← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5100/2010disposed of

Mukesh & ORS. v. Parmod Kumar & ORS.

2025-11-03Mr. Justice Parmod Goyal14 pages



           

       

 !

" #$%% &'( ) (% %%% **

( +(( & '& ) (% %%%( 

(  &  (

 (,* %%% **

( +-(

,

  ((  &  * &

   ( %%%( 

( &#  .* &% (

 & * 

  

 

   !""#""$

 %&'( 

 

   !)###""$

 %*'

 

  + ,- 

./0'& (1  2222  & */ % 0*1 

3   

  -   -(  

   /-( /      #-    3-'$ -4 44 -(  /   " "!

#""

 -(      & 3-'        53-'6$

# #

 3 

    '4        /      #  /    

4 4  4  3-'0'.   4'   3-'4 ' '   

    3 /     4   (4   0'& (

3 

    '4      ₹!"""""8'     ./47!(/   '  /'"! # #"")  0 / 4    .// 4 *  4 ' (-44  . "!1 #9#  -' 9 ""

   ':/  -   ( 3/-4 -(  ./      / -4  

 '  4'   -' 9 7"

 / ( *4(  '   * '-44  . 9; "<=/ 8 4   /  -  3/4  4 / -'  

4 >'    (/  -   '' 4'?'  4      ./  3    @  / '   "9 # #"") 0. <7 "!

# #"")/4      '    <

0 /   

     

7 /4₹!"""8   (4(    ₹!"""""84/   !

/4' -(3-'   

        



    



     

 

 

     

  !"## $ %      &  &    

&&  &     !"## ' 

    

 



     

 

     &   

 !"#'   (

 3  3-'   4    

4'-(   0'. #  '  

  /0'. 7/

'  0'& ( 33-'    

4         /  4 

            4(  - (  (  / @'

 /   /    0'& (  ( / '   

        /    3 3-' /       ₹<)!<""84/       = !A '  

4      =

1'  

 /   . #$ /'  0'& (4 

4  3-'/ 4  ' 44 

<

       .  / 4  

4   

/44'

$ 3       4 / '  'B' 

$ 3   (/-4  

' /'

-(  

$ 3    /  ( ' (     (   4   (  ( /    ' 4    "!

# #"") )

 /0  (     -   0'& (/ 

 /  

4 3@'- / '           (/'

-(   (  4 

 /' -(    ' 44  -' (44      ( '     ' 4  44         - ;

0      

4   

  / -@  44 /      3'44 4(44      '4  3       (/(4   -(    4 44 -' (444   "

( '     ' '

 -4 - 4' -   (

!  (/  ' / 4  0  (       "!

# #"")    -( -44      '   '-/  /'   C #$4'-'      '       

 / 3      (/   ' / ( '

C#$  (    

4 '/     / ' (4  ' 

44(/  ' - 3 ' -'  7"

        >- /  ' 4   ( '

 /     ' ( 44( 0     - '    / B'  - ( -4           (  / /  / '    8 4        .  /  -( 

 / /   '/   D  /    ( -

 ' ( - 

 '       ' 44   -  -'    (               

 /  ' /@-(

 /  / '  C#(/    (     (  /(4'     4 -(     '   /  

4/        -'

    '' 4-(C#

9 - @   

4 

0/  -  4'-(  '  

 / 0'& ('

  4  C# (/    /  ('  3' 

' -'  0 '   -   / 44     -'    '    #

4(  4  3-'0'.  '

 (  (-('

 7



 / 4 4 1 3-'  

4/ 4          ' ( -  (/     ('      / 

4 0 4'  /-4     (     / B'    -   ?'4     "2 "!34"  56"7 * % +!% '52!8 '34 ) 4!% . 7=; #""9#7 "7 #""9-(>-  '  4'    B'/    0 4'   

 -(   99 7$

$   %   /B'/ ('   <

 '

      

        

 ) 4!%

'

$ -(   '  

= 

   /(    '     ?'4       6->,      B'        ( !

  (   ' (     99    %   (  /       ( /        4 -( &   '  ( 9

 99    % (  '   

  ('           ' /    ( - @     

 99 ''       

   

  !"  

