The Press Employees And Friends Co-Operative Group Housing Society Ltd v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
" #$$ $!%$$ $ $ $! &'
( )*)#+,- .
! "
&'
/ #
$ %
! % "
!$0 12 0!3# 4 4 !
4$! $5 !
12 0!3# 4 5 2
$! & ' "
() *+
!
' +)' *+
+ * , ' #' *-+*
' +)' *+
, ' ( (*+
!
5 2
$! .#3 .
!/0
* # 1 ! ,*
# , *# # # !
# # *! # 2 ! 3.4.567879
, *
) !
/0
*
* /+27.0*1 !
1 *
, ! .8.+ ! "
+ 1 * "# " + *78.9/!! :+
!78.9;0*,
*
.6 < 78.=/+2.50* >
!
" !? @ ;
)!
! / 0* * ! 1 # # !
#
* A
! 1 @
+ *
) !
/0
*
!
2 ! *)!
/+27.0* , * 1 @ 1 *# )
*
* ! !
# ! ! ! * !
! * ! 1
*
) !* ! *1 ) !
/0
*
7877 /+2750
B!
#)
!2
*, #
* !
# #!
* ,
*
! !
* # ) ! ! 1 !
1 *,
, , # ) 7889
!
* ! 1 ,!
# )
!
*!
!
*, , #
1
"$ $2$5 !
!
*
, * ,# 1 #
*!
@ ! *
* *
.*7*9*4B*4C!
) 2 /'-
20 1 !
; , ! ! * .C .<<<* 6 ! + 1 + *.=<6/!! :+ !.=<6;0*, ,
#
C !+ !.=<6* .4 !*,* ! .. !+ !.=<6* , 8< .8 D #
*
! ,/ 0*
! 1 , # 1
* , !" #E
C5
8< .8 + * !
! 1
/ 0*
* #!
, #E
357867888 , ,
!* .7 8= 78..* , ! 2 &
! " #
""
$
%
$&
'
"
"
() * +
, -
&.& #
"
) %
/ " ) " "
"
0
#
""
1
"
0 "" #
"
)
" "
"" "
1 ""
" "
) 1
2 )
3 =
D / 0 ! *
! #!
* ,
,#!
* * ! 1 * *2 ! * !
#
,*
!
+2.9*
*! !
/ 0*A
!
.8 8< 78.6*,!
, # & +
(" / " ) 7$8 7.$& $
$:;;$$;
$.;$ ..::$ $;$ <
;$ .;
. . $.;$ :
7 ) "" 1 -:- "
*" '
) (
=
1" /
"
"
;= / ""
!+ ) / ) > ) (
?"1 1
2 +2
1" ) $&8< $$&$$& $
?
+
/ "
1"
)
" $$&$$& $ 2
+
/ "
1" " , ,= "
"
" 0
" " =
"" @ ) = " #
"
"
) /;/5!6;$&$7 &: $$&
<
"A ! / 0* .8 8< 78.6* +2 .9*
* ! 379=.=78.6 ,* * 9.
8= 7878* , / 0*
! * !A 8C 7878*# B ! ;# *
!"# ,* #
!
* ,
/0
2 ! *! # )
! .8.+ !+ !78.9*! )
.8
!*
*
+2.= .=-*787.*#!
/0
*
*
, * *
1 ! ! 1
, .8.+ !+ !78.9
! ..
,*
/ 0*
* !
! !
"
*, *# ) )
!
/0
)!
/0* *
* !
*
! 1
* *
*
7877
.7
*
!
#A # ! , * *
*, #
/ 0,
, * #A
#
* .8 8< 78.6/+2 .90**
# / 0* 3 79=.=78.6*
,
# * +2.C !
*, !
!
)
* A
, # !
# )
! *# ! # #* +2.C* ) ! .8.+ !+
!78.9#!
'
* ! ! ,
/0
*
#
! !*,
!
*# !
!
)
, , ,
# # * # # ) ,
.9
!
) * ) ! .8.+ !+ !78.9*# ) ! ! 1 * * @!
!
, , 1 # # .8.+ !+ !78.9
#
* * !
! *,
*#
># F> F!
!! #
D
! # # *
A # .5 7879*
$%&"###&
'* ( ) *+
,- .6
, ! ,
.8 8< 78.6/+2.90*, ! , * !
,A #
*,
#
"
""
!+ ) > ) (
?"1 13 !
*) !, *, ! # ! * 1!
#
$$2%44 .4
3 ! !# *
/ #
!
**
,* #!
!
*, # !2
#A !
!!2 .8.+ !+ !78.9* + E
7. ! 78.=* * # !
, !
8.
