High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3295/2008dismissed

Hisar Geeta Coop. House Building Soc. Hisar v. Suresh Kumar Etc.

2018-05-02Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar48 pages

! " !"# $!

% #$ !% &' &()% &* '+ & ! % &*

%& " , - .

* "

, /

0'1& .2

" , /

3'1' 1!

3&*!'** 4% !**!!1 %* *'5*!'&5 ** %6

!*! &1 !%'&!!1

** ' %%1 1 '+!*&

3 " , - .

* * 1 * +! * 1 **!*1 ' * 7 &! *5**% 81*% , , !&1**5 ***5!&*

'&%**1* *** ***"!' !/ 2 )! ', % , 0 -9 9-:

;% /9/:/2 ;%

:/2 ;% <:2 ;% 0:2 ;% 9 :/2 ;% -9 :/2 ;% /:2 ;%

:<2 ;

: 2.;% 6'& *!&!1 '&%1* 1=*&1 &!5= *1&2'=*&*'* =*"!- 2 ..

!1 '5 - 2 ..5 1 & * "!% ! %! '&%+%%"!%%,% 81 >*1&2* -9/%!-< 20?)*!=%! %!

'&%+%%"!%%,&

2 <2 ..

*-9/%!-< 20?)5! 1&5*&!/ 2

)%'*!''%! %8 1%'*

&*%''%! %81 %**! ''* 9/ 1&2!/ 2 )+!1*

3* -9/

'&%'1*!&!% &*** *%!1' 3&1 &1'* @&***!1* 1

7'** #*2 3 ! **+ 3%** *1* '&%1* %*!, / -

-2 .2 ..0-9/ *&%''&

'!11* 1 1! )!( * % *%*'*1*&! * 9/ > 1 * * '!(! 1+*!1 % %! %''1

' > " >.".*# >!%'& **2=* 9/ 7*% **'=&*"! =!

2 .2 ..*&*()*+,-.( */0123(+,0*)A* !/ 2 )** %- % 921 0 % 92

2 .2 ..!*=*! 3 *=*'*=*- 2 -2 ..

3** *"!=#'*

*&**!%! %, ! 3*% , !'1** *"! 7'*& , !' A( -2 .. 1 "+ ! *'&& *%'! 1!* %--% 92'1 "+ ! '

2 -2 .. !(** ! 7'* &7!3=*1 !% &'=1 # , ! 2 -2 .. ' &7!3=* *!&1 " *' 1='

*!**1 &

3 & 7! 3= * !!

3*% = 7 '& , !'1**A "&%*%*!'11 '&%!!**

3*' &%! % "+ ! '%

**# *&*, !&

2 -2 .. 1(*!

2 .2

'&% = ' **% ! &9 &*"!1 ! 3 7!3=* 02 /2 ..

3* =-9/!-0 20?) 3 ' =

2 <2 ..

*& * *9

3*%*2 & 1 *! 9/ * #**8 1 # *&* , !'&15* 3*#**'1= 9/'*&**

3 ***' 3* '*% 9/* **%*!*! ' &!/ 2 ) &!*''! 3(* *!*'$2

B**1 ' * *!/( ! !(',

(, (,

0 -9 9-:

2 ;% /9/:

2 ;%

:/2 ;% <:2 ;% 0:2 ;% 9 :/2 ;% -9 :/2 ;% /:2;%

:<2 ;%

: 2.; * +!1* ..

!, / - - .

..0% %3C>##

B!1

4 *!C># -

B*** C># /

B**1 ' *!*C>#

B&+ C># < B!1C># 0 B***1*!2+* C># B****=&!* 'C># .

"* 3&& #**1 #B 8#B

3** &!@= # @= #@@= # @= #

3* =!B B < >*B !%B B &' !' B

!2'==!&* **81! !@= @= <'& '&% '1!=*'&2 !5"+ !'=!'1% % 1!*!1 !*&

'5=!=!22*5'*2 =!1% %=

*&% *1 **%1 ! % !* 9/ %6%1

* 3!*

5 *&1 11& * >'%* 1 '**& + 3 &'**& 9/ @&!@= 0%!1 *& 9/ *** '**1 &1 %&!1 * 5@=0@= @= 5'!' 1 "+ ! ' !' ! 1 !

