High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7372/2012dismissed

Maruti Suzuki India Ltd. v. Presiding Officer And Another

2015-08-28Mr. Justice Darshan Singh24 pages

!"#"$""" "% " &'&()&*+*&*&,

%-*+ .+/&&,

+*&*&,+) 1+)2

+3,.+,* &'&()&*+*&*&,

%-*+ .+/&&,

0 +*&*&,+) 1+)2

+3,.+,* " 4#5 !

6 "!1""""

)++,*

! "

#$ 77777 % &" ! ' $ () "! *' "!1""""8! & ! ! ! $+, -$+%$! "- "./ 0 12.34&

.(#565$$+%$

!! . ! !- "

*! #78+ %999

! " !- - 5:; " )

! " !-

- !

" ! ! "- .

!! & " !) "-!! &.< -! ! "- %%/

*! %975= 2 3>

" ) ! !!

$:; " ! "

& . < !! ! !

%%/ ! !.

&,.2*-,-/9&,+(5&:&*+. 9. :-,?1%9@74% ..%:$ - " ! !! -& !. ! ".

! ! "-!-&

" . );:+,

&)+*,+ <)+ -,. 2==+) :3-,< ,.&- '* 5*. ' 9+ -,->+:+,*

%956.%$$5!. %% * %975 & %% -&" " ) A

%% &" - !

- ! !! - < ". !

) -<

%%/ ) ". ) -

! ! "-!- -!

< B-

"- ! -

!! ! !) ) B-

B-

" ! ! "-! -,->+:+,* -,&*(++- *-*+'

9+);:-,8

%95%.$%5% ) " " & . ) - ! <)

%%/

/ < B B- B- )-

C ".

B-

!!-

!) -

)

".D) .<& ". !!!

) B-

! ! "- !-- - " -!

)

%% "< - !

" " "

!"" E %%

%95$ ! "-

! &" B ! ! ) ! - " "

" "

" < !!

- -

"-".

" ! ")

! "- %% * *"9%95%"- 7:%95%& !! -!. < """-

);:+, &)+*,+<)+

0 -,.2==+):3-,< ,.&-'*5*.'9+-,->+:+,*

%956.%$$5&. ! ! -

* =%:%$%95%> F/ 2& " " !

B-"

%% "

- C B-" "- !-

! ( ! "!-

%% "-&" -

! !

"- !- " " &" - D ! ) "

&&" - ) "

" "- & - &" !! A--

! ! & - %% ! &"

"! # ) &" !!

) ! ! !-

"- B-! !!

" - &" ! "

" G ! !"- %%

" "- %% ! &" ! ! "- !- &"

" "- B-! "-"-

" &" - ! ! ! "-

! &" !

%% &" -

! -" !

)

&" - !

! "- -

-! &!

&" "- %% 3 &"-!

/ & 0 /H $

%9@7 " ! !

" !

- ! %9@8/@5%99:/98

! C<(/%I%(/%I8! -

- B" "- "

! -! "- "- @,- %998

9 %998

!! -

"!-"<!

" ! ! "

"-" ! "

B- & " - ! !! & 2" " 3 0 & !- &

B- -

"& B-!

" ! --

"- !

!"-

)

B " & !

!!!0 !!

%$164 !

$ " ./ 0 ) ) & #$ ! - -

B-

! -H 6 *"$++9"./

0 B-

!! ". B- ! B

!! -

! - B-

" #! - !

" "

. ( #89@7$+%6! "- -" - 6%-%998

!! 7 - ( J !

!! < !! & " < !!

!- & !! "- &! %66 - " &

) )

B "-.

! -&" 6@ - <!

" "

" -&

< - " &

" ! -

& !! ! " ! " & ! //!

- " -

! !- -

B-!! B-&

! & !

6+$++5"-, %.&

! "-

" & " B- " 6%,-%998- "- ! - & "

B-

! 6% ,-%998

" ! "- ! & <" "

B-

".& "

C <

< $8 %995"-& <" C< %I$7

(%I$:& -

! " -"-

B-

B- 2 3&

!) B- -

*"%995

9E"-%99@ " " B- !! !! ! )

! -

!! -

-& ! )

" ! <

" ) ! & !

! -"

7 -

!" - 6@ - "

!-! " ! - " "- "-

!- " ! ! "-""- %% !! " " !- !

"".

! " ! " " )-" ! !!

"- ! - -

! !

! ! " C " )

!-! - ! "

" ") ") . $+69

$+8@.

.! -

!!"

" ! " ! " ! - "

" 0 6%-%998

7$+78578@75%

$%8 . ! ! ! "!- -

" ! !

" -

6% -%998

%995 !

