Surjit Singh & ORS v. Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd & ORS

    
  ! "#$# %# &# ##
# % #  

%' ( )*

+,,- 
 


* .

*/*   
 
  










 *0

(

* 

,   
 











* .

*/*   
 
  









 *0

(

* #1+ 

2$3 1 "4
44# %##3# 











 
!"




# 
  
"









# 
 $ 
%






&
 ' (((

44# %##3#5"6 '7 




 
#

*
 
+ ,-./0

,0..1
#
,2$0
 
3 #
#
 
 

   

 
#  
 

# 


'
 
# 
*
 
+ ,-./0
#
,2$0 


 
#
'4
 







,,05,,1
 #
6 
# 
 
 
 $
 4



 
 
,$$,$...


#
0$$...
7

8


# 
 
#

#
$/9










'4

$0
 





 :



 4

*
+ $01/2
#
$...

# 

 $;   
#
 



  
 



# 
 
'#
#
  4




 
   3 

$<.=
7  #
# 
> 
?8



#


 




'

 4



 

4
4
'



'4
 
'




#


-$,$... 


4
3 

'
 

#
 @
> 
 

  '?

  4

 



 #
 


4
 4



)
 
# 




'
 
  
 '




3 

 

 

#  
#
 


 6

 



3 #




 
 

!
A


# 
 
 
#
'#
 $ # 

 
,/0$..0
 
 
=


# 
'4
 #

1$$..1
 
 
0

B
$1



 4
  

 

 



,2/$..1

" 4
<29
 

#

$0
 



'4
 $

 


0$$...
7 @
5$8
 
 
 

#@ 

,1  


'4
 
 3 
 ;;'
!   
78
A

;6; -

  



#

#
 

 
 $<

 

 


#  

 
$1$,22-

" 
 $



  
#@ 

,1
  


'# 
 
'4 #

*
 
+ $01/2
#
$...

-$,$...
#   @ 

  ;

>
   


 3 



34

 
'4
 
$$



4

'




#@ !
 

C@ 
  + 
#
 
# 
,/=,222  




  
 3 

!'


'4
"
@
 



   4 

  


'


;

 



+ :

% 

 
 @
 #





 4 
 

 
?

D 4


  
0.,220 @
5,8
 

'
 
"#
 
# '
 
 





0$$...
7 @
5$8

" 
 



 ;

>  

 
'4
 

 !
A ;; 3 
)' 
$1$,22- 


 
 
 
3
 ",1
 




' 
# 

) #

 
  

6

 
'
 

 
   



 
'

   
 
 
 '


6
#



8 #4



0$$...
  


3 
 ;;'
! 
  
78

 
 ,









'
 4
 #
",1 

E 
 


 4
  
'
 
 3 
)' 
# '
 



 5 




0$$...?

 

 $;  #

+ ,,0
#
,220
 
! 
%

 

$.$,,220

" 
 



 ;

>6

'

 


  

  #
 
 
$<

'# 
"#  
# 






# ",1
 



"
/2 2225;

  

  "#
 
     3 
 
F
",1
 



+

'
  
 4




'
 

'
#
'4
4 

 


'
 

#


 
'# 


  
 4

#  
 
  
 

 '
  4
'4
 
 
 
A

#

 

#

 
 

0.,220  

*
+ $01/2
#
$...

6
 4

'
 


C  
  


@ 
 
 
 
;

 
 
 
"$0
 








 
 

'
;


F
",1
 



) 
 


' @ 4


#4
 


'
 
 *
#


  

 ?

" $
  #

  
'#

@
 


78
+ 
-.0/
#
,221





 .-,221

 
3

4

'
    D 4
 

 
+ 02,.
#
,22.
 
$1$$,2$/ @
5-8

)  





'
#  6
 

 



'





 4




'
! 
G##
78;; 3 
A


 
 4






# 
  4 4
'4
#
 
 
 
-=

'
 
 

'

 

   

' 
   " $


4


'



 
@
#
<29

 
!
! #

/-$..1


 


0$$...

# #

,1
  



#

= 2/ $= $..5;


$0$$...
 
 


6


 4




  
 

'
 4

3 #

 

 

6

# 
'


#



4


 

#







  



! 
%

-$,$...


'

   # 

 


 

 
 


'
  


 
# 
 3 


'
# 




 
 

 4



'
 
 4
'# 
D@
  

 4

'
  
"#  

 
# 
 
! 
%






'



 

 


 
 
 4
#

 '4
 4



'
  


  
 


'
 4
 
 #4


) 

 

'4 
 
 $;  
 
 :
'




 @
 #




 4
# 
 





'


 $;  

4   

#
 

4


'
 

# 
 4 
#
#



  4



 

#






'
 '
 4
 
 

 

) 

-$,$...