!'*& % "+ ! ' * ! 3&!' !

) 1%"+ ! '! 1 ' 5*5!(11* *

3 '( 3 1 *&*"+ ! ' "* @= *&** %' !@= 0"+ ! ' *&*&* *-9/ !&1=1 2 *&** (*&"+ !

' '&%*'"+ !

'!1***

3*1 *"+ !

' * * * *! & ! 9/ 1 **

! ! " * * * -2 * 3* * # 5 ! @= 0 9'@= @= '*

!'&&

7'% 1%&"+ ! ' 3* *-9/* 16 5 @=

* -2 *3**# ! 9/ 1** 3** ' **'!*!* '1 3 & +!1 * * 1*' '&' !*1 *

3' * & *1'* **%**& 9/ % '&& "+ ! ''1**

B '!**5' 1 @= 05!5"+ ! '&1***

,!1(!* 1' '1 "+ ! ''!

'*!* '1**

3 !1 1 !*!

16@= 5 !*& 1*51**5' & @= % ' ! & 3* 1 2 '( 3& D"+ ! '!' **D!!( !1*** &!1!

*&** %' #B & !5 '' * B < 516# ** % &"+ ! ' 'D!1***

'&% &!*

D"+ ! '1**

!!'** B !'!*&*

*'**B., !! *'&"+ ! 3' *&' !** %!"+ ! '* ! > %&*'5*% "+ ! '&1&

&* 1

3* *&

.. ***! 1!'* 1 ' *E&F!

&1*!*

5' "!' , !%# * **!!'* ** * 3**** 3 & , * ..

& .. *E&F! , !'D ' 4 **% ''*%'& % 3*%'!1 'E >F: >2* "!;& >, * ..

1*%''!

E&"&F1 3! &"&*1 %9*% *, !%*# % ' '' % * %!'1 ,* ! '&1

*!% *1 * '*1 !'! * 3 "*** % ' ' 5''*1 ***+!

' '* ' * , 5''***,

0 '+'* 4&!

@= 0!**+'* 316 =*@= 1**1!' =1 , !'** #

*&*, ! 4!%!@= . @= &****1!'!1

, ! " -2 *3**#

%' '&1* %&'**'' !1'*** * &'** !' &"+ !*

3 1& * 9/ !

!** '"+ ! '% %**

* 1 ' ! 1 A'

&**!+!1 *1 *

B!5&>

2 02

.%*'16*''*!1 $2 B*2 *!*!@= 0

2 .2 ..5 (&'*-9/** "! & & -2 <2 ..

G B * 1!!*1!!

5'***!*!@= 05 &**!'16% !* *#5*161 1 2+

*# 3'&1! 1&11111 **%&! *

*#5'!*2+

'!!1 !% 1!&*

*#=& 3 1**2+1 5 * 3*16 * 1 1 ' ! 3+!*F1 ! 556 7 4&(* 8*++(3(9++(01 " +!*!6

47' 4&(* -(1((:(8*++;;120(!(1 (<*+=(10+(01(12 ,*+%1!2+ &&1'%1&'* 1 &*

# =&%2+11 &*% % *

#1 +!*H1! '& (>(2,>(1,+(;(12,*+8*++.*()01*90(12(1,* * 2+%1 1 *&&1' 51 &

*!*&*!!!

3(!*%* 1! * * *! * 1&2 !56***5 1*1 &"+ ! '%&1 11'&1 ****

3!*&#*11*% 1!&='

#1' 3+!* = 674 '&0(1=(0/01(>(=(*.?;* (12(1,*8*++!**1(:+,0..(; (12,*+

'67 & ,008(;(+( *!0;;+8*++ *3(*.*11! &1**&%6 61 &111 31! 11'!!&%''1 * 1'&!*+!% '=!1!&!=1 !1 3!11 *&1 1 *** 3*& 1& 11** *!

