High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25477/2014allowed

Hardial Singh v. Financial Commissioner Appeals & ORS

2016-11-15Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi5 pages

! " ##$%&& '(!)* +&

,- (%.

& ,/, 01(%-(!)* , 02

(%.

& 33333 !"# $%&'" (%)*+ $ (, 4 & 5 $%7! 86' 6

5 $%7!89'(4*0& 4&&:#*( &. # 0 # 4 ! #& ( 4 # *0 40

. 4 *

&9 &4#4 *

& ! &

; & :#*

. .

&(*! : < (:#* 4

!&.04

& 4 & :#* % & #&.#*0

(& &&*1(& / * 4

0 4 & 4 0 =

&& & :#* . 6

5 $%7! 8' +& && * ##(4

4#4!.! 0 &(.6

5$%7!89' . & * " ##( 4 *.8 & *0 ## #

4 87#! &&&&( && !* :#*=4&*0 " ## $%7!8 '+& #!*040 . $/ *

=" ##(8&!)*' = !( . 5 $%7! 8 '( #" ## .&#>#& 5 $%7!8 '(&*0!(" ##& $%7!86'5 (&& & :#*(4&

. ! & * ( !

&! (! &1& .4 0 !# &!

0 *( # 4 !* &&# & :#* > *!& 0 5 0(4 4 && *0 " ## :#*( . 5 $%7!86' =# & #4

*0 " ##(& ! 4 ( & &&*1

&( 0 0>.4 #(" ##!

. (44 4 %& 5 04!

*&& # ! :#*

#!&&. # .

4( 4 .4 && -.#

( &!

0( = ! ; 4 ( & 4!

*&& #!4

( 00 &!&4!

*.*0&& #:#*> ( && !

.&& & :#*( (4* # 0*# ?=4!

* !* 0! .

&&#& :#* # 0(

#&!

.0&&& #5 0 ( :#* #>*.(4#

&* # > .4 4 * ! *.( 1& .4*.#*0@* !&#! >

! .4" ## && ## & #( * ( 4 & (#*!:! & !

. 0 #

!# 0(* # . (! ! #&!

& *0 " ## * ! !

# &

0 &.0(4*!( 4

!#4 &!

!# *.(!& 4 #(! .4 #&!

& *0 " ## * !& #

0 &.*& =##

(2&! &

!&& :#*( 0 4 4

0( 4 *.8 *. # !(&4&& (4.( 4 - . &1 A B +&* B