← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16073/2024dismissed

Union Of India And ORS v. No Jc 665871l Sub Maj Hon Lt Prem Singh And ANR

2024-11-05Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma13 pages

 

        



!

"#$% &' 

 #$#($) "#$%& 

  

  





   ! " #$ %



& '

*%  +,*  --

- .

  +,* - --  - * % # ()

$  *%+,  $'

-$ .

 $  *   . .

 $'

/  '

-

- .

/    !$ #$$  - '*$' $ 1  *'

 # $    2 4%5   167*   '

  ( $  .  % "  8 , !

 .

,, *  -$ $  ,. "  $ '   $ #    

.(' -  ..-

0)1(020)34 #($"

& ' -  ..$% "( 9   -   ,$ #   "  +,    : 2:

3232    .-  ", .

, # ( ,,$ 

.(; "

( ('  ;

 -

#$  $ . ", .  * . (  ' .  2 329 !$ . ", . ,  $ 

.(

,"#  $  ## +   (   #   .    ".

:

!$"'%$ ( ,$,. " #  

.(  '     $  '  +        2 2:

& ' '



  '' .$  #    $8

%''.. ""  -+ *$,  ' -

,  ( $ %''..   ""  +        32 2 323 & ' .  '' . #  $  ,  " 

(  $  8

 %''..   ""  -+ *    

+#    , '$  '' . ($"'%$ (* '  .

% *  $. % "8 , !

 .,, * -$ $,  ,$ ..#$ +"  , 

!$



% * , " ..-+    2 !$' + $    5 ,$  

    

 

  

          

   

            

 

       

  

                   

!   "

#     





   $% & 



            ' !

 & 

 

       )

  



 )

    

 

 *+%,   -%,  





  ' !

 &  &)

 .$/0%$01  

23)



 $%$04

  0%$.

    

   

 

 

 

    

 

    3 

5&6

& 

      */,  

7 8.# ## + "$    '

' $

% 4 7* ($. % "8 , !

 .,, *$ ' 1 $ .$  #  $  - '

 $  $5

$) #5167#( 1  < '

,#" = ,+ , ' $'

- '*   .

 ,  "#-$$

$  .." ( + 1>1+  (""

$, '

.* ' $ # ..$ "(* ' $ .

 #*'$ ,"#. *  ""

 $,"

  , . $"* " " #,*($ ''  '*$ ' . "$, #, . $ ,# . #, . ," ## +  #  .". +,*$   ,? * "*$'

,'.   $$#"   ($ ;

.%'5 *, .

    * '       !$  .+   '

# '$    $    + ,    5 , $  

0) (  

   

 

 8  9

"# 

   

 

   

       



    4  

  

   0%,         :

             



  

 

;

    3      &   <    )   $/0=   )

4"3

 $>-# "#)    

 



 

   

                  :





   

 

 

    

 

  ?3  +3  $."#@ "#5      "

 

#    

         )  

 

    

 



 

   "3  # "#   



 





    

 

  

 

  

     

  

 

        ?3  $."#@ "#        

  

 A

        

 

 A 







     ?$."#@ "#

          

 

 

    

    

    



  

  B

C  : 

    ?$."#@D 

! "#

 B

C 



   &  4 =E 

B

"B <  #  0%%0  F  =;

    9  E

  <   =   

  >/

  

  -%   

         :

   

    

 

    

  %, +  #4 7$ +5 ,'

,'. * $#$'.(,.

*$ -$ 

.( ,"  .' (""

$,"

 , . $"* -$,$  $ 5  32 @   + *  $ '*  $#$ ( ,$ 

. ""

 ?   + .  "$% "(* ( $ 

?  

#$ 

.('   $.

*$

#"

.('  ( ""

$,"

 , . $"*-$ ,"  . -$ 

.( ? "32@ " * "' +.(

?   ,.

   "  $  , .  < *   , .( ,#$ $   

.( #  .

,"# ## +  (". !$ ,.