8.
78.6 %. , , ?
"
" 0
= 2 0
2
:<7 5 " 2
:<76 ) "
"
() "" "
"
A
() "
"
0
B )
0 "
"
@ )
" ) "
) " "
() 3 .C
!# 2 )
# *, # !
* 1+ !.=<6** ,
*#
># F > F!
#
*!
, 1 ,* # !
* # 2 # *
*
2 ** !
! *! *# ,
.5
# ! # * #
!
*!
,!
A *!
A
&
/0 $ , 1 2 ,
& ,
' 3 4 25 2
6 & , . 2 2 & ,
6 4 , 7"!8 /0 $ , & ,
'
1 . , , ,
.
1 .,
4 1 , 7"!8 /0 $ . 1 4 2 2 & 1 2 3 2 ,
, .8 .=
B!
!!
A # !
*
!+ !.=<6
.<
1
*+ !.=<6*
, # ! ! 6* ,
2 *
# *# 1 !
*!
#
!*
! #A # #
*! 4+* ! / 0*
C !
,* 1!
#
/ 0, #
# ! ,* ..* #
!,/ 0*
#
,
! 1 *
.C*
* 1
#
*!!
# ! * 6*C*...C !+ !.=<6 !& !%2 , , .,,,
&5 6 ?
)
C ()
" " "
D "
1"
"
C D
"" "
%
" (@
C "
"
" "
" ""
"
"D
""
""
"
)
) "
" "
C5
"
"
)
"
"
6D 5$6 / "" ""
""
""
@
()
"
) 1 ,
) 1 ")" "
" "
, "E
""
"
E
" 1
"
1 5 6
E
1
")" "
"
1
E
)
"
")"
1
"
1 "
"E )
"" "
"
""
5"
6
) "
)
" ) F
# 4, 2 , 5
) G##
2
C ()
2 ,
5$6D
" " "
"
""
()
"
@
C
"
" " )
7 ,
5#6
)
) 5 ) 0 6
2 ,
5$6DE C)
"
" " )
7 ,
5 6, 6 "
= 2 0
52 G"
6 % <8- 5 <8-6
= 2 0
52 6 2
<:7 58:
<:76 ""
A
"
E
6 "
= 2 0
52 6 2
<:7 58: <:76 ""
A
"
BD )
D
"
"" "
""
"
"
)
"" " "
C*A"
, #
)
1
7 ,
5 6 "" A " *A"
$ , ?
""
""
"
)D 5$6 C*) "
D "" "
%
" (@
C
"
"
" "
"
" ""
" "
""
""
"
"
)
) "
" "
"
"
)
"
"
"
6
"
"" D
" )
"
#
A " ""
)
"
"
"
5.6 / "
"" " ) )
" "
E 1
"
C () D
0
" 94.2
&C5 6D %
A
0
""
"" 0
5 6
)
<
:
)"
" C
"
7 ,
5 6D
)
"
"" 1
,
"E
" ""
"E
""
1 "
)
"
"
)
)"
B C)
""
""
,
) )"
()
()
@
"B )
""
()
""
1
)"
"
()
" C5$6 H
,
5 6
""
""
"
)
"
""
"
()
1
0 1
5.6 /
" ,
5$6 ""
"
" "
"
)
2
576 H
>
2
<&:
8 <&:6 ,
5$6 "" "
"
D
2 ""
, / ""
"" 1
"
"
0
" "" "B )
"
"
= 2 0
52 6 2
<:7 58: <:76
""
*A"
, #
1
"
"" A "D #%. : , ?
""
1
"
""
C) " "
C() DD ""
+
A !
# 2 ) #
! ,! ! 1
* !,** !
# 1
*
...C* 1 #
#
* *!!
#
7.
?+ !.=<6* 1
,*
6= ! # + *
,,! 1
6= !#+
#
,,! 1 !
* ,
# )* # * !
! 1 # # 1 *
* # ! #
2
, ,,! 1 6= !#+ 2 & !7
,4
2
2..
, 5 6 *A
)
.8
() "" "
0
"
1 5$6 ?
)
()
0
""
""
0
""
""
"
2
"
" 5.6 / ) ###
2
"" "
"
3
;# *A *: - ; 1 ( *
, ) :*
<'#
,
* 7C 8= 78.<* 2
! 6= !+ !.=<6 DA / 0* !1
! 79 .=<9*,
, !,, ! 1 * #
!
*,
! 2 ! * ,*
, #
# )*,
# ;#
!! !
# 1!
!
!
* 6= !+ !.=<6
*
# ,
! ,) ! ! 1 * * 1 ! ! ! *
!
