Ashok Kumar Tayal v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"
# $% &&% '()'*&% # #+, -./0+#1213 2+#+0 -./0+#12#+#1 %%'& + /+''4*56&%4
&%7%&8&8'% 999
/) 8*2'85% 8&! -%"&68%'6%4 8*&: %7'*%'& % %8';8 %* &&% %,&%'*% '&86%*&%* :''%< % ,; 8'58&8'= )8* &%8'*858* "> %8'" 8 >=%'68% 7% &8' 6! & % & *5'6%* '6% '&8& &%4 '* & 8"
? @&%'& %4/&8'*4 7% 8* 7& %"&*&%'* &8 % ) 88' %,&%'*% *6
%'&@ 7& + '*&%%,&%'*% *6
%'& ) 8&&%*@% %&)%7%'%*' & +%7%&8&8'% )%8'=%"8=8)"% ) 8&&%*%,&%'*% *6
%'&'
"'=@8& %A 88&%% '%& '%!'*&%'*% %% ""& %'& &%7% &8' 6!77%68 8%*8'&%&%'*% '&86%-%" ) 8&&%*8
8*58&&&%@&%"%7 7 8%& 8%'*+%*86"
=%'68%4+'4'*@'&*%) %* )"6"8&%*)!'!*%7 & %'&
2'8'>&&%?5% '
%'&%8*&%'*% *6
%'&@% % %6%85%*)!
,, %7'*%'&' 458*%6'@"%*= %'&*&%* :''%< %, ;-@%5% 4' B 4&%7%&8&8'% %6%85%*'&86% & =%, 8":''%< %,C; %7'*%'&8'
8'=&&8)8* @*8A "8 8%*'66 '& %* 8'8& &85%'*"%=" %''
%'A 8 !4&%7%&8&8'% 6 %&'@&&8)8*@*8A "8 8%* &% &%'*% * %&7%'*%'6! "%="6%=8'&8 '*8 66 *8'="!4 &%7%&8&8'% ) 8&&%* %7 %%'&&8'*&%* :''%< %,D;
& %7'*%'&'* "'=@8&8* "!@ '
8*58&46" 8 !8'= &&'6858" 6 8 8'"6%@ 8"%* 7%'*8'==8'&8 8 ) & %7'*%'&'* *8*'&&%'!6&8''8 %7 %%'&&8' == 8%5%*)!&%8*6&8' %7'*%'&'* 4&% 7%&8&8'% 8"%* &8 @ 8& 7%&8&8' '*% &86"% > &% '&8& &8' '*8 8 '6% @ 8&8'&%'& % 6% &8 8 8'=&%'&86%*&%* B :''%< %,C;*8A "8 !8'=&% 7%&8&8'% &&%7 &8'&%&%'*% 7 6% &% 48 '6% @ 8&8'&% '& % '*
)%%' =&&*8 %6& %7'*%'&'* & ""@&%7%&8&8'% &&%7 &8'&%&%'*% 7 6% 0% '%*6 '%" &%7%&8&8'% 6'&%'*%*&&&%7%&8&8'% )%%'@ '="!'*8""%=""!*8A "8 8%* 7 &8687&8'=8'&%&%'*% 7 6% 7% &8' 6!& %&*5'6%*'6% '&8& &%4 '* & 8"? @&%'& %4/&8'*4'* 8'8& &85%'*"%=" %' #%7'*%'&'* 5%& '%**% % &&% %7 %%'&&8'*&%* :''%< %,D; ) 8&&%*)!&%7%&8&8'% 6" 8 !8'=8&'* &&'6858" 6 8 8'"6%@7%'*8'==8'&8 C &% =858'= & =&
"6'8*% &8'&&%6'&%'&8'
, , "% '%*6 '%" &%7%&8&8'% 4@%*'& 8'*'! % 8&8'&%8'&'& @ 8&7%&8&8'4)%6 %&% &&% 8'*87 &%86'& 6& "8''& %% 7%< &8'
%"*&&@8"%8'58'=7@% ( *868" %58%@8' &&% &&%'*% @ * 6'& 6&46% &8'7%68" %& % "*)%) '%8'
8'*&&%5"
&8' &%'*% '*@ *8'= 6'& 6& %%%'&8""!
6
% 68"
'6&8''*7 8'687"% %A 8&!'*'& "( &86%&!& *8&'6%8' 6 &&% @% ( *868" %58%@@8""'&)%8'5%*& 7 &%6&7 85&%8'&% %&&&%6& 7 )"868'&% %&4 &*%68*%6'& 6& "
*87 &%%'*% % 6'& 6& @8&= 8%5'6%6'"@!%%* =% 8'6858"6 &%6 & "*%<% 68%( *868" %& 8'& '"%8""%="8&!
)8& 8'%'&%7 & &%?5% '
%'&8'&%% &&% 877 %'& D '58%@ &% %8*%&&"%*7 78&8' "@4'= '*
8'&% % %'6%)!&8 & '*% &86"%> &%'&8& &8'
'*88 *% &'%A %'&"!4 8'*8'=' % 8&8'&%8'&'&7%&8&8'4&% %8% %)!*8 8%* #%=8& ! 8 *8 %6&%* & ) 8'= &8 *% & &% '&86%
%7'*%'&'* 4&58*'!6'6%" %'& &8 *% )!&% 7%&8&8'% !
5% )% 4 "
#!
'*( %&% 7%8'=> %'%* 3%> %&% #%7 &)"% 3%