High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20437/2017allowed

Vishavjeet Kaur v. Baba Farid University Of Health Sciences Faridkot & ORS

2017-10-10Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa9 pages

!"#

%#&' ( &)$* +',%-.%/

'/'

%)% %0

'1#%,2& &'* %03% 0'

'4 '

' (5 +3%'%*0&%*#,4

5 5% ',%06%*0&%*#'4 $

%%*0&%*#'4

,%*0&%*#'4 8

9 %:

,;/' 6,&, %''#& '0% ,'&%''

6,,,4 ,%') / #%10 0%0<'' ,52 /' 2,// %<%' '/#50&%2& &' '%&,* <'%%=% '%'%'0#,2&,0/0%'%=1> ?

@ ,#%&'<%1) &0)#1

?!@ ,4 ) =','0&%=1#2&,0/0 %'% 0'%'0 #2%# -%) 2,%44%0 ,% % =)18&/<8 % &'9#',*AA:8 $"6, ','&/0 !7<%3'% 0,% 0%% 36%'$BCBB '4 '

7%' ) =,'0&%=1#2&,0/0%' ,1%44%0

* $"% 0,'&6%' D$% 0 ""% 0,% 0%% 3'6 $C77C % 0 !C7*'4&1 ,,4%8'4 '6,/'

4%&06 <,% ,4 8

? @ ,%0<'' '52% 02/'' ,2%#

-%) 6 & 0/&0 )1 %)% %0

'1 # %, 2& &'*

%038'4 $ ,&% 00%'6;/0%441 % , &/ = 6%' %' & 0/&0 , 4 %440 '4 $8

'1 # %0<'' 52 /' % 0 =% 4 #!

50&%='

2,*,6*00 =%0<''

52/' ,#'% 0'& 0&/ =) =6 < , '0&%=1 ,'& 0 &/ =,0 $C

$"*, 4 A' / &%< # 2 /' 6,&, ', %&&40 2, 6%'

4' %1%0<0 $

$"% 0%&%02,// %<%'

'/# %2& &'% 0 '%&,*<'%

?7@ ,%'&/8##0%#%0<'' '52% 02/''

E40 !$

$"% 0,%0%*,4 A'/ #%'%

52/'00 &<%'4,< ,'0&%=1

'4 '

7) =#%6 <00 =%0<'' , 522/',E41#,%'&/8##0% ?B@ %44%',%'<'%' 52F2/''<% 0 #0 ,2%'# -%)% 0%1% %0/%6% 004)<

,,2%'*,#*%440 A)2/4</#E '

#<#&/ ,%44&% '6%60)1,4E/ 000%0$

$"*6,&,%0'%'#6'(8

4 ,% =,&/ '*,/<%0,#6

%05 .

+ /=4%*% 0 1 % # , 2% # -%)* 5 3 2% =6% * % 0 00 %0&% %#,2%#%1% %% 5 %/%2,%<%*% 0&/ '#,50&%/ & # 0%

' '/)<0 )1 5 .

+ /=4%* % 0 1 %*,%0/%6% 004)<% , 0'/)% &'* &/ ' = &/0 ) ,0 '

'/)<0)1,<,%,'/0 '# -%)% 0%1% % %%##&0)1,'%0'/%

,'%<%=/< '

%0% &0 )1 5 3 2% =6% * % 0 00 % 0&% %#,2%#%1% %

% = ,%0 % 0 &/ ' # , 4%' % =%0) =,%0,'4&%&&/<'% &'*6E 0, <#&/ ' ="

,E 00<',% ) %44&%) # ), , 2%'* %<1* -%) % %1% % &%#0,% ,2%'/0 ',% =,) ##E ' #<#&/

5 ""C# $"'0'4'0#%&&0 =1

?"@ ';/ /4 , E ' # < # &/ = "

$"* %)% %0

'1 # %, 2& &' % 0 '%&,*

%03''/0,#6 =4/)& & !

