← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28065/2013allowed

Nachhatar Singh Etc. v. Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana And Another

2016-07-28Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan6 pages

  

         

"#$ %$&'(')*+ "&,,"#"-.')/, $#'#')$- (!

0$-(1( ,$1)2"3/-'&14#1-"4 )'5$-('#6781%,'")"")%")#,$- $(9)%$)#(

 *  :8  . ;

8.  -$($)#*< -0.,"-="7.$)'-%5&"#$7>'#,7 (.,'5")'.,"-="7%5&"#$7 -#,$9$#'#')$- -. '447%5&"#$7 --$(9)%$)#(  ,$#,$-#,$ $9-#$-( 4&"4)$>(9"9$-="63$"44>$%# ($$#,$21%/=$)#?$(  3$-$ $--$%##,$ $9-#$--)#$(

,$#,$-#,$21%/=$)#(,14%3$-$9-#$%')#,$%'/$(#?$( << << ;

8. 

8!

,$9$#'#')$-7')#,$9-$($)#>-'#9$#'#')7,"('=91/)$%-%$- %"#$% ))$@1-$<<+!79"(($%36 $/'(#-"-71)2"3/-'&14#1-"4

)'5$-('#6781%,'")" ')(,-#:-$(9)%$)#< )'5$-('#6:!75'%$>,'&,,$>"( %$)'$%#,$($4$&#')/-"%$')5'$> #,$')(#-1&#')(%"#$% A")% AAB #  &=$(  1#  #,"#  #,'(  '(  ($&)%  -1)%    4'#'/"#')   ,$ 9$#'#')$->"(>-C')/"(" $(#-$->'#,-$(9)%$)#< )'5$-('#6$2')$% #,$($-5'&$)A")%14#'="#$46-$#'-$%)+B,$9$#'#')$- &4"'=(  #,"#  #,$  -$&==$)%"#')(    #,$  )% "6  =='((')  >$-$ '=94$=$)#$%>'#,$

-=A+")%#,$-$&==$)%"#')( -% "6 =='((')>$-$'=94$=$)#$%>'#,$

-=A,$($>$-$

<< %146   "%9#$%  36  -$(9)%$)#< )'5$-('#6  #  '(  &4"'=$%  #,"#  (')&$  #,$ -$&==$)%"#')(>$-$"%9#$%36-$(9)%$)#< )'5$-('#67#,$-$ -$7,$'( $)#'#4$%#($4$&#')/-"%$')5'$> ')(#-1&#')(%"#$% ))$@1-$< < !7 44>$%36')(#-1&#')(%"#$%AAB ))$@1-$<<! #"4( &=$(1##,"#9-$5'1(467#,$9$#'#')$-,"%"99-"&,$%#,'( 1-#36>"6  '4')/">-'#9$#'#')'$ BA AA 7#'#4$%"(  



          

   

  >,'&, >"( %$&'%$% 36#,$.')/4$$)&,  #,'( 1-# )   ))$@1-$<<!7')>,'&,'#>"(=$)#')$%#,"##,$9$#'#')$- >"(/-")#$%($4$&#')/-"%$ (<#'44 A,$("'%>-'# 9$#'#')>"(%'(='(($%363($-5')/#,"##,$($4$&#')/-"%$>"(%$)'$%# #,$$=946$$')#,$9-$<-$5'($%9"6(&"4$(%1$#')"&#') #,$"1#,-'#'$( ")%4"#$-)7,'(&"($>"(C$9#9$)%')/#">"'##,$-$9-# -%"6

=='(('),$9$#'#')$- '4$%#,$8$##$-("#$)#99$"4'$8 A  "/"')(##,$21%/=$)#9"(($%36#,$.')/4$$)&, #,'( 1-# ')      BA    AA 7  #'#4$%  "(   



           

   

 7>,'&, >"(,$"-%36"'5'(')$)&, #,'( 1-#")%"44>$%#,$("'%875'%$ -%$-%"#$% ))$@1-$<<! ,$-$4$5")#$@#-"&# -=#,$ 9$-"#'5$9"-# #,$21%/=$)#'(-$9-%1&$%"(1)%$-*< ,'(  "99$"4  '(  "44>$% ,$  -%$-(    4$"-)$%  (')/4$ 1%/$'(($#"('%$$>14%7,>$5$-74'C$#94"&$)-$&-% #,$ (13='((')  4$"-)$% &1)($4  - #,$ -$(9)%$)#( #,"# ($4$&#')  /-"%$7  ')  ")6  &"($7  >"(  )#  "%='(('34$  #  #,$

$(#-$-($(13='#(#,"#($&#')/-"%$>"(9-5'%$%#)46 ('@&"#$/-'$( $=946$$(1# #>$)#6 >$5$-7#,'('( %'(91#$%36#,$4$"-)$%&1)($4 -#,$"99$44")#)")6&"($7 '#'()# -1(#/')##,'("(9$&#')#,$9-$($)#"99$"4

