High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2216/2011dismissed

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Savita And ORS.

2016-02-12Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri7 pages

! "#

$%%&'(')

!"# $% %%%%""

% &'()*) )!% )+ ,

%%%%( " --- ) *+

, ,,

-%(%$)

% ,. / .0 + 1 , ""

% 2 ," )3,0 + 1 " 4 % 5

% ) ,0 + 1

% + 8 ,#"0 + 1 " 4 % 9%

% 8%8% , ,0 + 1 " 4 %:% ...

, / /, "" 6# , ""

!"#

3 , . %% "

6# !

0 ) " , 0 ;, /6 < / = 4 %:: 1 > 6# + 1 .,, , 3 ,

" 4 % 1 =" 8 !0 .,

1 ! +,

0 . . !" %

" 4 % , ,+

23 ,! 1 !" % /, 1 .,, 6

?%9%>0 =" 8 !

3 3 1 ! =7 6# ! 1 , ! # %@(9>A:% B, , , 4 3, ( 0 6

63 3 4 %@(??

,1 1 ;, 113 6

< 63 + , # 3 3 # 6# = )3, " 4 % ! 1 ! , 1 4 3, , 3, , ! # % ( " 4 %

1 , 113 6

, " .#%

1 , !"0 =" 8 ! 1

7 % 4 , 8 ! 1 (!

4. 0 #.

1 , 0 ,1 ,! C " @ " 0 1 ! ., , . 1 !!

# @ , 0 8 2 6 ,

!6 , 7 1 ! (" 4 %9 ?%9%> ) A> 9 1 , = . 3 = ) =7 , " 3 6# 4 , 8 ! " 1 , % " !3 ! ) 1 ,

&, 0 >??

, 0 ;, 1 >??< 6# )+. . D, +

1 =" 8 ! !"

3 +0 .

1 , 113 6

% ( "

, " 6# 1 3 " . !

, + 1 , " 0 1

% B,, ,

3 , 1 ="

! 2 "

1 , 3 3 +3 1

4 %@(?? 6# , " %0

3E ==% % B,, , " 3 !" 0 1 0 ., !

1 ! ., !E ==% % B,, , " % . , 3 + 11+ +3 , ! 1 , ,

+ , !

1 ,

30 1 ., 11E =(% 9% ( 1% , , " + ,3 ,

1 ,

,!% 3 , + + 6 ,

! 6, 1 1 , " 0 , /6 . !" , 1 ( %?0A0?95 , , 3 , "

+0 .

1 , 113 6

7 #

# 6 1 "#! 1 , !% 3 33+ 6# , . "

6# , /6 0 , ""

!"# , , ""

)+ D, + ,+ 1

23 ,! 1 , !" !

% /,

! 6# % ,. / .0

1 , ""

0 % 2 ,"0 1 "

4 % 0 % ) ,0 1 " 4 % 9

% 8%8% , ,0 1 " 4 %: ,+ 6 ,

% /, + ?%%0 6 +3 , " 1 , 1 1 "

/%% 4 %>? 1 9%%0 , ) " , "

. 1 , . . , 0 ., 1 , ! , " 1 6# , ! , .

"3 61 , /6 =,2

, , # 3+ 1 ,

!"# , , !# 6 1 . 61 , /6 =,2

! 1 1 , / 4 %9A 1 > , .,, . 6 33 3 ., , "" /,10 >%% , "

, 1

! "#

%& ' () **+% ) #

(!"# "

'$& #

)

) ,

- , ! . " 1 3 ! , ""

!"#

6! , , ,

3 , . ! 0 , , # "# 1 "" ! 1 , !

1 . 6.

, 3 ,

3 ! , 1 , ! # )+ D+ " 4 %:

, , ,0 1 , "

, /6

, ! 1 , ""

#3 !

, !

1 "#% 4 ,3 . , ! !"

3 , 1 " "

/, !

. , , 1

1 ! F" . % /, !

1 GAG ""

6# ,

"" " , . # 3 ! 3 A # , 1 5 1 ! , ! 1 . ,

" +3 F" ,3,% =B )+ "

, =" 8 ! .

# /, ., ) 8! = . )# !

$! , ! . ( %A5 " ! ,% ), , + ,

# 1 'F%= 3 .,, , ! 1 , .

( %A5 " ! ,% @ .+0 , /6

, ! , # !

1 , ( %:>95 .,

33 # % "" , , /6 "

, !

1 ( %9:95 " .

" + 1 ( %?5 " ') .,, "" 6

1% 3 #0 , # 1 , 2 ( %A5% /, 3 1 ), =" 8 ! . A # , !

1 A 3, # ""

6# , /6 % /, . , " , ! 1 , ! # , .1 )+0 D, + ! , )+% /, !

6 "3 5 1 , ! ,!

1 !3 5 1 , 3 , ! 1 , " 4 %:% =

1 , . , .

, !

, 6 , ! 1 , . " " % +. 1

, 3 1 , . A # 0 ,

" 4 %: , ! 1 , 6# :H . " " % 3 #0 , !" "#6 ,

, # ! ( "

( %0A5 % 3 1 , A #

% 1 ! " (7 , , G

" ( %095 9% "# 5 1 ( %09 F I ( %?05 :%

A % /

00>95 , !

1 ( %00>95

"#0 , !

1 ( %:5 . , 1 F"

, ( %:05 ., , !

1 ( %:5 . .

1 ! , ( % % 1 , !

1 ( %005 . ! 4 % ! " 4 %:

! ,

+ 11 % , 6 + "! 0 ,

" 4 %: , !" 1 ( %:0?0>95

6 +% 3 #0 , "" 6# , ""

!"# 1 ,

67 6#

" #

.% /, . %% "

6# , ! 1% /,

67 , , !" 1 ( %A0:>095 , !

1 ( %?0A0?95 . 6# , /6 % /, , !

1 !" ,

6 "

6# , ""

!"# ., 9: # 1 ! , 1 " 1 1 "# 1 , 3! 1 3 .,, ,

6 , , !

, 1 A%:H " ! 1 ! , 1

J % /, !

1 !" .

6 ,

67 !

, 5 " , . 1 , /6 ,