High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/40896/2021allowed

Harbhajan Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2023-06-0211 pages

!" !

!# #! $% & '

()*+,-.* ##### %/-/-0%( 1,, ,//%02 $+)0/*%(3 ####%340%/3 !

()*+,-.* ##### %/-/-0%( 1,, ,//%02 $+)0/*%( ####%340%/3

! " #

(%3%/5 (#!*-(-%(*04(&607/%&20(/*%4%/-/-0%( -)0/*73%3# (#$((3*,-.*,-*$&& $+)# (##,# -3,(#607/% 8-/*(#906%%%/*:$(&607/%& 20(4(-6/%(%340%/3# ;;;;

" #

,-7%)0/*/*%)06%<%/-0%4%/-/-03*6%(-3%0$/ 02/*%3<% &/*%(%20(%&(%)%-.%7-%)=/*%70<<00(%( 27/3(%)%-./:%2(0<

*%4%/-/-0%(&)=8=02/*%4(%3%/4%/-/-0&*34(=% 20(/0>$3*/*%0(%(/%#'#

&433%)=/*%?%(% -/-0?,%33-03 $.%&-(-<-?%6-3-0/%

(%3/0(%/*%0(%(/%@# &433%)=/*%?%(% & ?0$/#*%?%(%-/-0?,%33-03 $.%*3??08%/*% 44?-7/-0$%(,%7/-0'

#&??08-./*%(%6-3-04%/-/-0 2-?%)=/*%707%(%(%340%/3*33%/3-%/*%0(%( 433%)=/*%?%(%.-3/(/%8*%(%)=??08%/*%44?-7/-0 $%(,%7/-0'

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

<%<)%(3<%?=2/*%(-?8&<0/*%(-?8&)(0/*%(3-3/%(02 /*%*$3)02/*%%7%3%70<4?-/#44?-7/-083?30 /*%(%2/%(<06%$%(,%7/-0'

#)=*-<20(<:-./*%< 3-/-0?77$3%# @# :-.-/0703-%(/-0/*%70/%/302/*%3//%<%/ 02()*+,-.*/*%44?-7/-0&?%(%.-3/(/%-33$% 3$<<03/0/*%2/*%(-?8&<0/*%(-?8&)(0/*%(3-3/%(02 /*%*$3)-(%7/%/*//*%=(%/0)%-<4?%%37077$3% -(%7/%/02(<%7*(.%3.-3//*%<#*%3-0(%(433%)= /*%?%(%.-3/(/%/%@# 837*??%.%)=??/*% 20$(4%(30320(2-?-./803%4(/%(%6-3-03&0%)=2/*%(&<0/*%( 3-3/%(02/*%*$3)02/*%70<4?-/ %7%3%/*% 0/*%( )= ?+-/ ,-.*& )(0/*%( 02 /*% *$3) 02 /*% %7%3% 70<4?-/# 9%(%-/-0?,%33-03 $.%*3&2/%(-37$33-.

/*%?8(%?/-./0/*%4(06-3-03$%(,%7/-0' #&(%7*% /0/*%707?$3-0/*//*%(%-303$)3//-?%6-%7%/0-<4?%/*% 3-4%(303377$3%--/-0/0/*%*$3)20(022%7%3 $%(,%7/-03 3%/3-%/*%0(%(02/*% ?%(%.-3/(/%# # 9%(%70$3%?20(/*%4%/-/-0%(3$)<-/3/*//*%(%83 34%7-2-7 ??%./-0 <% )= /*% %7%3%D70<4?-/ - *%(