< < 3$&"1($ #,$-$"()#,"##,$="##$->"()#&)('%$-$% #,'(")/4$36#,$-$(9)%$)#(<"1#,-'#'$("#"44(=$)#')$% "35$7#,$)46-$"() -%$)6')/($4$&#')/-"%$>"(#,"#'# &"=$#3$"34'(,$% -=A$7#,$-$ -$7"44>#,$ >-'#9$#'#') '4$%36#,$9$#'#')$-##,$$@#$)##,"##,$&"($

#,$"99$44")#(,"443$&)('%$-$%36#,$-$(9)%$)#( -/-")#

($4$&#')/-"%$)'#(>)=$-'#(")%"(9$--14$( -%$-##,'( $

$&#(,"443$9"(($%>'#,'))$=)#, -=#%"6)&"($7 #,$"99$44")#(#'44,"(")6/-'$5")&$36#,$-%$-#,"#="63$ 9"(($%7'#>'443$9$) -#,$"99$44")##&,"44$)/$#,$("=$7 ')"&&-%")&$>'#,4">E &&-%')/467  #,$  -$(9)%$)#(  &)('%$-$%  #,$  &"($    #,$ 9$#'#')$-")%9"(($%#,$'=91/)$%-%$-%"#$% ))$@1-$<<+! ,$9$-"#'5$9"-# #,$("'%-%$-'(-$9-%1&$%"(1)%$-*< )#,$4'/,# #,$-%$-( #,$):34$'/, 1-#7#,$ -$F1$(# .,"&,,"##"-.')/,7@< $(#-$--$&$'5$%')#,'( 

'&$) ,"(3$$)$@"=')$%")%'#,"(3$$) 1)% #,"#"(9$-)#'

'&"#')'((1$%36#,$ =9#-44$-7 5'%$   ++ %"#$%A7)46('@&"#$/-'$(

$=946$$(>$-$9-5'%$%($4$&#')/-"%$1# &"#$/-'$( ")%#,$-$>"()9-5'(') -#,$/-")# ($4$&#')/-"%$# #,$  9(#   $(#-$- $(#-$-<&1=<"

#-'   ,$-$ -$7  ., "&,,"##"-.')/,7@< $(#-$-'()#$)#'#4$% -#,$/-")#

")6($4$&#')/-"%$>$ A7"(&4"'=$%36,'=,$ -$F1$(#    .,  "&,,"##"-  .')/,7  @< $(#-$-  -$&$'5$%  )  '(,$-$36-$2$&#$%E ,$9$#'#')$-'("//-'$5$%36#,$("'%-%$-%"#$%

))$@1-$<<+!79"(($%36-$(9)%$)#( ,$-$(9)%$)#(7')#,$>-'##$)(#"#$=$)#7,"5$#"C$)#,$(#")% #,"##,$($4$&#')/-"%$>"(/-")#$%)46#('@&"#$/-'$( $=946$$(")% #,"##,$9(# $(#-$-%'%)# "44')#,$("'%&"#$/-6 8"#$-)7#,$ -$&==$)%"#')( -%"6 =='((')>$-$'=94$=$)#$%>'#,$

<B<

-=A")%#,$($4$&#')/-"%$>"("34'(,$%>,'4$/-")#')/#,$ -$5'($%9"6(&"4$,$9$#'#')$->"(/'5$)9#')#&)#')1$#%-">4% 9"6(&"4$(-(>'#&,5$-#)$>-$5'($%9"6(&"4$(>'#,$

-=&1#

%"#$,$9$#'#')$-9#$% --$5'($%9"6(&"4$")%&)($F1$)#467,'(9"6 >"("&&-%')/46 '@$%>'#,$

-=A ,$-$(9)%$)#(,"5$ 94"&$%  -$4'")&$  19)  4$##$-  ))$@1-$< <!  %"#$%  AA    #,$ -$(9)%$)#7>,'&,=$)#')("31##,$/-")# /-"%$"(9$-#,$')(#-1&#')( '((1$%7  5'%$  4$##$-    +B<   7  %"#$%  AB  36  #,$ 5$-)=$)##>"( 1-#,$-=$)#')$%#,"#"(9$-#,$-$&==$)%"#')(

#,$  -% "6  =='((')7  #,$  5$-)=$)#  ,"%  %$&'%$%  #  (#9  /'5')/ ($4$&#')/-"%$>'#,$

-=A ,$-$ $-$)&$,"("4(3$$) ="%$##,$#,=$$#')/ "-%  ")"/$=$)#7,$4%)A")% &)($F1$)#467)#'