   )*+,  &

     &      

     



 -

   

 

 - -

 -        





    

     &     

    -   . / 0 -

-      -  

  &     



  

&







  

 1  #

      &  23 

- 

   & -

 

& 2   

       1  #

          &  & -2 3  - 

   & -

 

& 2  

         -

   1  #

       &  23 

)  - 

     & -  

 

  & 2  

    

 

      

    - & *$+ /         &  & -   

2    

  - 

  &       -  &2 3     

    & -       #

    &  - 

   

& - &&  

  

  -&  1 *'+/      *+   -) * +  -   

    -  4   5 &  . 5 & 

 5 &   

    - &&

  6 *+ - 

  -    --   



        -

  -   

2  

   - 6 * + - 

 -

2     & 6 * + - 

 -  - 



& 

& -

 6 *+ - 

 

 

  

 &

 & 

  

    -6 *+ - 

  -

 & -   -. 5 & 

  6 *+  -   

   -     &    

&

  

  &     2 -    







   

   4  5 &  & -2- 

  

"

5 72

-

 

;  6 * + - 

2

 



 8  '2

  &6 *3+3   

   4  5 & & -2 - 

  

  "

 5 72 

-2  -  

   

 . 

 

   2   

 . 

 -. 2 

-

 -   6 *+  -   

 

     &  -   

   '  

&- -      

6 *&+  -   

 

2 

   2  9   -     & -2        2  

 &  9  

   -2 



. 2     

    

  6 * + - 

    4  . 5 & & -2- 2

-6 *+  -   

 

  3        2    -    & 

 

 

          -  2  &     

  & 2  &

    

  6 *+ - 

  

&- -    *+.3       *'+2    *+  . 5 & -& 

   

  2 - -&

   - & 

 8 

   =

0 /  4  # $  

  

%  &'#"< 7;$& &$!#  4,

"  &' '( >,?'4    -   

   

*. + '   >,/      (  (4/     ( 3&'  46 ( "98

'

$''  :

 / 

  &    

; &; < * +  

  

,   %  4= 4  >   && *$

*+4*4  +'

2.& 4   -  



  

&   

  & %     

   

&

- /?

   >   3 

    -

  & -    

 

  & -      &   

   / 

2  &   2      &          &   

 -   /   2 

,   %  4& -.   .

$

*$+4*4  +2 &    

 



  &     

    -  -   -/

   

    -   

          



    

  =         &- 

 & 

 

    3 &   &        

  &     -  

/?

   >    

 -  3 & %2  2  - 2   

& 

/3 & 2 

2    

     -

 

      &



  

     /?

   >   & 

 -8   3 & 4 >   && "

 

2

   

  

4 >    && < 9 - -( )

3  ( -( 4  '

      -44'     B'/'   ' (    B'   (4     @      ( @  '   99   % &B' ('52!8 '34 ! '

$     

  ;

0  

          / B'/  99  % / ( '  / 

  - - -(   99 7$

$    %    

4 4 . / 

   /  -@        .    / '

        '    /  ( 0- (   99 7$

$  

 % ;))     99 7$

$   (/ 4 (     4   

- (/- /( #"

0    

     / /44₹!"""8   4( (  '4        / -(  

# 3-'  3    -    4'      /  (    / ' '   / 0  '      3-'

 '  @'  /  @            /  (7;( 4      1'  

  4 / '  '     ( ' @     '    #

  4   '-      '   '       '     ##

E@   -       / /4    / 4   !"""8    .'  B'  ?'  (4   //4/    C 7  4 ' ' 8  - ' (   - '    /    (  ( - /4    . ' ( -( -(C7/4  -  3'-   - / ' '-  '   -!"""8 0  '   

 1 3-'  '/4         

7  - '  0 4('

 #7

 /-' 7;( 4     /-"< # ;9; E@ 7@       '   5!6/'-

-  5<6   //-(6- '

&' 5    



()      *++,%&-*- 33-' (  / ' '   

    /7;( 4  <"A/'-

-  //-(6- '

 &'   

 

#  

' *+-. %/& 00 %& -++,  3 '    87 /

@  /4( 4/  '-   / ' ' '4  - 8<  0    & 8

 -        """"8 / '@  """"8    #!"""8    8

  / '    ' #<

4(  /     /   F

    ' 0   <#""8   

'/4$  <#""8   ' '@  <"A

 <#""8G9)"8$  !))"8 >'  8< 

 !))"F <="8$  <<"8

'   !

1  (  <<"@!@#  =;7)""8 '@   """"8  """"8

<

-(3-'$ 1 E    """"8

-(3-'$  """"8

'  '   .   !"""8

-(3-'$  #!"""8    '   . # <  #!"""8@7  =!"""8 &   / -(3-'  <)!<""8 &   / 

  ;7)""8 E      ;7)""

/  

$    <)!<""8

/-(3-'$  <#)<""8 ;



  -          = !A ''     4 

   :  

     - (  (   -(  - / #"

# 

 /   4 4  3-' 44 - (   '  (     

 / ' 

   '     

  13-' '' (   '     /  ##  4(  

  -(  

   /- / 

  -( /    "7  #"#!  0& *1 ?

 C  48 H C   - H8.