Surender Singh v. Union Of India & ORS
!" #!$%&'%& #!$ #()'%& " #%$%
*('%& " +++++
"*"' ($ " "( ,(-"'* , .,- "&$"
/%0 12 3 "- " ,(-"'* ( !( &
&*
$ "*&( ( * $ * " "*(( 4-5 6 77 '
- "" ( "* &' *"&"(( 8$$
$ -
' " * ,$(
, &* &(,9$"( (
$((
&
-5 ($' "$ "(: &($(-' "*,- #(4* * ,& 3 $ $* *,- #(4 ; 7
;' < 7
6 !) ,( $
445 &"" - ; "
;, $(,'459"(!=$ >( >1000 &( ? ??539@4?%!
5 413 4 & 0$ 7
6,(
445 "
$ %55@3 @A9? 5 3
&45 ,(-&B A@ $&* (B A@
(-,,( &B ?
'',-* " B % ; (- ,,( &' *
& ,- ' ,- * " B 3!@%3!% C#( -$$
9 % @
6 ,(- 7 * ,& $( - * @!#%@3
$>& E %% @4A9A9 %3! 3
(&$$ - %
0, %
5> &($"(-$ %< ? , " #(4' " * $ & *
$ 7
; % $ ' "* ,(-")" &* " #( 4' * ' * * ", &('(- ,,( & 3 " ($ , ,(-",- $ $ * . ,- " ,- ,(->* "
* ' * &('*,,( & ' ( ,(-", ($
3 . ($ "
/%012 (( "* "
" $'" & ( "(- * ,- - & " ,(-" "(-' ,
"* , & *
$
, $(, ( *,,( &' "( ,
,(-"3 (&" "
"(- <3 " #(4" 1 F 1 ; 7
;' " *
$ %55@3 @ A9? 5 3 &45 * *"("$
#( - 9 % @ * C ,(- 3 " *
& ,- F ' * * ,,(G&, -* *, $&* 7
;
* "-, 3 ' (
?F?#' "( ,(-($< & (( " &
* ,( $ " , &( $& "*
$ %55@3 @A9? * ( & ,& * $3 ,(- " , "(- , #( 4 " (-
,,( & " &* "(- & $" & $ $'
"*
$ ?' " * *$"$'* -
"', "*
$ ' * (-'& $ $ 77;@& #(4'* 0$ "' &
& " ,(- * C D ?' * "* $ $*
$ ', (- ( "
* (& $*
& 5 ' #( - " , "(,- "%0!1 $( -' , "*(
(( -
-$"$ ,$ &,( $ -
* $* *
"(:&3 (&" #(
- "'* ,0,- " $(& < !"#$#% &!&'"
'&!!(&(*(
((-
'
;
8(-<
&( * E - &(* 445* * 4(-/ 2% $ * -3 * 8$$$( (( ,&$"( *& - ?,($ ', ( "* $% * % # >( " 59H 459"('!=$ >( ; C
&($ - -? % #>( &*"((- $ % - " , (
$ " " * $9 ($$$59H459"( >( < ?' " $(& "* *""& - 77 (( -
' ( &(" * (& ,* $ ,, &* "* 4-5 ( 9
* ( /2
( && )*+, '-. ! ' #'#%'/ '/#".&! $* $($ ( $"(-* $ $ &&("' $ ,, & , ,(-",$(- " #(4* (-
(- ,,( &3 (& " "
&& )*+, '-.!0 !&!+1
3 ( ""' (('
"*(( 4- 5 /452 ,(
$"( , $ ,- 3 /3245= )$"' ";74'45
"' * 5 9"(' 45' #( 9 * ,E(- ", (#(4$' 4 ( C
3 #( 4 " C
( $
$I!9* &%!
* #(#!J( $ & 45 3 " & * E ''
'; 6 " (& "" " " "
,(* I ,(- &BA $& * (BA
(- , &B ; (-,&'*
& ,- F ,- * " BA' 6 ,(- DJ 3 " * " , !&*#(4;
"
&E''
';6(& "" ""0,(* ,(-&B A $&
* (BA
(-,
&B ; (-,,(&'*
& ,- ,-* " BA' 6 ,(- DJ ;4 ,&"' "*
$& "
-( *
$ C ;
C 3 " ( * "' , /2 >
', "-$
D ,(- " *
$ 6 ;
"- ,& "' " "&& 6
"*"
& 6 6
&* ,& $ 6 3 " . ' * $((- 0$,- #( 4 ;
3 $ " 0" ,- 4 E;(&"
,(* I ,(-& ; (-,,(&'
*
&,- ,- ',- * " J 7 3 " * " , !&*4 6
'* "E ''
;" ,(*1 I ,(- &A $& * (A
(-,,(
& ; (-,&*
& ,- ' ,- * " A' J
4 ,&"' "*
$ & "
-( *
$
9*&',(-" * $' ( "" ) ,&$(
3 "
& & " $"(
-
E( - & ,(-*( ,,( &$&' * & -% (7 C
*' '( ,(-"
( 7 C
' $ $" "-,( ,(-
$' :$"(- & -%4 $ (& "" "" " ,(* I5 $ $" "-,( ,(-
$' ,(- : & * -K%L ,(- ( ,,( G&$&@0$"(*(, ($ () ( ' "( ((' * ( - - K4L ,(-*
",,( &$ &
& ,- G&$ & ,
0" ( *)'
&$' ,. 0$ * "(
: ( ,(- *(,0$"(J
%, ,& -/2*( * *,*,(-( ,(- I,,(
&$&JI
&,- &$ &J (',(-$
( (*(,"-,(
% ,0,&', " ;
'(( $(" &
$ ,(- * & *
& ,-
3 ( " * & E " * E * (- $ )"
* $(I(-J,,( & -4 ( 7 C
*I(-J*('
'& * ,(- ,-,,( &$&' *
& ,- &$ &' &
(0* &$&
;3 0"I,,(J * * 0" I
& ,-
&$&J'( ( (& 0"I,,(J, &$ &*$
C3 0"I,,(J ," $30%' 7;
* * I& $J 3 0" I,,( J $"( I ( , ,,(- $,* ((-'$( "',-J M "/2M $$ $ 30' / 77C2
L-' @' ( '" ' * ( ( ' *
(- "0$' - 3 ( ,,((- &$-,$",( ,(- (,
(-"(,( , (* ,(- * (&,- -%3 $" " &,- 0"
( ' *
$"
6 "' $(" ((- " ,(-*& &
(- ,,( &' *
& ,-3 $( * " *
$ ,(- $ ""$ $ ( & , $ ""$ %,"( ,&*( * "
$(, & "(
&&& )*+, '-.!0 !&!+1
$(" (-,",- ( 9
,- G& ' ,(-"'
E$ (- ,,( & ,,( $(-&*
( , ( $ $' $"(- ( ,(-"' ,
$& "*((' #(4 (- ,(-*,- " & * "*
$ $ $
(- &'*
&
,- "' ' ( &,(- "
* (& & ,,( & ?' * " , &(,,( &' "(
,(-" ( $,- "- $("'* , ( ",- " $(& $"
/%012 ' " (( ,(- "" ($*
&'
* *&(*
$7
;3 "," ,(-"' * ( !(,- ' * " *&('*,,( &' $ * ( * M $ *
",$( ,(( ( $* " $ $ " "- 2 3 #
'
") > -> ",(B ->