High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18865/2018dismissed

Balwant Singh v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam And ORS

2019-08-01Mr. Justice Amit Rawal14 pages

$ %&'&(# )"# * +,+ $ '- .$/ 0 $ $ +1(- +2+ +30+ '+4+ 5-( $ .$/ 6% 786 $6 8

4 +,+) ! " #$ #% &#$%

) * * ' ( ' ' *' ' ( (

' + , - $.

&#$/'

' ( (

0 " *

' ( ' ( ( 1

' *'

+9(!-9+( 0 ( $/%2

3 4 ( 3 (+ !

( $//5 &##6 373

373 ( 8 4 ( 3 (+ , )4 ( + 9

: ;

<= - $# #% &##/ #5 $& &#$2 3 "

3 ( 052( '( " - &5 $$ &#$>

9 3*(-

( ''( ? $5 #$ &#$.;7?

5= '(" ??

! ' ( ?

( 3*(-

#& #6 &#$.

!3*(-

'*( &/ $& &#$. ;7 ?.=

#> #$ &#$%;7?

>= ! ;7?>= '(

'( ( "@?$$2#?&#$% 4 $/ #$ &#$%;7?%= '(

' ;7?

>= ! ( ( && #$ &#$%;7 ?/=

( ;7?$#=*( 9 #$ #5 &#$%;7?$2= 2>

( '

37-

( (

( 7 !

, ' A

)

373 ' !

;7?

$2= '( '( ( "@?>$26?&#$% ! " #6 #2 &#$%;7?$.= '( '

;7?

$2='( '

' ( 5 '( ";7?$.= :?>2>?&#$% ' &5 #6 &#$%;7?$%=

' ( &2 #6 &#$%;7?

$/= ;7?$2=

4 #2 #> &#$% ;7 ?&#=

1 ( $# #.

&#$%;7?&5= '

(+4 !(: 5 ( ('

' (

( , )4 ( + 9

3 (;

&##>;

<&##>

'( ( &% #6 $//$ ;7 ?$=

)

" 3 ' "

;= :

' ( '

7<,<

' 3 ( + 3 ;3 =

$/>6;

<$/>6

<= 1

" 3

( + + ,

;= 3 $/>6

( " 3 +

(

( " 3 '

0 (

( ( ' ;= &##>

' (

&;= &##>

' (

(

' (

7 $/>6

> &##>

(

! '

&##>

(

& 5

7<,< '

&;= &##>

( (

(

2 !

7 $/>6

> 0

#5 $& &#$2;7 ?$= '( 3 " 3 '

37?

'(+ ,

$/>6

( '

'&4 (!6$+3$ '-+&+ = 5/

+ (

, 2>'?

;7= ;7= )

'(+ ,

, #> #6 &#$6;7?$>= '

&$ $/>6

4 ( 3 (+ 3 (;

$/%# ! ?&

7<,< ' $/>6

' 3 (+ 7

./ 3 (;

(=$/2%

<4 ( 3 ( + 3 ( ;

$/%#< ;

<$/%#

$/%#

( (

(

+ (

(

( ' ( !

&##>

(

&;=

( (

( &#$% &##>

(

5 '( ! A(

&$;$=

7<,< $/>6

! ?

$ 8) 8

8 .

/ << << << << <<

% << << << << <<

55-+- +&!: +(,-9-4+2= !95) - +&-2 4:,5 4:( (&9- : +(+ 5-+::++&-2(-+=+((:9!5 :: 5<77> ;

?@77 .

!5 '&+ @"

/ 6 8$ << << << << << << << << << << 6 8$ << << << << << << << << << << %@ - :&:( ! !9 ' 4 : +( .

! 9././+=/ -9+'(!

!, '!!9()-:& (-4 +&-2, =--+4+ + 5+::++&-2,= -!&+5%@

$&: 5 ' ' "

<9& ' (((+ <9& ' (((+ ' -+4+

&+5 2-9- 9+ !!9 9(: 5 ' - += + 1C(+&( =& - -+

+5!:+4 %@" -:&:(! !9 '4 : +(

-! ' + 5D&+(+&()-:& (- '

/ + 5+::++&-2,=-!&+5 %@A - :&:( ! !9 ' 4+3 : +( .

! 9 . < +=/ - 9+'( ! $9 ! -( '&+ () - :& (- '

+&-2,=!&+5> 0

) '+ '

' (

$/>6&##> $/%#0 ' '(&##>

' ( ;= @ $/>6

#$ #/ $/>6( ?

