High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20169/2017allowed

Karambir Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others

2020-09-30Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa15 pages

!"!#$!%&'( )*! #&+&,!-!&*'.

' /0 1 11 # $%&'()*+& $,&'()*+" $-&'(%).( $*"()*+ / 0 $ 1'()*+ 2 $ .

"()*+ 222 $)()*+ 232 44444 11 " & "05 "6 7 8 "

""' *

" / 9 " ' :

+ "" "" 3+& 7 &"" '+ "+

'&+ ;

' 1+ %+ *'

:""'+' + <"'+1

= =

5)>

6 "" ' " 1"*

+ "'+1 ++)

8 '' '+ + 2 / 5)>

5)> 6&1" + "" )

8 1 "

1 *+ 7 "'* 1 ' 1"" 1 / 3 8* '"1& " ' ++5 6 +' %"' )++

+' "

+ )+ '>& '+

1 - "

* / *""'+ '+""*

" - +'

3" 7 ( &+ /&7 8<8'++''

* '& '+ "+

-''+ &;

& & "" :

+ & -& + 78<8'++'())<8'++'( )7<8'++'+ ""'1 " &;

+"+" (&+& ''+ " -& & + +1" " ++1 ) +&" +'

3 2 ' )2#13&45)&%*5!#"6" 0)&% *5!#"+''''

+' '+

2 -:'' "+ ' & ' -("

+ + +& '' "" '* ** / ) "+( " )

8 & ' 2" 7 " ( & '= 2 )'&+"

+ 2 '

/ + &*""'' " &+1"

;

'+ + * * '' ""'+ 1 * ++<+"'+ * 1 '"+

(

++ & '""& :- ""'+<+ & '' +1 "+

'+'

+ &*""' " )85?-6<8'++'( 78<8'++'( ))<8'++'( )7<8'++'

* ;

'+ < $++'<9 +<8'++'8'++

85%8'++'86(+ + *

++ '"+

( 1 ''""& :+

++ '+"+

(+ & ' + "'&>= " "">&+'

' @&*(*& + 2( " "" " &'' ''1

" 1"

%8'++' 8'++ 8

3 ) (" '& '2= 3 +#%!!7 13&45 )&% *5!#" 6" +&2)8 1*)*! 9!# #7#)*3&03-3*!%)&%*5!#" ++"

' + + 2 "&++

' 8'++' 8'++ 8 +'''" 78<8'++'%+ &

"+ ''"" " 7 858'++'61+ 8'++'

8'++ 8 ;

*'<" +;

'+ " - +&"+ "'

3 3''&+"

# A

!"# "

% !"#

"" !"#

& # ' (

)$#

* +,"-."+-,/"

% "

"1 91: ' &"

1 ++&" 1' 3"

:" * -,+2= 3 +#%!!7 13&45)&%*5!#"$" +&2)81*)*! 9!##7#)*3&03-3*!%)&% *5!#" '

++ '* "

:*&+"

;

'+ %8'++'8'++ 8 ''

'' " 7 8 58'++'6 * ** / 9 +"'++ / / 2= 3 ++ " " &

""' " / 7 58'++'6 '" &"

''''& ' " & ""'&+ " +

&"+" *1 '+"+

' ?'1++ ' *+("

+ *+ +'

+ " )

8 &'>

+ + 9 +" +

"" 3+'&+ " &&1 ' + '+"+

+: 1 *+ 7 ''""

)

8&1 39 +"

* " 7 8 58'++'6

+ "" ' " / * : " " + +';

1 "

& ( "" >"1"&+ ( ''

" :1+ " *

+ + 2 /

5)>

"+*'1611 " + "" )

8 '1 1"

1 *+ 7 8 ' "'+ *1 '+ " "'+1 + : 1 " + + ' = =

5)>

6&1+)

' <*+

1("1>("+

+"'1

& *+'+ " <+ &+& '" 0 + ' " " &'"" &" ! ' 8'++1 , *+ 8 58'++'6 ! '

/&+ #

2,/

)

)3$4

% 4

"1 9

" 1"* 1

>"+" 7 8& '" ;

+ "" )

8 3" +)$98<%@' ;

+" 1 /&+"'1 >"+'11 =("

+ + 2 / 5)>

5)> 6

++ "" )

87 & ""

+1 3 ' + " "

% 8'++' 8'++ 8&+ ;

;

'+" +

/ ! '

+ +' " + "" )

8 3"+;

' -"'+1++ ' = =

5)>

""'+'

+ ++ ' +)

8 &+ + "+ '&*"""* "

*+'" *

" + " & "" 1 39 *

"+ 1 2= 3 ++" ( "' & ""+

= "

8'++'8'++ 8 "

+"" &1 / 9

" "'

++ 1

+ "* """" 1 3 ' 9 " + *+'"" /

'1+;

1 >"+" 7 58'++'6" =1+;

''1" " )

+" B

*+'"* " &

""' /&+&

++"& 1"

+*+;

+ +& :""- + '1 '

" +

+ &+ +1 ''C ' "" & ' ' ' '" *'"'

+*"

D "

'1(" ""'" 7 858'++'6 " * / (

1") " '+"+ (" "" & ' = 2 9 " *

''1 & (1&"" + 2 +' '' 1 "

;

'+ % 8'++' 8'++

8 - '' .:

; +#%!!7

13&45)&%*5!#"6" +&2)81*)*! 9!##7#)*3&03-3*!%)&% *5!#" ++" - : " ">" 1++ + + ;

*'+ 8'++' 8'++ 8 & 8'++' 8 , " + ,"* )9/ 2 3:+ +

+ !+ !

