Rattan Singh v. Financial Commissioner Haryana, Haryana Civil Secretariat, Chandigarh And ORS.
!"
# $
&'
** # +(
* ) + +( ,
&' *- # +(
." ""
/$ (" '
0"" (0" ))
'
))
120( - ( #!
, " $)
( " !"
120(- ( 3) ( '
- (
! !
, " 4)$ " ! )$ (')$% $ )) ( "
() ."
*" !" ))
()
) (
( ( 56 7+
89 )) ! *" !"8
!
8 !" ( -3
0"
0
$ ))
"2
"2
"2
"2
$
( ' "
) ( "
2
"(
"
($"
'0 0""
)
)) ! "- ($ $ ( ."
$ : -
$ 7"
( ;
$ <9 ( "
3)
" - ( $ 120(- (
!
$"0 !"!
'
) ) "
('
!" 0
" ) 0"" 0
$( ( "
2
(0 !"
( $ *" !"8
"
%$"
0
(""
$
"
$(
2
) "
." 0"
'
8*" !"
' !
%
0 (( ( (=5
)
0 ( ( " $)"
(
0+))
0)
0""0(
%
57+
>9
=0
0""0 () '" $( ( (0""
"
) ' ! (
( (=5 (5 ( !"
%
" '2 !
)
$ 8
$ )) &' ?0 !
("($ !"
)
'
0 $(
2 - (%
"
!"
) !
) ( "
))
( ( ( 7+
89! !0 !"!
(
2
0"""
"() ( "- ( 0""02
((
/$
+ !( $ 8 0
(""
( $ 0
2
( $ 0""'(
2
))
- ( $(
( ())' !"
()
0!
." ( (7+
890"
'
' !
0""0(
( ! @$(!
( ( ( 7+
>9
0"" 0 "
' ! - +
' )
8 !"
0"" )) 0 ( ( ( ( 7+
89 0
(""
"
('
0"""
!
!"
! (
( - (0""02
0" !" - ( 0 $(
)$!
) ) /$' ( "$
$ ."
1
"$"
("
($)
"
(' +
$
?
( (
$"
>
! ( ( "
!"
$
7)
"
9
)"
0
( " "
"
%
"(
"
2 )
(
( )
("
))
& 0 ) :$(!
0
(""
$0
$
:$(
" )
"
$(
3)
."
0 ! ( %
&' ( ( " ( 0"0 3$( !"
"
(' 6 ."
1
"0 '
' ! ) - +)) 79
0""
$) "
!
5 7+
89
&
< $) $ 0"" 0 ( ( 0" (
( ( $ 0"
$
! $
' '
&!" $ 5
&' ! "
("
) ) ( ( (=7+
869 0 !"
'
!
' ! ( ) ' "
($)"
( !"
) ))
8*" !" "
- ( !
" ) !"
(
(%
"() ) " )
0
( ( !'
0 !) !
($
/$
)$ ) "
(
$
!>'
)
("
( !A
) !
$ *" !"
!'
1 ""
0
/$
!
" 0 $ A )$ ) "
(
*" !"
!
#!
4)$ 0
!
0"
8 !" ( $ "
, " (0$
!"
) ("$ 0
($ ) "
"
0
1 2
) "' : $
) !"8 )
0*$ ) A
0( ":
3)
*" !"
1 2
"
( "
( " !" A )
$
! ( ' )
!" 0 ("!"
) $"
() 0 (
) ! 0"
$
!"
!
!
( 0( ' )
! *" !"0
) $0
("0
)' !- ( = ."
)' 0""02
0 "
( ' "
"'
$
" '
'
0 !
0 !"!
"
! ("
(
0"
- ( !
) !"
) "
"*" !"0
"' :
$
)
8 !"0*$ )
0 $ 0" "
) , "
$
(
0 (/$"
)
(
/$
! ( "
(
$
( $
0 !
($ !"!
) "
0"""( ( $ *" !"8
( ! " ))
- (."
"
0 ' "
%
&'
'
) $
) '
0"" $(
." " ( ! )
0 )
'
!""
! !"
( (=7+
869)
%
&' 8
( (567+
89)
) -
( "
"2 )$!
' !""
%
&' "!
( ( !$" $) $"
0"0
!
(
0"" ( ! " 0
)$ $ "
(""
%
"
2
" "
(' ( !' "
( 7+
89)
1
" " $0 $)"
(
0""0( $) $ 0""
%
0 $(( ( $ 0"
$
$
' '
( &!" $&$
""
$) $0 3
)
0""0 3)
1
" " $ 0
(""
0
1
"
"
)
0" !(
"
('
($)
($)
(0 "
($'$)"
( $"
0" ) ! "
)$!
( (=7+
869"! !
! ("
! - ( !
( ."
%
" ( )) " "
1
" :$(!
