 5 ##G&I

# @# 9F##0B@#6+3 D"99

$=99> ,, 0(#4(!0(!04*5 H 0*0460* 0*: E (## @# 9F##0G& @ '& /:$ & '& /:$(* .-010%-. 9F ##0B& /:$" ## 0&'"0 #'# @#4 '@'#&# 2#66##@ " '## # 6 '" " ## # 3# 5 ""CJ000 # &# 2# 6## @ 5 ' ## @ # '4<' ## @ ## '# " ' @ ' '& /:$""(..

1 '5)#<2### 5<2' 5 ' E )### E)4@7 # #' # @# 5 15' : # 5 # >

? ?

; : #

;

; ;

;"5#5 ' 15' 15'

# 57@##0 G #4 &5 #@'# @# 9F##0G" # ( E( ?

< 9

;3).<).

421##&54) #:E'## 415 0I

'5@6=@#6+3 D,, , - ##0)- B# ##@ ""@ '=@( 0*(- .-010%0-0 A ).( !(. .& 1 ##@')%%&<%2& '## @ ##6 #C 5"#%&.6## "5 ## 0 != ' 6## 5 ""# ## '###@6@ ##0!=@' ' )%%&<%2&6"5 ##@ @##'=@(#.# @#' .

- 9 99,

,, $= 99>

;

' & G & ## @ @7 5"## @#"5# &< @ "5 &< ''' 5 '# ## "5 ##@"""#@##6 "5# &< ')%%&<%2&5)# ## ## @ @7 "# 15' 0<&< I @'"" ' C #H'"64 ..C' %&.6##"5##0!=' 9FB ##0C6##5 &6 B@ ##"@ 5 "## @#"5@"5&<

4 ''' "@#"5##0 = %&.6B 6 ' 21#4) #415 0@"5 ' ##6 " ""# ' # 9F##0B+3 D 9,

,, $=99 > %&.6##"5##0!=!#6##@ 5 21&4) #E'## 4 15 0"5'' @ ' 6## 5 ""# ## '###@6@## 0!=@' @7 ""#@## ' <## 6##6' # "5 #@' ""# '<## @&#I

"##

4 ;; '

6 5#5?> 1# ' "" C# 5#@# *&)&7&)+<'60'&'/)(%111'8' *?)&%1,'(&6 ".5%/)8%65 : &%1 *'%&*+ : )*&6)47&) *'%&*+ F!5 ( ##0B 9F 9

## > E 0& (!0

4 # &# & 9FK K

#;;

6 @# 62 >FKK

K ?>KK 0?6&%& 1# K 0 ## " 5 < @

#6 6#'@ '#"# 9 6#'@ '#" 9' KK &5#@# 1# "6 2@#62' 4@7# 5

' '" " 5 62

# @#'" ;;

@#6+3 :"+ 1)8)4)1)&@(6)&'6)%%/%/0)**)?6('/76' 6!! 5%/)8%65 1 *'%&* 1# 4 & 4 62@#

' # ## #5 ''6%1

1)8)4)1)&@6)&'6)% ?%8'!:

#5" C' B# C'

#<## H @ ' # #<##

" 6 5 "<C35' 5 # 8<<>30>3

;< >

;I 0 99

" ' ##

4 ,

4 , "5 # @# '## @#65" C' '#<## H@

4 6"5 @@C " @ @ & 7@E4 7@ ##6 @"@+3 D

# @@ 7@ 7@ ## @ = ' 7@ 15' 2"' # '5 ' 300%#<><893>00<8?84? /488?402< <8?3>3 < 8;?; /#4 88 02<><893><00< /4888

@2"' #4 4 ' ## @ '5" L L C'

'7@ 6"< L L C'B5#C' '

H #< 46@ 7@ ###@# @# 0 56 7 '

;

@ ,@# 7@ # @# ' '

6##@#+ ##5"< #C'# L L '& 7@I #''#& 6 @ &@ B 6# '& C@

C #'" 4" ## &B'@' @""#6@# & ' 6 B # @# ' # # 5 @ &7@5'#

6# # @# @ '# " B# C'L ' H#<## 0C '"

4 @' .5 # # @#6# '" *"#@ 6 6 '" "5 6 D

4 I 0 @ @ " #'" "#&#@ C# '# #'&<

4 " 5@"5 "# 4" ' "6""#&## '## &@5@' ##

4 6@ 5"6 @# 5# #@"5

4 # & ( (':E, (' 2*%:

(..

5## 0!

