The New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Kamlesh And Others
! ""# $ $%! && ''() *
+,% "
) , %('-).( /0()
''()
2
)-
)&& ('(/(- )
&
34)2
(&& ''()5
) ( $6&(40 (/(- ) -6&/
() &(
34 '
,) - ) $'(-6 -3('0 72-8(-92
-(1)
( : -3(';<*- -6&/
() 0'
-3('2((8( 6& ()-1
0 0 5 ))2 '(-6() ()1 ()2172( ()"-/2-)2 (- )() 0()1 2( --/1
82-'
--/$()
-/
92
-(1)
)(
:11 -/ ;< && ''()5- ( 6&(4- (// - 34)2 1--/1 -3('-
082
34
2(
2 ' '-(3'
1 ( -/)2 (- )() 03422( --/ ( 6&(4 - ('
(// - 34 )2 (6) 1 6& ()-(8( 34'
-3('))2 '(-6()
%
' 1 )2 (&& ''() 2( ( / )2() '
-3('2(
-'-/ 2( --/)2 &( )1
(2( )(&&
-() )2 1'(-6() 8-)
82-2'
'4 )2()-)8(
16) 4'
&82-2
8( ) ( ''-/0828( 2( )2
(&& 6(-'4
'- & 1 "0828(
8-)
(()2 1(- )( ''( &-''- -
-'' 1() 6) 4'
(( / )2()
2(1(-'
)6(-)(--
6 $()
82-2 2(
') - )2 (- ) %
' 1 (&& / )2()-)8(
828( )-( -/)2
(- )()
(-(')
()- / )2()&
)- (
1) 0-1 )-
3'(6 ) 2-1) )
=
'-( 3
/'()-1)2 '
1
(
/'()- 0 % -3(' - ( ( ( 2(
-
)2 1 0822(&& '
8-)
))2
(' )2()( 1(
8(
02 )- --/)2 (1
)2()-)8(
82 8( ()1(')( 2 2((&&'-
()1( )
-
()-0)2 - (834'
-3('
()3 1(') 8-)2% -3('2( ()'
/)2(&&
-() )2
?(6-()-1
?(6-()- 2( '
'4 )2()2
()2
8
)/
6) 4'
(8
1''8-/)2 ) > ()'
) >6
+('(( (72-8(-2
16) 4'
8( )3 >652
11 -/) >8( -/ ()
1 >652 *- -3-'-)48( )3 '
(
16) 4'
-/2 '6 )% -3('2( ' )2()
6)2 1() 34 -)- '
'46( ))2()()) 6&)8( 6(
346) 4'
)
)(> 11 -/) >2
&
- -3-'-)4((- )2()(> ) (&&'-()-13
34)2 11 -/ 2
-//- 34'
-3('()3
1(') 8-)206
'43 (
>1 63 2- -)@1 63 2- --)
'18-'')'
())2 -)2()-)- 82-22(2-))2
11 -/ 1 63(>8'3 ) '-(3'
1 ) $) (1()82-2- )&1()
(- 6
(2(
A
0
2( ) && -))2
8-)
3?)- '
6(
1
(3
1(4 2('11
/( 8-)26(
1
(- )0 '4 )((-'(3'
)2()1 0822('
'4 )2()) > 2((&&'-
(()1 (&&'-()-13
6) 4'
2(2-))2 11 -/ 1 63 2- 3) -)- )41 1''8-/)2 -1 ))6(-)(--
0-)2
0-)2( 82
6 )2()- -/ 6(-)(- & &
'4 34 )2
6) 4'- ) (1)
6(-)(--/- 0(- )( ()1 (&&'-()-1
-)('' &()
13
(2 )6 )3
> &)-6-)2()$()
B-&& 8-)2&
16) 4'
- >3
2
&
)-6
) >( 6) 4'
-11
) 2
0-(3
1(4 )2()6) 4'- )8( 6(-)(--/& &
- 0-)()3
6 )2()6) 4'
2(
>(/(- ))2 11 -/ - -/6(-)(-
6) 4'- )2 1())2()
(&&'- 3411 -/ 82-28( -/ ()1( )
2( )3
3))
0)2
0-)2
- 6
-(3
1(4
)2()6) 4'- )8( )6(-)(--/- 0)2 - (834 -3(' () 3 1(') 8-)2 (
6&)- 1 2 ( --/)2 &( )1
6) 4'- )(3 (-
'-(
&C/6 - !"#$%&!
