Municipal Corp. Gurgaon v. State Of Haryana
!
"#$
(')*+*,- ')'./'0 1
- 3" 44 "
0'+',&- 045%*6',(0%%*,14',*0(7)%&'8*&5 0%90%7::%08%61 04%,('';45%0.%1 0+58%,*<9.%090%1 056%8%& 0 0 )5*,&%,( 0%.<9.%04%*,*
0 +45'',9490%1(7)%&'+ 0&5'6%,(8,'0+ 045*7',(0%48%0;1++*+&%,&(7)%&'','0%61%0=%,% %>'+5*,(%6
!"#$ %& '!( ( &
%#$ %& #)&
& ) * + % , & %, & & %-.
&
#)& /& & & ) .%& & 0*'
6=1&5' %)&+%0'&5%&&5'6%,(1+*&9%&'(*,7*66%:'+(%.;901 %(+5%5;901%&'5;9014%.%+;90%,(5%+6%1'5+*6 *+&0*)&90:%, 8%++9:5&&/'%)?9*0'(/=&5'4&%&' %0=%,%7*(',&* *)%&*,(%&'(
1*++9'(9,('04')&*,$ &5'"%,()?9*+*&*,)&1 $
0 +50&1A&5')&3! 0('7'6;.',&%,(9&*6*+%&*,&5'0' %+4')&00%( /'&8'',4')&0+$ B2%,(2B2 190:%,&8%+ 668'(/=,&* *)%&*, 9,('0 4')&*, &5' )& (%&'( $ 5' "%,( )?9*+*&*, 66')&0
0+50&1&5'66')&03!17*('%8%0(
(%&'(
1 ('&'0.*,'(&5'.%0C'&7%69' &5'%)?9*0'(6%,(D$11EB;'0%)0'
;'0&%*,*,:&6%,( 7*66%:'(%.;90::0*'7'(%:%*,+&&5'%8%0( &5'
66')&01&5'6%,(8,'0+ *6'(/>')&*,+,0'
'0',)'9,('04')&*, &5')&1&5'6'%0,'()90&/'6817*('%8%0((%&'( #$ 1%++'++'( &5'.%0C'&7%69' &5'%)?9*0'(6%,(D EB;'0+?9%0'=%0( $ '0&%*,*,:&&5'6%,( 7*66%:'%(+5%5;901&5'66')&017*('
%8%0( 2(%&'(
1%++'++'(&5').;',+%&*,D 1 21EB ;'0%)0' ::0*'7'(%:%*,+&&5'%8%0( &5'66')&01&5'6%,(8,'0+
*6'(/>')&*,+,0'
'0',)'9,('04')&*, @ &5')&1&5'6'%0,'()90& /'6817*('%8%0((%&'(
1%++'++'(&5').;',+%&*,D EB ;'0+?9%0'=%0( 2 '0&%*,*,:&6%,( 7*66%:'%&'5;901&5'66')&017*('%8%0( $(%&'(
1%++'++'(&5').;',+%&*,D$11EB;'0%)0'
0)5%5*6%,(::0*'7'(%:%*,+&&5'%8%0( &5'66')&01&5'6%,(8,'0+
*6'(/>')&*,+,0'
'0',)'9,('04')&*, @ &5')&1&5'6'%0,'()90& /'6817*('%8%0((%&'(
1%++'++'(&5').;',+%&*,D EB ;'0+?9%0'=%0( '0&%*,*,: & 6%,( 7*66%:'4%.%+;901&5' 66')&01 7*('
%8%0( (%&'(
1%++'++'(&5').;',+%&*,D 1 21EB ;'0%)0' 0)5%5*6%,(::0*'7'(%:%*,+&&5'%8%0( &5'66')&01&5'
6%,(8,'0+ *6'(/>')&*,+,0'
'0',)'9,('04')&*, @ &5')&1&5'
6'%0,'()90&/'6817*('%8%0((%&'(2 1%++'++'(&5').;',+%&*, D EB;'0+?9%0'=%0(
# '0&%*,*,:&6%,( 7*66%:'5%+6%1&5'66')&017*('%8%0( (%&'(
1%++'++'(&5').;',+%&*,D$121EB;'0%)0'
0)5%5*6%,(::0*'7'(%:%*,+&&5'%8%0( &5'66')&01&5'6%,(8,'0+
*6'(/>')&*,+,0'
'0',)'9,('04')&*, @ &5')&1&5'6'%0,'()90& /'6817*('%8%0((%&'(
1%++'++'(&5').;',+%&*,D EB ;'0+?9%0'=%0( @ 0&5'+%C' ),7',*',)'1(%&' ,&* *)%&*,9,('04')&*, $ &5')&1&5'%.9,&%8%0('(/=&5'66')&0%,(&5'' '0',)'90& %,(&5'(%&' %8%0( &5''
'0',)'90&*,&5';0'+',&+'& %;;'%6+*+ 'F&0%)&'(/'68*,&%/96%&'( 0.-
.9,&%8%0('(/= .9,&%8%0('(
%8%0( ,&* *)%&*, &5'66')&0;'0%)0' /=&5''
'0',)'
&5' 9,('04')&*, *, 90&;'0+?9%0' '
'0',)' $ &5')& =%0(*, 90&
G*66%:'(%.;90 $11EB EB
#$
G*66%:'%(+5%5;90 21EB EB
G*66%:'%&'5;90 $11EB EB
G*66%:'4%.%+;90 21EB 05%5*6%,( EB 2
G*66%:'5%+6% $121EB 05%5*6%,( EB
"'%0,'( )9,+'6 0 &5' 6%,(8,'0+ +9/.*&&'( &5%& &5' '
'0',)'90&5%(:,'80,:*,%7'0%:*,:&5'+%6'),+*('0%&*,+58, *,(*
'0',&+%6'(''(+;0(9)'(,0')0(/=&5'6%,(8,'0+0%,:*,: 0.