'&"#')%"#$%A ))$@1-$<<A!>"('((1$%7') >,'&,&$-#"')&"#$/-'$( )'5$-('#6$=946$$(>$-$/'5$)-$5'($%9"6 (&"4$(>'#,$

-=A+7)#,$('@#,&"#$/-67#,$($4$&#')/-"%$ >"(  =$)#')$%7  >,$-$"(  '#  >"(  )#  =$)#')$%  "/"')(#  (=$  #,$- &"#$/-'$(7>,'&,')&41%$( $(#-$-(7 $(($)/$-6(")% ,C'%"-($#& ,"5$,$"-%#,$4$"-)$%($)'-&1)($4 -#,$9$#'#')$-7#,$ 4$"-)$%&1)($4 --$(9)%$)#(")%,"5$"4(&"-$ 1446/)$#,-1/,#,$

'4$ #&=$(1##,"##,$%'(91#$'(-$/"-%')/#,$/-")# ($4$&#') /-"%$##,$9$#'#')$-)&=94$#') 6$"-(:($-5'&$7>,'&,,$,"% &=94$#$%)A#'("4()#%'(91#$%#,"#')#,$-$9-# #,$)% "6 =='((')7#,$9-5'(') -($4$&#')/-"%$>"(#,$-$(9$-#,$ ')(#-1&#')( #,$ 5$-)=$)#%"#$% ))$@1-$<< !7G #,$ &"%-$>"(#3$/'5$)($4$&#')/-"%$#'()#%'(91#$%#,"##,$-$>"()46

<< )$9(# $(#-$-")%')(1&,&"($7#,$("'%9$-()>14%3$$)#'#4$%# ($4$&#')/-"%$7'

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

"44  ')  ("'%  &"#$/-'$(7  =$)#')$%  ')  #,$  ("'%  =$$#')/    "-%  

")"/$=$)#7 ,$4% ) A.'='4"-467 #,$ 8"3-"#-6$&,)'&'")( >$-$  "4(  /-")#$%  #,$  ($4$&#')  /-"%$7  5'%$  -%$-  %"#$%  AAB

))$@1-$<<! #,$->'($"4(7)&$#,$-$&==$)%"#')( #,$)%"6

=='((')>$-$'=94$=$)#$%")%>$-$"%9#$%36-$(9)%$)#(7#,$6 &14%)#="C$")6%'(#')&#')-$/"-%')//-")# ($4$&#')/-"%$#5"-'1( &"#$/-'$( $=946$$( '#>"(%)$"#"447'#"=1)#(#%'(&-'=')"#') 3$#>$$)#,$$=946$$(>-C')/1)%$-#,$&)#-4 #,$("=$"1#,-'#6 #3$')/(7"= #,$5'$>#,"##,$9$#'#')$->"($)#'#4$%# /-")# ($4$&#')/-"%$>'#,$

-=A,$($4$&#')/-"%$,"( )#3$$)%$)'$%7"44$/')/#,"##,$9$#'#')$-'()#(1'#"34$ -/-")#

($4$&#')/-"%$)"&&1)# ($-5'&$-$&-%,$)46/-1)%=$)#')$%') #,$'=91/)$%-%$-'(#,"#)46('@&"#$/-'$( $=946$$(>$-$9-5'%$% >'#,($4$&#')/-"%$7>,'&,'( 1)%#3$ "&#1"446')&--$&#7')5'$>

<< -%$-(   9"(($%  -$/"-%')/  #,$  $(($)/$-  6(  ")%  #,$  8"3-"#-6 $&,)'&'")( %='##$%467)#,$'=94$=$)#"#') -$9-# -% "6

=='((')7#,$($4$&#')/-"%$>"("34'(,$%>'#,$

-=A ,$9$#'#')$-9#$% -)$>(&"4$>'#,$

-=A>$5$-7,'( 9"6)#,$&=94$#') 6$"-(:($-5'&$>"(#3$-$< '@$%"

#$-/-")#')/ #,$($4$&#')/-"%$")%#,$)7&--$(9)%')/ '@"#')>"(#3$="%$)#,$ '=94$=$)#"#') #,$-$9-# -% "6 =='((')>'#,$

A")%&)($F1$)#'"4 '@"#')'("4(#3$="%$((1&,7#,$9-$($)# >-'#9$#'#')'("44>$%,$-$(9)%$)#("-$%'-$&#$%#/-")##,$($4$&#') /-"%$##,$9$#'#')$->'#,$

-=A7>,$),$&=94$#$% 6$"-(:($-5'&$")%#,$-$"

#$--$< '@,'(9"6#'44-$#'-$=$)#$$%4$((#("6 #,"##,$-$#'-"43$)$ '#(>'44"4(3$-$5'($%')"&&-%")&$>'#,#,$ -$(,9"6

'@"#')")%#,$"--$"-((,"443$9"'%##,$9$#'#')$->'#,')#,-$$=)#,(

-=#,$%"#$ -$&$'9# &96 #,'(-%$->'#,')#$-$(#"##,$-"#$ G 9$-"))1=

;

8. !

   + (2C( ,$#,$-(9$"C')/-$"()$% * $( ,$#,$- $9-#"34$ * $(