$'()* &$$!
$'() 9<% 0$'#$#*# %#)'! (* #+ 9< $ 9$--'< =0 !#$( !
# !)&!,( $ *"#$%&!
$'() -../0 12.-/ !
&# %&*# #!3'!
$'() =1 A
8
0
12 '&))2 (
1(&& ''()( 1()61 ) )&1() (- 6
(2 (
3)-)- )41 82-2- 2-)6(-)(--
0)2
6 )2()- )6(-)(-
1 1''8-/()2
)2
0 -
0)2
0 C/6 -) (3 12 '&))2
(
1(&& ''() %$
2(''
/ &
1 ())2 )-6 1(- ))2 / )2()2 )(6 - BB(
)34 ) ) &'- ,
6 )--/ 1 " D +(' ) 3 &
(6&(4-/)2
))2 2 &-)('34)2 2 &-)('()2 -)-
() )3)&
1 "0828( ()2 1 )- 6())
166>8'
/ )2()2 &-)('()2 -)-
8(6 1 &
) 1 6(4 &
(6&(4-/ )2 -C
5
0
06
6 )--/1(6 34) -8-'')6(>
1 3)1' ''8-/6& ()-8(
)3 &(-)'(-6() 34 -3(' "
(
$(''()- 9-< "('( 45-6
0 5&
6)2 9--< 1)
(-/ E 1 9-< (3
0 F0 G 0 5 9)3 ( ( 1)
) < 9---< 1)
)-/519--<9 )
0 ? 5 ? G
0 5 &
(' ?&
1 )2
((''4
<G 9-< $6& ()-(1)
6')-&'-
1=
0 ?=G
0 0 5 - (&&'- 9< %
1 )-60'
1' (
= 0 5 (11 )- )G 9-< %
0 5 9--<
('() ( & )()- ?&
0 5
)-2 .. ...45 ( $6&(4 - ('
(// - 34 B()6 1 6& ()-%
''()- 2(''
/-/)2 (8( 1
0 5 (2()1'
(1
(' ?&
( ( & )()- ?&
(( / )2()-)/2))2(
0 5
(2
2 ( )- 1
/ )2()'
-3('/2)) 2( E)8( 1)
)
8( 4
' $'(-6() 2( '(-6 (/ 1
) 3 = 4
% -3('2( )(> (/
)3 =4
028
-6 -('6 -'-/, 0(/
8(
(
()2
0'
/ )2()'
-3('/2))2( (/
)3 4
8
(/
-, ()3 ( (' 1
/( -/)2
(/ -)- /
(''4
)2
)- 1&
&
)3 2('1 1
- "2&
(- '
(/ -/2)'4 /'4 3C ) )-1 6()-((-'(3'
8-)2)2
)()-/)2 (/ ))2 ) 0-)-
(4
(/
2(
=) 4
0(
)2
6()
-('((-'(3'
- 81 1--('()
1,) *
)0(&&'-()-1E)8(
1)
?&
' )2()
2( 6&'
4
()3 1(') 8-)2 )- (3
'- (
(
'3
)2( 4
1(/ -/'(-6 34'(-6()
(-- 81)2
)- 12- 1(6-'46
)2()2 =4
'0 (8( 1E)8( 1)
?&
&2 ' 3)'
-3('
2( (8( '
0 5(1
('H) ( & )()- (/(-)3
0 5 (282-2/2))2(
0 5 (20
0>
&-/-- 8)2 1())2())2 (6)1
0 5('
/ () - ?
('
1 )-62(
&(-)(/2)
1
0)2- $ )- )-) -/)-)
-)2 (8( &(
-3(' = && ('- 8-)2)(46
-)
- 6-
7 -8.82.20 2- (C
"& (>-/5
I
& )(3'
I