EB& EB;'0+?9%0'=%0(%,(&5',%;;6=*,:%)9& $H&5'0', 5' 5*:5'+& +%6' 'F'.;6%0 +596( 5%7' /'', ),+*('0'( ' 90&5'0 +9/.*&&'( &5%& &5' 6%,( *, &5' +%.' %0'% 8%+ %)?9*0'( '%06*'0 7*(' ,&* *)%&*,(%&'( @
#5'6%,(8,'0+*,&5';0'+',&)%+'('+'07'& /':0%,&'(*,)0'%+' 0&5'&*.':%;
,&5'&5'05%,(16'%0,'()9,+'6 0&5'4&%&'+9/.*&&'(&5%& &8+%6'(''(+;0(9)'(/=&5'6%,(8,'0+*,&5')%+'+;'0&%*,*,:&&5'
$ %)?9*+*&*, 6%,(7*(',&* *)%&*,(%&'( @
#%,(85*)55%7'/'', ;0(9)'(*,&5')%+'*,5%,(%0'(*
'0',&5'+'(,&(';*)&&5%&&5'0'
8%+%,=*,)0'%+'*,&5';0*)'+*,&5'%0'%,)0'%+' 0&5'&*.':%;)%,/'
:0%,&'(,6=*,)%+'&5'0'*+.%&'0*%6,0')0(+58*,:*,)0'%+'*,&5' ;0*)'1%+8%+;0(9)'(/=&5'6%,(8,'0+*, $ I 49(%.%%,(&5'0+75'4&%&' %0=%,%%,( %,&5'01(')*('(,
&*+%)%+' ,'7*(',)'5'6%,(8,'0+(,&('+'07'&/' :0%,&'(%,=*,)0'%+'*,&5').;',+%&*,10%&5'01&5'%8%0( &5'66')&0 ('+'07'+&/'9;5'6(
&5'0*++9'8%+0%*+'(
'%0(6'%0,'()9,+'6 0&5';%0&*'+%,(;'09+'(&5'0'6'7%,& 0'
'00'(0')0(
G*(' ,&* *)%&*, (%&'( 1 &5' 6%,( ;'0&%*,*,: & 4%.%+;901(%.;9015%+6%1%&'5;90%,(%(+5%5;908%+%)?9*0'(5' %)?9*0'(6%,(*+*,+.%66B+.%66;)C'&+ 5'+)%,,'();= &5' ;6%, ;0(9)'(*,
I564*,:5%,(%,&5'074&%&'
%0=%,% %,( %,&5'01 (')*('( 7*(' +';%0%&' >9(:.',& '7', (%&'1 +58*,:%)?9*0'(6%,(*+%;;',('(/'68-
2
$ 5'0'*+,+*&';6%,;0(9)'(,0')0(/=&5'6%,(8,'0+%+ +9)5+58*,:&5'%)?9*+*&*, 6%,(5'4&%&'8%+(*0')&'(&;0(9)'% +*&';6%,*,)90&(';*)&*,:&5'6)%&*, &5'6%,(185*)58%+;0(9)'( ;'09+%6 &5';6%,+58+&5%&%)?9*+*&*, 6%,(*+*,;)C'&+6)%&'(%& (*
'0',& ;6%)'+ 5'6%,(8,'0+ 5%7' ;0(9)'( 7%0*9+ +%6'(''(+ , 0')0(185*)5;'0&%*,&&5'0'7',9''+&%&' 7*66%:'(%.;90185*)5%0'%+ 9,('0- F
0'%+6( &%6+%6'
7'0%:'
G*66%:' 0':*+&0%&*,
<B !
