← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/3707/2009allowed

Partap Singh And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2019-02-07Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia14 pages



    



 !!

"

#$$ #%&  '"

"!() 

          

  *(  +,*  ---.,      

 

  

 ! " 

  # " 

 

  $



  % &  $ #    ' 

%     

 %   --#!"

#/#%'# 01 #%2 (                )*    

&030405 ))0))0505 0 66 60

&)3653)      *+ #  ,   -./+0 

1  123 3

  3   % &  $ #     4-4+)44/ 3" -5      3  &  6 3 (   &     , 7/

  3    " ) +4 44489  3  #

 ,  &     0   

  1   &   12     

4/45)44* ) (      +  

  -/4+)44+   3   "  5.55             3:

-/) ( ;< 6 3 

 3  , ( "   &  

 4=4=)44)0>?+-2  " +/  -* "0 ?"= 2    *= =* ).-89

"    7/ -- 44489        ,   5 &   

  " >?/

  3"      3  ,      #  4)-4)44-( & 

43+- #

#7#!#8& 9#!

:;9#+  

)/4+)4-4  7 =4489 ,

0)/ 4+ 44489     2   $    3     3"    '<'%$$ #%433)+ #<#!'8&- #

#7#!#+  "

        3     .==89   ,  

0+- /- ++489 23 ?& 

   

   "    "  + $ 3"      &        

3   "

 "   

)@4/)4440>?+42  )  -="   

7 ).489  ,  

 "              7 -5 ** )4489 " >?5+ +      * 

3"  -4

  

  3"             3       "  " 

3    "    

-@--)44=0>?+.2   " +4    

)   3"   " +4

  "   --45)44.0>?*42  

" 5 )   3"   7*4

    

   3      *    3      

   4+4@)44=   3     "      3  7@- .@ +4489  

3353)6+ #!"

#!

8&

9 #!";$ ##!"

&+    ))4@)4-* "    3       

-)4))44.

3"  3  7*4

      

  44    )6  +#!;9#!  -'!=  8& - #

  #7#!##!"

&+   ))4/)4-*$3" 

      

 

    ,     "      4-4*-//.0>?)@2 3 "   $  3"   3     

,  "  3 

 =   

   3           %

&  $ #   "   4=4=)44)

 0>?+-2 3               "

           3 &    @ ( &  ?"     3  

       ""             3  :  

 :

-4                ""     6 3         < (        

 3      3       3   &  . A9=< "B   

  0>?/2  "    , 

 '

      %  

    3 

 

"

 

  "        95?  



    C      # 

<

3 

  "    ! 

<  <    " (  "   3  ,   "     ""   + *

@9 > A9)"&   ! 

  

"

      #    , / $       --45)44.

>?*4 >?*5   3   D "       7 *4 

    



     

 ""   (   

  3   % &  $ #" >?. -4 3 9       

 : 

 ?  " ""

%  "      $      3          

4-4*-//.0>?)@2      

  3    >?5) +4 "

     "      

          >?+-3    3

"                 $      )*4"  "  ,   (   &  

     7-4E "

3 3   

  - )"

3     3   ? 7/ -- 44489  3 "  A9)-,   



"

 3' " >?+-  3)*4"      -4    



 A95 

 <"   

   , 

 3      6 3 : 

:

-4       

   A9-!% &   

   % & 

6 3     9?"  "



"

       #    "  ,  3  5.    +  '

 : 

:

-4    

  3    # 

 ,  3 .44"   

  )*!"3  " -- $               #  , '

   $   "  3   3         '           ,    >       "   

 :

5

  "  "   # 3

   ,  -) (  "        

4)-4)44- 

3   *4

 

 +- /- ++489  3    3 ?& 

'3 $      &         9#!

 :;9#  1&;$#2      3    "             )-4@-//5  

)--)-//. 3  -)E  "



3    =44, $  "

    "

    3   "  "   " -//5 -//.  ( ?&   

  +*#!>:;9#

&8&- #

#7#!#

&+)512

1'<'%25)3  +,< %

!:;9#

8&- #

#7#!# #!"

&+)512 1'<'%2)     3      ?"  

                         



(      9  

      

                   

                           



                                  !

