← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4784/2010allowed

Ram Kuwar & ORS. v. Ram Chander & ORS.

2026-02-16Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

          





 

 

 



 

!

"

#$%

& & '

 #$#($) "

#$% '& & '

*+#,"

"

#$% & & '

Whether only the operative part of the judgment is pronounced? No Whether full judgment is pronounced?

Yes  %  -.

/& /  /

/       



 

    





 

!"#    $ %%%% /

/

&

& '          (         

)* )!

+)&)

($   

  '(    

     &,,  -   &.//0  

1'( 23    

           

+ .) *))4"

  56 78 

  

   - 

 

 )* && +))/ +



       

  

9 

   ($  '(     

  9  (

  : ($ /

//  /  .   /.

   / !

' 

    " 



   

($  '(       (

 

'    $            (   

  (    * 

  

 

 

!"#    $

  $     $( 

   

 

($  '(   $(

 

' $  

  #  

    

 /. .0 

  / 

, ;

2(              Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 1 2

'

/(*

#( 4 ,



 

 

       "

<30     

            

    

       

              

   

     

 

     

 

      

           

   

         !"#$           

 %#  !"&$

  

 &'   !"($      



 31)

       

        *           (+,                  









  

  

-  

    

 

      

     

 $          .  /

 

         

              *  

 

                    

  



         

      32 

                 (+,          

    (+,          

        



  

         

             



 

        

   * * * * * * 42. )     



    &$          0

 1   $       !2    !(%+ %!

%(

$ 

    

 3!4 %'#+

3!'#!#(

3!(#'&+

3

!&&!&(

 3!#&'(+

  



   

 3!!(!((

35 (''+

34'!'(

 3(''4+

;

2(    National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 1

'

/ ' 5     

&,, &,!" &,/  -   &.//  

 "

03 =    

      >      ?

0@3      ?

03  ( $ ?

0=3 

(   

   

 $  

 

  >



 ?

0A3 B

  

 

     C (? " $ > $ '   C

  

 "

<52. 6  conventional heads

    

   

 7/

8*

    7 %(+++       

  7  !+++++  

  7 !+++++ 



 

         

      

   7/

 0  9 

 





       



   

 

  



 

   :    

 

     6                   

     



 



    

   

  

  

   

  ; 

       

          

     

        

   

     



   



              

  

*

     

            

  

 

  

     

 

!(+++  7 &++++     7 !(+++  

    

                    



    <              

  

 

 )     

               

  

    

  

   !+,   

) 

 

 



  





  = = = = = 59.3)    

  (+,    



 





 / 

'

  &+

    

 #+,  

  

&+ (+

* 

  

 (+'+

    !(, 6   

   

 59.4* 







 $ 

   &+,

 



  

    &+

6  %(,

  

  &+(+

 !+,

  

 (+'+

   

  

 

     59.5.              

          #+#%0> ?  



    59.6. 

         

  0> @ &%/

 59.7  

        59.87   

        





 

    

 7

!(+++7 &++++ 7 !(+++

  

    

  !+,  

A

/ ;

2(    ,83, $ ,+

$( ,$)

#3*,$9 .:3:4 "

;&

,$( ,3 ,+:, <(< ( ,3  4<

1  

/

6 5 

  /, +, ;

3, (* ,  ,$,9 / 4<:

/(* ,



  

   

 "

B216  <

  C  0 8        

  

         

  ;

   

      

 

*  

D D  

 



 D    D  D 

D D D 

      



 

 

  



    )  

      

       

  



%!! Spousal consortium   

        

         

    



D 

   

     

 /  D %!% Parental consortium      



              

   D    

   

     

   

     D %!# Filial consortium             

  

 

  6



     

           

  

   

    

     

              22  



 

     

       3 /     

 

  

E    

 

       

   

  3 /                

   

           

 

  

      

 23 3> 

6  

    

      

  

 

   

* 

       

             

               

C       

    

   6 6     

    

      

  

 

           

   

24  

        

 

   D

 D   C  0 8*  



        

          7  &++++      

   

.

       

(+)$  

     



'  '(   $

   +) $

;

   '( 

    $ 

($:  

     7+$

           

 

 &/  (   && &)       

 $  -> $ 

 

  $

 

/ )))4"

# (   $

 $  (      

  '( 

      

 (  : (   ;$  ;

 :       : 

 

 :



  (:  



    

 ( :  :   

  $

  ( 



7 )))4"

    C  '  $

  

&7= > &&       '( 



$  &4! > 

>   &4+ 

  

&+        

 



  



 :  



  0+)$  8

   (

&!

B      

 B    '(  

  $   



  D >

'  9        ./ 

&* #  

 ($;

2(   (   C

 

    

' 

)* )!

+)&)   



$  '    "

        

    

    

 " "

Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded &  $#



7)))4" + B

 5*)8

+)))4"0*)8 7)))3 !

=    

 

 > &4!

!7))4"06)))E&4+3 * '

#



!7))4"06)))"!7))3 *  &/  = $

7, )))4"0!7))E&+E&/3 ,

A 

&7 )))4"

B A>

&7 )))4"

/





& ,) )))4"

B

*) )))4">* #4,+ #3* $,4:#$ &2='= >  "()4:#$    ($'(  &=2 = > $<,$) "

,3#($4 &'=77=' > 2' 2 

&7     

 

 ($;

2(  Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma   '

R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation  

/(*

#( 4 ,

=   "

       5.8          

   G

&, 

   

 !"#      $       

       

  

  '(   

     

$  C

  ''( 

   (     

  

   

    4 

  )* )!

+)&) '

  4            ( : 

       '(  &6   

 $ 



/

/



'& & '

H   I : "

:  J 4

I (  J