1'%16% &&D%* % *1'5 6 '&*+ !+!

* !5 * %%!*!

' '"+ ! ''D1 1*'"+ ! '& *5!5 *

3*%! 1"+ ! ''1*** 5 !** !@= 02!

..%@= .27!3= 02 /2 ..

%@= 2 * ! -2 .. % @= .2 * ! !*&%@= 2!*=*! (*7!3= 2 -2 .. @=

2 <2 ..

*-9/ *&**

"*!%1!*

* * !% '

4& ''#*

"+ !'!!1** !* !*& %!*&*"+ ! '% %61*&* *

4!* &*!*!!1 'B 2 !% B2 % B 2& !% B

!!*'& '!!'1 "+ ! '1*** * *'&* ! 31! 1'&'' *! & &

76 1! **1'16 !&* *&'* 3*%&& 1 1 1 6 !* % !!*!1' *6 "+ ! '' 1***

3* ' ** 1 26!*&

*7 %1 8 !11!1''6

+!6 '74 4&--,(.(8*++0=, *;,0(12,*3*+!* !6

5745 &!(1) ,(0((12(1,*8*++*3 *;,0!10<0?(;1<0;6 1& &* 3+!*! :

76 7455&0*+,*3(0(12(1,*8*++ (* *(2*+,(12,*1!1 !'1 **!& ''(*16 6!!!* '** 1=*&** % *%**1!( *'!!*6 !2* *%"+ ! ' !1***2 5'* ''&*"+ ! A**

4 '&*5*5 & -2 *3**#

*1 ***+ 7 1!1 ** & 1!1 **1 &* '&(* *** 3*1!*&

*1(*1 1'1 & !*! 3&* ! &'& * 3 ! *'11 1'

3 &**&** 3+!*! 6

'7 5 & 01=* 120( $2 /*++ ,(12* !,(1 ,(2,((12,*+ **&1 (* 31! !'1 "+ ! ' ' 11** **=* 3*!1 **(*5 !-9/ 1=*& ** 51 2&*! %"+ ! ''!*

3*% 1&1 ** -2 *3**# 3* !&

71! 1 ** !& 3 ** &

5 !1!1

3 ** ' @= < '*/ 2 ) % 11

**(1 **1 ( 1!&*'

% & * -2 * 1 6 * &1&& **2

3+!*! 474 &,(0;*+,,(0>(3(18*++!,(1 (;-0+,1($;;( =1*&& &&11**& 4 !% +!*! 6 47'5 0<,(,(.(8*++(* ,,(0+=(,(12 ,*6 47 $(1<1?((3*$0.0*28*++(*

*(2*+,(12,* '&%'!* *2+ !1 ! !&111 *&1**5&1&

*!@= 0 7%!* **&11 2+= B *1* -2 *3**# % *** ' E!F&!%*2 !EF&%!"+ !

" ! * 9**!* 7 5'!2***+* 7*% % 11!1 6 !1 !1 ! 71 H**&6 9/

@&!5& & 1 * 5*!***6 9/ 3* &!'& '*&' * -9/ +* &1

*' *1 ** 1 11'

3'% & 3**11* '%* &! 1'*11*' 7*' '*1'1

#1' !!' 3%*%*! *6 5'**'

@&** * !!"+ ! '5* ***!'! '*11*' 3* 11

''*+611*' 3 &! & *1 &1** "!** * #2+

:7 ;*#% *%' +!*! 6

7 4&(01(;1+0* !*1(;*(;,@* <0*1<*+8*++((.*+,3((& *&( #1**& '2+16%''*1+ ! 1 ! % 1! #'! *' !!! 4!&& '11 ! ! ! **2+ 5*2 +%*&1* 1* '*1 ** 3*%** #*

#&1 3&& 1 1 *

7 * * * *!5"+ ! '** ***5'**1 ** * ! !! 3* & ' ! ! * ' "+ !

