Satya Parkash And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

CWP No. 24027 of 2016 -1-



   
   

!"#$%

"&"'

!"#%( )*+,* *-* .*"!+.

...

&

)+*+ *,*"**"!+.

...

1"!

"+  2#  342  )
 0
)5 6
  )
  342  )


 44


"+#7 224).*8*6! '*+ 6*"! 2)& ./95&8*).*8*6! '*+ 6 +.

1

 2"-&2/++*96!!9! '*+  *96*,*"*6:/+. 2)*&*;.2*<6

+! '*+  *9*,*"*6*"!

5& .*9!

15*&2*"'.*"!*6! '*+ 6 +.

1"!

"+ 

      .

1

.* /9 !/"

+*"+:/+1 +/+/"

-/"</

&*"'

 :/+ /" +.

 "*+&    +/*/  =&* ./"< +.

 "+//'*+/" !*+ $*"!/

& !&"!

) '+/"*"!) '+/" +.

4*"! '=&/ /+/" '+6 ($ *"! *:*! !*+ ! $%  /" / :  ) /<.++ */81 *+/"*"!*"

1* "',/" 4*"!'=&/ /+/"6

.*;/9/+*+/"*"!

++9 "+'+6%> .+6 @+.

'+%A? 2.

.

'"+

,:./'.'11 !&1*&"!/"+ +*+/") '+/" >?+.

'+%:* 1&++

+;,+.

"

+/+&+/" "'.+.

)&1  &+ /" +.

 '*

 
   

            
  

;, 9*,/"< !:"

CWP No. 24027 of 2016 -21/"'/19

  !

'9*/"< +.

 *'=&/ /+/" *  !

!+ .*  ;

" 9*1

&"!

) '+%.

1 B&+.* !/ '&

!/" !

+*/9*99+.

* '+ "

'

*,*"! *"+/"+ +/"<) '+/" >?+.

'+%6*"!/"+./ <*!+.



"'

/ /"<8*!

+  '"'9&!/"< 1**<*1.  +.

 C&!<8 "+ :./'. / 1!&'

! .

/" ;

9:#7 DE     !"

 # $#$"  %        

    ! "

"   ! "

 !  &'      !

"(

  )   

 !"

! & 
 "  %  )  %   %% !! *"

(  " )      !  " '  "( 

 "   "

 # $#)$! "

!  & "

!

!  )   & , % -.   "

  #$ ) %

"

  )-. -. ,     !  "/  "(  "

  #$ !  "

! & 0

"%  "

!  !!     "

"  ! "

'  !   ) 0"

 ) 
  %'" ) 0'"

    )          ' ! "

 ) '  ) 0

   

 , *  1 1      ! "

  #$ !  "

 !  &    "

     ! "

 " ,"/"!2  

    "

 #$"  )   %  "

  3 !  ( 

 )!"# %$  ! !" !

"/ "

 ! "

!



)   "

 """%     ! "

! &
" ) ( "

&  ! 4"/ "

!

 )! !

'     "

 &  !   "

 " ) (  52   ! "

  # " $   

 

  ! "/  "(
"!2    %   "

   3  !  ( ! !   '"

  "

! &  )   6 %6  ! !"  ! "/ "

 ! "

!

 7
 " 

  )



 "

   "

& # $! "

!

CWP No. 24027 of 2016 -3-

'            "

    "/  

   "

  #$   2     2   !"

 " ,) (    "

  ) (      "

 & # $ 4 % %  !  ""

 "

   % (  !" ! ( "

 ' "       "/  "(     "

 #$! "

! &  ,   "

 #$! "

! &  )      ! "

  #$     ! "

  # $#)$ 8 , ! 0(  "

!

 " 

 "

 #$)%(! /   9   :"%)   0( "

 ! "

!

'

        (   "

  #$ !  "

 !  &'  "   ) 0   "

 #$ + ,   ! "

  #$  ( !      ! "(  

")   "      !     "

  0

   "

  ! !     )! "

! &"  !"' "(!

 "/  ( %  ""     

 

, !) "!    )"  )*"

 "

  !! 

 "

 #$! "

! & (   % " ! "

  /   (  ! ""



"( !  "/  "

   

  

"( (  !!"  ! "

!  &''  


      2)         ""

 "(  

% % /   ( ! ! 0(

    "(   !    ! "

    !"      "/ . % .

&8*"! &;

+*"'

+.

/"+ +*+/") '+%;,+.

)&1 &+/ +.*++.

