Satbir & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!" # $%&
!$%$'%( # $%& )
*& +, *
- -- .
+, *
- ,,
!"!
#!$%&! '( ) !*$* + $ ! !!,( !!
( !
$ +$ ! !!
) !*$%&!,( -(!*- !&(!!$%&!! !!% *!$%&! '. /0 -- .
/
(!, &!##!
( 3 * #/%!42 (!%!'( !7!&(!'
(*!&*!! '(! $ (!&(&*!!! &!#!&8'(9! &:&$2;<6=(!''!>(&'2;<6?@$
,!!4< 4526$(
,((!'#!) '( !&*!!$(&& :(&# '&'
( (!/#!!!!& 9!&:$ (!
*!*#&$452A =(!''! (>&'452A?@ ('$ (! (!* !* *%!&&!
&#! (!&'!'&!&6 5B 5;
452A$ ! * !* &! &#! (&: ( !,!$ ! !
( 9! &: /**&$ 4< 5B ('$ ( # (! ( '&!=@ =!@$
!,!!4< 5B 4528$!: :!($!$ !$(( $(!&(!'#!) '( '&!=7.A@$(3&'452A3(!!#'&($ (
(& '!&:,: *!&( (3&'452A3$(!(3&'2;<63 ( !
% ! & ' ( /
( *! &* ' ($ * $ !
&#&#** !,
!%&!,
( C *7 /&!*!>
? ,(&( !"#$%!"#&'('' ! '
)*+ ,--.,%,--.' '(,& &!#! ( C *7 /!!
!( A2 '(%&=!@$!!
!(,('$
!&(!'$(!('#*!(:' *!,$('!!, (
! " ! # $ %& & '& $( '& ) & & '& $ # * % & & '& $
! '((!
%7!&'#*!: '*!,$%!*(!(,(&( !
( C *7/ !!,(((!'& (3&'
2;<63$&##&( !'( #!) '!'&! & 6 '( !&$,(( (!'!&: & (3&'2;<63$&##&(!'#!)
'!&*!!&8'(3&'2;<63 !!(!( !'(!, ':'*!, =!@$! '#( %&& &46=2@'(3&'452A3$% ,('!7!&(!' '# /
,,&"#
0
+( )
! % ! ,-$ .
() % !
/ ()
% !
%$( C *7/,! !
#!)
!!' ((!*
>& !( 3&'2;<63$ !&&&46=2@ ' (3&'452A3 !!,(!
%:'*!,$( C *7 / !!
!( A4 ('$ !!
!( ,(' &# 7!&(!'$(!7*!$(!(!'!&: & (3&'2;<63$(&&(!'#!)
'!'&!&6'(!&$!$(!(! '!&:& (3&'2;<63$&&$ ( !' !&'!&*!!&8'(3&' 2;<63 0 1 !
'&
20 3 # '$( )() 1 2" # '$( ) () ! % & & '& $ '& # %
'&
! " 4 # % ! & & '& $
'&
! 5 !
'&
'&
" ! # $( ) % !
1 ! "!
# '$( )'& 1
'& %
" " 1 " % '& 6 # '$( )()
'&
"
1 %0
# '$( )() 1 '& 5 2 7 018() 1
9'&
" ! '&
" : ;68 9 !
# '$
2
# '$( )() # '$( )() # '$( )() '& "
1 : ;68# $( ) & & '& $ & & '& $ # * % & & '& $ 5
'& 4 1
) # '$( )() '& 1
%$ ,(*#!) (!
%!( !
%! (!*
$,(&(&&(3&'2;<63$(
C *7/!!
!(A4 &!%&=!@$ ( &&*!$(!'('&!&6'(3& '2;<63$(&# '&'(3&'452A3$ (
'(!,!$,(&(,!(, !, #'
&22$'(3&'2;<63$(!,(&#
'&'(3&'452A3$!,&# '&'( 3&'452A3$ (&: ( &&$!(#'
(%7!&=!@$ &# , ,(
%!* $ &#!)!!,!(3&' 2;<63$ (#!) '!!,!(3&'2;<63$( (&# '&'(3&'452A3$ !( !# '& #!* $ ( &#! !#!
* &# ##'(! &*&#*!( 3&'452A3 ;
&:&$(! ,#$,((( &: ( &&$('&!&6 '(&'2;<6$((&# '&'(&'
452A$!#&(!$,(((!'&! &!# 4526$(,((3&'452A3!#'&!0&!# ! < (!
% !$$(!('&! ! & 6 ' ( 3& ' 2;<63$ ,!
0 5B 5;
452A$!$,((!'!&'(!'&!$ (&# '&'(3&'452A3 ('$# '(%&=!@$(!&:& &!#!! &((3&'2;<63 /:* $ ( :* &*!!&8'(3&'2;<63$%'(!' #!) '(!&*!!$,! :(&# '& '(3&'452A3$ !0$'(!,!,(&( &!#! &:&('$,!! !'&# '&'(3& '452A3$!#&(!$ &!#4< 5B (*$ ('!&#'!&'!'&!&6'(3& '2;<63!(!!$ (&# '&'(3& '452A3$(!(&&*%!&!#$('(
%!*! ( :* &*!!&8'( &'2;<6$!$'!*%!*! (!,!!:!( "& *! (#$'(&!(* !''!% (! ' ( !&: *! &!# !# % !! E!#&(! 886!4< 5B %$(! &#!!#!,!!4< 5B 4528$&#!
#' A5$BA$;B40. &# $ ( ) #=@('$!(!#* (9/ !&&'(
&# *!(*!*&& !$(&#!(! &!*&*!!( !!#*!,(3&'452A3 ('$(!&: & (!% &#'** !*!,'** &&* "&
(&#!#(!,!&&$(
#!#'(3&'452A3 /&* !*&(! !$(* !''!%$ !*! &$ (! ( "& *! ! ! !* &#'(*!
*!$(
,(( !'!&*! ( *%! *& /:* $,( *&(!( **%!*&'(!( '( *!* $(/'#(!$!$ &!# 1%23 !# !
$4 $'!5
24 !'#!($(/'#(,$ !$,((!
% %!$(!## (# '&!=@$ ! &: ( !,! ! #!! ! !''# 2A !& &(#!&!*'(! &$($!**( !*&!=@$'! $!*!=@'
7-- .8 7,, 8 )
)!% ( F((!) 0! 0 F((!
* 0