' 3 '!! ''"+ ! '%# !*

'!1 "+ ! '&' (1 "+ ! 3 &"+ ! ''1* 3 & &'**"+ !

'*!6 > % * !* &1 ' & 3 **1 "+ ! ' *1 '* "+ ! ' ' ! %6

)&% *"+ ! '* -9/*=*&** 1 '* 9/ % &!*' * 1 1! 5 !! 3 !

6 9/ 3 '* * *!% ! 1 &

%+!*F1

=6 74 '&0(1=(0/01(>(=(*.?;*(12(1,* /*++!**1(:+,0..(;(12,*+ 1

#*2 +1&( " !%* *9* *

.. %9**! % 1*!

2 .2 ..1**

!%1*&5! * 1* *!

'* .. 9**!('** 5 !%&'!* # ***&! 2 -2

.. * 3 & ' 1 ** 3 ' ' .. *& * **# '' * # , ! ' 1**** 3 '!*** 3 *'&1 &+!

>''&"& *!3% '!!*%* !* 2 -2 ..- %*

! 1*!

2 .2

.. 1 # , ! ** 16 *&1 !!*&5

7*1 ** **('**!1 * ****+ .. 5 =A"*"!5!*! * ,

1*!!

2 .2 ..

3 ' ../2***' *! * !1 ,*'*

%*9 ' % 2***=

2 <2

6-9/1*!

2 .2 ..%& 9/ ***1 % **&& (* 9/ "! *'1

* 9* % * 1!!*'=!1 * & !' 1** &*1!' * ! B < % "+ ! '* !'& &!1 ' D!!1* 3'

! 5 1 "+ ! '! *!* ' !

3' & '&"+ ! * "+ !&

%! **

"!** 6* -2 %3**# %* * !**9 !EF& !E!F&"+ ! '%'&5&**'(!6

*E!F&* !5"+ ! '5& !'

71!!* *!!&1 *&* ** !!&1

%*&* ! 92& 6& 1= 3! +!*! 5 & ,(1+,(.2(+(12,*+/*++;;*< !(2(+ 7% =1 &"+ !

'*&**

%!1 "+ ! ' *1!' 61 & -2 *3* *# *1 > &! * -2 *3* *# 3! +! *! 6

'74'&(.9,( (.2*()*8*++((1 (?)0,(6*(27,=,$+ !*& 6 %*1!' *&*'%6 1&(( '

7**1''6 %& *! 3!+! *!

56'76080;7 &,08-.(,(.( /*++(1+,-.(0 &* '1%*

' **% * !(**** *&*9*

3&!!1 *!& * *1 1'9*

%16*'*!!*!* 2* *!

# (1 2*5 1'5'****!1

"+ ! '%'(' & 1* !*2*%*%' **'!!%&

& E@6 F&*2* 1!6 =&&& 1**& 4 %* 6 &'* **! %!*6* % 6 1 1!*'6 %1 1'1& 3 % 1&'&&* 1&&!*6 % ** %'1!& * &D*E6 F+ *

@6 1*+*! F 1 +%''1&1*E& >F ) !*& 6 ' !&*!

!!11 **6

B'*=*'* %'1* +5' 36!* D*E F1 F +,1 %7 ' (' E!(F & ! ! ! '( !(*@5 *@6 * &8*#*!+ 6 !'+9&& !

*5'* 1 5!*6

1**&% '6 'E4*F

31&*D*1* + % 6! * * EA'F *E@6 F

!!*)&'5&

!1&*D!1 !*E#'F%E4!F EF55!& ''* %&*E! 7 ! %EB*#F' !

EB*#F * 3EB*#F* EBF** "*EBF* D* %IB*#F!!2

4 !1 3*&*!*1 ! * &% EF'*&!& 3! *!*! !**E"1F'& !&1&1 !&

"1! '( & ' !( & & ' & *! 1 ! 5*EB*#F @& 1 &1 *!' E"*A'F 1 * "1!