/ +*"! 8 +'"!/+/" +

- 9*1 /"< /  +.*+ ;+. +.

 '"+/"< "'/

 1 /!

! /  *;&+ +.

1., /'*91

/"*"!+.

1*,8 "+'81 *+/"* +;

&9/99 !6 *"/"<+.

;,/ /+.

+.

'"!/+/"

 / "+ *+/ / !6+.

:&9! ;

"9*1 /"< ** ;9/<*+/"+8*- 1*,8 "+/"9/ &+.

9*"!*'=&/ !/ '"'

!6/+.*

"'9*// !+.*+ &'.;9/<*+/"+ 1*,/ '819 ;,+ /"<+.

'81 *+/"6:./'.:&9!8 *"+.*+

CWP No. 24027 of 2016 -4- '81 *+/"*8&"+:* 8*!

* */9*;9 ++.

9*"!:"

*"!/.

.* "+*''

1+ !+.

*8 6/+:/99"+;

* */9*;9 +.

9*"!:"

+ '9*/8+.*++.

'81 *+/".* "+;

"1*/!)/8/9*9,6:!F!

/+G .*

"/"+ !+8 *"!

/+/"<:/+.+.

4+.

 &,



"'

&+*:/"<1*"'."*8*.*

"'"

/!

!+;

* *9/!1+*-/"<1., /'*91

/"*"!"'

9*"!

/"+.

6+.

/ "!/

+/"<1 /!

!&"!

) '+%.

)&1 &+.* &+.

'9*// !+.*++.

1 /! :./'. *", /"+ /8 !

 :*  /" 1 *+/"6 :/99 ;

B'9&!

! :./9 '81&+/"<+.

<*11 /!/ , )/8/9*9,6/+.*

"'9*// +.*+) '+%!

"+</ /

+*"

:'*&

 *'+/" + =&

+/" +.

 9 <*9/+,  '"'9&!

! 1'

!/"<   9*"! *'=&/ /+/"* /+*119/

+"9,+.

'*

:.

/"+.

1'

!/"< :

"!/"<"+.

!*+  "'

"++.

'+%    1  '*

 1&+ +. ;, +.

 1

, *  :"

 /"

/"  +.

 9*"! ;

*/"< 5.* *  % HH%HH >7(? *"! % HH  >7? I *9/  :"<9, 8 "+/"

! *  % HH >7?J /+&*+ ! :/+./" +.

"&

+*+ 0/99*< *-.9*6 .

/9*"!/ +/'+&&<*8.

*/! 9*"! :*  *'=&/ ! ;, +.

 )+*+   *,*"* +.&<.
"!& +/

1*+8 "+ /!

 "+//'*+/"

 !*+ ! $ *"!  /

& &"!

 ) '+/"  *"! ) '+/"   +.

 4*"! '=&/ /+/" '+6 ($6

'+/ 9,6 99:

! ;, :*! !*+ ! $%   +.

 1&;9/' 1&1

6"*8 9,6+.

++/"<&1.*&!.*, /4*9
"!& +/*92!

9 :"

./16 .*

706 2*"

*6 + ;

 19*""

! *"! !

91 ! *  *" /"+ <*+ !'819 B
"!& +/*96
"

+/+&+/"*9688 '/*96

'

*+/"*9 *"!+.

1&;9/'&+/9/+/

"9*"!8 &/"<$K *'

K-*"*9(8*9* /99*<

 *;*!* *+ .1&6 *&*"<1&6 2*"

*6 4*-."&9*6 *.*1&

CWP No. 24027 of 2016 -55* *" *"! )./-.1&6  .

/9 *"! / +/'+ &&<*8 .

 1

'.*99 "< ! +.

 *'=&/ /+/" 1'

!/"<  /"     %  6 .:

6+.

9*"!'9*/8 !/"+.

/"

+*"+1 +/+/":* "+/"'9&!

!/"+.

*/!1 +/+/"*"!*'=&/ /+/"1'

!/"< =&*9*"!/"=&

+/":

"

'.*99 "< ! ;, +.

 1

 .

 1

 .*  '"+ ! +.*+ +/99 !*+ ,* /"1., /'*91

/"+.

9*"!/"=&

+/"*"!"

/+.

,.* '

/ !+.

*8&"+'81 *+/""/+.*

"!

/+ /" *''!*"'

 :/+. 9*: ;





"'

 &+ .& , .* 1*, !  !

'9*/"< +.

 *'=&/ /+/" 1'

!/"<  + .*  9*1

! &"!