! " " &

- "& " & B- *#J G J =A>* ! "- *J ! - - --! "

! -

*"%995=/7>

! "- ! "-

! "-!

" -

"- !

! !

$% . K - " -" ! -"

" - "!-

! !-

". ! & < ! G ". B-

" ! ") !-

.& ! !(

"-" " -!! " ! ! %% ! !!!&"."

"- ! ! "-. ! !

!!-

& !

-"! -! "-" )! & " " "! -!

! "-

" "."<) - - ! !

) " !

" ! &.

! "- E

! ! ! !" &

"! !!- !-" 2

3 ! "- $% . !

"- -

- "

! - )

) & ! < )-

- ! "

"-" "

)

! - - ! -

"-& ! <! " "! )

" . ! " !! - ! ! & D

- &!-"" !! %66 -

" " & ! & <! - -

" !

- -<

&)+*,+

" " 9-#)+/-?.)6-,>9 -,->+:+,* @ 9-#)+/5&:&*+.A1$++@4:..::9 ". "" -!

)

%% "< ) - ,

"< -!- "

! ! "". ! $++9! B-

"- ! B-

". !

/ <

-- ".< B-"

!! - B !

- <

& "

)&") !!- %%

! ! B-

!!& - !

B-! ! -G -

"- - "!& $ &

! "

! B !

"-."- -! ! - %+1%414 $ * ! 2

$ %% !! ! - 2 3 &

* 2 3 2 3 ! CB- $ " - &!! " !

"- %% * G -!

-" . . )

! ! "-

! -- ) (.<

) "

" !! "

!! - ! B ! ! ! (

"- " & " . .

(. $$8 ") < -

< "- .&) ! -

) "

"- " - ) ".

%% * B -

" "- (

"-! !<!

" ! ! "< !

" !

B ! &"!

-" ! --

!!- &)

%% < &" ! "- )

$$8 . ! -) ! ! " ! ! C

(

"- .! 1%97@4 % JG $$6

" !"/" - " "B ) -

" ! " "

!! -(

"-! !

!!- & !!"- ! ! D!! -D

< - A

0 -1%99545..786 !-

<! & ! "

!! -

" <! "- ,

,! B -!. J

?=$++%>$..6@8 ! 0 -1!4 " <) J1!4 !

&-! F/ 2141 4.

%7F

-. "

%7 <

- "

")" "- - "-

& 14 "

%7F G C-!! &# =%957>7 .. 6% G ,

!! %7 D"-D "

%7&! ! - . - " "- "- "

" " 1"4

%7 "

!! -!!

!- "-

(

"-!!

- F ( ! - &! !

0 - " B D" D1

- ! ( . !!-

%7 !! -!- -

.!!-(

- -'E

"! ! "!

"3 <<< "

%7 " - B B- B B- B . .!- .

< ")

" "- . "

!!- D!! -D

!- -3 <<< 2&

%7! !!- ."-!!- !! -

B D"-D

")*&/(+8 ! !

- " (

"-! !!!3 <<< 2! -

F &! !<! ! !! ! %7 "!! B D" D !

< -

)& A

=%9@5>7..8%% . D!! -D B ! "." !

D -D !!

G.. A

=%99:>8 .. 579 . ! .C . " -

-" ! . ! -

0 - &" ! !

! ! -B D"-D

. (

"- ! !

- -& !!-!! - !- . "

%7!! <&. !

(

"-! ! -

B ! -

" - "-

! -!

< . "

B ! 3 - "

!! "- " . - -

".<

)

! < ! "- A -&

<". ! "- ! ! &". <! 2"

! !!

! %++;

-%9@8/@5%997 ! %+-

" ! )

" &".

! !! "

) < "-<! !B-

< "!" ) "

&" " ! .

<! 6<+.

$-;='B6-.9-;)&9,-,8

%987.755 ! "-

"" !!" ) & ! - - ! & !!

! - " . "- " <) "- .! $$8. &".D ! !! "- &

! " " -! ". ( ".

"!"

L$:;

-") -$:;"

- !-" -%995&

-! &! !

%5G *

- "!! ! - ". -

" /<

" /< "!" &EG .

-.9--: 2,&/&3-(::&**++8#-),-(-?%9@6$%

! &EG B " - !- - "

- B "

" " !

< !! -" "

" " %995

!! "-".

$:;"

-- "

$:E " . " ! - -" - ! !

! & ! <! "

". " < ! " - -! ) !

" !

!- !- ! -"! -" !-! ) " -" ! "-!! !!- ) !! %995"<!

" " !-

" ! -

) -" -" !! !

" "

- , -$+$+%$ "

$:;"

! ("

! !

-" ! " "!1"""" !

"2>2*8 8

0 J