#
, ##
!A / 0& $. / "
$. !
:<.
) "
B ? ) "
" 7:
) ()
" 0
" 1
"
"
1 # 0 "
>
""
)
IF ) "
"
)"
"
() "
) 0
" )
?
1
()
)
A
* " ) "
"
)
" ) 1
" " ()
" A
)
""
1
"
I )
"
""
)"
3 5 "
6 .: ?
)
) " ,
" 0
"
7:
=2 2
" / " " )
"
"
" 1 ,
"
0 0
"
0 "
" #
1
)
"
"
7: ? ) "
()
"
7:5 6
2
&,
""
)
)
"
) ?
)
()
""
1
)
) ) "
"
"""
3
+
! # * !+ !.=<6* 1 *
, ,,! 1
! 1
#
+! 58 ! * @ 2 ! + !.=<6* * ) ! # !! ! 1 **
+ !78.9*, !
, !
8.
8.
78.6* # + !.=<6
# !+ !78.9!
* & 5 1
" 0
" "
";
"
E
)
";
"
E
1 0 ) "
"
";
"
)"
"
0
"3
..6 !+ !78.9 !
>" F # /.0 ! ..6 !#+ + !
.=<6*, # /70 !*,
* # /.0 # A
!
C ! + *.=<5/!! :+
!.=<5;0*#A > , F ! * ..6 !+ !78.9** C !+ !.=<52 !& ! 1J 6 / = 2 0
2
:<7 5 :<76 " 5$6 )
)
2
" ,
6 "" "
" "
8
(" " 2
:<- 5 & :<-6
"3 # 9,, , K?
2
7C " 2
D >"
2
"
"
" "" ,, 56 ) )
A
"
1
E 5 6
)
"
"
E 6
) " "
"
"
0
"E 56
"
"E 56
)
""
) " "
"
"
"
E
)
""
"
"
>"
3
/ 7C
!! ! # 2 *
! 76/.0 !+ !78.9*#
# ;# *21
= /
0 >> ,*# ! 76/.0/0 !+ !78.9* ..6 !+ !78.9,
C !+ !.=<5,
2# 76/.0 !+ !78.9*!
!
, & 5 6
7
2
$& .
"
"
"
8
2
:<- "
L)
) M
2
$& .E
6
8
2
:<- " )
"
) " "
" "
)
3
.8. !+ !78.9*
! 1+ *# !
!! ! !)
'
*
#
1 + !78.9*#*
# 1 1+ !.=<6
7=
!
*! , ! ! !
1 + ! .=<6*
! .8.++ !78.9* + E
7.
!78.=*#
, 1 !
1+ !.=<6* 1
, ! ,!
* #
! #
># F > ,**, 2
! ! .8.+ + * + + / 0* #
7<
.8.+##
, 1 ! !! ! C !+ !.=<5 #
*, 1 #
># F> F!
#
#!! ! ..6 !+ !78.9 C !+ !.=<5
# ! .8.+ * C !+ !.=<5*,
2# .8.+ !
*
, !
*# ! .8.+*
# ),, *! !
!
* ! ! 1
# , !
, !#
#,
*,
!
!
#A
* , )
#
9.
*
!> #
F#
@ 2
# ;# 1 ? (4
>/ 0 / 0 # !2 & -. "
"
"
"
0
"
"
"
# "
0
N"
1 "
"
) "3
D
,) ;:%
""> > ' ;# 2 !> #
F !! @ ! 1 !
#
*
@* # ,* # @!
#
#
# , ! # *
# # * / 0* & . # )
" 0
0
= 2 0
2
:<7
8
= 2 0
2
)
""
/ 0
B ?
()
"
" O #
" "
"
0 "
"
)
" "
"
#
"
"
"
"
"
" "
"
"
"
"
)
+
)
"
#
A
)
)
2
)"
+ ) N
""
"
A
) )"
?
)
" "
%
"
() " " "
"
"
"
)"3
% ! #
*2
# ;# *
!> #
F#2 *#
*
!
2
,!
! ! 1
#
* ! .8.+
, !
! ! * , @!
*
# !
! ># F > F ! 1 !
# -(())+*7+8,)7+97* &:7;*)**+77,)'
" 4 !
$ < " !0 2$
44
( # * ,
, # !
44 43&'$ &'
9C
DE /0/0#) * # !
#A
+ #
*
, !
1 *# ) !
.8.+*#
#A ! * 1 #
># F > F!
#
#A ! #! ! *#
#A
># F> F # ! *+ !.=<6* *+ !78.9* ,* ! # * %2!
- *>E # *!# # F**>E !
