Union Of India And Others v. Ex Hav Rajinder Kumar And Another
!"#$# %&'( '(
)& *+) ( , ,) ,, *+) ( ,-.,,
!"#
"$ "#%
&&&&& ,) ,, /(0 +1 '
# ( !""
)
12 !
34
+*
53!"# )!" 6 ( # $ ! )! / !% %
! 753!"82#349 ( #
' !3
!""9
%%
34 %*1-:,-:
%"% ;
)< 9 %!(! ((*!( % # )
<
+
"!( "!(
%*
0!*!%
' "
! )
!3"4%>
!!
?1-: !3
%
'#3 !3
7 !3!3"
"!4
!))!<!
34 "!4 # )!%
'?,-:%"% 34 )
+ %% 1-: !3"434 "!() "!( C % 53!"#
!"6 ( # 9 "
"
!
!"#$# %#&$ #&'()! C %83"
$% !* ) + $),$#- ()!!"#$# %#&$ #&'()!0 21,2/(
% 3* !( #
%
(!" 6! ("
!"4 ! ! !3"4 %
' !3
*"!4 !))!<!
34 # )!%3
'?,-:%"% 34 1-: !3"4( (! %!(% !< 3
!
(!
( (
(< 34 53!"9 "
!)
.
@ !< "
! !< ) ) (! %"
9 !3"
!!(
,
((
%!( !! 9
'
%* 1'
'- +-+'# !" 4
* !+-4 !% 9
% !
!"!((
%!( !! 9
'C
!*
%( # 9!*
(!""4
0!*
! 9!% %% )%*!4( # 3!% 9 ( #
' !3
)!
("!*%
'(<
%!<% )!%
!
C %83"
% ! ) + $),$#-.! (!
5 <! !! 1-# 1+! 11 % C * ) + $),$#-.!(! !2! !
1-
! % !4 !3
(
! %!
""!D !((
!( %*"!4
5
!< %!"
3) ( !4 (* )) !
""!9!
!* %( ! 34
!4 %% )%*(
!3 %!4 ( ! %!((
!( %C)%!
""!9!(*3 !%
(!"6! (!""% ( ! "; (*)! ! ("
!<
*
0!*! !((
!( %*"!4 #3 ) ( )) !!4( ( 9!(!""
%34
(!"6! ";
! ! !<
(
9)(* ((" ! !3"4 *"!4
%!(#
"(!%* %
(!"6! !
%* $"! / 2% !!)!
+% %
(!"
6! #9 ( !%""9
>/ 2 (! %! !3"4
$ 3! "
! 9 ! 0!("4 (! %
E !3"4 "!
*" F 1+
!% ! <#
!() 4%!"
(
(!"
6! )< !4 !
% #
!("!"49 %(
!3"4!<!"!3"
(
""! ! %!((
!( %*"!4
@ )) ) !% ! %!(
!() 4* ( !(!""4 !
% (3!
%
(!"6!
"
,! G%D"
"
%$!!"4
!49! #'GH+D#
""!
%
* ! * %!<
.
!3 % !4 <
( 9 !
""! 9! %% ) %* IJ !"
K / "
42F! %!((
!( % # 9""3 *
""!9! 4(!"
* !"( ! % )
! !" !!;
"!(
"
.+1/!2%J !" "
% %
*) ! L 9 (! % !
!3"4
! ")%* !3!3"
#**! !"9 (! )<) !3"4
! ((
!!
("!
!% M!(< ! !
*!"
!( (
I$"!%(! % F !< 3
(3
!$ !
% N
!!)!
. !*!(
"
4! !" ( !) ") %* C !<
9! !%%
34!)#*!( )# ")
! ) (
# * 9"
!3"4 %
""! 3 ! (!!"
( (9 (
#!
3483"
$% !"#$# %#&$ #&'()! !/ )# , %3#%,#!4%%( <) *
#9 !
) *
0!*!! % M (! 9! % %#3 L "4 %% )! !3"4#
% %
34 ! * 9"
! !3"4%%
!3!3"
"!4
<!
!!% C / !2! !
>.
64 %!
!"
""!/2 ! L #9 #! < !"#9
, !
!!) !) %
!! (* % % )!) #%%
3 %% ) %* * !3"4 9 ( !3!3"
!))!<!
34 #
)!
%% )%%%
!3"4
5
""!/2 9"
( !# 3! % $("!
'/+2MGBM/
$2
34 4% % # J< * % !#
1'
-'
+--'# !% !
%*!
!<!"!3"
"4!*
"9 <!"
% #! !4 (! )4 % *
(
!3<
, @ !< "
! "
@
!4 *
C /2!
/2! !""
!" 9 (
! ((
% )%%%
! *
#9
! (
*!"% *! 9""3 !;
%34 ) $!9 ""!34 53!" )!)!
! " %
3 *#%!4#9 ! ) )!
!3
!3"
! %"!9 !<)3
34 83"
$% !* ) + $),$#-.!(! !2! / / !2
)< 9 %!(! ((*!( !9 ""!
* ) + $),$#-.! (! / !2! / ).! (! !2#( ! % (#
'9!*
(!""4 0!*
! 9!% %!""
( 9!"4 ) #
'9!% %% ) %*
5 !3 )# ! !3"4 !3 !3
!
%
(!"6! (!!;
!9!4 ) %
'("!*
!#34 !3"4%*1-:,-:!
/ !2
!)* !3
!
'-
# !3 %!4
< 43 )
*
12 3!% %!(
% "!9#
(( )"4# 9
*
'+
)!
"(!/2#%!4#!
%
0 ,) ,,1 0-.,,
1 454$ '/ @
!;)M !
@
!3"