),+*('0%&*, ;'0+?9%0'
*, =%0(*,
#
@1 1@ EB
# (%.;90
#
$1$21$ EB
@ (%.;90 $
#
@1 1@ EB
$
(%.;90 2
#
2
$1 12 EB
B(B
#
@1 1@ EB
$
B(B #
#
$1$21$ EB
@ B(B @
#
@1 1@ EB $
B(B
#
$1$21$ EB
@ B(B
#
@1 1@ EB
# B(B
#
2
$1$21$ EB
$ B(B
#
@1 1@ EB
# B(B
#
2
@ 1@ EB
@ B(B $
#
2
#1@1 EB
$2 B(B
#
#1@1 EB
$ B(B
$ B
$121EB
$ B(B #
$ B
$121EB
B(B
$ B
$121EB
$ B(B
$ B
$121EB
$ B(B
$ B
$121EB
$ B(B
#
#
@1$1 @@EB
B(B
#
#
@1$1 @@EB
$# B(B
#
#
@1$1 @@EB
$# B(B $
#
#
@1$1 @@EB
B(B
@
$
1@21 @EB
2 B(B
@
1@21 @EB
B(B #
@
$
1@21 @EB
2 B(B
@
1@21 @EB
B(B
2 9& &5'% 0'+%*(+%6'(''(+1*,.=;*,*,1+%6'(''(+ F &F !1%0'0'6'7%,&%+&5'+%.'8'0'0':*+&'0'(*,)&/'01 5'+'%0'*,)6+'0%,:' $& EB;'0+?9%0'=%0(+&5'%0'% 8%+*,&5'('7'6;.',&+&%:'%,(&5'/9*6('0+8'0'/9=*,:&5';0;'0&=1*, .=;*,*,1*,)0'%+' 0&5';'0*( ,'='%0%,( *7'.,&5+9;&&5'
(%&' *++9%,)' ,&* *)%&*,9,('04')&*,$ &5')&('+'07'&/'
%(('(&5'0', %C*,:&5'/%+'7%69'D $EB;'0+?9%0'=%0(%,( :0%,&*,:)9.96%&*7'*,)0'%+'D
H;'0%,,9. 0,'='%0%,( *7'
.,&5+1&5'7%69'896().'9&& 1$2#EB;'0+?9%0'=%0(,+*('0*,:
&5'+*J' &5';6&+('%6&8*&51*,.=;*,*,1%)9& H*+0'?9*0'(&/'
%;;6*'( &'00'(9)*,:&5'% 0'+%*(%.9,&1&5').;',+%&*,896().'
9&& 1 EB;'0+?9%0'=%0(5'% 0'+%*(%.9,& ).;',+%&*,*+ %6+0'%+,%/6'* &5'6%,( ,'*:5/90*,:0'7',9''+&%&'+185*)58%+ %)?9*0'(*,
#1*+).;%0'(
'6*%,)' 6'%0,'()9,+'6 0&5'6%,(8,'0+,&5'>9(:.',& &5*+90&*, 49(%.%3+ )%+' +9;0%! 0&5';90;+' %++'++.',&
).;',+%&*,*+.*+;6%)'(%+&5'6%,(('%6&8*&5&5'0'*,*+6)%&'(%&% (*+&%,)'%,( 90&5'0&5'0'%0'+%6'(''(+%7%*6%/6';'0&%*,*,:&&5'0'7',9' '+&%&'16%,( 85*)58%+%)?9*0'(
# ))0(*,:6=1&5'6%,(8,'0+%0'5'6(',&*&6'(&).;',+%&*, D 1 EB ;'0+?9%0'=%0(5'=+5%66%6+/'',&*&6'(&%66+&%&9&0= /','
*&+%7%*6%/6'&&5'.9,('0&5')&
@ 5'%;;'%6+%,(&5')0++/>')&*,+ *6'(/=&5'6%,(8,'0+ %0'%668'(*,&5'.%,,'0*,(*)%&'(%/7'185'0'%+&5'%;;'%6+ *6'(/=&5'
4&%&'%0'(*+.*++'(
%>'+5*,(%6!
9(:'
')'./'0 1 .C
'
'0&';0&'0!