7 7 5 ' %E"*A'F111** *71 F1!*7 -*+3(1(12

,(0<(+* %1&71&1 E" *A'FE'F1*!!' *7

) 1 !E"*A'F% ' '6 C3'*E,F 6 + *!1* +C '*E,F B'&EA'F '*& *6

B&' 1 &*EB*#F

3'&*E**!& 6F=!* ,E6 F '&!* 1** & *1(' *!!'1 & EB*#F* !'**611*

5 61' , E@6 FE@61 1 * "F ! 3 *! ! & *** 3*%E'F' ! 11E6 7 7 ! '& 6 ! 1+51* ' * 3 * "* % #& ' * !%&#*! &*! 7 %*@&!*' *&(@!#!!*=!* *6

'*'E6 F&

!7 !%!%'= &1

36 '%'&&**'!

1 3111 A!=!E

F ' ! EA' % 1 'F 4 % =6

575

4&-(.,(12(1 /*++(* -*(;(6 =*

1! 7!&%F1 =6 7

'&(* (:,(12/*++<,(1(,:;((12 6 !'1' '&7 !&E6 F1 =*B+*+ &51*'61' '5&& !*&(6 5 !&''*&= ***6 *!

*&*5'='

=* 3' 1 F1! 6 57 4 & +,:( /*++ 108*+0> =0<;(;<0*1<*+@ 'F1 = 6 '' 1 A'61 ' * 6

'&% 6 1 ! '

%6 *% A'1! !&1 "*A'

3A' & '66 1 6!*6 ** !!*='

"**%* !!1 1'

111'* !**&'!!1 *' '!*1&2 *'&&6 % 'A' 51&1 *' &1*& 3*% +!1 1'1 '

3'+!1*&1 *!+%1

3*%+!1 1' 11& 11'*' !6 %&111 3 ' 1& ! 1 F1 !+!1 * '&%*+! ''&

*!1&! * *'!1*& E6 3**1* *! **2*' 6 '!('&

>'%!** 9* 1 & * * * 1 3* *!* *9** * &! 1'*11* ' ,'&!&1 * * 11*' ,'%211*1 !1(*6 * ! 4%'*1 '1 ='

# 1'!!' 3%* %*!*6 5' **' 3 *' ***!51***' '*'& * 6& *!1 *** =&** @& ** * !!"+ ! '5** **!'! ' *1'1' )

11'&!!*

' *! 11*' 7* '1!!!* 1!*! *' **%611 *%1 1 ''*+ 611*' 3* 1! & !

&*1 &1** 111 )1 ****& * J!*+2** &('*&&* 1& *!**9 * 61 *

*#!2 +%* ( ! * ! ' * ! 2+ 5 !1 % 5 !!&1115 *!&1** 9*****& 11 2+= 3!* *&'***2+% % >'%* %*!*6 5' **'%** *

*# 3*

&( 1**& '2+16 % #' ! *'!! !&&'1 !

! !**2+

5*2+*& 1* 1* ' *1 ** 3*%* * #*

#= 3 * &&11 *

7** **!5"+ ! '** ***5'**1

**% * !!! 3* & '!!* '"+ !

' 3 &"+ !

''1* &' **"+ ! '* !6******! > %* &* &1 ' ' & 5'5%!& *1 "+ ! ' ' "+ ! ' ' ! % 6

)&%* "+ ! '%1&*!5

*-9/ *=*&* * 1 % 9/ &!*'* 1 1! 5 !! 3 ! 6 9/ 3 ' ***!%!1 &

1 *2+ 1& = 3!**9* 2+1&**

# 51*2+1 *5* 16*J* *&' *2+11 **5&!!'% '&%1*

*#5'* 1*!*@=5 !&1EK F1 *!*'

!1 &*! *!*

#5 * 1 * 5'1+!' %1 1**#'

*& &%(! *''11 !1( !