* & ""# &B ## ## "5& " ## %67

7$' %67

1# 9

7@ 15)# ## #

% # 6$'

1# ?>

%2&' 10)&4!= > 2 25& 2 >

1# ?

%2&' 10)&4!=

$" &$" ?;

%2&' 10)&4!= 9 2 57& =$' ?3 888 1# ?8 %2&' 10)&4!=

"55 '@ "5"5"" 6#'#5# '@4 5 ""#& ## 0 ' @5 C#@'@@0 "#6

4 " 6#5#'"##5#5" "## 0C@"6 # @#56 #"#""5 # @ '566'%4 '@"6 "#6

5 C" ## 6@=/#"6 # #6# 6#@

5'# ' 6@'6' ' # 5'' # "5@ '"@"### 6'

> "6 '7@ '@45@ 5"" ' 5## " 0#6 6%/''?%)'&('&(<* ) /)% %/&5'6*"8 0!&

4M@#&"' 6#'"H #@'##5 6#'5@'@&15'@ '# @ "5 @ # @ # 5 @ # 6 # 0-=6 "5 #" '4'#6#@"'@# ' "" C'" @5'@M@# &"'2"/M"+3 D # "# 15' 0' 5@ B'#" 6 56=@@# '"5 ' #' )%%& @ ## 0 .

#= '

#B6'@ 6 # @ C 5 @

B'#" @@ 5 '"## C# ' ' 5 & @ ' 7 " '" $ #4/ # '= / &, " !"+ N!5 '3@ =" = @ ' '"AC# 56 '''B# @4&'##4##@# @'"##C#@6##5& " 6'@5#@#4'@=""

'" ' # 54& #='"#C# = "546##@' "5@# " "4 " ##4 ' # #4 # C### B#6 ' 5B#@ B#" #63' @ # ##4 # 3 # # 3# '# & "# " 4 @# 54 7 7' "#"# 6= 6 "# " '"5 '3' #76' ## N 6##6@5'@#

9 / 6 5# ' 6## 5 ' @ ' & 15' @ ,'#,B'6& @ #" 65" B# C'#@5& C# ## B'4 # ' # 6## 5 @ #5@ 5# # I 07 '@M@#&"' ;??

# %A/''?5*5<*,&%&' **%0 %/&5'6*;

4'#566=""5 & '"5 " #' 6"B# C' '& '

# ### '@56#@& 6#@56##6 "@ " 6' '@" 5 "5" C "6#

? 0' &<

4 ""# 0C "6 7#566 #"5C '@ #6#6 '"#@6#5@'#@## # " @

@ "#

74@ "# 6& 7@

'@&' 6 ## # "@@#="66 " ""# 7@ 4 #6&4"5 @ ''# # @# 5 " L C' ' H#<## 4 6 6#55 #' " @ 7@6#@"5'## 6##

4 4'@@6@ "6##@66" # ''5 @ # @ >

4 " ' 6

#C@# 06#@ #5 6'

4 ' 6#%65 #C"#@66=@# 6' #' 65 #' # 0 @#6'' '# '"# 9F##0B6# ' &'"9F##0B#6#@ # '&

#C ##@ =" 6 5 " ##

;

4 @ 4 ' 6" 6' ' '"#'5#@# ""#@6C' 5 6 6 5 " 566" "#& @#' @ "<#'& 4 ' ' " "5C" @

&, " , '6# #5 5#@## '#"# ""##5 ' 6=B

"5#"7 ' 99

#OB%B*5%'5&%<* .5%/)8%65 %/&5'6*M?8

6#& #/ # B@@0-""#" 7 '4'6" @ B #66="" '

@ "46#@""" # " @ ' # %60%/% %(5% /1'<*,&%&' %/5@% 6%/'*5%/%&5'6"

&8 86">9M@#&"'@5 15'"6 '## "#@ #C "6 7#56@##

'#"50 "#

#6#"5 %#4"# ""##@@" "5"""@"' ## #5 ""# &!75 ' !'4 # 5" ' "" ''= '#@' @5 7 ' # %61''5''0%<*,&%&' 7A%4%/&5'6*"

966"L C' '# 7@6### @# "# & 7@@# ' C" @5 @#6+3 D90" L C' @"@" '## 0" L

C' '# 6#' " L C' '& 7@4 # # " # " @5 &"' !' & ( / 7&

& 99 5 ##6 "6 #15' '"# "

8 1#4 ' )%%& # '"#6= & 7@# " #' ' )%%& "6' " L '