*# ! *! !# # ), > @F '
* * , # 1*!#1
#
# !
! #
*
1 ! * #> @F!
!! #
9=
+
!# ,
! ,* ,# ;# * # !
! *# !
.8.++ !78.9* ! @ 1 * #A
, !
*, # 1+ !.=<6, #
># F> F!
*#
# * !
2 > #
F
9<
'
* # !
1 #
># F > !
!! * > @ F ! 1 !
*
! *
,
*
) ! ! ! 1
) !
DE
/0*, # ! , ! A * #
B ! ,
# ;#
6.
+- B ! *,
>, , ) ) ! ! * .8.+ !+ !78.9F* $%&
! &
#* 12 1*+
, - *
- B ! * 8.
.8 7878*
,
/ 0* ,
!
! ! 1 * .8.+
!+ !78.9
#
*#
, !
1 *
! #
># F >
+# !
/ 0*
*
#!
;# *# !
< > !& @,
12 1 *+
,- ;# * .4 787.*
/ 0* ,
2
, .8.+ !+ !78.9*#
, ! ! 1 !A / 0 & & /
" 0
()
)
"
& ,2
$& . 2
/
) "
) )
"
0 " ""
" 0
" "
# ""
()
0 "
A "
/
)
" 0
:<7 2
G
"
+ ) N
" ""
()
A
& ,2
$& . 2
"
)
$ 2
"
? 1
"
,"
()
& ,2
$& . 2
() 5 6 E 1
)
()
0 "
) " ,
" "
A
. /
" ) "
0 "
)
()
"
0 " #
"
()
""
"
) " ,
"
)"
"
0 3
! ,* ,
/ 0*, # ;# . /0
1(=*+
,-= ! (%/ < #!
,
,
1#
#
# ,
#
# !
# D,!
! *, # * # # ,
!
*,
* ,
2 !
, # ! * , ) ! ! 2 !
:
& ,2 $& . 2
5 6 ) "
()
"
A
() "
"
0
& ,2 "
)
()
" )
"
"
0
= 2 0
2
:<7 ) " ,
" #
()
" 0 ) " ,
" H " )
" 0 ) " ,
" "
"
)
/ "
"" " "
$75$6
()
$&<$& 8 /
$ &$&$& /
"
"
" A
"
0
" )"
"
@
"
"
"
,
( 5 (6 /
>
"
& ,2 ) )
" 1
)
" 0
" "
/ ()
"
" " )
"
$ /
""
" A
()
)
"" ) )
1
" 0 "
"
3
!
* !
/ 0* #
,
) ! ! 1 *2 !
,
! .8.+ !+ !78.9* ,* ) !
! ! 1 +, ! #
!
!
!
!
# , D#
!
!# ,* #
/0
!
*,! !
/0
2 !
!
! ! 1 44 3&'
,* !DE
/0
*
, !
1 * .8.+ !+ !
78.9* , #A * # C !+ !
.=<5 !
* 1
*,
,!
+ !.=<6* ## !!! !*
# C/ 0 ! .8.++
!78.9*,
# *# # !
1 * !, !
! ! ,
,!
1
;# + 2 -
,
( = A*+ :11. =A
/'0 / 0"'!2
2 !
# ! !
+ !.=<6* *, ! 76 !+ !78.9 D# 76 #
+ ! 78.9* #
*# !
2 ! !
! !
;# + 2 * , #
* # , !
, !! 1+ !.=<6# !
#
,
#1!
! A * !
! !+ !.=<6, #
# * ! , , )
2 !A / 0 &
$$ / " "
)
$& . 2
)
"
" 0
"
@
@
"
)
1 0 ) "
"
"
2 "
) )
$& . 2
B P2 2
"
" "
",) ( "
)
" 0
"
)"
"
"
"
"
"
"
)
"
" 0 0
0
1 0 )
"
"
"
)
"
0
"
)" " )
0
"
"
P $. N
" "
)
""
)
$7 "
F
F "
$75 6
$& . 2
/ F
F
) "
)
"
0
" "
@
@
? ) "
F
F " 0
"
=2 2
" , "
$7 ' )
F
A "
""
"1
" "
)
$7
$& . 2
"" A"
" "
/ ##+;/2/*;%!!#//**
&7$&$$ )
"
" #
)
$7 A
1 ""
" "
)
"
$7
$& . 2
" " '
" " ""
" 0
=2 2
" )"
"
""
"
" 0
=2 2
"
" "
) "
) " )
" "
"
"
" " "
1
/
""
")
" "
"
)
$75 656 "
$& . 2
/
"
) ""
A
)
"
" " /
0 6C
! ! # #
/ 0 !"#,* ;# , 2
2 !