70<4?-/)0$//*%(%340%/3*6-.%<%08(=02 4(060:-. /*% *$3) /0 7$3% 4*=3-7? 6-0?/-03 0 /*% 70<4?-/20(0/)(-.-.3$22-7-%/08(=#*%4%/-/-0%(-*-3 083//%<%/<%3 C*3?30<%/-0%)0$//*%6(-0$3 (/-7?%3.-6%)=*-<3E /0*-3$.*/%(&8*083 /$(%0$/2(0</*%</(-<0-?*0<%#*%%/-(%(/-7?%3.-6%- <((-.%*6%)%%:%4/)=/*%(%340%/3-/8334%7-2-7 73% /*/ /*% 08(= (/-7?%3 8%(% )%-. <-3$3% )= /*% 20$( (%340%/34(/2(0</*%*$3)#*$3&-/83(.$%/*/73% 8*%(% 80$? 44?= %6% 3 .-3/ 20$( (%340%/3# # *%70$3%?44%(-.20(/*%(%340%/3&0/*%0/*%( *&3$)<-/3/*//*%8-2%833$22%(-.2(0<43=7*-/(-74(0)?%< 020)3%33-6%70<4$?

3-6%-30(%(02%B/(%<%?%6%?#,*%80$?0/ ??08=0%/0/%7**%(0(%/%(*%((00<0$/022%(/*/3*%<= .%/70/<-/%#%340%/3*6%-/*%-((%4?=.-6%0$//*% /=4-7?3=<4/0<3020)3%33-6%70<4$?3-6%70/<-/-0-0(%(/0 33%(//*%27//*//*%8-2%8343=7*-/(-74/-%//*-334%7/ 83 0/ )(0$.*/ /0 /*% :08?%.% 02 /*% (%340%/3 0( /*%-( 30D*$3)02/*%%7%3%70<4?-///*%/-<%02<((-.% -/-30?=?/%(0/*/3--3%3%83(%6%?%20(8*-7* <%-7/-083?

@ 43=7*-/(-7 4(0)?%< 0( 3*% 83 7004%(/-6% /0 /:% 4(04%( /(%/<%/#,*%(%2$3%/077%4//*%2<-?=02/*%*$3)0$/02 2%($?/-</%?=/*%*$3)2-?%-60(7%4%/-/-03 70$/%(/0/*%3--60(7%4%/-/-0&/*% 83(%.-3/%(%)=/*% %7%3%D70<4?-/#/-3$(.%/*/33%-0(40?-7%022-7%(* 70$7/%/*%-6%3/-./-020$/*%70<4?-//0)%2?3%3 .-3//*%(%340%/32/*%(&<0/*%(&3-3/%()(0/*%(02*$3)& /*%(%83070.%/%6-%7%)%20(%?%(%.-3/(/%/0/:% 70.-F7%044?-7/-0$%(,%7/-0'

###*%=*6% 3$440(/% /*% 0(%( 433% )= /*% ?%(% -/-0? ,%33-03

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

(%340%/2<-?=-3?30-/*%4033%33-002/*%4%/-/-0%(#/-3 3//%2$(/*%(/*//*%2<-?=*?30-3/??%-(70-/-0%(- /*% (00< 02 /*% 70<4?-/ ?30 -3/??% .%%(/0( /0 <-/-/*%%?%7/(-7-/=3$)<-//*//*%(%-3073%20(--/-/-. 4(07%%-.30(((=-./*%<377$3%# # *6%703-%(%/*%3$)<-33-03#

,%7/-0'

#(%33$%(5

!"### $ %& ' # " ( " '!#'

## ' #) * " )) "## #

! ' + )"

# ## *)) $,%& + ' )"

)) ' ) # )"( '# # $ % " + '! ))

')" " + # # ( " '!#' ## *)) $-%& +

. $ %' .

$% #

!! )) #

. / $% 0 *

#! $%' )"

+ 1 2 # ##

( "! ))

%&'(()*+,-.