 4

 


 
  
0.,220
#  


'  
 


! 
%

 







 
 '
 4


'


   #

 4


 
 :
'

 " $;  

 
'#
#

 #
'4



 @
 

.-,221

 
3



 


  #




 '#
#
 

 

'
  

 
-$7$8
B
7,8


-=



 ;

9  ':;

  ) ;0

*'

 ( *  *';



/ 7$8
G
 

 
 
$$


 
 4

'4

 
 

 




,




 4

 


'4
 




 
 

 
@
';  7,8
6#
 4



 


 
#
 
'
  
  
 



#
 
'
4








  
#
 




 

 

#
  
$<

'
' 
 

4



'

 
 4
 
 

##4

 








 



 
 



'

 

4
 
 
 
$<
 


 

 




##
 
 '4
4


 4





4
 
4

 
 
 4
 
 
 
 #4
   @@@ @@@ @@@ 8  ':;

     *+
* 
 

#




 
 
'#    






 4
 



  #
H

I 

# 
 

#
 
  







'
   


#
 4
 
  
 

 




4 
# 


 

 

##







'
 '
# 


#
@4




4


 
 


 
'


'#

#

@4?

 


'
 

,2/$..1

 4
 
.9


# 
 
#
4 



#
#


 





 


-



  #
 
-$


-=


) 


-$,$...

! 
%

  
 


'



# 
 
 

  
C 
 

' '  

'
# 

 



 

 
#   
'
 


 
'4
 
 
)




 
>  



 

' 


# 
 

4


 


'
 
  

"#

'


' 



'4


@


4' #**';.*$''<0':'<'%=';')>' 4'

*>'674

8" 
' 
 


  >,$

 


  
 
 


# 


 

  




 
# 4

4


 
'

 
4  

 
#
 ;# 


 

# 
#   
4
 
4 
 
 
'


#


#  #  

 4
  


 
  3

 
 

# 4





 


 
' 
 
# 

# 


'# 
#   ,,
'  



 
768

7668
'

 
'

 
 
 

 
 
# 


 
@

 4
  
 
 

  
 
'4
 #
 ;
 4

 
 4

  
'
#
'
    
# 
 
4 



 

  

 


 4

@
#
@ ;



 4
 
 
$=,
 
6
 
 '




 
  
#

  

'4
 
 
6#




' 

'

# 

 4


4


 
 

4
:

4  4

# 
@

 

 
 

 

 
 
 
 
 






3
 

  


 



# 

#

 
 

4
 
 
 
#
 
 
4


 



 
768



 
7668?

" 4

 $



#  
  4


#




 




4
 4

-$,$...
4






"





 

 


 
'#

#


# 







#
 4


4


 4
 ##



'
  
 #

#

 
'





 

 
 
@


4

  '
 4
 



  4
 

6








#
 


4
 

" 


'

 /> '* 
' (*3(.*4' 1 67-4

8-

>';;

( '?.*4' 1  6874

8    # 
 '
 
@
 

=' ''<' ' '>'

( '

> .*4

 

@*5% 0';

 1

*A

@:'

( '

> 6874/0 ;


/
'* *,-) 
 
  


 ;

>$2 6
 
D 


# 
 
7 
 




 
##

 

 



'

#
 
'4





 
' 
 







 
 
) 
#



 

  '




 #


 4

 




  J




 ' 
 



'








'
4
 

 
6

 

#



 
* 


 4


 
 



 
   '





 4


 




 
 


 
 4


## 
  



 ##
'
# 
 
#


 4 
 
#
 4
# 4



#  '


#
 4

 
 #
 


'


 
  

 


'
#
 




'
  
) 
#
 4


7 8
 4
#
'#
    4
 
 

 
7'8

   
#





 ?
" 4 
 
 
'4

"







# 
 $

 

 
3 #



'


#  
 
 
 









 4


'4
 


 
 4
# 4



'# 
D@
 



 3 

  
#  


 4



'


#
 

 5





#

4

# 
 
'



 



 

 4



'




 
  4
 
4




'
 '



6

@


D@
 



 #
 
# 



 
= # 

#
$..0


 
D@ 
 

4


'
 
 


# "/:,5-   6 44# %##3#7 <'

 "/(@

*  
  5 

K5+ *  
  ' K5+