← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB/189/2020disposed of

Polycnes, Through Its Proprietor v. Municipal Corporation And ORS

2021-02-16Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill4 pages

 



       

 !"#$!%&'&"()!*+*,- .  /- 

 / / .0  11111! & &"(!* 2!*'+'

 .  

/ 111!'3"($!( '

 ) 4.

/1/ 

./ .. *!'!( )

*1!!35/&(67/&(&-$8"% !#"* 7!3! & &"(!*1

*1'7&'7$8-$8"% !#"* 7!*!'3"($!( '1  999 7&': !*&'!&(6 5!(+3#"*7!*&(6 7*"+678&$!"%"(#!*!(%&(6$+! ""+ *!5"# 7!3($!:&%- 21 *,!* &( 7&' 3! & &"( +($!* /!% &"(  - ;-   "# *& * &"( ($

"(%&<& &"(% -#"*'7"* => 7!% ?

&'#"*33"&( :!( "#'"<!&($!3!($!(  *& * "*1! & &"(!*@'<<" !$ 7!@"*5"# %"(' *+% &"("#8*&"+'*"$'@& 7 &( !*<"%5&(6 38!* <"%5 AB 6*$!- : 7&%5 &( <$!8 6*- C*$ ("1 -

+*6"( <<" !$ 8&$! :!:" "1

D2D;D $ !$ 11; "( 7! '&'"# !($!*'+:& !$"(;11($ %"(' *+% &"("#8*&"+'*"$'@& 7 &( !*<"%5&(6 &<!'#*": 7": 5 "*!8!(+!' C*$("1- +*+6*:<<" !$ 8&$! :!:" ("1

D

D;DBA $ !$ ;1E1; "( 7! '&' "# !($!* '+:& !$"(111! & &"(!*&''  !$ "78!' * !$($%":3<! !$ 7!@"*5 @& 7&(' &3+< !$3!*&"$'3!*' &'#% &"(($$&*!% &"("# (6&(!!*&( 7&!#-+  7! 3,:!( '@!*!'  !$<,(" *!<!'!$1$&'3+ !$:& !$<,*"'!! @!!( 7!3* &!'1 .!6< (" &%! $ !$ A11 @' &''+!$ , 7! 3! & &"(!* #"* 7! $!3* :!(  " '! <!:!( 1!F+!' #"*33"&( :!( "#*& * "*@'<'"$$*!''!$, 7!3! & &"(!* 8&$! <! !* $ !$ E11 +  " (" 8&<- 7!*!#"*!- 3*!'!(  3! & &"( '!!5&(6 33"&( :!( "#'"<!&($!3!($!( *& * "*7'!!(#&<!$1

 ( !*:' "# %<+'! B "# 6*!!:!(  $ !$ 1E1- 7!*! &'  3*"8&'&"( #"* *!#!*!(%! "# 7! : !* " 7! '"<! *& * &"( "# (, '!*8&(6 /+3!*&( !($&(6 (6&(!!*"# 7! +(&%&3< "*3"* &"(- +*6"(- "!(":&( !$, $!'&6( &"(, 7&!# (6&(!!*  7!*!<!8(  &:!1 7!%<+'!&(F+!' &"(*!$'' +($!*G && << $&'3+ ! "* $&##!*!(%! &( *!'3!%  "# @7&%7 7! $!%&'&"( &' ("  #&(<($%"(%<+'&8!'7<<  7!*!F+!' -&(@*& &(6-"#!& 7!*3* ,-:$! &(%"::+(&% &"('!(  7*"+67!6&' !*!$113"' !*!#!**!$ " 7! '"<! *& * &"( "# (, '!*8&(6 /+3!*&( !($&(6 (6&(!!* "# +(&%&3<

"*3"* &"(- +*6"( "!(":&( !$,$!'&6( &"(, 7&!# (6&(!!* "# +(&%&3< "*3"* &"(- +*6"(  7!*!<!8(  &:!1 7!*!@&<<!(" "H!% &"( "(, '+%7 33"&( :!(  7  7! *& * "*'" 33"&( !$ &'