 ,"

 ($;

  3  & <  )  $/0=)

4"3

 $>-#  8 " *$#$$   '

"'

# + 1>1+ '$( , . " .$ .$ (""

$ , . $",, * ', ..(-$ $  #$

,"# ..*$    $ ,"#  -$ ( + *$#$$  $   .

 

"'*  $   -$  (      $  *  $  ,,



?.(*  $  $     $ ''#      4 7  

 #  ( *   '

"   ?.$

 #  +,    ""

   $  ,   . $" "' +.(*$  '

+#$-" ?  

7+ 1>1+ $,, *  $"'.( *  , *$  "  1 ,$ #*$ '*$,. " 

," . ,+

.('  + * ..$ ,

  , ,"

 ,       $      +,  (  $ ,, *  ,. .( , A*$  ,.

#-$$ $   ( + 1>1+ $,, *   ?.?  

 ". +,  /  $ "  #  ## +   (  #  .". <$  " (*$  ,"  .

  $ 

,'.4 7$ ($ ,   .

.(' $ ,, * .(') 7%$" ,,' ,$,, ".

+,* "# ,"#  ($ , .

<   + 1 1+  $ #    -$      -$,$ $-+ * ," ,,. (  #$"

 ,". 

7  %(        $  *  " (  .

?.( ,",,. ($ , .< *      "      ". (  +,   #

  .". +,* " # ,# . 2 8 *$", .'$. $ $ ,. $ + ,", .5 " $,,  # " *$ '

 $ ,"#.  +,*$ ' *$

"-.. "$ +  # +,*($

 4 7*$ , .<  ?   $  

,,.# 

+ *  .

,.

 *$  "    , .< ..-$#. . -$ ' 1 $BC , .4 . ( 7*3223DBE.") C . ,'. 3 !$  *$  - "-$$  "

 $ +'

,'. *-$$  $". "$'



'$% "(*$    '

." (", .5 " 

#" + 1 1+ $ $ .$*$   , "  

"  #$" / -$$ " , " '' $ $  -   "   # + *  .

?   "* "$ ,  $ *-$$ $  ,  .5  $ '$ * / $ #

 *$ '

*$ ' $ .."$'



'   =#  '. ,*  + 1 1+  $  ,+   ( $"  ". +,*-$ *$  " (,,.$ $  $   -   ?.$  # +,$% "(

"  ,$-   . , " ## +  ($  # ". :

 *  .

 ?  # $  "$

*-$$ , .< * ..('

," =  ., + , .,$,=*'

,.

.( ''  #$ +$ *$ #$"'.("   % ", .

,$? *  $  +.#  $  .,=  ,$   #,  ,,* -$  "

* $  , "  , + *$  "'.(" .

& . .(*$ " ( ,",,.? ' $ *$

?$ '' . " =# '. ,* - ,# . -  #  ". +,   #  . ,"# ## + 

('  " ,". 

.(*$ "'.( ,$?  $  # '' . " =#'. ,*$ ($

, .< ,, *.   ,,. *$ $  

 " ,,  ( * ($  "   $ #$. " ('

.$ "(* +(  

 , & . .($

? ,+,/ '$  *  #$,

 ". +,* -.  ..( .  -..,,.  ($ , .< *$   ,+ '

  , "   ,   "    ,+  ,  .  #,  ,, -$ $ -.  .

.('  6 -+ *-$  + *$   ?   5 ,#$, $'* , "  ($

#

. ", .    .+ 5 ,'

 6$

'.(. ($F'

"$

# .%''.,   $ . !

 .,,  .

 

   <."# 5)

H&II+/>$6; 

B(< 

 

  ) $+%.$/>



    -$%-0%0% ")J#

)3  $-"-# "#"#$+.              

 

   '

    

  

   %$%.0%0% 

<& )"<#)

<  < 5

J$/%0%0%%0%/$4%$%%

  

   

 



 

         <  '

   "$$%#7  $  % &' (&$ $)$*$$+$ ,*- +*(./0(* ! #  1$2'$  1    31   4 $  $*$$  $ ,*  &

, $$  &(    &*(.    $( $  ((&'(&*$  (   ($ &.*(.$,$ ( $$($$(5'* . 

