← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25507/2014allowed

M/S Jai Narain Alloys v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd & ORS

2023-05-15Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj12 pages

    

       



 !"#"$%& '(# " ) "$**+#  "

"$) ,)#-# -$.

/0

1) )2)

"$3"4"

$  5)#  #2$ $ #

'%  63'

 0 7 0   

  



    

7 0  89 ) *:





 

"

#$  % 

'(&( )

*& 

+&

 

( 

, 

(( -     (   

./  

012!

 



 

3   (

4 56 2

! 8 (  

*& / +  



 



  )

 (( 

+&

:     (  



; (



(



$

;;

( 4 5" 76 2 (

*& / +       

 =  +   >

   

(

#+

+ 

+ %

 

 /.

   ( +   ( 4 !!  2 

 

 (  !?

 

 

 ( 4 > $ (





 ( > $ (

( +  + $

  !8

"



 $  

 +> @@

/& /

&   !!

/& / ,

      >

( 

<





 

( (  $ 

:  

 ( 



   

 *& / +  



)  (   + /.

 ((  &

;&;

,

 & (  

   >





!@

3+   

( 4 5" 562  4 56756 2  (   !@

(( 

: !5 

 (

 +  (  ( ( 

 

  

(

B

   (     . =  ( =  4 B(  

 

5 &   *

  . =  ( =  4 B(







 *& / )

4 

((  

 

"

&     . =  ( =  4 B(   &   . =  /( ((  0   !@

&   *

  . =  /( ((     !"

"

  & '(&( )

*& !"

"

   *

3 

.    &+  



4

/

 ! 6  +





;

;

2 



( 

 

$  C 

    

  

         

           

 

   

     

               

         !  "                    

                    

          

     

                  

                 

D @

3  ; (  

 &+ 

=( E

 

 

 (  (



 

4

 

 =( E (   > + (

 2    (

& 



( 

   ( 

>

$ (   =( + ( +   : 

   : 

 

   /(&

  + (

;;

 *    & 

 =

     +  #$ %   "$   &   &'&    ( ) 

     *    %      "+,-., /,  &   0) ".+$,1 +, ,&'&

  () 2,,$+2, ,!" 

 +, ,                     3 ,, $

/    



       4      4         %     

  !"     ,11, ,       4 

  

   4       ,1 1, ,     ,1,, ,            ,1 +, +   4 *    3,$

/

      )      

          

   4 

              

 

 

     

       

+  2       4  ,   50),2+$+ ,, +61+ 2 , ,7%    4           %             

    %       

;=;

%<     %           4     

      

 % 

   ,6 -, +        ,1 +, +     



44        

4      4  6 %   6       

     ,6 -, + - %     

      -          

  3+ -.

+-$/&(!

)  0

('3 8   ,

-.      9 .   

  

 . :   &

  .        

       

     

                      

      0   5  7      0 5  7 

     

      5+ 7 

         

 ;    3+- $

/<++-$ /        3+ -.

+-$/  =  3+2

$ +-$/                 *  "+++  ! ,6 ., +  >

.  

&   (   $ ( (>

 (

 (  !    

;;

  (

)$ 

 : =

  

 



 4

$



  4



 &+

(  

.   )

/

 

)

4 

((  4

$

+  (



  $ 

(  

 

<     

 

  (  & 

   +  (  =

    

+  

   ((  !""



&  

 &* +

 

&  

    ,, ?@0A/28

A  

&  

    ,, ?@00  ; B 

&            ,,  ?@ 0  0   A/  8

A  

  -

& .

8@&  ,, ?@00A/2,, ?@00; B 

&  

             8@&  66  ?@ %66?@00 C B 

;>;

%< &  4       D  

             B0B(  

                    

   

   B0B( A  

E4  * 

                66 ?@,,  ?@0 0 A 0 C     

     

4             0A  &  D4    

 

                              66  ?@ 

     B0B(  

                 

D

      +   

 = 

/(&

B









; ( $ &+ 

=( E +      !

 (  (

   >





F 

"

4 $ & 

+

 

 =( E ( (    > + (  (  



( 

3 &

+

;<;



   ( 

  (&

(



 

: 

&*

  

 (

  

=



  

&

& =  +  * (



/    -

 +    

 

(  2  

( 

& 

(  

(  (  

       $ (   

 &  &

2 (

   &

4   

+

(     



  (( 

   /(&

  >

 (

F     



  ( : &

+

< 

 =

>

&

 (



  /  

@

(  +  $         

 +    





;;

) +    

+ $  > ( 

 >  

 



   (   #+ 

(    $ 



(%  +

+    

 

 

     

( +  ( &

$  + 





  + (  

(

  >   &



(



 

 

(



$



 >  

   +

 ( (



 (

+ 

+

 



1

 (



  ( 



 ( 



 >

$  & (  

 



G    



   

  

;;

 

>



 

:            =   (     :

  (

G

 ( >

   

( 

4

)

/

 4  ! 6 <   

 &+  (

 (

      

= 





( ( (     ( ( 

(  

  

     (



    

  =

 

(&

 

 (  $ 

 &

 (   $ (     +  

 >  (

1  $ 









 

 + 





+

 

 &+  

(



;;

%< 4 567562 



 



( 

+ 

(        

 

  ((

97 0 :    &   1 > 2



I2E 1 &



I2E