                       "#      #   

      $     %

              &  

'  

                                     

    '

      # 

      (   )       

'    (

  

      

'      *    

  )    #  

                             *

'     

  +        

    



      ,- 

      

                  .                     

           

     /!        

           

          

     

         



    !         

     

     0        

'           '

          

 

  



' 

         )   

  #    

  

'  #   '   

   

   

          

   

'  "    

            "

      (

*  

    

 



        

 

        1 -5 "      3    ,< %

!  :;9# 1&;$#2  9 0%2     !

 

   4   )   

          5 

 

         

          #            

       !

 3  4

   

 55 



 )

       )   

 

      -,,

     , 

                            2    !"#$%&'&#%&() *

+  ,  -!!     

         

     

          

1 -+ $   "   3?" 

 "   4=4=)44)0>?+-2 ?  "

       -4  "

        3             "     

"

3  "    " ?     

  3      3  ,"

  .

*5 4*=89 "

3 "

      3      

   "  (    "  3  3

   0>?+-2 3      3'  3 3      $

    ?"     

 , "      

,

    : 

:

-4  " ?" 3  -*   >?+4  )@4/)444 '

  )  -="    -5 ** )4489     +4E" ""  3    "      (     3

   3     

   >?5+?  -*       +     -/.@

     3     

    "

3   

 >  

  3 3

  

  

"3   "       

&      

           >?+. *4    3            3    F '%#!"# ;#%#&$# '!,'9'

"8&

#9 & ?

#'  '<#!?

#'  #

%  #!"  #!

@  5  1)62  -  630    3     ?  "           "      "        

  4+4@)44= -)4))44. 3 ' 

          

"

 

 "  @- -.

+4489 3,    *4

    '

   3 

3 

,,    ,   "  G<  (      "  3       *#!>:;9#

,< %

!:;9#1&;$#2     33  

>?+-3 &  -=   "          "  "    3  &  &   3 

3   

      ""         3 $      "                  "   ,  " 

"      ) -4"

  

  '

"  ?&    1&;$#2

            "      &     -*E  " 3 3  

       "   3 

     "  9 4=4=)44) 4=4=)445 -/4+)44+ 2 0 ?"-4 "

2 / -- 44489   H- 5= =*489I H- /*=)*I -4 +@ =*489   -- @.

=4=)* 0-- @.

=4=89C2   9$ !&# '!- ;

;

&

,

  -@ # "       " " G

 $ 

5+ 9# #98&- #

 #7#!##!"

&+" * 4.

@)489 3     

  6"   9 "9<         ,          ,   >?--    )*+5=4 ,     ?0>?--2 

3    / == *=.89 3           7 )44   ,            6"     (     3A9=< "B  -.  

 >?. >?)=

                       

 ,

   &    "

   3  7)44, C 

                 3   

  >?--       

 54489   ,       

         @ =5 4.489 -/ "     G

 

 :

)

4+#'

 <'#!"

&8& - #

#7#!# #!"

&+ " 5 *4 )/=89 3    3  )4489,

3   -@*-+.,  (       >?-5

 "

     "   3      

?    , 

,     * )* +++89

%'

 )4    7-- @.

=4=  

  3      

 9 

  3   3   "

 "    )50-2   )50)2  '

"  ?&   +- #

 ;!>#?8&9#>'

-'!= +0))162-6 ( "   9 &*-634 

 #         */34 !           

         ! *"

3-4    

 #        *-634 2      

 

  6,7  #     

    *"

3!4*-6     !&050/    

 #  

  

  *-634 2     

 

       -7     #            */34  

   

     #  



       

         

       *  -63!4      *-63-4    # 

    *-634!    

*   *-63-4  

     

       *

,   -63!4   *  

  

      '(    

     ( 

  *-634 ! +  

                ! 3 42      *-634   !  3      #         



       

       

  '(  

     (  

   "

4 34*  6,7 #    

    -634! 34!

   -7   #

        

       

   

  *-634!    

*-63-4 4)     3 4 34  34         #





 '

   57    

    7        1 )-   

  

         3    

    

       %

&  $ #"  " ,   

 ,  1--.,2



0)   9  #'

  :

; '8 9   :

; '8