High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24967/2015allowed

M/S N.V.R Forgings v. Union Of India & Others

2016-03-22Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik6 pages

!"!#$%$&'(

)*%+ ,-$&-% ! $ $&!, +%

&$&&"$&" .!,% !%/&"!& % )' 01) 23 ) )1 01) 2 2 1

! "#$%& "'() *

! "%+"("'()

45367,)$ 89 , ! "#$%& "%+"("'()

- - . /0 . 1 ! "#$%&"'()

2 ! "#$%&"'() 34- 5 .3 -3 7 .3 -

"( "'("

0 3 ! "#$%& "'() 3. ,

- - 6 - / 5" 86, ($5) - 3 "''$9(' . 2-86 ( + "''+ :-(5 ($ 86:-"''";:-< 6 6-3 8- .-0- 3-3

1 6 0 - 3 "''$9('

, 6 - 60

=/ =/ ..-

, 6 ($)% 6 ,-0 - ") "'('0.30 - 3-3

- +'%#(&>9 - -..- 06- - - :8( 6 4--:-($:-

? "# "'(( 4- 7-

-3 30 - ,

7- -3 (% + "'(( 6- # 20 - 6- . 30 0- , 7- -3 3 +''''>9-:-"):-

.3 . 86

, 0 0

0 =/-3 04-. -. ,0 -0

- 6 , "( "'("6- ) - 3 -3 , . @2 3= +)88

.3 . @

/0 006 0 @ , @

0 3@2

, "5 5 . .3 300 86 - ? "'() 6- 5 -3 0 .- 3 0 - :89( 0 =- 0 0 0 . 6- =/0 - 6 / .3 #

- )

A --. 0 .6.3 4- 10 -- 3

: 0 7-

! $#()($$'"( ('

"'() --. %

B -. - - -7-

/ - 2:($&' (&( 7- 6- !!

!! "#$ 2:($%# %#5

% -

0-7 3*-

0 .0 - 6 00 .3 10 . 2 -9 ;) ,

,- &

"'('

+&/,)"(C/

0 0 - .3 10 . 20

-9 ;: D- "

A - -. -3 86 , 0

-3 - 00

-386 , 0-.6.3 3 .3 -. .3 1 / -7- / -

3 3 C 3 A

"'''

((& ,"$( -. 4-

3. 3 ,4- . 0 3 - 2 . - 7- / -

3 . .3 / 3 - ("

($$' . -

, 6,.- . .3 0 1 0 . 3 0 3 - 0 ,.- 9 > * A 0 / 3 "''( (5/,)&% ,,/

BC= A

/ 3 "''"

($/,"&" ,,/

,6A - / 3 "''"

($/,)") ,,/

>2 2-A :0 / 3 "''+ "(/,##" ,,/

A , / 3 ($$# #/,)+' ,,/

3 0 4- -

- .3 10 . < %

- ) "'() ! $%5+($$' -0-- #'"

.3 10 0 0

/0.30 - - #'"

0 00- 7- <

2 - 0 .3

3@2 00 86 - ,- 0 3

. .3 10.

7- -.3 - 3. 0.

- - ,- 3

- $

20 . 0 ,- 5 ! "#$%&"'() (% $ ) ! "%+"("'()

/0.3 0 0.-0-7- 7 3*-

"""'(% :