High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28180/2013disposed of

Satinder Kumar Jindal v. Punjab State Warehousing Corpn & ANR

2015-09-29Mr. Justice Satpal6 pages

! "#$# % # &# # # %

%' ( )*

+, - ./ 012 ,' 34.'" ('

*4*

('

*

!"#$%#&'"!'#('!!

+ 5-4" ('1#( )'

#.34 ('1#( )'

* !'#('!!

)$

7'* (7*:-

* 8'*( (' (0#

<=-'** '

4 6'/ ,' ' 8

:7 /> > 101=?<7'*/

.- (4-

)' **)'4*

,'('.

*(

( .7**''> *4)7'.'

7'7 :

4((':

@A 7**''>'

(/''

1'

>1:

4(/ .7* '/

*

7'*'*

)' 4 44 ( .-48

( (' (

< -'** ( /> ,- )' , ) '> #8)44 '-- '47 > (*.** -

B* '-- ' * '*

.-48

7*:-

(*-4 ( ')* ' 7' -

:'* '-- ( '* )' 8%*)'

'8 1 4

,'

84:7

(- (@0

:'*7 ' ('*)' 8% -4>'

'8 ..

)''

'()

' 7'

(8'7

(' =:'***4 %*)'

'8 *

,4C*','7/1 8' '

( ,'

84 ' 8 8 7' * 7

. *7'

/

)7'8 . ('8

, *

*'(

1#

<17''*- *4)

(' ) -> '<@1 - *

' ' *1

>7 /* * 8'( 8('8 :

, /4:'*

)

**

/>%*) '8 *7'

' ) -> '<1'.

012?< ( 101@?<* /'

( *

('8 ) -> (2<= 8

->1 . (D#

<:'*'8' '(( **

%*) '

'8 *1 4 6'/ ,' ' 8

1 , 4C'*','7/1 8''

(,'

84#*7

((

->1 *7

(' (#

<:'***4

7.- * 8 101=?<'*:

'*'((

'?.

-4

*4/. ( 7* -> (' (

<@1 ;-' 87'7 :'*

'7 174*1

>*7 4(/ ( .7.

1 .-48

(' ( 0 #

<= :'* -'** ('8' *7

.- * 8-

'>'*( ' ('/

B*'-- ':'*'* (*.** (( (

<

()

*4/.*7'-

:'*- ('%*)) 1,'

84 .@ 0 #.

( ) ..4 )'

(' ( = #

< ' * ) -> '@<2'

(2<=17 17 )'

(84> ')

? ')

'

)4./

'** '--'

7'-

:'*

:7 -)4 '7 1 7**4'

-> 8 ..4 )'

#

<1 *7 4(

> .

-4

' '

'/ *' ('.

!47 .

1*.

..4 )'

(' (D#

<27'

7'* ')/

8

*'

(7 7'*/

*7

'/ * 7**4'

1.-48

*'

'/ '*(

4 *'( '84.

*1

( ) 7

**4-- *7 .-48

*'

(-'>* 4-7 ( . 7

87'-

:'*

- (4 8> (2<='

( ( 8

;-'

'

'*

:7> *7 : )'4*

7'(/

**4 ( ' ( **

)'4* (=<D> '*- 7*- 8'7

1 : 8 :'*-'** (/>7* 4

202+<

()

7'*-

')7' 101=?<7'*/

1

>

8 (7'7

7'*

- *7

**4 7.1

@ :7)7 7 487 :* *

1 ')4'> )1 1 7 -

*- ))'> - 4 *4/* G4

>1

@17'7 :'*

- (' -') G4

1 ,'

841 1 :7

*:

' (>8

' . *17 /> )'4* 87 ' *'( **

7 ** *1 '(. (>1

'*- *7

#

<- ' (2<=,'

>1

'-- '47 >1 * (

<14-

'-- '

'8' *7 ' *'( (D#

<=1*- ))'>*' (7'7 :'*- ,'

> (#484* #484*

1 '-- '47 >'* 1:7 4

'( 8 7*

-

1 7'* -'** ( 7 1

< '

8 %

*7' '(' '* 7 :1 7

:'*

84(4 87 @<2 '

( 2<=1 7 :'* **4 ( ' *7 : )'4*

7' 8 )'4* ( ** *

<

1'/ 4=<D> '*- 7*- 8 7'

'-- '47 >1 ,.'(7 3'''1 :7 -'** (7 #

<1(' (1

'-- '

1*7''*

'('1*' 8'* :*4)7'/'*))

:'*

'-- '47 >7 4'( 4/1 '-- '/>7 '-- '47 > ' )'-')>

1:7

1' '*

.* / :7 4 - '--)'

. *4/6 ) :7' * *'

'('/>7

'/ '.

) 1 7* 4 :

4( ;

)*

64*()

C'

;-'

'

.*4)7'--

'47 > ' *'( '('* / ( :7 ('>*1 ' 8 :7)7 7 '

8 %

( 7 ) '.

( '/ 1 *7' / *

'>-

;(' 7 ' 8 #(6 4

002H 4*4'

7 1'('*(' (02:

/>'

1 4

'*:

'* 7 '-- '47 > * .

( 7 7' **4 '.

*

('8 (, ' * ' '*' *4 '4( /6 )

)4

/'

)7

/*

== 7' '.

* '/ *

*'() .<@

:'(* ' 8 %*)* 8'1 , 4C*' ,'7/ '

( ,'

84 4*4'

7 1 (=#

<:'***4 %*)'

'8 * *'(-') * ' .-*.'( 64*>')

'8' *-

/> 87'7 4877 G4

' * '*'*

('/ /4/ 8%*)

'(*:'*7 (4> %*) '8 * 'C 4-7 .' :7 *1

>'

>7 *'.

'() 17'

(8'7:'*7 (4>

8'

* *'.

/4 -

((

)7

-> .- *

>'

(-

'> )

** 487 64* 7*.'

*'--'

7'7 *

(*-4 '/ 47

/ 8 -)4 '7 '*@<2'

= 2<= *'(( 7.:7 >* >

8 (7':'* 7*(4> 7' 'C

**'>')

'*-'-'/> 64* (*

(7'

')

7'*/

'C

'8' > - *

- 4* )4./

* *'(- *1/>7

% -'.

7* ') * )

.

( />

( ) 7

*7 *

64*'/ '*

8 ( .- *

*4)7 >4-

,'(')

*) '>4 64* (4 )' ( 7 1-4

101=?<* '*(

1.

-4

)

*64*

')*'*))4.*'

*'*:'* )4./

4-

7' 'C

')

7' *'8 ( *4/. ' - ->

..4 )'

#

< ' 7 > 4* 1 '--*

'47 * 8 ( '>'

(')4'- *

7* : -

* (*- :7 7 '/ *'( ()'

.-48

*(' ( 0#

<='*:

'*(' (#

< !*+( , - ./ 012 $,-.

*