Mangal Singh v. Punjab State Warehousing Corporation & ANR

 
 


 
  

 !" # $!"% &'$'$(!&) *&)+,+ %&,!- . ' '& )&%(,+$!"
()/() '$(! !0 !('%&) &+/(!0&!'+
 12 



   

      




 

                    !

 " ! #!

 $%

'()!
*

+ , $- .  . ,  / 0     ! !  10  
!  ,  !,

 
! . 2 ! 3 ( 

43 5+

$

6           ! !,7      $  ()! 
*9+       !  ",  "

         !   
8&&&&&-* ! !,

     !0   
8&&&&&-*      0    

,    !  0"!   , :&; ,0

,

'

        '

$  0 00  ,   ! !,7 <   0! 
8&&&&&-* " 0   :

.! ,                       *  

0

==8" -      0      ,  "  >  !

  
8&&&&&-*"

!,0  ?"   !  > !

"

>,3

@"0  !0 !#!

       >  !

 

    *    !"

,   

3!

3  "

! ,   3! .A
  .!0  3! 

       3!  "

   0

 0   )! )!

3 ,
8&&&&&-*   3       ,  !

           0     !    >

!

<)! 3!     "

0         $'

$&&9  ,  <)!  3!



    "

 ,

  "

  

      )!    @"      "

0  ,        3!         

&B & !   

 :*.! .  ! ,

 -3

 "

 3!, 3    <)! 3!   3!    "  "

  "         &= &'

()!
* 8+ ? &

&B &  3! "

  *     3 7        

/ ! "

     &= &'

 ,3!  "
   

  

 

                            

       

    

 

           

 

  ! "# $  %

@"          .  .

" 

" * = &% &()!
*

'+" "  

3
'

'() !  

 

*+ ,   * -                 !   

  

 

   ! 

!

  

$     

 

  

   +  ./         !

      !% %

     , *   !0       3!     "   

0  <#!,?!0 =

()!
*B+)     ! !
012$     



   

  /+34 $($    



 ! 

-  

          !   

(!  

     

       5 

           



$6 &  

+ ./   !

$6  !      !

  !   7    % =

"      

  /     3 0!

 $()!
*

4 9+""#!, C   , "

     , 0! 
8 0

  0!

 ,  ,#!, =

()!
*B+

"  !#!  $$

$()!
*%+ ", "!, 

 /      3   ,     ,       

&'

$()!
*=+."3 ! 
 ,."3 !        ! .

  !0       !  3 >      .  !>" @     0  $&

9"0,3         &9 &9 &  $& &9 &    &8

$&&9

      /  

 
!   .   2 ! 3   0  3      00!   " !,    

,0" ,/ 3

$

   ""

  0    0   !        

 "

" , *

'

@!  !  0 ,

     C"

 ,     "

 "!0  ,    !

:

C  !

    ,                       !               !     *3  C  0           !

!,7 $()!
*9+  

  !,7()!
*

+ !

!,    

  0                 0         

",0 "  > , 

 /@      , D! ,!00"

    C ,  0 ! 3  !,        3!>    /  @   ,  !!  0  !    "

         ,    3  E!          3      !    *  !    

    /@  !     0   "3  3!,"

, 3  %:$B$& &    

5 , / ! 



  ,"

   !/@ ! !       <)!  3!   "  0 

 "

,    "3  !/@ )! C 0 " "!  

0     "

   *       ,  ,  "

0

A                       @ 3!      #!           3!    

/    .  !  

 

  "        0 3  B  "!00 3!        " .

0 .!00 .C# .      $% &$ $ (,    !00  "

)!:+ $

.        -  . C# .  .  "

     $% &$ $

@     .  C#

.     "  "

 !   ..       "

  ! 0  (,  !00 "

 )!*8+

  '

.0   !"-C#

.  .0   !"

     $% &$ $

@  !   .  C#

.     "  "

 !      .   .0      !  "

!  0   (,   !00 "

 )!*B+ :

. 
    -   @ .  !   !00$:

&$ $ (,    !00  "

)!*9+

.0  1    "-   @ .  !   !00$:

&$ $ (,    !00   )!%+

. .

 -   @ .  !   !00$:

&$ $ (,    !00  "

)!=+

.     "   !00  

 ! !  !00       3! ! !  
8  0 

%

C"0,!     0!

   $%

'()!
*

+

! !,7 $()!
*9+ *   #! ,       " FB; !00 0!  !

!0

=

" " 0"  

67 

 8

  2 > -  G- 2  G-