High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4635/2019dismissed

Nirmal Singh Now Deceased Through Lr v. State Of Haryana

2019-11-02Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

!"# $%% &$%'(& !#

) * & #+ ,

- )

# ./012 ) /3. 012 %-

+ /%4&! 011(0+ ,

6% 2 - $ %

-9,1 " .&$0) %/&"2:%% & ;& --" "< !"# $% "#% =% # $%% &$%'(& !# $% "#% 9 # $%* &#+ , >0< !"# $% "#% =% # $%% &$%'(& !# $% "#% 9 # $% * & # + , >0 <"- # $% * & # + , > <% # $%* &#+ , >0:%%: " 2 8

9, % % 1 "

.&$0) %/&"0: - "9 $

8 "< !"# $%* &#+ , > : !

? ",0%% %=%: # "#% ""&%" - - ,2""$.& 06%" ) %/&"@ %!0%2"2&- % & 0 !",#A#% 9# $%0 !"# $%0"-# % # $%@%" :B& @ & #

7%' 1B& 10 :"9,""%& 9 % " 1 " .&$01!9"2:

77 : &!

"/% - !- %B& " #""" $""% & 9 % %9 &$%C19 %+$%& / $ % ! !- 2 - % C1 8

0 % & % % % !- D A- B& , ;& :"9, !"# $% =%: # $%% &$%(& !# $% "#% 9# $% %!" :"" "- # $% % # $% -,! !- !& %93&$!

7-9,#&9.&$="04% 2"#&

7 & $- ,%;& 093 : "9,% # $% =%: # $%""$ $%9# %

0"-# $% !"#

93 % # $%%"- ;& %% %"-# $% %9 & "&

"-# $%%& ! &""2 $9% % # $% % ", "2 $ 9 % 6% 93 : 9,(& !# $% $%% # $%% $% 2:%3&$!

7-9, #&9.&$="04% 0:%%:9&- !- ! 9: & 9 % 9# $%0 !"# $%0% # "-# ?%"-# !"# $%: & ! &" "- # $% : $ :% % # $% !"# $%: $:%9# ?%9# !"# $%: 29,(& !# $% 9# -":%% 2 9,%!0%,%9B&%% - - "& $ $% 2%!- B& " 2& (& ! # $% 9, ;& $ E""

80 %:,(& !# $%:% ",' & !"# $% =%: # $%@ %93&$!

7-9,#&9.&$="04% ", 9# !"# $%: :

- %" 2""$.& B& %" ",%, % ' " 2 % !- % !-";"& %93 9&9# !"

# $%% " B&%% % %" ?%" 4% -& 0

4% 2& %93 % # "-# $%

"& " B&%! % % # "-# $%

%B& " .& %9%!- !% 3&$!

7:- +- ,% 93 - 9! !- ", $ % ! % # "-# $%9-%!

3# $%%""93 $%

%9!- ! 29: %& 9 % 09 # !"# $%: :

- B&"% %B& " 7/ " ! " "-# % # $%: "$ ,% %!-

9 # $%%"2 $9% 3# $%0(& !# $%% 0#& 4& 01! 34& .: 4& F&$% ) !4& :: &- %9# $%0!", "! : 29: 3# (& !# 8 0:%%:&", $ 9,""%"$"

% 9# $:%%9%% : " 2 % !- @ % (& ! # $% % " % $ $ !", "! :%" !2 $

--" !-" $' 9# ! !","! 8 0 3# $%93 (& ! # $%0 9% 9 # $% : " 2 !- %B& " %;"& % "$"

% 9#

(& !# $%% %93 $&- $ :"" 8 9, 9 # $% % 2& $%%" : "$%!- % ""$!","! : &" &0 0%

9&) !4& !% %93 (& !# % !!&

C - - 3& % 2 ,0 " 1 " .&$0) %/&" !"": $&

E%% % -&9: '9# (& !# $%"! $%!"9% ","$"

% 9# !"# $% %9E""

8 8

E%% 9# !"# $%: ;&2" $ & $ E"" 8 8 -2", 2& (& !# $%G )(& !#

E%% ,!","! : 2! $%"$"

% 9# $% 8 G ) 3

6%- : B&-- & " % 2

1 % $ $&! 0 % & ! % "& %%!- $ $B& "

2""$.& %99& ""%& 9 % 0 !",0 #A#% !"# $%09# $%0"-# % # $%0""

=%: # $% %"": $

6%""$!- !3&$!

7 H;

1 H;

1:-&9B& ", %& & # %' 1B& 1

1!", !& %9%""$!- !

7: $ $.& " 9& % ! : & % B& - 3!9 H;

% " ! % ! & 9 %

6% : : - 9, ' 1B& ""

7 :%%!& !-

: %!0""%& 9 % %" & # 7%' 1B& 19 .&$0 1!9"0 :%% : $ 1 " .&$01!9"@:

770% ""%& 9 % %"C1 8

%+$%& / $ % ! !- % C1 : @%:2 %!- ! :

9 &$%% ,%&% , & @ "%&$%C1%9 "9,9# $% %!"

8 ,"-# % # %% 2 %!- %!" 9%""-# % # $%9&%9," - 2%% 93 6%+$%& %"%C1 2& ""%& 9 %

2(& ! # $% -- $ 1E % ! % - & # %' 1B& 1:" -9,%& 4% : !

% & 9 %+$%&

2=% 9 " %%" B& 2""$.&

: % " 0 :%% : % &93 ! !- ! -9,%2"& 4%

26% E"" H;

8 E"" H;

8: ;&9,9# !"# $%0 -2", 2& (& !# $%0:%%"! !- B&% % 6% % $ %:%%:"": $ & 29

26%!","! H;

EA8 : " &- 9, 3# $%9 % (& !# $%0:%"! %%" $:%(& !# $%: "B&"% !-

+:2 0:% ! 3# $%: E0%! % ;! %%

7 !", "! H;

EA ! & !-"! % - - - !","! : " ! "! + " !%(& !# $% 2 ,!& !

%!- !","! E#& 4& &$% 9# 3# (& !# !%!","! : 2 !-"! 6%& %9&%!","! 3# $%

"!B&"% %!- %% 9 #

= "$% &% 9 2 0 % H;& $ & "&% % !- !"# 9# $% 0(& !# $% " 2% ! # "-# $%& ! &"% # 9 $%9 % " 2%% "-# 9%:

6% - 9, % H;& $ & :""

0 9 - - -- " 2 - ": & ! , ""$", !,!&%"-- % 6%! - 2 9 , =% ",9 - 2" ""$"- -"

6%&$%" & " % 2 %

% & # 8 )0 % H;& $ & B& ! ""B& $9: %- %&

:%%% :- 9: % - 2 " $%;& 0% $ % 0 :%%% 9 %- ?&= %% $&! 2 9," & " 2 2 ! 6%H;& $& %":%""%93 -" / 9,%93

9% ,%93

%9 3 &!! ,!

:%& $% ! & %H;& $& :% &% - ":%" $%93 9%"% 93 6%93 ",9 " % % 9 3& "$%% &! % " 3&" -

6% H;& $& % ", "& % $ 9& 9% ' & " % 2 %& % &9! %%H;& $& % / 2:# % )" $:%- - % =" ,"$ &%

6%-&9: %- : :% $ -- ! % %!-

!& : & B& % " 6% H;& $& % ""%-% "& $

%93 9,!%"! %9:""0 !","! 0 %2"& %$ &% 2 %% 93 %2 9 ":%- - ", & &

C $ ! % 2 - 0%! !

? 3

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#