"8 1/!*8( D&('!*8&%!"# +(&%&3< "*3"* &"( +*6"("* 7 7$ " $!< @& 7 7! : !* " @7&%7 7! %"( *%  *!< !' &( 7! %"+*'! "# 7&' $+ &!'' "8 1/!*8( D&('!*8&%!"# +(&%&3< "*3"* &"(- +*6"( 7!7'!I3*!''!$7&'8&!@'"(<<"*(,"# 7!: !*&($&'3+ !1 7! *& * "* "@7": 7!: !*'&'"*&6&(<<,*!#!**!$!&(6 *('#!**!$"* 8% &(6 7&' "##&%!- 7&' '+%%!''"*&("##&%!- ' '+%7 '7<< ! !( & <!$ " 3*"%!!$ @& 7 7! *!#!*!(%! #*": 7! ' 6!   @7&%7 &  @' <!#  , 7&' 3*!$!%!''"*1 * (%'! 7!*& * "*(":&( !$, 7! 7&!# (6&(!!*- +(&%&3<

"*3"* &"(- +*6"(&'+(<!"*+(@&<<&(6 "% '*& * "*'+%7#"* (, *!'"(- @7 '"!8!* 7! 7&!# (6&(!!*- +(&%&3< "*3"* &"(-

+*6"( '7<< ! %":3! !(  " 33"&(  ($ (":&( ! (, " 7!* /+3!*&( !($&(6 (6&(!!*"# +(&%&3< "*3"* &"(- +*6"('*& * "* &(7&'3<%!($ 7!*& * "*'"33"&( !$'7<<!!( & <!$ "3*"%!!$ @& 7 7!*!#!*!(%!1G 7"+67*!3<,7'(" !!(#&<!$$!'3& !"33"* +(& ,-<!*(!$%"+('!<#"* 7!*!'3"($!( '= +(&%&3< "*3"* &"($"!'(" $!(, 7 $&'3+ !7'*&'!(

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





          ($ 

 !

"!

#$ % !

!

$

&'

( !

 "#('

)-& &''! <!$3"'& &"( 7  7!/+3!*&( !($&(6 (6&(!!*"# 7!*!'3"($!( "*3!*'"(&('!*8&%!"# 7! +(&%&3< "*3"* &"(%"+<$(" 78! !!(33"&( !$'*& * "*1 .!*(!$%"+('!<#"* 7!*!'3"($!( &'+(<! "$!(, 7!+('+' &(&<& , "#+(&< !*<33"&( :!( "#*& * "*, 7!:(6!:!( 1 0!!3&(6 &( 8&!@ 7! #% ' ($ %&*%+:' (%!'- 7&' 3! & &"( &' <<"@!$1 /71 11 6<(- &' *&%  ($ /!''&"(' +$6!- ! &*!$ - *!'&$!(  "# <  "1 BA- <5(($ /"%&! ,- /!% "* B- +*+6*:- &' 33"&( !$ ' 7! /"<! *& * "*1

"@!8!*-'+%733"&( :!( @"+<$!'+H!%  " 7!$!%<* &"( "!:$!, 7! *& * "* +($!* /!% &"(  "# 7! %  @& 7 *!6*$ " 7&' &($!3!($!(%! ($ &:3* &<& , "'! <! 7!$&'3+ !'! @!!( 7!3* &!'1 7! *& * "* &' " %":3<! ! 7! 3*"%!!$&(6' @& 7&( 7! &:! <&:&  '3!%&#&!$+($!*/!% &"("# 7!% 1 7!*& * "*'7<<!3&$#!!&(%%"*$(%!@& 7 7!"+* 7/%7!$+<! "# 7!% -':!($!$- "!"*(!!F+<<,, 7!3* &!'1

E 2!(+! "# 7! *& * &"( '7<< !   +*+6*: "*   (, " 7!* 3<%! %"(8!(&!(  "<<%"(%!*(!$-'+H!%  "$&'%*! &"("# 7!*& * "*1 * &!' " 33!* !#"*! 7! /"<! *& * "* "( '+%7 $ ! ($ &:! ' (":&( !$,7&:1*"%!!$&(6':,<'"!%"($+% !$ 7*"+678&$!"%"(#!*!(%&(6 '+H!%  "%"('!('+':"(6<<1 .&' &<< !*+*,-       +$6! rts C7! 7!*'3!5&(6D*!'"(!$ )!'D" C7! 7!**!3"* <! ) !'D"