Shruti Jain v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!"#" $% & &
' ()*+ " "$ ,
"
" $ * - *#+# (
*.
$ $/ ) *# , #0 $/ $ # 1% 231&( 1 (3
! "#$" ! %
&# '
! #
()*+ ,,, 1 (34 -./
%%)2%%+ 3 4 (+
.
& $" 56 7 8 %
00 %'
9% %90)
.
&$"56 7 8 - :- 3;/ 4 < = > " =
!
"#
$#
$
%
& '
"& & #
'(
)
*
+ ,-
* ,
%
.
&
'
/ "& & #
* , '(
" $ $1/-
0 /$$ ( 23 "#
# $#
'
4 "
= %?
9'
%90)=" 3;= == 4
= = =
= =
=
)? (?
3 %@ 9% %90@ = A6(
/&7
& !
2 /"
((7
!- &
87
/ 9 :1 ;
( 9
) < =
)> ?<1 @<?1 @AAB
:$
<C
/ 23
) ( @.
7 $"
<< @<?
0(7
) &
2"
$ 23
D
$$ 2
((
"% E1A1<C @E A@
((F
!-
D
$$ 2#
# ( "%
&
(
#$#
#7
7 $ 27 '
$
2( $
%#
$ ( ( "% G
0
4 "
$( $#
$ 2
! $1/-
0 #
$
0- <@7 <@H
/ /
$$ 4 $
"
:#1
1* , 2
# $
?
@A
@<=
"
' #
1* ,
"# &
"
23
( #
& &
"#
>" 1( >"
#I
$ &
>"
>"
*$ % &
%
2 "%$
"
2 ## /
&
( $ %(
5 "
:( & 4 $
'
#$ 7 #$ (
"%
'
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
'
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
'
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
<
8 (- % 2 %$$
&
1$ (
%
$ $ ( "%
8
$ ( $ " 2 $
2 # $
?
@A
@<=
0 4 #
$$
"% $
&
"2
#
$$
8 2# $
" & 23 $
$$ % "
#
#2 & $ $"(
81: % 2 $ 2&
((
$# "% $ $
'$
"% % 2 #$
/$1G
/ $
/&5
(
9B 9'
%90@
"
4 :!
2 F 1
= >- "/= =
'
?
9B 9'
%90@ ( # 3 " . 6 = )
= %'
9% %90)
%?
9'
%90) 1 09 %90@ 09 = %@ 9% %90@ = = 9B 9'
%90@ = = 1 %% 9'
%90@ 309 9( %90@ = =" 9( %90@ = 1
? = 09
= $ = =
= = = 3 K. Manjusree v. State of Andhra Pradesh and another, (2008) 3 SCC 512Tej Prakash Pathak and others v. Rajasthan High Court and others, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3184 " =" = ==" 1 3 6 0?
%90) Satish Kumar
Malik and others v. State of Haryana and others, CWP No.22746 of 2016 6 9'
9+ %9%' Harvinder Singh v. State of Punjab and others, CWP No.17436 of 2013 = =" = " = +
" =" "
09 %9%?
6 "$"= 3 = % C "
@
! ! = )? (?
=
4
= 2 = D" = 2 = = 4 " = = =* 09 %90@
4 = =
> < = 1 < < 3 "E " "
3 E 43F " E " " 43F E 1 = = < E * 1 09 %90@ @9 < *
09 = ? E 09 % %9 1 =" 3 = /
(( & $%
%#
# " ( $$ #
""G"
G** & 3 #( $
$"( <<1
:$ G
@
@<=
8 0-
<@@ 0-
$(
+
C@ 0- ! "(
0
?@ @K ?E EEK
=@ @K $ 2"
@C (- <@ (- <@H
?@ @K ?E EEK
=@ @K $ 2"
@C (- <@ (- >$
?@ @K ?E EEK
=@ @K $ 2" @C (- <@ (-
&
<@ (-
?@K $ 2" & %
07 <@H
$ >$ @C 0- =@K $ 2" & %
07 <@H
$ >$ <@ 0- 0F :#
%
=@K @A (-
(( =@ @K $
2" @?
(-
+ * , @A (- 0 6 1 @
(- 0 @A 0-
6 !
2
<@ (-
)1)"%
!
2 $
) $
9
"#
*/1*// (2
@
(-
) !
2 -7
2-
$ 9 %
*/1*// (2 G
8'
)
2-
2 $
2&
* 1
2
%
*/1*//
(2
@=1
(-
2
1 2 $
$$ -% $# 2$ " ( !
2 $
2&
* 1
2
%
*/1*//
(2
@
(-
23 ('( ( <@
(-
'
@?
(-
(- ( $ & '
"
$ 4 #
$ 4 $ '
#
$
23 ('( ( @?
(-
/
<@ (-
!
* "
#I$ 2&
*$
&(
@
(-
!
$
"
#I$
2&
*$
&(
@?
(-
! &(
"
#I$
2&
*$
&(
<@ (-
/ 23 ('( ( @?