" $ "(
(
0 ( ! $)
%
0"
"(
)
( ( (
' ( :$(!
."
1
"0" !(
"!
2
0" !(
)
8B8
"
( 0""0 ($)
1
"
2
0"
( ! "
% "
( "
" ( ( ( 56 7+
89 ) ' "
"2
"2 &
( " "
$
)
0"" " 0 2
'"
) !$)
3)
(" " ' ) "
!
' "
0" ) !"
)$!
+ !("
%
""
, "
4)$
$(
' !
0"
$2
! ( "
- (
!
!
0", "
!
(!
& ") !
!)"$
!
, " "
)
' ( 0"
- (0
$
4)$ 0""
)$ ( )$!
"
( " !
$"
", "
!
') "
$(
/$'
!
$ (0" !( ' * '
$
$
!"
) "
$!"
(
"0 $(
(/$
+ !("
$
)
')
! ( !"
"
3 )
('"
( $(
(
0"""
))
0( '
60"
0
' $$"
$
0 !
! !"!
."
%
" $ $ " (""
" 2
"
0$ "
" ) '
0"
"( ' ( "
"
(
(( ( "
0""((
'
"
( (
!
$" ( "
" "
( 2 ( "
'
! " "
"( )
*" !"
0 A
'! !""
"
('""
"(
( "
'
( " $
( $"
"(
( " &
(""
$ ))
"- ( 120(- (
(
$
(
$"
( ! $)
0"
" ))' " )
) $ ( ( 2 ! (
( 0" "
)
+ ( $ &
""
"$
$
( '
"
( 0 !"
0)
'$)"
( !"
"2
"2 !( )$!
"
(
" (" !"
$) $
( (57+
89 %
" !"' )
( ( ( ( "
$ 0"
$
$
' '
( ' "
&!" $ &$
"0" "
&!" $
( (7+
89 $(
"
2
3 ) "
( 0" !(
$ '" !(0" !(
0
!
(&$
""
"
"
!
($ !"!
(
( $
( '- ( $ 0
0"
') ($ ! ' ' ! !$' & ""
$"
0""0 $(
)) !
- ( + !("
(
$
( "
( " "
(
$
( ( ($
"
'
$"0")
)
!
0" ! "
( ($ ."
'"
)) $ ' 0" "
($ ( (
"
'
'
$
."
)$ ! "
)
$
("$ "
!"'2
+)
"!
! 3)
'
"- ( $(
(0""
($
- ( (" !!
(" $!" 3)
:
) ( ( $ ))
- ( &
( " )
))
"- ( '$" $ "
$ )) &'
" !((
$ 5 0"" 3
$
0"" ))
'
,
'- ( ($ $ $ - ( "
($ ( 120( '$ $ 81 ( 8
$ ."
)
" ))
) " - ( $ "
120( '
)
$ $ )
$ $ $ 0"" ,
'- ()) (
) (
))
"- (."
$"
0 $(
"
"0 $(
))
,
'- (&
"$
( " $ 5
$ 0 $(
)) - ( "
/$
( $ $ ( & $ "
" ! "
' "
0"" 0 $(
'
:$(!
1
" " $& "
'
0"" ) ($
0
!$
$ %
"
( $"
'
'
!
( " $)) ! "
)$!
( ( = 7+
869 ) ' "
"
("0
( ((
"
) ' "
( $"
' 2
) ! 0 "
1
":$(!
" $ 0"""(
($"
' "(
."
"
($'2
") "
!"
() ) ' !") )
0"
$( !"
$ ."
() ) 0"
2
( ()) ""
(0" ) !"
)$!
0""(
'
'" $ '
" "$
( ( 0)
?"
$
( "
) (0""
" !
" $!""
( ."
) )
0""
""
(
" '
()$ ""
"
"
( (($
!"!
"
!
?"
(
$ ':$(
' )
$> !
0") ' (>
"
$(
(0"
0
$"
."
:$(!
($)
"
)
")
! ."
) 0"" /$
( 0""
( (5) $) $ ) -
+)) 79
0"
"
0
1
":$(!
" $( (7+
89 ) (
(
! "# $ ."
( ( 57+
89 ( 08 %" $ $ $
& ' $ $ # & $ $ $
( & $
$ ") & !
! $ $$ $
) * $*## * & $ *# " +
$
0 $( "
0 " "
&
< $) $((
( '$ !!
0" "
( ( 7+
89 ) ' "
1
" " $0" ( !"
) -
."
0""
(
%
0
3
( ( !"
$ 0"
$
! $
' '
( &!" $"
( "
3
$
(00" !( )
3)
1
"
)) ) " ;)
"
< 0
!
( $( "
$
(
2
' "
." ) ) $( ! "
(
( !$)
%
0 0""0 ."
