High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20673/2019allowed

Aishwarya Sharma v. Central Board Of Secondary Education And Others

2019-09-17Mr. Justice B.S. Walia3 pages

! "#$%$&'(')*

'(+,"-."/+"-0" $#'#')$- 2$-(3( /")%#+$-( 1 $(4)%$)#(

-$($)#* -/+')%("5%6&"#$-#+$4$#'#')$- -"6$$)+4-"5%6&"#$-#+$-$(4)%$)#( 7/ 9

-".$-')#+$,-'#4$#'#')'(-:3"(+');))$<3-$ = %"#$% >

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

( 0#+$- ,+$-$"( "#$- 0"--'";$5+$-)"0$,"(&+");$%#")#'/+"-0" 89 D$"-)$%&3)($@&)#$)%(#+"#4$#'#')$-('-#+$-#''&"#$5"( ,$@@"( "((4-#'$))$<3-$ = %"#$% ")%))$<3-$ =%"#$% A> F -$(4$&#'6$@. -$&-%( #+$ &--$&# )"0$ #+$ 4$#'#')$-5 +$- 0#+$-")%"#+$-"('(+,"-."/+"-0"5")#'/+"-0"")%/3)'@/+"-0" -$(4$&#'6$@.

89 ,"( "@( 0"%$ )#'.'); #+$ ')#$)#') #+$ 4$#'#')$- # &+");$ +$- 0#+$-?( )"0$ -0 $+" /+"-0" # ")#' /+"-0" ') +$- #+ @"(( /$&)%"-. /&+@ $-#''&"#$ '((3$% ";"')(# @@ - #+$ /$((') = >")% #+@"((/$&)%"-./&+@$-#''&"#$'((3$%";"')(#

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

"#+$- #+$ 4$#'#')$- #+$-$')! # #+$ $$&# #+"# 2'-$)%$- I30"- ")% 2'-$)%$- ");@",$-$)$")%#+$("0$4$-()")%#+"#+$,3@%)#&@"'0 ").-$@'$3)%$-&-'0')"@7&'6'@4-&$$%');(5'").5)#+$E"('(&--$&#$% 0"#-'&3@"#')&$-#''&"#$')-$(4$&#"#+$-?()"0$"(2'-$)%$-I30"-') &"($#+$("0$,"("@@,$%3)%$--%$-(#+$';+3-#)#+$E"('( "'%"6'#"(,$@@"("%+"-"-%")% "-%2'-$)%$-I30"- 89

$4@. +"( )# E$$) '@$% )- +"( &3)($@ - #+$ -$(4)%$)#(7/E$$)"E@$#%'(#');3'(+#+$#+$"&#(#+$')(#")#&"($#

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

( "'%"6'# # #+$ / "3#+-'#'$(,'#+')#+-$$,$$H(-0#+$%"#$-$&$'4#&$-#''$%&4. #+$-%$-)#+$("0$@')$("(,"(3-)'(+$%E.#+$"#+$-3(+"- ");@" ') F> "@); ,'#+ "-% ")% "%+"- "-% ) -$&$'4# #+$ "'%"6'# "( ,$@@ "( ,$@@ "( ")% "%+"- "-% #+$ 4$#'#')$-( 0#+$-5 / (+"@@ ,'#+') > ,$$H( #+$-$"#$- '((3$ -$(+ &$-#''&"#$( @"(( # #+$ 4$#'#')$- E. 0"H'); )$&$(("-. &--$&#') ') #+$ -$&-% E. ')&-4-"#'); #+$ 4$#'#')$-( 0#+$-?( &--$&# )"0$"(")#'/+"-0" F +$/,+'@$'((3');-$(+7&--$&#$%$%3&"#')"@&$-#''&"#$(,'@@ -$&-%')#+$("0$#+"#G#+$&--$&#')')-$(4$&#0#+$-()"0$'("(4$- #+$-%$-(#+$ 3)C"E"-.")"

/"@'"! 3%;$

0'# +$#+$-(4$"H');7-$"()$%* $(7 +$#+$--$4-#"E@$ * $(7