(-
+
/ 23 ('( ( <@ (-
/ 23 ('( ( <@ (-
G "
@
(-
L
@
(-
LF
@< (-
/ 23 ('( ( @
(-
$ 2"
*"%
@ (-
8 "% % 2 $ $ #
$ $ # % % 2 #2
-% $#7 %7 #7 - %$
#2 + 7 ! 2#7 '7
7 + " 7 7 7
2"7 $ (-# + $
=" = = E =<
= E
=" 3 2
= 0%
6 5 E3K. Manjusree (supra) "
= = 1 E 6
% $ " 2 $ %
$ #7 2& $
(( ( (-
"%
8 (( ( (-
"% $ " 2 $$ 2& $
!$ #
: +
/ $#7 >$ **
* #$
7 $("
(( ( &
$$ " $ "#
8 "
$ $ 2" % & (( (
(- &
% '( $
'(
, " $
) $$
.
@@< $
<
@@
$ $ % %
$$ A@ <<
@@.
% & (( ( (-
% '( $
*"%
8 7 $ 4 ( (( (
(-
"%7
# % '( $ "% %
( $7 % $ ( ##
#( #( % &$ % &
((2
,
$ "% 2& "
$
*
( Ρ.Κ. Ramachandra Iyer v. Union of India, Umesh Chandra Shukla v. Union of India, and Durgacharan Misra v. State of Orissa
MMMM
MMMM
MMMM
A=
8
%"7 $ $ %
4 ( (( ( (- "% 2&
" % %$ $
% " % $$
% ( (# $
"$
) $$ A@ <<
@@.
$("
(( $ $$$
# % '(
$ "% $ " $ $ %
4 ( (( ( (- "%7 %
$
(# $$7 % % $
% 2 #2 $ 2
8 7 % $
"# ( 2& $# (( (
# (-
"% % ((2
0'
35 Tej Prakash Pathak v. High Court of Rajasthan 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3184
K Manjusree (supra) ="= 3 =?
,7 7 %
%# (
=?
<
) ( ((
(
$"( #
$ $ %
#
"N
=?
#2 &
2# $
7 $ ((( (
7 2 #$ ($%& #
(
' ) (7
$"(7 % &
' ) 7 (
" #
(2
$
'
)
$"(7 # % $ " (
4 ( <.
$
& G2N
=?
8 $ K. Manjusree K. Manjusree v.
State of A.P., (2008) 3 SCC 512 & $% #$ %
$ % $ / 2
$ 0% [State of Haryana v. Subash Chander Marwaha, (1974) 3 SCC 220 / 2
$ 0% [State of Haryana v. Subash Chander Marwaha, (1974) 3 SCC 220] $ %
# 2 $
( % ;
03 [K. Manjusree v. State of A.P., (2008) 3 SCC 512] $ % # 2 $
8 % $ % #
$
N
=?
.
) # 2$7 23 ' ) 7
(& $" $
2##
( # $ "$$
$
$$
7
G $(&1G2& $ '
23 # 2 "$N
=?
?
' ) "# &
2$#
# 2$& 2 ( $ $
#2 &
%"7 % G'
7 $(" (&
#N
=?
=
! ( #" $ 2
# (
8 / ( &
2
$ (&
"
%"7 " '7 /
( & 2 & $& (
% I $
0(
=" =
= > = < = D"
<== 4 3 4-434/4 3F 4-43F/ "
= 343F 3< E " 43F < E " 1
5 "= = " "= ="3243F
= 1
= =
= = = =
=
= " = $ =
= = 3 = " "=" = < 4 = 1 " = < 1 6 " = " = 4 = 09 =
343F ="
' = " " " 0?
= 1
=="" :"; = 3 <
" :"; =
< 2 "
= 4 "
= 4 = = = " ==" 0)
5 3Sivanandan C.T. and Others v. High Court of Kerala and Others, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 994
6
="$ 3 = =
"
" " E " E 4 G = E 6
E 6 =@
8
%# "%
2" $
8 #$ $( 4
$ 2 ( %$
&7 &7 $ $2 &
"$ 2# ($ 2& $ " "
<.N
$"$ % ( 2 (
2$ $ 2" #(
' 2
%#
#(& 'N $ $
#( ' $ "
<.N
2 & ( 23" & $( 2&
# " ( 2
$ % 2
(
#( 'N
"
8 $ #
; &
(( ( G
"" " '(
& )
<E=< )
"
8 #
O $ & (( (
G
(-
"" "
2" #( '
8 $ 2& $ " " <.
" * ( % $ % $ 2
& 2 $ $
# $ /"
( '
&
$$ % "
2 $ & '
& # 2
$
8& % $ $ " 2 "#
$ $&
# (
# % $ 2 & 2
8 $
% $ 2 2# % $$
% $# $
# (
8 $" $ I
2 '$ $
% $ 2 2
0+
> = 3
" =" 4 = 4
3 6 "<" $ " = = 3 = 0@
4 =* 6
3 3 = = = " 71 (38
& &
' 0 ;
(
2 H = H