$"9 8D:(8 G%)% %0

'1#%,2& &'* %03

%38 ,1'&%/ =#I# 52F2 2%'8

52( #'%'#52&/'9 # %#,54 4 / 0#/ =:*=) ;/%#0&% 00%'#<%,2%'# 0%* &/0 = -%)* % 0 # %38 ,1'&% / =%/0/<*//) 02 =,50&% =* %03

$"/4$$ % < , '%'6)%&%0%&&0 =,<# ,=)&% 00%'

% 00%',%04')% 0<% 0 0%# # / # #%/ # ='%*

2* 4%1%) % %03 % 0 ',6 = % 0&/< '%,/ = / ,#',%) ;/% , %</ %' 4 , # # , %&%0 &=

2(2<%1*=);/%#0&% 00%'

#<%,2%'# 0%* &/0 = -%)% 0 #%38 ,1'&%&/ =%//) 02 =, 50&%=* %03 B

$"%D % <

'<'% 0& 0 '%'%<%'< 0%)

,#'/&/#,'4&&='F '/ ''

%%%)

'1 6)' 44&% #<F# 6%0'#',='% #'/<# '

!F8 , ',%4# #%/# ='%*

2* %03 6)&&0 ,'4 % 00%'6,,%- 0 ,%&%0&=' % 12% &/0 = -%) /4!$

$"% =)4%&4%

9<4,%'')1/':

?C@ ,4 <<0%104'0,;/'&/ #

$"9 8$:%'',6% 0%3%&,% &#%0<'' 52/' ,'4 $8

'1*,6*/ 006 , &%< ,4<',%',6%' =)'3%0<'' 52 /'' &',,%0%3 %0<'' ,2/' '/% 1*6 '%''0#2&,0/0%'%=1&% 00%' 52/' 6##0'4 '

% 07

?D@ ,%==04 <<0%1%44%&,0,'/

?$@ ,'4 ',%#0,418%##0%'

?$$@ ,%,%0% 0&/ '#,4%'6,# & ,;/' #</%0 ,4 =4%%=%4,#,'0 ?$ @ '%0 ),%##,'4 $8

'1%'

6%'4%'4 ',% &,4 ,%040#2 /'* ', &/0 =)1 <' # , 4/)& & 0%0 !

$"*40/&0 4%%?"@#,'0*% 0',6%'=,10 0

%0<'' 52/' ?$!@ % == /,/=,#/& '0% ,%#8'%0 & *60 # 0% 1<,

'%1'#,%' ,% , 4/)& & 0%0 !

$" 9 8D:* #'1 & 0 6%'

<4'0#%0<'' 52/',%,&% 00%'6,,% - 0 , %&%0 &=' % 1 2% &/0 = -%)* /4 !$

$"* % =) 4%&4% , 6%38 84,1'&% &/ 2/&,& 0 6%'<4'0 1#%0<'' ,2 /' 1 '%<%#&<< 3 60=,%2'4&0 )% #&/'%'&<4%052&/'% 0#'&,&#%

%'4% ' %%)1#52/' 1 ,

'1& '&/'1 00 <4',& 0 %',#'%'52/'6 ;/0)##0'&1 0#<*'4&#,#%&,%% &% 00%,%0%%01- 0,2/' ,4 E&'0)1% &% 00%#% #&/'*#6% #%'% 52&/'%'4 ,'F,<*&% ,) 30%'% '44 %'%&%30 %0<'' %'4,< ,' =% '%1 =,%%&% '%'

6%38 84,1'&%&/ =6%';/0)##0 0# < &% 00% 2&,0/0%'&%=1,=, <,% , 4 &%<#6%0'3%0<''

,4 %440#6%38 84,1'&%&/ =% 0'/=,%0<'' 52/'%'4, < ,0 %#%0<'' , 1)&%/'',,%0%%01= %0<'' 2/'* /& '006*'%1%)%1% ## 0'&$ #, '/

?$ @ ,& 0 ,%,&% 00%'6,,%) %0, =' /4 !$

$" 6 =) 4%&4% 6%38

4,1'&%&/ =*,%') '0 1/ 0,,%0G 2H%

/ 0,,%0G 52H/' ,4/)& &40/&0

%%8"#,'0 ?$7@ 2 #/,* , '4/% , 4/)& & 0%0 !

