Andaz @ Mintu And Another v. State Of Haryana And Another
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND
HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
!
"#
$#
%#! & '#( "#
) '
*+,-.
&
/0&12.
*2&'
, 1
*2&'
, 1 /
!" #$%&
'"!'" $($)'
*! %
$($) +,! )- .! . /! /00 !123 %$ (5 $($( ! " 6% 64)$)#(52. " "7 /00 8 8 8 !" 4. 8 !99 !8 *! (6 (6 $($# .! " /! /00 8 8 , 8 0! !" )4:. 9 $ & ! 9 123 8 9 ;! 89 8 9!< = % (5 $($(8 " 9
! 8 9' ' 9 9 ! !($ # 8
8 8 '! 9 ! 0! 9 8 ' 8
98 9 123 8 "9 8 8 ! 0;!9>9!<8! *! 8 8! =!" 6% 642.8! " )6 2.8 ' 9 8 ' .!9 $98 .! ) 7! ! 0!9"
8 9 ? 69 ! " ) 4 . !99 ! @ (%
$($) 8 2 ! !
9! ! 8 8 ! ! 8 !
98' .!9 $ ! 98 9 ? 69
9 8 9 .! 8! 0! !9 88 9 289 9 8 9 8 ! 123
! ! !
9 *! 99'! 8 9 ! !999 ! 2 !! 8 9! *! #
9 A"! !9 2 ! 9 9 9! 9 :
2! !!
% ! 8! " 4. 8 ! B
$4# )# 5 "# )#
))#5 6 5!7( + - ? ! *!
9 ! 99 8 !! 8 ! .! 9 ! 8 99 +$- ? ! .! 9 !99 !9 9 *!
! +)- .!! !!!999 ! .! ! *!
8 99 +6- ? .! ! ! + - +- ! 99 8 C + -
8
! 0 ! +- 9 ! ! 8.!' <!8 *!
899 B
9 9 8 8.! !
*!
.! .!! !8 .!99 ! ! ,! ! 9! !99 8 !8 99 ! !99 !
( ! 8 , ! " ) 4.
8 ! 8 !88 , 8 !99 < 28 D "!9.!8!" 4.
, 8 2 , 8 !98 2 , ! " /! 99 !
99 = 8 ! 9 9 .!!8! ,
! 9 28 ! 9 9 .! ,9 *!
9!
9 9
8 9 9 99 ! , ! !8! 2 ! .!! 9, 8!" 4 .
9 8.! ! " ) 4 . !99 < D , .!
! " #$ "" 8 8 ! E+ - 8 , 8 ! ) 4 ..!99 8 8 !! +
-1989!! 9 0! 8'
+
- 8 9 !!.. 8! !! 9 !!
! !9 9 !
! '!8 + - ! ! !! !!
!! +-? ! !! 8 ! + -" 4..8! 8 ! +
- ! 0! ! ! !!8 8 , !88
9
! ! 0! 9 8 !99 ! 9 8 9 ! F !
+
- " ) 4 .. 98 ! ' ! 99 ! + ,- 8 ! ) 4+ - .. , !90!9,! " $(:F$(%..99 8 ! 9 +,- ! , 8 ! ) 4 .. 998 +, - 8B B 4..9 ! 9 ! 9! ! !9 +,
-2 ! ' !
! 88 ! 4.. , 9 ! +,
-2 F! ,9 , 8 ! ) 4 .. !+- +, - F! ,9 8! 4.. , +,- 8! 4.. , 9 ,9
! 8 ,9 +, -G 8 ! 9 ! ! ! !99 8 8 8 9 123 ! 9 .! 8 ! 4..9
123 ! 9 !99 ! 9 ! !+9 9 ,9 ! - +,
-? , 8! 4.. .! *!
F 0! F ! 8 9 8 *!
! H
$ =
9 8 ! !9 8 9 1238 8 8 ! 9 9 ;! 2 8 8 ! !!9 ! 0! 9 9 9 ! 0! ? 8 !
0;!9>9!<88 289 8 ! 8 0!9 8 ,9 ! 9 9 8 ! 0!
:
9 & ! !9 ;!8 !9!8'
' 8 , 9 8 .! ! ! 8 8 8 ! 9 , 9!8 ? 688 9 , 8!" 4. .! *!
9 ! !!8 9 9 ! , ! !8! .! 8 ! !99 !29 ! 9 9
9
(MANISHA BATRA)
JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No