High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25069/2015disposed of

M/S Indian Oil Corp Ltd v. Chandigarh Administration And ORS

2016-01-19Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih4 pages

!"# $ %#&' ($"

$! )*' +% ,% ./0.'+/1& '/+ 12. 3%'.+,4'''% )% %05-%67

8'/' .% +0%.+9 '% ./0.'2&%1% ',% +.'

' ( )

)%.%:% 42 +&%6. ) '.'.;%,4+&%4#., ) %3'.)% /:%4+&%4#', '

$< ) / % 42 +&%6. ) %9% 2.%9%4+&%4#', = >>>> ., .%'&.% 0+% ++%+ "

$,%''+ ?1 ',

% + < &4 % ',4

14 .% +0%. % + ' % )% %04 .% +0%. % ',

+%3 04 .% +0%. %&&, 0 . @/% # .%% /9 ,% -+ 5 -7A', = ., .%'%''/0.% ++& $ < % . & %& # . '/,,1 # 0. 2,+ '527*2A8 '#%/

$<%++''+% 1., A +% ,% -+ 5 -74 ', =A.%% /9 ,% -+ 5 -7 % + /9 ,% -+ 5 -7 @/' 0 .9 9% ', $ < . % # 2*2587 . #9% %%&.+ % '%+ & % 06. .

& '% +9'% '

.'6%'4.#4 % , + %'.@/% '6@/'+ 1#9..0 9 &9,% '4

%914, A -4', =A -% + - < ,A?+9 06%'.+ = "

$6.&.6%'% ++ ?1%.,%'& & + 1.9 04., 4', = + - 6 @/'+ @/ . %' # . '%+ ,+/&' . ,'&?+,#9%%%+1'/?9+.9% +@/.%' % '%+ ,% 06..9'% '+/1'0 +%'%0+ /, .9 '&++?1%+%+ B "

$%++''+?1 $ < . , 4 ', = % + -4 . 9'% '6%'%+9+1#/ '.+.,%'

.'6%'

= ', . '%94 ', = '/?9+ ' @/% %' ,'+%+$ "

+9+14.'@/% 6%' %',. '%+9'% '+'&/''+% +%0+ .9 0.+ = "

$ <4 .64 & + .% .%# = #%&%0+.%'# &%?+6/+? .9' '',/%+ .+%+ B "

$6.&.%'#+ .'%+9'% '

?.%##.', '4% &6%' ,%&+ ,%%0%,.'A$C % + $" # . , & + .% .' ' %+9+?1., '# 6#.,/,'#.':/+09 ,'/9 .% ? ' .% 4 . ,&'' %+,+ ?1 ', '

$<6%'/ #%., % +,?%?1 .

/9,% 6%''/9.%&% '&/'% +' % + . %''''9 # ?+' , +' + %,,1 % ,&'' '/&. %' .' 6. @/% ' % + #9 ',&#& &,% '*?++'

64 '/&.&%''4.,&''9/'?#% .'&%'4 #.?++' ', =6%',9+&.% 0

'?+%#%.?+'6, + =4.#4.%+. ? # # ' 0 . , D' ?+ %&&+ 01 &.% 0+ ' ?+ ?1 %&&, 0.9'% '6.&./0..%+ .#' '% &

.' +/?.%.?+'/?9+ $ "

$6%' & #91 6. . 9' % + & ' /, 6.&. . ?+' 6 +4 %914 .' %0+ /, . 9 0 # = "

$ % + %' &++ .'%++%+ B "

8%% '%'.%+.# &% 9,&% '

6 %''/9 .% % ,&'' '/&. %' .' 6%'

&''%1 # ', $ < :& . =. ', D' ?+ %' ? A', ' 64%'#.%9/'?'/0. #%/#. , .%'./+%'.%? ,9+0%&9, 0?+ .#%/+'6/+%+ :/'&., #', = 6%' 0 % ,,/ 1 # &.% 0 0 ' ?+ 6.&. .%+ # &% 9,&% '4 %# ' 0 . , D' ?+ . , 6%' %##++.'%9,,/ 1 .%6%+#63 #%/#', ='4.#4%??'A%'+ !

=& +'.%.%'%%+1', % %9/ #! %&' ' 0/,. #%'/&/,/'/% .63%6%++ '#%/ ''/?9+.%.'//0. 4.#4E&'' E%+ %1:/'+& ., D'#%/ . ' % &% % '6 .'

-% + ' &/ ' %,,% 0 ?.%##., %3 0 '/& ''%+.%. , 6/+ ? 6 0 %3 % . 63' % + ,%1 # . '%9 2& +14., .%'%0+% +/ +%3 9%&..%' ++?1', = .#'.?++ 0,&''

6#.'4

#.', '%%+'1%##&+

.&&/9'% &'4., '+','+#?1,%'' 0. #6 0+(A 7 .%6%+#63 #%/#', ='@/%'.+% + 'A%'+ 7

$<%%?1 #'.?+'#9 . . &,% '4 %914 . , A +% ,% -+ 4 =A.%%

/9 ,% % + /9,% 7 ./ +%3 0 ?.%##., .%6%%' 9%&..# &%?+#', = .%0+9' ''%&&,+% +''++ 7 ., D'/ +%3 0%3.63'&%+/ ?1', =% +,%1#.'%9 . # ? 0%6%++.63'%&&,+ 7 . #'. + ,&'' ' &9,+4 . 9 + +%+$B

$'.%& / 52 8F 7 2 $"

$! 5

--7 G% +D