& 7@ 6 6= 6

& 7@ ? 7 " &"' = H "#6@'B# 6#5" L

'& 7@<#@ 6 '"# & 15' 0< = 6" 7@6

7@ 15' " G "4", 6=

1#47@46#@# "@"" # '" 6 ' 654 6# " 6

" 5 " C' '&&# 4 6#@#@6

"C' '& 7@4@ @5 @ 4 6#"# & 7@4@ " & 7@ " 6##C'" ;-# "@' ##= '' &"'7 '"@ 5 " L C' ' H# @ "# & 7@4#@6# L C' '& 7@ 0564 '3 56 6 @ @5 @ ,@# &"' 7 '4#@

#C(@47 'C "#C 7 '@0 6 46#' # 5 "4 "'B # L C' '& 7@6#@ # ## " L C' '# 6"# & 7@ 6# ""#6 ##

5"=" '#' #6@ 6@##

"I 0 7 '

9 0-! 7@

# 45'@A)&,)85<*5%/)8%65/0))*&6%&).5%/)8%65 @5@#6+3 > 0 #

"@ "

" #4 @ 15''"# & 7@4 =#B# #46& 7@ @ "# 7@4'#@

46 7@15' '"#@C# '

' )%%&<%2& 9FB 5 " L B# C' ' #< ## # @

" "'# # 6 @5# #6#6 @&"' !'

& ( ,"4646 " L '

46@ 6# L C'

'& 7@4@ "# & 7@44@" & 7@4# 6

""#6#@""#@#535 6## "# & 7@5 ' '4 4 " @ '"#"#45##

"B# L C' '#4 @ "5'@ 465#@#)# ## "# & 7@46 L 4 6 " C' ' 4@ 5 " '& 7@&'# @ B@ 546 " L C' '& 7@ = ' #B "# "@"

> # 15')# ## "#4&> 4 4 @#46'@ & 7@@ ' # ' )# @ "# & 7@ "3 '=# @#6 " L C' ' & 7@ ##@&"' !'& ( ,"6# @""#@#6" L C' ' & 7@4 "##6466# 6 "" @ & 7@4"5 #46 6B@ # ##@ 6C"#"546 I

B# 6 "" # C" '@6 65 ""@57 ' 0 7@6#@@ " # #L ' "# &" 6#@ 7@@6#'"# 6= "# @& 7@

@ 5 ' ' @ " & 5 " '@ @ ' & 6## 5 06@ #'@ "#&#@& "'#'@ &C"'"## 0B4"##66#' ' #6 ' #H"4"= &B4@ ##"@ "@@&

#"' ##0'"" 9F##'##0B6 ' 5@ ##"@&"## B0 ##0# 54# 5#5@= &B6&B @5

4 ;;P 6 5C##5?> 1# 6#' 'B&B6# " 5@'@ "#& 5 @ "' #' &

.=66@@0 6 " ' "##'@" 5&'##@"#' 6=@#" '5' D&BI 6## 0 @#@ "5@#&' '6 &# "# ' @

4 45#

## "

" '@ ' @ &6#5@ 6&@6#5## "" B6##

''#66# 56 '= ' '@ "56@ (..

16## 6

B#=B@ ' @#6+3

6';7'&1@*B'/;7'*&)*

,6 >7'*&)

'?1@ 0 ' ' @ 2# '

" #0 ###' D,&%&' '1)8)4)1)&@

6 $=11/)%>7&% C &@=@ '#5 654 # ""# # @ 2# # < # @# 9FB 6## @ = @ & '

# @#4 6## @ 5 '6

#@'5 '

5@ '"## ##"6@"5@#6 D CCCC

' #<6 @ @ ! ')%%&<%2& &<

C" # # @ )<21& > ' #<6 ""#< ""# 65 ""#@# #6

')%%&<%2&4

&G## I

6#"" 5 &B@## # &6'@ " "#& 6505# 6&6" #' @ &<@@ '#' '&56''@

6" 5"6 4 @ ## <# # 6# C" ' '"" 66'' "

4# #@@''"

"/,"4&@#"5 " @= # 6' &

@ "#' @54 6 5 # @ 5 @@6 '"

4 "#' @ @

6# # @ # @@ ' '

4 "'C"@' C #@55" >

# # '6##

;

'"@##=@=6 6"'#5 @"##@#'6#56 ""#@""@##654,@'

#@# '6=6# =6'" #65 @ &6#@@ '#' &<

4 ' 6##4 4H ##'@65" #'@ &6#@# '

4 (###0=(..

##@=" #' = '

4 "" @5' %5'*56<'6 7/8'

%5%4)6,)85,)/57 = 7/8'

"= < A<( "@# A<(