!' 1 +*

6 1*'

%'& *! !' ( 1* 7*

' ! ' 1'&1(&('* &'***2+1

*#%1 51(2*1

*!EK F 3* F1!*7 467

4&10(-+,3(,( 8*+++,(?2(1%* =!! * D% E 8F*!5 1**1 1

* *7 7$2 &*!!1& &'L*L

*1!* 9*% '

+1 1* *% ' D1*

**7

7*L*L! * 11 *!(*'&%+ 1**L+L' **6 *!*( +*&'**

B&%*%

' +***

* B + ! ' 1 * * / * % ' 6 1*'6*' D12D B 1 6 1*'6*'! !*=&* '

7!&1 1*1+ *'' +! 3DH1 + !!& *!*11 * /1 6 1*''6*'

1* + !!6 * !!% %1& (**!*6 1*' 6*'*!( 1 *6 1*'6 *'!

*%+1 1* / ' 3*%!( 1! *E 8F! ! D !2' 1 = =

6 *& *+! !*+= & '1**&'

#!'! =E 8F 7+&

=**%* %*1 *+ 3!* 1**!E +F* =1 &'!+ 3 + &!* ' ' 1 D**!*D !=!!!1&!

. * # 1 & & +&&&= ' = 1 ' = 1 ! * F1 !E 8F1*! 5=*.*#1 '!1

*#'* !*=&=E 8F 3 !'('& &&1&!!D ***!*E 8FD 7 !& !=*E 8F1 '1&D1 1*

**2+1=

*& 11 (1 =!*!* +5 * 1 * * % ' *

4 *!*D1!1*1

7&'*1&F* * !**9* 6 *9**11 !!*!* *2+

*9* +!!* *2+ '&%+!1 *''! 7*+! '2+11 &***&* **** )&! **2+1 '* &*2+!! '11 2+@=

# 3**!' *9* !

'* !* '*1 ' * *1 9**'!1 3 * *!* 611** +*5' **1& 7%***6

9/&11 @&!

5 & 1 ** '6 9/ @&=1 !29&*"!6-9/ *&* '**'6 ! 9/ @&*1 &"+ !

'*****! & 9/ *** ***6 9/ 1 8**! &1 * '!1 -9/ 3! 9/ !' ** #*'' 3 &! *'& * 9/***'1 1 !(! & !* 51&1 &6! 9/ *** %*1 ***1 ' * 6 9/ * !!1 3 *1 1'***!

3!**9* &*!% "+ !

'!1*** 5 '* ''&* "+ !** '& *5*5 & -2 *3**# %11

1 + 4 * ! & & *&* -2 *3**# &$2

A(?* .(1<* B **

!!&1 1 '1 !1**!

'! *1 '1 % *%*!*%( * *%*%1 %*!* !**% **!'*!* %%'MN!O%' !**%*1! !1*1 '*!1*% * !!11*! **!!

* *'*( %= &1 !*$ #&*** **'** *!*

1*1&2&!(

-2 *3**# &16

**!!* * '! '&6 !1 1 1

!5'6*!* 1 E*FE! !F *1 1 *!!!* '!1 !

1& * 9 * & * * 1 '! ! &'

! *!

&'&!6%! % "+ ! ''&6D1 * !* '&&*1 16

5' !1* -2 59* %**% ** !%&**! %* *! *!*' %'1' 4'1* -2 *3** # % ** * !* E!F *!%9* ! EF *% ! "+ !

' 3F1! 6

'74'&(.9(, (.2*()*8*++((>(1 (?)0,(6*(27,=,$+& -2 *3**# ' ** 3*!!1 '*

6 ! ==****' ! ! * 3 * &1 -2 * !!

7*** !'& * * 3'+!* F1!1** *1 11 !

