High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28043/2013allowed

Hdfc Life Insurance Co Ltd v. Permanenet Lok Adalat Public Utility Serv.Gurgaon & ANR.

2017-02-13Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

!"##$%&%'( #)*+!*, - .

/"!'0!*01%#'&+*!'$#1"0-+*2!'

#"%"%'#* 3#*&+&

#*4!'#'"150!6!" +)6%$ "%6%",/#*7%$#&-+*2!' "8#*& #&9'0#'"&

!"#$ %&'()$ )(

#*%&+,$

*#&#'"( *!*%&88!*0:!;-07$!"#* *,0%98!""!$8!*,!-07$!"#- *"8#9#"%"%'#* * !5#&8+9"!-07$!"#- **#&9'0#'" '#**#&9'0#'"& <<<<<

)(

#*%-

#"%"%'#*= 1%#'&+*!'$#49!',1%4%"#0%&!22*%#7#0 "8#%49+2'#0!:!*00!"#0. ''#>+*# = *#'0#*#0),"8#

#*4!'#'"150!6!"-+*2!''!'!996%$!"%'+'0#*/#$"%'= "8#1#2!6/#*7%$#&+"8*%",$"- ?.-:8#*#),"8#9#"%"%'#*8!&)##'

0%*#$"#0"9!,!&+4 &-.-@.A=""8#*#&9'0#'"=%'&+*#0 *!*%&8 8!*0:!;- 6#!*'#0 $+'&#6 *#9*#&#'"%'2 "8# 9#"%"%'#*&+)4%"&"8!"*#&9'0#'"80!8%0B8!'-!"8#**%!'!

&%'$# 0#$#!&#0 8!0 &+)4%""#0 ! *9&!6 *4)#!*%'2 @.?

0!"#0 ''#>+*# = :%"896!'0#&$*%9"%' '#,!$5 &&+*!'$#!6'2:%"8%'%"%!69*#4%+4 &@A=8#&!%09*#4%+4:!& *#$#%7#0),"8#9#"%"%'#*$49!',7%0# #$#%9" ?- :8#*#!& *%'!0%#0'

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

0 %'"- *#&+6"%'2%'"9!&&%'2"8#%49+2'#0!:!*0 ' "8# $'"*!*,- * !5#&8 +9"!- 6#!*'#0 $+'&#6 *#9*#&#'"%'2*#&9'0#'"=%'&+*#00#&'"0%&9+"#"8#7!6%0%","8# %'&+*!'$# $7#*A*%&5 !'0 9!,4#'" "8# 9*#4%+4 !*#4#'"%'#0- )+" &+)4%"&"8!"%":!&"8#0+","8#%'&+*#*"%&&+#"8#96%$,%'0+#$+*&# 8# *9&!6 *4 !$$49!'%#0 ), ! &+4 &@-A= !& 9*#4%+4 &+)4%""#0 !'0 *#$#%7#0 %& ! 0##4#0 !$$#9"!'$# 8# %&&+!'$# "8# %'&+*!'$#96%$,:!&'6,!4#*#*4!6%",&&+4%'2*"8#&!5# !*2+4#'""8!""8#96%$,:+60'"8!7#)##'%&&+#0*!'"8#*9#*%0 &%>4'"8&!'0"8#%'&+*#08!00%#0-"8#%'&+*!'$#$49!',$!''""!5#"8# )#'#%""8#"#*4&!'0$'0%"%'&-%#-0#$6!*!"%'"8#6%#")#!&&+*#0 !&#'7%&!

2#0%'/#$"%'="8# *9&!6 *4-"8+&-9*!,&*0%&4%&&!6 "8#:*%"9#"%"%':%"8#>#496!*,$&"& 8!7#8#!*0"8#6#!*'#0$+'&#6*"8#9!*"%#&!'0!99*!%&#0 "8#9!

8#"#*4&!'0$'0%"%'&-%#-/#$"%'="8# *9&!6 *4 *#!0"8+&(= C

! " ! "

# $

! " ! "$

$ !

" ! "

! " ! "

$ $

$ ! " ! "

! " "

&$'()*

! " "

% !

! !

8# 8%286%28"#0 9*"%' 0#& '" #'!)6# "8# '&+*!'$# 49!',"!&&+4#"8#*%&5-'#"8#$'0%"%'")#$496%#0:%"8' !$$+'""8#0#!"8"8#%'&+*#0""8#)#&"-"8#%'&+*#0%&#'"%"6#0" *#+'0"8#9*#4%+48#$'$#0#09&%"%''*#$*0%&"8!""8#96%$, :!&'"%&&+#0"0#&'"6%#%'"8#4+"8"8#*#&9'0#'""8!"%":!&"8# 0+","8#'&+*!'$#49!',"%&&+#"8#96%$,8#!$$#9"!'$#"8# 9*#4%+4$!''")#&!%0")#0##4#0$'&#'"%'"8#!)&#'$#"8#%&&+!'$# "8#96%$,8#!*#4#'"%'#0!&9#$"8!&'")##'#>!4%'#0),"8#

#*4!'#'"150!6!"!'0-"8+&-"8#*#%&2*&&%66#2!6%",!'09#*7#*&%", '4,7%#:-"8#!:!*0"8# #*4!'#'"150!6!"%&'"

&+&"!%'!)6#7%&=!=7%&"8#2*!'""8#*%&5""8#"+'# &-.-@.A=!'0 "8#&!4#%&6%!)6#")#40%%#0""8#)#&"-"8#'&+*!'$#49!',%& 6%!)6#"*#+'0 &@-A=9!%0!&9*#4%+4!6'2:%"8%'"#*#&"D?E9#* !''+4 %"8 "8# !*#4#'"%'#0 40%%$!"%' %' "8# *0#* +'0#* $8!66#'2#-"8#:*%"9#"%"%'&"!'0&0%&9&#0 / 01-2*3 )(

# -4 %&+,$ 6 6 57 -8 9: -5

;

< 5:

6 6

-0

< 5: