High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28175/2013allowed

Gurinder Pal Singh Chhinna v. Pec University & ORS

2016-12-07Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari6 pages

"# $

&' "()*#+,("-,$.$* %##*",$ *&+/,-,$ 0"$*'$$ "

%" (, #-,$0""#' $#$1

$$ "*,++ 2#$*"",$ 1

4&"

516',##78"#' $ .*"78"2#$",$ 0"1"(9#$"

.,#, ++*,++ 2*,#,+#7 ",#$$*# 0$* ( ,$,$ : 13

4&" 5;6.*" $.,# $$*,$* .&+ 7 ,++. $ 9- 0&"$*" $* '"2",99 +8 0 $* $ #,"0&+0++,0$"$*-,+&,$ 0$*&"#.,#$7 -,+&,$&" 2$*&"" $#9#$",0$"-" 2,++9' $# .$*&$,$$ 2$*+,###" 2+8$*#,"".,#,+# -8$*9 : 13

4&" 5!6 $#$*,9$$,#0$*',"$#$*,$**,$,/

,9## &+8 $*&"#0%,#$"0-+ 2 "

"2",9',## ,++0&"&"##0#$(9#$"7&$*#&" 9,"2 ,+' $#2", $*#&7<$0-, %,$*9,$#

.,#,++.$9'"- $*#,#&7<$,+ 2.$*&"#0 #9#$" 9'"- *# #" 0" $* #&7<$ 0 -, %,$*9,$#, #&" :9,"/#&$0 9,"/# #&+$, $+8*# 2",0"9==. $&'$== $,++8*# .*+& $ 2*# "#&+$ ,$ $* 0 7$* #9#$"# .,# ; ; *.-" ,0$" 9'"-9 $$. $&'$;;.,#$*",0$"2- ,9##

$*1" (9#$", $ &,$$ 2$*+,###*",0$" * .,# 0"978$*9'&2 99& ,$ $*,$*.,# $+27+ ,##&*0"9- 20&"$*" ,#$*9'"-9,"/#7$, 78*9 ." $$,/ $ #",$ , * $*,-$*">&"

3 6$#,+#$7 $$*,$ - $"9"",$1

*.,#,++.$ $ &$* &"#, $*0 ,+"#&+$.,#*.-"#&7<$$$*# 0$* ."$'$$ .$#7"&2*$$$* $, # $ #'&$$*,$ '$$ "*,#,+#7 2- $*2"0%,#$"0 2 " 2

-+ 2 " 23($"&$&"#6 ('$97" *$'80$* 2" ,.,",+ 2.$* $,+ 9,"/# ," *,-7 '+,

"" $#,#0$*"#' $#$*,$,#'",,9"&+#0 % "2",9$*'$$ ",

$"2#$"0"$*#,9&"#$ 9'"-*# ,0$"#$ (9#$".**#2",$"$*, ;, $*&#*#9'"-2",0"$*&"#0%; 1# &++0$# $*&#$*#$, 0$*"#' $$*,$,#$& $,

$"2#$"0"$*

1" (9#$" & +## * *,# 2",$" $*, ;; #&+$, $+8 "2#$",$ 0$*'$$ "0"1"(9#$".,#, ++ $#,''," $$ $$*,$( ,$*,#$#+0 $, *, 9 $ $* +&# $*,$ $*" .,# +,8 $* ',"$ 0 $* "#' $#,##&* # 9,/ 2, $*"0"*#*&+7 ,++.$9- $*'"2",99*"+-, $',"$0$*#&##

.***,$,/ '+,",#,#&

!"#

9'"-9 $ ,# 0%"&" " ,+ ( 2* (

% ($"&$&"# *997"# "#$*# ,/ 78 $*, ,900,"#00$, ++$*

2#$",$ 0 %"&" "',+ ( 2* * , (

$*&"#%;

10"$* #9#$" 1 .-"$.,#0+$$*,$$* #$& $ *,#7 '&$$#,-, $,2&$ +,8 $,/ 2$*## $.,#$*"0" $*,$# $*#$& $*,,+",8 $*&"# $*'"-&##9#$"*9,87 -,+&,$ 0" $*# &"# &" 2 $* &"" #9#$"-" 2,++9' $#0-,+&,$ -# %?$"9 , ?$"9 4,9 ,$ # ,##2 9 $#>&@@#$.$*&$,$$ 2$* +,### &$ $*# #*&+ $ 7 #$ ,# '" #*,++ 7 ,++. $ 9- 0&"$*" $* '"2",99 +80,++ $ #0"$*#,9 ,"0&+0++,0$"$*-,+&,$ 0$*#&"# *&#$#,''," $$*,$ #$$&$*,$#+0,++.$* '$$ "$9- $$*1"(9#$" #'$0$*0,$$*4#$ "&+# $'"9$# & #+0"$*'$$ "*,#'+,"+, &' $* <&29 $0$*'4&"$

"#$% " && '""

.*"78$.,# $$*,$ $*#$& $.,#,++.$,''," $*4,9 ,$ #"2*$+8"

." 2+8$* $*#$,$&$.**9'."#$*

-"#$8$.$*",.$* , ,$&" ."/# $#+0 &$ , $* #$& $ &+ $ 7 "0&#

,9## #&7#>& $+80, 8 0"9$8.**&+*,-7 +/ $70"2- 2$*'"9## $,'',"*"+-, $7#"-,$ #", ,#&

$$%

(

) )

)

*+,* -

.!*+,/

(

)

(

)

% & -

*+,/

% 123 4'#

5 5

67 )

( #

8 9:

*+;<

= "

;< 4'#

4'#

9 >

!% (#

& !*+,@

A *#,<&29 $.,#0++.78$*'4&"$

%&% %& %'(%)*!+,%"-'+&./!+*. 01# ,!+*22 3 4 .*" $.,#*+$*,$,$$*$90$*+,",$ 0$*"#&+$ $*

-"#$8&+ $",#$*7<$ 0$*#?,++ +27+$8 0$*, ,$*"+-, $7#"-,$ #",,#& ?

$ #

$# (

% '$ $ (

(

% '$

1 ' $

-# *0$*#&"$ 6!! 7'"%+ +.-% ,.

)* % !#8%+0%&%223$4 ,+#*+$$*#,900$ $*,$.* $*,9## .,#, ++,0$",+ 2'"0#$&8

$*2"& $*,$$*9,"/#7$, .,#+##$*, ;

A ,22"2,$$ .,#*+$*,$ $*".,# 0,&+$0$*, ,$, **, #$&0"9, 88,"#*#*&+7,++.$#$&8 $*#, &"#$.,#*+$*,$ #&*,972&&##$&,$ $# $'"'"$ , +$*,9## ,$#&*,+,$#$,2# $*+/*,9-

)' 2 -.$*-",++"&9#$, #, $*0,$$*,$ $*'$$ "*,# .',##&$$*#&"$#0$*' $*,$$* $"9'"$$ #+,7+$7 0"9 " 2+8 $*'&+,"0,$#, "&9#$, #$* 9'&2 "",$ 1

4&" 516, $*#&7#>& 99& ,$ #,$ : 1B: 13

4&"# 5;B

5!6,">&,#**,9## 0$*'$$ "#"2&+,"@, * # $$+0"$*0 ,+2" *."$'$$ #$, #,++.," 2+8 9 :

# C*$*"#',/ 25",# # C*$*" '"$,7+ #