) '+% K

& &*"++/

&*"'

"+/'

8+/"6+.

1"!

"+ /9 !* !

+*/9 !:/++ " +*+ "+*"!+.

*+ *"*/!* /+/"+.

9/<.++.

C&!<8 "+1*

!;,+.

)&1 &+/"
"! 

"+&+./+, > &1*?+'"+ ++.

19 */

!;,+.

1

2"-&2/++*96 *"

! !!/+/"*9 ! '*+   *96 *,*"*6 .*  19 *!

! +.*+ +.

/"  +.

 9*"! :*  +*- " ;, '!/"< *1*+  K !*+ $%  <*!

'81 *+/"6.

.* &;8/++ !+.*++.

"+/ *8&"+'81 *+/":* +

!*++.

+/8 *""&"'

"+ *:*!*"!8 +.*"(L++*9'81 *+/".*

"!/ ;&

!*"!

+*8&"+/ * */9*;9 !/ ;&

"+./ .:

+.*++.

*8&"+ '81 *+/":* !&9,+

!*"!+.

;9/<*+/"+.

+1*,  '81 *+/"  !/ '.*< !
" / : +.

6 ""

  +.

'"+/"< "'/

1 /!

!/") '+%* &9/99 *"!"!

'9**+/"* +9*1 /"<*'=&/ /+/"1'

!/"< '*";

8*!



 * /"<.

*!+.

'+/ *<&8 "+ 6.* /"<<"

+.&<.+.

'+/ 19 *!/"< *"!*; *996+.

B1 /+/"/"
"! 

"+

CWP No. 24027 of 2016 -6- &+./+,> &1*?6:

* +.

'"

/!

!1/"/"+.*++.

/"

+*"+:/+ +/+/"/ 9/*;9 +;

!/ 8/

!8 +.*""

" *? .&<.+.

1

.* '"+ !+.*++.

,* /"*'+&*9 1., /'*9 1

/"  +.

 9*"! /" =&

+/"6 .:

*/!* "+/ "++ "*;9 /" / :+.

/"+ +*+/" D

 

A 8*!

 ;, +.

 1 B &+ /"
"!

"+&+./+,>)&1*?:.

/"+.

"A;9 &+ .* '*+ </'*99,.

9!+.*++.

:!@1

/"A&

!/"+.

'+  ($ .* *8  8 *"/"< *  +.*+  @1., /'*9

/"A&

!/") '+%.

"  )+*+   "8 "+ *'=&/

 9*"! *"! !*:

8*"!&8  +*-/"< 1

/"6 :./'. /" +.

 1

"+ '*

 /  ;, '!/"< *1*+ M"*8'.*  K !*+ $% 6/+*8&"+ ++*-/"<+.

1., /'*91

/"  +.

 9*"! *"! "'

 1

/" /  +*- "6 +.

 / *;

9&+

+/"<+.

9*"!/"+.

.

*+ 6

"/  9*"!:"

+*/"

 1

/"  +.

 9*"!6 .

 /  *

1*

6 *"! &'. 1

/"  +

1*

"&

 + +.

;

/+ *"! " ;

.*9  +.

 :"

 /  )+*+  )/"'

/" .*  ;

" +*- " ;, '!/"< *1*+ M"*8'.*  K!*+ !$% 6+.

 61., /'*91

/"  9*"!  !&9, +*- " ;, +.

 )+*+  .

 19 *  +.

+.*++.

,* /"1., /'*91

/"+.

9*"!/ 6 +.& 6.

;, '+ !
*+*991

/".*

" +*/"

;,+.

86/+/ "9,* +

1*

*"!"+* :"

 * '"

=& "'

6 "

  +.

"+/*9   '9*/8/"< 9*1 /"<*'=&/ /+/"1'

!/"< <



CWP No. 24027 of 2016 -7- ;?  <*!

+*+& '81 *+/"6+.

1"!

"+ .* '*+ </'*99, 19 *!

! /" +.

19, +.*+ +.

 *8&"+  '81 *+/"  +.

"+/  *:*!

! 9*"! :*  8*!

* */9*;9 +*99+.

9*"!:"

:./'./ &;

+*"+/*+ !8  *'+ +.*+ +.

 8*C/+,  '81 *+/" *8&"+ !/ ;&

!++.

9*"!:"


"+./ <*!622/++*9.*

! +.*+ /" / :  +.

B1 /+/" /"
"!

"+&+./+,> &1*?+.

;9/<*+/"+.

+ 1*, +.