&*(.0$ &$$$$ (6*7 * $  8 *  $     (  $  8

  %''..  "" 5 ,$  

F

.

& 4  "

(  ('   4 27 !$

.( ,"'.5 '. ( #,*  " .,    + " .

 ,

*      '      .  

 -+ * ## +  ,, $     ,,

 -$.  +,    8/

/ %%'

.# .  $   , * $

.(,,

 -$.$+ .- '  ' ,

 *    ,    $#$  .



*  $  ,    +    ' , ., ..$"$  ,$ # "

$ +, ' $  $, ' # . !$  ,. " .  $'

-$ 

.(  +, .  ,$

.(,,

$   .      ## +   ". +, "

 6:$ '

    C

 3223*  ""  322   E."&. 322   %  #$ + .

$  $"$ '' . " =#'. ,  , ""  "

$'

,'. 4 7,.

 ($ ;

.%'5 , .

    '0  ($ , .

< *$  " -$,$$-+ *

$'



'* ,". $% "(*" = '

."  #

   *  $  ,.

    . -    #"  4 7  $  $   '

"'$ $,

#$  -   ?.  +,* ?   +

.( -+ 1 1+ ' !$#$ $  '

"'

 . $ . +, $ '

"'

, "  ,   '  $  '

 -+ *  $    ,   +, ,# ,$ ## + 1 1+ '*  ,#.(

#$ '

"'*   ..( .

,   

( .

'$ , .< *# # .$ +   $#*  $ #$  "'.("    $      %   .,=  ,$  #,  ,  .  ,,  ,$?4 7*  -$    " (  , "  +.$ $ #$ $ "('

.*

, "  , " , .#, ".($  + *

 -  .

 ?    $", .'*$  $    -.. "  -  ,# .  , "$  ## +  ( , "  .".

 -+ *   #'4 7* ,. $ $

    (' "   $ +     $  5  4  & .(* ,    +,      $ "'4 7$ . ($' *$ *$  , #+-#$ #$'$", . *

5 ,4  ', .(*, ,,  

#$

.. " *  $ $ #$ ,      ?. , .#, ".($  

.(* ?  ,.

  "  ". (     *     ?       ,.

     . ,"# ## +  ". +, $'

 '  

+ *  $#$        $   $   $   ,,

-$. +, , "'  " ($,'

.

 ' ,  *  ,$  5'

"  $

.+  #.  *-$,$" = $ # $  ' ,  * #  ?.$  ,$*;

 #    "$ ". +,  , " ## + 

$". , ?,*$. ,=$  5'

 "      $  #.  *    ,   $     

 ,,.*$ +$ # $  '$'



',,

 ' ,  *$ (*$  # 

,.

 ," ## +  ( #  .  ". 9 8 * , "

$#"   ($ %'5 *, . 8   )1(A



 3*$9 -$  * ,.

 " $ 5*$ $  #* $  ,"- $,,  & . .( .

$ 

  . #$

, "  +     $  '

  '    $ =#  ?  $ ''  #  #" $  +

E+  $ -   ,  $  ,.

    . -  "    + ,4 7" = ,.

  5' . . -  "*$ *$5' . . - "* " + , 7 .

" = $$ 

,

  + 1 1+  $ ,  '

.  ,, *  *     *  .

  .  $ ,, *$   (" =$# #$-"

" $ 

* $ *$.. ,"'."* '. 

*  

',+$

* (*. ( . ,$

3 !$  *  $  # #    $      $  '' 

# * "

$+ ,4 7   ($!

 .

,, * .

    " (..# .(  ?  '$.

  

7$02 "

#5167#( 1   " $*$   " $- ' -$

+  +*$ "  "

 3:

!$"'#  * '

 ($. !

 .

,, * "     " F '  .#-$ ..'# ''., 4 7* (     8-

- .

  8-  - *9 & 

  = + #$ 6 :

037$4;

0#$ "

% ;# 6 :# 10<2

% ;#