; <9(!-:,(9 !5=29+&(.9/!

$9 E*!-992.$&::2/9) *B )- & 3+= $+992+5(:+(54+1-!, '

'&+ (' '- 9&4 + 59 5 (!

(9!:( ( +:: 5- & 3+=$+92 +5$9! ' (.99+/> ! (

7<,< $/>6

(

+ !

&$ 7$/%#

$/%#

(

5;=

$# ?

;

& (- '&-2>4+ (-+&-294: 4:( : +( & 5 '&+ ( ' '

+:: 4 ( + 5 - 9 5 ( ! (9 ! - 4:2(!-+5+ 5,- (&9-94: +&-2(59+5& 5-(9'&+ (!- 4:2)-:: '&-2,=- & (- '

&-2> ;= ! "

(

(' '(+

+ ! '

$/%#

' ' '

&##>

(

&;= ?

;

& (- '&-2>4+ (-+&-2 !5& 5 -$9 '&+ () !9) +'+44:2) + 2!-: +((:9!5 '&+ @B> ;= 0

( "

$/6> , ) 4 ( + 9

:" ??

, '

" ??

(

;= 5/ '

(

( ?

;9(4+2+:: 944( A* $&=39-(9 (9 + 5 $9 "*"

!-9)-+54+25'++ 2!(:,( -6+ +' '9!-4:+ 2 944(!-+59 (( '!(&9-64= 64=( 4 9( + 5 + 44=64=(!-4:+ 2+(- 1( !) + 5 4+2 !4 4 4 1 + 5(9-+' + 2 (&9- :( 44 ! - +5-,-2 :++ 5 -+( :( ( :&:(() =& 2 (&9- :( 44 ! - +5 ( !45 (-+ - <9(!-:,((5'+59 !4+ '&+ (-+4+2!444=4:(5 =2-+5> 2>

( '

37-

( (

( 7 "

;7= ;7= 2>

(

;

,(!6+ +' '9 B -6+ +' '9!-4:+ 2(-+=-

9:+<9& !!9+ 5-4:2(!

- 4:+ 2 (-+ <9( - :,( + :!4-5&(& 5-((&: 5 9+ 9 (-+<9(-(:,(+ 5:!4 -(5&(+(& 5%@

$& << << << << << << << << << << .</4+1+:: 4 !-(+!!+&-F5=2 -+5!9($+!!$9 &( .</(&:(+ 59 (+!!!- (&

$&=5 + -4 + 5 4+ + - 9 !5 + !( + 5 4:( : +( +( : $+!!$9 &( << << << << << << << << << <<> ;= !

$# #.

&#$% ! (&##>

' ' ( $/>6

( 0

, #> #6 &#$6;7?$>= ''( (

#% #5 &#$%;7?&$=

, ' (

) " 3 " 0

( + , &

( 0 ' 7 ' ?& ?

;G$ 80 6 # -6+9-)"#

B*C$C54 @# <9( ! :,(

$5 9 !5 & 5 $9 H .A/ ./ ! +2+ + 992 !4(9H **E)+5,--992 9H"##A)9B"!-9(!((9+ !

0+ 5+- += ':,( -(=-+!)+5 ,-9B!-9(!((9+ !0) - +1(- +2+ + 3 0+ '+4.0/( :+(5+&-(-:& (- '+&-(I+::+ +&-(4 5 += !4 : +(

(:9 ! +((@C 9+((@ +F5 !!9( + 5 - :& (- '+&-(I::++&-(4 5 += " ! 4+3 : +( (:9 ! +((@ C9+((@ +F5 !!9() !5 5 -( !!9 !9+ BEC$C54 @# 5+5# #A"#

)( ' =,%@ <<<<<<<<<<<< <<<<<<<<<<<< +=@"

,( !9 6+3 & (-4 I ::+ &-2+F5 !!9(

./ ./-! ' 6+ +' '

9 -+4+

( <<<<<<<<<<<< <<<<<<<<<<<< 4( ! ! 9 B ! - 9( ! ((9+ !0)-6+ +' '9!

$2 -94:+ 2-+(-:,(4:(: +(+( :$+!!$9 &( " 9+( :& (- ' +&-2 -+:: ( = -+4+ @9&4@6+ +' ' 9) - +::+ +&-2,=-+5!9(!0 <<<<<<<<<<<< <<<<<<<<<<<<> ?&

(

'" ??

( '+ , 0 ( (

( (

( '( "

( '

(' '(

( 0 ' ' '( (

#$&#$/ ;

@ ) A B @ '