' 1:' 8'++'

8'++ 8 '' " )

8<8'++''

7 858'++'6! ' & ++'1

;

* 3

1"*""'+ + " )

8 5?-6<8'++'( 8'++' 8'++8& +C *';

'+- :*&* + <

"++''1 ""'+'

;

+ 1 + ;

*'+ * '' + " ++" + ' -,+''1'''& # 2 $

" 5

(

& " $ (

" !

(

6 &

" # ( (

0 " ) ( $

"1 -

(+''1 " &+' &''11

;

!1*' ''1""' " * -+' '' +#%!!713&45/",)"! "+7#) ++ " " & '*"& + &""'" ;

" * / "+" *1

'+"+

<& '= 2 9& * ""' 1*

" " / 1* & "" 3+&5 6+ "

""" 7 858'++'6 - +#%!!713&45/",)"! "+7#) + '1-""' *

" /"

"+"'+ ++1 +#%!!713&45/",)"!

"+7#) " &''1""' " * (+ " " "" " 7 58'++'6+ 3"&+ " ' 1 +*& ""

'+ = =

1 ")>

&+ +"'+1+ + "'+ )

8 & "'+ ' " 9

+ + &

* + (&+ + ' """'&+ &+& '"++

++ '

1("1> +' '';

"+ ''1 '& +

;

" )++'1( "'+1 + & : 1 "

+ = =

5)>

+ + & )

8 '+ ( 1& '"'+ 1 "+ '& + "+*+ '<'1 9" + &''" &

""' '"" / "" + & 1 3 & & "+" *1 '+ "+

<& >-

+' & +''1 ' "&'" '' "

;

'+ "

+*& * & + +#%!!713&45/",)"!

"+7#) )": + = =

5)>

6""' " )

8&+ + "+(

+ + + '" " &1' +"'+1+ = =

5)>

6& ' ""'1;

" 7 858'++'6 &'')+

" +:

'*' )+' 3

9 - + ' " ! '

/! ' " "

1 >"+" 7 8+ "" )

8 ++ " / ' D! ' " ;

+"'1

*+>"+-A>"+E " 1" 1 '&+ "

'- ;

1 *+''"" )

8?+*& :" ' "" 3+& 7 8 &"" *1 '+"+

(

+ ++"'1 *+& '* 1 ' -+ '"* " * + ""1* "' & "" + "

% 8'++' 8'++ 8

9+#%!!713&45/",)"! "+7#) + +1 ' &

"++''1+''&+# A$

"1 +

& ''1'&1 & *& " ;

'= 2 ,1* (" " +:"*+- ' &>+ +

+ *" &''+ &"

% 8'++' 8'++8 * ""+"& ';

+ + ""' " * +''+1 '&9& *

;

'1;

>''

+ + &':" "

%8'++' 8'++ 8"+" = 2( * 11*'&" - "* " 5 2=(3 = ( =(

3 ''& # A)

0 +84+9"-8"+-,. "

) 0

"1 ''1 '"

+' & 1

+ + +'

" *++"

& "

% 8'++' 8'++

8:& = 2 "" " *1*

++&" ?+"'

+>+ ""' *

1''+ & '* +

'1 + &>& '= 29 ++'1 - +'1 '

& - ;

++ ++ + & ' & " * +

'' & 1'1@*""* *+' & 1""+ 1&1' 2= 3 +#%!!713&45)&%*5!#"6" +&2)81*)*! 9!# #7#)*3&03-3*!%)&%*5!#" ++" + & " + ''& / / - "

""' " " ;

" / 9&" ( "++* "

" 1

:+'+ "" 1 3'&+ + "& :? + + 2 / 5)>

5)> 6&

&1" & + "" )

8 1"

1 *+ 7 ++ +

& :1'+ " "1" F+&

/ " G &+' &"D

+ ++ + " +

'1 F +*(&" ''& -" + "" " 7 58'++'6& 7

& "" & "+" *1 '+ "+

<&>'= 29

1& ' +

+&> + " " )

8 & '

+ 1

+ & ''

'"1> 1 "" 3+@&*(

+ "1 >& '' 1& '' '1"1&:" 58'++'6 " ''& 11 1!7*!-8!#.<

":< #B < "' #B <