! 6 % 1+ * ! % '! *!* 11E!F* **1% '%**6

@=%

'& !*'

&*! -2 *3**# % ! ' & * ' * -2 *3* *# ,'%=61'

' 111* !6 36 1' 9* 1 11'

1&%&*9* ! ! & 1 * 9* E*F! 3!( '** %= 1 *!%! %"+ ! '% ****!9 **56& !*& ! 5&

7! "+ ! '&* ! ' ! 3 &!& &*"

*1*" &( *!

*% **9* * !6 4* *!* **& *1( *1 1'1 &!* !1 * ! &1 ! *''& * 1'* ** 3* 1'&!!

1 '!(*'

' *1* 7' 1 1'&'! -2 * 3**# %D '! ! ".

*@& = &!*'!!** =!* 3$2 .

@& * ! * % * *!*!$2 B!*%*%* * %&1*!* !%' !61

'1*!*!%

% &* ' &!1& 1*

2B1**61 '1 '%'' **%'1 ' 1&

2BM!1M7OO! 1 &1 1

236 ' %* * !'

' !!

2B!% 1&

@=- 23!% !'&% ***% !*&!*

, %@& = & = !1 !!** *

.-* $2 .- @=*&=!!1 !$2 B ! % *% !1*&%&! 1&** '''! *

;;+(01+ :; '%*L %

% L @&1&''' 1&

:1; 1( @&1&* *' ''' '!1* 7*!1* -2 * 3**# %'!!

%1 '** '& &!=* *'! 1 *2 ' *

'' !6**"+ ! ' *%* * 1 11'9* & &1 &

3*%* *&1

( 7 9* ' &D"+ ! '1* !'**'&16 & *!1**

% !%"+ ! '11 1** '!' ** > %' *!1!! *"+ !

'! 6' **5* ***! 1*&*!

7 '1 * '*! &11 *

5'5"!

:****;'&!%'

%!'' ''*** 3*% * *&'! >%! 61*"!*% **1!'* %*1 ' *! , *

' 1* K! %' ( 1 * % ''* ***, !% '=!'!5*

&611 !* %

1 !6' 1* 4*1&2 %'' (&%* !6 1&& * 1 **9

@6 ! 16 *(6

@&1 * &%&* '

*"+ ! ''1** %*

4 % & = *! 1 ! * 1&2 &*@& %&*&( *%

7! %!* ' =!1 * & !'1** &* ! *! B < %"+ ! '* '!%'&%!1 ' D!!1* 3 ' ! 5 1 "+ !

'!*!* ' !

'4 3'& '& "+ !* "+ !&

)&%!

"+ ! '!*

1 *"+ ! '

****!*!!& %'&!* '

%! **

,=!**% 6!-9/ *! !'=*&*9* %*% '!6'=1** % %1 E6 F&'*%! 1&11** *1 E6 F% -2 *3**# %1 ** 2' * 3!!1 E6 F'E6 F! 1 3 !*1'

3*1 *! =**% * %*%=**%* !'*6 *1

3**61 1 1 (E6 F%1 %1 * 31' *1

*!66

!%6 1*%1

'5 '&1 = * ' ! ! * -2 *3**# 1& 1&%*1E6 F'&6 ** !% '** ,*=** !11 *6 5*1 +! *F1!* (.9(,(.2*()*6?(7

1*E6 F1 1 ( E6 F

%**1' !** * ! +!% '& 1&!1 +!1&

,*+! ''& 111 1 (E6 F !*! *=*6-9/ * !!!1 2*&* %** !6 &=*& *&* =! @& *"* 1&! =*&* 3!* 1*!!1* 4'&%"+ ! '%!&* * 6-9/6= *&*

'&% &

' !66 9/&&'

****!6&& '!&

>'5 +!*F1!* (.9(, (.2*()*6?(7%!1 * ! -2 *3**# 3 !1!!5!*=* ! 7 %* 1** E! F*"+ ! ' ( *! * =6!-9/ % !

& 1 * 9**1'=1 # ' *& 1''1 ** @& =, !*' # * 2**'* 2 ,!

7&'*1&%*!%! %*%!+!1 1'

! & +8

B(9P9,

B1CP9,