$"0';/%#1%&% 00%6,,%'%%01=%0<'' % /' %' <4'0 )1 ,

'1 ' 0&1 & #& 6, , 4' '& % 0

522 52F2

22222 28 , '4&/'*/ 0,,%0 =G &0/ # / =% 0 =%,='H/ ;/&%140'

,%(G#&% 00%''%'#06,'%%&%0,<F,0/ = &/ =*,F',' ;/04%&4% ,'/)';/ / 0# &/ ='

&%'*&% 00%6% '/4=%0F&,% =,'F,'%*,F', 6,%4%&4% ,'/)';/ / 0#&/ =% 0=, 4# &'%#',#,&/'F&=F&%=1F;/

?$B@

& , '4 8

'1 ,%' %0 06 % &<4 4&0/ , '4&/'6,&, &/0'= =% 44/ 1% &% 00% '3 /4=%0% % 0 &,% = # ,'F, '% ,/=, 4%&4% , '/)';/ / 0 # &/ = % 0 )1 = 4# &'%#',#&/'F&=F&%=1F;/%*,

'1&%

%)/41&,% ='/&, #0&%% 0%3%'<'%/ ?$"@ ''/< =,%,& 0 0%&% 00% =) 6,,%0=%0<'' /4!$

$"6%'%44&%);/%,'%'

52/'%'*1%44%',%,'%0& 0 ,%') %1 <'& '/0)1,

'1#0 1 =%0<'' ,4 , '%0& 0 <14,)',',/## =#%&%0&='

'%1 0## 1*#%'/0 6%'%0<052/' %4%

50&%

'1F=* , '/)-& & 0 00 4< '/&, '/0 '38%&% #<4%50&%= < 50&%= #%'%6%'%%%) ,%&= , & 0 ;/' &%

)'&,0'%1,%%'/0 6,,%0 = %0<'' % # /' 6/0 ) =) '3 %0<'' %'4,'F,&,& ,'/4&/'=%0''#,'F, < 8 2/&,%& '/& #,& 0 0'4/6/0 %0%)%1& ';/ &'%') =0< %,4 &4# <% 06/0%,)%) % J%#,'4%&06 < ?$C@ ,=&%& ';/ &#,'% 0%3 )1,'4 '

',%,&% 00%'6 <3'4 7*6,00 =%0<'' 2/',%'&/##0%*,%'/&&00 = =%0<'' 52/'*6,%'%&% 00%6,',=,

<% 06,4%&4%0 %,&/ ='') =0 06,%'

=<%10/,%'4< 8 ,%& #'4 $8

'1,/''6,1/ #%*/ -/'% 0 ;/%)

?$D@

,%' '%#8'%0*,64 '%60% %& # , '4 $8

'1 0 1 = %0<'' , 4 52/'''8%'0 '0&0,%,4 ) #,6,',#052/' 2, // %<%' '/# 50&%2& &'% 0 '%&,*<'%% 0#,'4/4',%0<''

#'4 7*) =6 <*)&% &0*# 0) 6* ,'/% '%)%&%0)1,4 2/' 2,//

%<%' '/# %2& &'% 0 '%&,*<'%*<%1) ##0'4

@ I, 0#/)0 6, %40# 63#<, 0%#& =%&#0&41#,'0 ?

$@ %'

&)$*

!"# $" 888 +',%-.%/'/'%)% %0

'1#%,2& &' '

' (5 +3%'%*0&%*#,4

5 5% ',%06%*0&%*#'4 $

%%*0&%*#'4

,%*0&%*#'4 KKK 2,8418&/<8%##0%#'4 *#0 / 0%1*'%3 &0 " # !

$ %&'() *)(+ " # !