1
" " $0" ) ( ( "( )'
( " "
"
$
"
('
!"
! (
( (- ( 0""
"
2
0" )) ! " "
- (."
1
" " $0"
!( "
('
! +
$
?
( (2 !"
0 (
! ( ( "
' "
&
< $) $
$(
"
2
%
0" ( ( ! "
( 6 ."
( %
( (=7+
869 0"""
)
" ! !
!"!
! ("
!"
- ( !
0" 2 !
'
$
0""$ $ !"
1
" " $
,
"#-./
01.1.":$(!
"
( $ :$(!
" $ $(
1
"
$""$
2&
$ ! 34
1. 3 5" 264!
!"#$ !34
-.3 5"264!
2&$
!"#$ !/ 34
/3 5"264!0*
"#$ 34
1. 3 5" 264 $ 7
!
$82& $ !3/4
-3 5"264 5 + !( "
$
( ( = 7+
869 0" !( )
$
( "
') ( ($ $ 79C7(9 0"
$2 !
)$'
"
$
(0" 2 ! )
0 ."
) " !
!
%
0" ) !"
( (= ."
) ' "
%
&'
$ "0
= + !("
)
'
) )$
!
"
2
" "
- (
! !
>) 0 2 )
!
' $(
+) (
) ' $ , "
!
(
'
(0"
4)$0"
!
."!
, " ' !
) 4)$ 0"") "
!
"
2
* '
$
#!
, " 0"" $ " $(
$!"
$
""
$(
!
'
"
$
!"
)"
$(
( !"$ $ "
') '
!! !
2 "
2 "
)0" "
($
- ( ."
- ( " 0 (
567+
89 $ 0""
0
)) $(
)
((
0 ! ) 0" !( )
"
" $ 8)) &' (
) ( ))
" - ( +( ('
$ 8 ))
120( - ( ($ 8$ $ 8 ""
(
) (
$ 81 "
)) ))
( $ $ 8$
(
) ( $ 810 $(
0"" ( 08 %34 & $ $ *# *# # 3*4 " ! ! * # $ $$ * $
+ ?'
(( ("
""
!
> () ) "
(( $ 81
$ ))
) - (."
("
!$( !) ) ))
' ) - (+)
) () ) 0""
)
"
2
0 (!
( ( 4 ' $ $ (
3) - ( )
< !'
!
( )$
3)
( )$ 0"" $( $( "
( ! $) (
"
()
0""
2
+ '" ! (> '
0"" $)
$ ' ))
- ( )
)
$"
'
0""
'
($
- ( +))
,
'- (( ('
$ )) '
6 0"" ( 08 %
9 $! $ * $ :: 34 $# ;
3*4 < #
$*# $$ ;
34
& $ $ *# *# #;
3$4 ! ! * # $ $$ * $
;
=3 4 $ # ) $ * $ ;> =34
& $ $*# *# # & $ 9$> =9 <: $ *:$& #) ="#> )$ $) $
$ & * $ $) $ ! * * & $ & & 1$ <: $) $* $ $ $ # & 1 < *
!-.9 <: $ & ! # )) $ $
& * $* $ $
$ & $!) $* $ $6 )
< ) $* $ & < *$> 34 =::::::> +) $ "
$ 0 $("
0""
)
))
"> $ $ - ($ ' "
$ ) ( ))
"> $ $ - ( $ 6 ."
$ !
" (0 $())' ,
( )) 3!
"
) ( ? "$
(""
$ $ 0"" "- (
( "
'$ $ ("!
($
- (."
$ "
"
(
'
$" 3
" 0 ("$ )) ."
"$ "
)
" "
" - ( )) ( 120( '
$ ("$ :
( + !("
( "
""
'$)
)
(
$
(
!
) ("
$"0"
'"
)$ !
$"
)
)
!
( "
0" ) ! "
( ($
!
)) $ ' '0""
($ ((
."
'
(
'
"
' (
)$ )$ ( $ $!!
2
' "
0" 2 ! )
(
"
! ' $ ' ."$ "
(
(
(
) ?
+
(
) "
)
$ )$
(
$ :$ 0"
$ ' ?
(
(( ( ( ("
""
)$ $!!
$
(
'
(
'
( !
"
" 2 "
)
(
+ !("
( (567+
89)
)
( '"
1
" " $ ( (
7+
89) ( - +
$ 6 ?
0
)$!
( (= 7+
869 ) ' "
%
&' 8
( (567+
89) '
)8
$ ((
( ( "
' ( 5 ."
) "
( 0"0 = (
)
."
) ""
) "
( 0"00" ) $
" "
( )) )
(
'! ! )) $ ' "
! )
8*" !")
) ($ - ( "
"
( "
(
2
) "
(
!" # $%
& '
"
) 2 !>
( "
)