 '81 *+/" /  !/ '.*< ! / +.

 *8&"+  '81 *+/" /  +

! :./'. .*  ;

" /"+ ! + *"+.*++.

*8&"+:* 8*!

* */9*;9 ++.

9*"!:"

;

!/" **%:./'./ 1!&'

!.

/";

9:#7 '...

    
   

     

 

      

 


 


   

 !

 



 



     

 !

 

 "
 #

  $



 ;% '  "

    !                 )    %   % )"(! ) (   0 

      " " )

 ! !

 0(   

%

 $   
  

&     

'





 $    

   

( $ ) $ *+(

 

      

  

   

, 

     #   "    &  

#

 $ 
  

&   ' 


   

   
 # $   #  " 

   - # 

    &  

' "   #  &  

$ 



& 

  
& 

 $  "        .

 

 



 

   

(&  


    

* $ ) $   

( 
     

* $ ) $        

$     


$ 

/#

$  

 

 
   $ 





       "  



$ 



      

     # & $    

 #

  

'




 



"

 
 #    

&     

 ;% '  "      

CWP No. 24027 of 2016 -8- %   (        ' 

)         "

 & ' 

 "  /#



 " 
   $ 



  '



  &    

      $    
$    

(

 # & 3 

 

 " 

 
 



4
5 , .

 * +*+ ! *'+  '9 *9,

*9 +.*+ +.

 *8&"+  '81 *+/":* !&9,+

8&'. +.

8*C/+,  '81 *+/" *8&"+  !/ ;&

! *"! +.& )+*+  .*  !/ '.*< ! /+  ;9/<*+/" +:*!

 8*-/"< +.

'81 *+/"+.

9*"!*'=&/ !*"!+.& 19 *;

/"< */

! ;, +.

 1

 +.*+ +.

, .*  "+ ;

" 1*/! +.

'81 *+/"*8&"+/ '+ ! '? )/"'

""

+.

'"+/"< "'/

1 /!

!/") '+/">? +.

'+%* &9/99 !* 1

/"+.

9*"!

 !&9, +*- " ;, '!/"< *1*+  K !*+ $%  1& &*"+ + :./'. +.

 8&+*+/" *9 

*"'+/"

! *"! &+.

 *8&"+  '81 *+/" .* 9*1

!&"!

) '+% !?

&+.

6 /+ /  1 +/"

"+ + 8 "+/" +.*+ +.

 *'=&/ /+/" 1'

!/"< +!'"'9&!

!:*,;*'-/"+.

, * *"! 1/"+ !&+;,+.

9 *"

!'&"

9*11 */"<+.

*,*"*6+.

9*"!/"=&

+/".*

"19*""

!*"!/ + ;

 &+/9/M !  !

"+ *  1  *11 ! 9*,&+ 19*"6

 6+.

9*"!/"=&

+/"/

"+/*9*'./ /"<+.

1&;9/'1&1

:./'.+.

9*"!:* *'=&/ !*"!'*""+ ;

! 8 +.

 *'=&/ /+/"6 8  :.

" +.

/"+.

9*"! *"!

*9 *!,+*- "

CWP No. 24027 of 2016 -9-    *

=& 9  +.

 *;  !/ '&

/" *"! /" / :  +.

 9*:

&88*/M ! /" 1** % % 
"!  

"+ &+./+, > &1*?6

'//'*99,*+ .* /"< '!

!+.*+/"+.

'*

*+.*"!6+.

1., /'*9

/"+.

9*"!/"=&

+/".* /"<;

"+*- "6+.

;9/<*+/" 1*,8 "+'81 *+/" !/ '.*< !*"!*9 '"

/!

/"<+.*++.

9*"!/"=&

+/"/ ,8&'.

"+/*9+*'./

1&;9/'1&1

6:

.*  " .

/+*+/" + .9! +.*+ /" +.

 /"

+*"+ '*

 )+*+  .*  &99, !/ '.*< !/+ ;9/<*+/"=&*;+.+.

'"+/"< "'/

''&/"</") '+/" >?+.

'+%*"!/+;

/"< 6+.

/"

+*"+1 +/+/"/ !/ 8/

! ( * /"< !/ 8/

! +.

 8*/" :/+ 1 +/+/"6 1 "!/"< *119/'*+/"6 / *",6*9 8

*8 *+ )+*+& =&6/*",6  *'*+ ! > 0
)5 ? 
  )
 >

 44
?   %( "!C .

*-/"<H "



H .

1+*;9 

H