# ! 76/70 !+ !78.9* !2 # & .8. # )
0
B,
: <
$75$6
2
$& . )
0
""
" " 0
$7 "
2
$& .
$& 7 # ) ) "
, " " "" "
0
""
1
)"
0
3
% ,!
1* 1
*!!
# * !* ,
!
! 1 * , #!
!
, , 1 !
6=
!# , D
/0 .8.+! , ! ! !
*
#
* ! 1
,
+ !
.=<6
6<
!
* , ! # #
**!
# *
, !2 & BC
C9<A/0D /
" "
& ,2
2
$& .
"
"
@3 0 "
"
)
,
"
" 0
2
:<7
) ) "3 ,
"3
"
"
BC
C9<A/0D /
H5
"
) /
& ,2 )
)
"
""
"""
" 0
2
:<7 BC
C9<A/0D /
"
) / "
) )
0 " ) ) "3 ,
"3
" )
"
@
"
" )
3
,* ! !)!
#
*
! * !
*
! 1 * !
#
!
* ! 1
*, #
/ 0,
# , )
.8 8< 78.6/+2.90*
!
!
/ 02 & - /
2A ,8
"
:&<$&&: "
< $$&&8 /
)
"
) )"
) +)" >"
2 2
<- +
/ " )
) ""
"
"
"
"
9 H ) ) )
A
"
"
"
+)" " ) >" : >" <-8
2
#
"
" @
) +)" " /
)
"
!
)
1 G
2
2"
#) ) = ""
"
"
" " 0
=
)
""
"
) "
"
" E
2 ,
, ,
1 3 2 F1. ,-C E ,-C F1 . 4 21 , . ,
% 2 . : , , F1, ,61
1 E F1 . 2
F1
2, -C ,2
1, -C
4 21 3F1 . 3 1 E
#
>24 !
< F
2, -C 2
" 0
"
" / " 0 )"
)
+)" " )
" 0
"
/ " ""
@ "" )"
"
)" " "
"
)"
"
"
)" " "
3 4.
"
* / 0 , #
* 379=.=78.6#!
* ,* , / 0* ! A # ;# + 2
G / 0 !
* ,
, # /0 #
*
/ 0!
! *#
!
*
/ 0 # #*# !
!*)!
#
* !
#
7877 ,*# )!
! #*
!
#
! 2
# !
/ 01 *, 1
,!
, # )7889
+1 # * ! ,
&5 2
$!'
#
#+,- . =)9
! "#
!
"
!
#
$ % & & %'
& ( %) %%%*
+
, - , -
!"
# $ % &$ $ ' % &$ ( $ $ $ ( ) *
+ $ $ $ (
( $ $ ( $ % &$ , !
$
.
+
!
# ! !
/
0 &
+1
!"# $ !
!
%$ &
!
'!
$
2
+
$ % & & %'
#
!
#
# + ! / 1 3 4 &
+1
(
) *
"
! + ! '
( ,$" * "
-./
0 &
+1
.
$ * !
& %'
.
.
. !
.
.
.
!
+
+
.
& )5*
+
+
.
!
$ % & & %'
.
# !
0 &
+1
$ 0 + 1!2 '
( .. $ 3 #
+
" .
!
"
#
!
!
!
$%$&'()*+*, !
6 #
1
$ % &
!
& %'
/ /
# /
7+
7+
/
7+
# .
!
.
8
!"# $ !4
! 0 &
+1
#
7+
$ % &
!
0 &
+1
7+
#
!
/
"
!
1
!
#
.
.
/
.
' $
7+
$ % & & %'
.
!
+
/
7+ 9
# .
!
+
!
!
#
$ % & & %' * 0 &
+1
(
) *
"
! 4
!
. .
! #
& )5*
.
&. &
#
. .
& )5* $ * ! & %'
.
:
9
.
;
$ ' & )5*
$ % &
!
/
7+
7+
+
$ % & & %' /
# .
.
.
8
/
+
+ +
1
+
/ 9
/
7+ +
!
1
+
/
! <
0 &
+ 1
+ 1!2 4
!
" .
!
$
# "
.
.
.
7+ +
+
+
7+ #/
+ !
! +1!2 4
!
+
/ 7+
+
+
.
/ /
.
+
+1!2 4
! =
!
$ % & & %'
/#
1
#
+
> (
!
!
+
7+
!
(
+
+
+
+
+
!
!
-
7+ )
+
!
7+
!
!
/
/ !
!
1
1
/ +
! 7+
5 &
.
/ . 0
1
1/ "
"
3,(+! )$+ ''+435$&6+47468 ''+ 3+(%7468