/%/(012+3%4%+'0/-(&5 (%40(/%- )%,(&03/-/$/-0 %7*02/*%4%B 0$(/&/*%,$4(%<%0$(/*%?/*//*%408%($%(,%7/-0' (# # 7 )% %B%(7-3% 0?= -2 /*% /(-? 70<<%7%3 8-/* /*%

(%70(-.02/*%%6-%7%-/7?30)%%B%(7-3%-%B7%4/-0? 7-(7$<3/7%3)%20(%/*%3-3/.%(-3%3#08%6%(&/*%.-3/(/% -34%(<-//%/0/:%70.-F7%//*%3/.%8*%(%/*%73%-3/0)% 70<<-//%/0/*%,%33-030$(/#C*-?%38%(-.>$%3/-00#' (%?/-./0/*%80(%6-%7%$3%-,%7/-0' #-/83*%? /*//*%%6-%7%<%/-0%-,%7/-0'

#70/%<4?/%3/*% %6-%7% 02 8-/%33%3 .-6% - /*% 0$(/ 0/ /*% </%(-? 6-?)?%-/*%7*(.%3*%%/0(73%-(=#*%->$-(=20(/*%3- 4$(403%-30///(-)$/)?%/0/*%-6%3/-./-00(/*%4(03%7$/-0)$/ *3/0)%0%)=/*%0$(/-/3%?22(0</*%%6-%7%8*-7**370<% 0(%70(#*$3&/*%27/30/*%(/*/*%</%(-?70??%7/%$(-. -6%3/-./-0&8*-7*(%0/-7%)=/*%%6-%7%8*-7**370<%0 (%70(&80$?)%4(/024(07%3302->$-(=20((%7*-./0 707?$3-0 8*%(% /*% -/-0? 77$3% (% (%>$-(% /0 )% 3$<<0%$%(,%7/-0'

$(/*%( /*% 03/-/$/-0 %7* ?30 (%7* /0 /*% 707?$3-0/*//*%0$(/*30//08-//-??/*%7(033%B<-/-0 028-/%33-306%(/0--/-/%4(07%%-.3$%(,%7/-0' ## 2 -/ -3 706-7% %6% 0 /*% )3-3 02 %6-%7% 44%(-. - %B<-/-0-7*-%2&-/74(07%%#

'# 3(%.(3/*%%.(%%023/-327/-0&/*%4%B0$(/ *%?3$%(5

' *

++ 4

0 * ' ! +! ) ,# + .

) 2 1 ' *' '

))

)!"

++ 1 *

# 33$5% -/* ,%7/-0 ' (# ##GH

# )%,( (%40(/%3 %6(5--%+'

&*.%5/%.%.

/%/(01 //%&&%'(5-%+'%+0/-(&703-%(-./*% ?8- %&'(()*+,-758%5(2&)% 0/%027$/-083?- 083$%(5

& " # #!! 6

! " +

7 # + # *1

++ ! ! ! !" *

#) *

4 ! *! )

!' ! "

+ ' ) )#

! )##) #

!! !! *

* ) # 35

@# (%7%/ 73% "*9%5 %/-(( .

/%/( 01 //%& &%'(5-$%7-%0 #'# '&:

))(%:0 01&/*% 4%B0$(/2/%((%?=-.$40%&'(()*+,-758%5(2)&%%+' %,%&.

/%/(01 //%&&%'(5- (%40(/%3 4(07%%%/0*0?/*//*%%6-%7%8*-7**70<%0(%70(83 0/3$22-7-%//03$<<0-/-0?77$3%-%B%(7-3%02408%( $%(,%7/-0'

#3-/-0/%3/)?-3*70<4?-7-/=02/*% 707%(%44%??/-7(-<%#

6-.0/-7%/*%?83%B40$%)=/*%,$4(%<% 0$(/&/*-30$(/2-3/*//*%27/302/*%4(%3%/73%(%6%? 4%7$?-(3-/$/-0#

# *%70<4?-/D?=?0.%/*%70<4?-/.-3/2-6% <% 4%(303 8*-7* -7?$% /*% 20$( (%340%/3 *%( *$3)#,*%<%34%7-2-7??%./-03-/*% &8*%(%2/%(/*% 7*(.%3*%%/832-?%&//*%3/.%02/(-?*%(3//%<%/70$?0/)% (%70(%33*%%B4-(%#*%70<4?-/70/%/3/*%(%0280$? *6%/0)%/*%(%20(%3$440(/%)=%6-%7%#

# /*%4(%3%/73%&/*%4%/-/-0%(*3%403%3 C )%20(%/*%0$(/02?8*33$440(/%/*%6%(3-0-/*% #% *3?30<%/-0%)0$//*%6(-0$3(/-7?%3.-6%0$/-08(=/0

*-3%7%3%$.*/%(//*%/-<%02<((-.%#*%6%(<%/*3 )%%<%02/*%(/-7?%3?=-.8-/*??/*%2-6%<%4%(303 -7?$-. 2/*%(-?8& <0/*%(-?8& )(0/*%( 3-3/%( 02 /*% *$3)/*//*%=(%)%-.$3%)=/*%<#

# 6-%802/*%)06%%6-%7%&/*%.-3/(/%*3-33$% 3$<<03-./*%20$(02/*%<3-/-0?77$3%20(022%7%3 $%(,%7/-0 #/*3?30)%%3//%-*-3%6-%7%/*/ /*%(%340%/3*4(060:%/*%*$3)02/*%%7%3%$.*/%( /0.-6%*%()%/-.20(%<-.02-/-0?08(=8*-7*3*% 70<4?-% /0 *%( 2/*%(# *% %6-%7%& /*%(%20(%& -(%7/?= 70((0)0(/%38-/*/*%70<4?-/02/*%%7%3%#I$%3/-002/*% (%340%/3 %2%7% 80$? 0/ (-3% / /*-3 3/.% /*%-( 70/%/-002/*%08(=(/-7?%3*6-.)%%(%/$(%70/)% 3$)+%7/<//%(02%B<-/-0//*%3/.%02%7--.44?-7/-020( <:-.-/-0?77$3%$%(,%7/-0'

%&'(()*+,-758%5(2)&%&/*%4%B0$(/*3 *%?/*//*%4%(303.-3/8*0</*%70.-F7%*30/)%% /:%&408%(3$%(,%7/-0'

#7)%%B%(7-3%/*% %6-%7%8*-7*-3/0)%?00:%-/07?30)%/*%3//%<%/8*-7* -3 0/ 3$)+%7/ <//%( 02 7(033 %B<-/-0# *% %.(%% 02 3/-327/-020(3$<<0-./*%0(-.-?77$3%3$)3%>$%/ 77$3%*30//0)%/*//*%(%-3?-:%?-*0002)%-.706-7/%)$/

-/-3/*%3<%320(2(<-.027*(.%#*$3&/*%%2%7%02/*% 77$3%3$)3%>$%/?=-<4?%%7?8=3)%4$/$48*-7*80$? )%%B<-%//*%3$)3%>$%/3/.%02/(-?#*%(%20(%&3-7%//*% 3/.% 02 '

(# #& 0?= ) # 73% -3 (%>$-(% /0 )% %3/)?-3*% 2(0< /*% %6-%7% ?% )%20(% /*% 0$(/ 0/ /0 )% %7%33(-?=0/*%)3-3027(033%B<-/-0J/*-30$(/2-3/*/ /*%(%-3%0$.*70((0)0(/-6%%6-%7%6-?)?%0(%70(/03*08 /*%70<4?-7-/=-60?6%<%/02/*%20$(4%(303#*%0(%(02/*% ?%(%.-3/(/%/*%(%20(%&70/)%2$?/%0(%(02/*% ?%(%-/-0?,%33-03 $.%%3%(6%3/0)%3%/3-%#

770(-.?=& /*% 0(%(3 /% @# %B$(%

&433%)=/*%?%(%.-3/(/%-)0/*/*%4%/-/-03(% (%3/0(%/*%0(%(3433%)=/*%?%(%-/-0?,%33-03

$.%/%#'#

%B$(% -)0/*/*%4%/-/-03(% >$3*%3%/3-%#*%?%(%.-3/(/%-308-(%7/%/0 4(07%%770(-.?=#

6-%802/*%)06%&)0/*/*%4%/-/-033/??08%#

%-.<-37#44?-7/-0 3&-2=&3*?? ?303/ -3403%022#

, 1 A,,

$%& '

! <</ C*%/*%(34%:-.D(%30% "%3D0 C*%/*%((%40(/)?% "%3D0