High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20594/2017dismissed

Satbir And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli12 pages

! "#$#%& ' ( )#* %!+ *$ , ##% *$ - *$.$ ( */ % %!+ *$ , $0%! %$

* $ %&1 2*-#3* 4(#%5+6!7"

6 *+ 0 ##% *$ 2*%3.*2# 86!!8!7"

% * 86 */ % 9#+ 2*( .* )+2 56$$#$ %!7"

% * 86 */ % 2*4 *-#7 355 *9 86!7"

6 2*(+#7 * $+ *6!7"

6 *+ * $0%! %1 :+

* $ #!0* $ %" #$) #%5* "*! !+*.5+7#! "% * %"#%5$#%" + 0*" !#%5$

* ) #%5"%!." !#%7#*.

8.*;

+ "%*7 *$/ #%787 ! #% + 4 + %! * 787 $ *.%! +

008#"

)#8#/ ( "#% #5+ #*40 %$ %!* %$0 * %"/ #%< %!"=.#$##%6 + )#8# %! $ 8 4 %"6 '%+

"$ + "

$ 9+ * #%+ *!.%! *$ "#% + < %!"=.#$##%" >

9 %%.%" ! % # 4* + % #7 / *$ 0*#* + "44 %" 4 % + " ' % $ "% %! ! )/ + 0 ##% *$6+ 0$$ $$#% + 8 %!#%=. $#%+ $%) % 3 %)/+ ( +.5++ "40 %$ #%+ $) %* " #7 !)/+ 0 ##% *$6+ / * * !/! 0$##) "3+ * * 6+ 8 0$#%5 "=.#$##%0*" !#%5$+

) %$.5+%+ 5*.%! #% "#%%+ 0 * + ( #% 3#%50+/$#"

8 0$$ $$#% + 8 %!#%=. $#% + "%*7 *$/ "*00 ! .0 *.%! #% *0* #% ( "#% :; " '9 $0. * $)/+ %$#.#% %"+ + %?)8 (.0* 4 .* %!# #%+ "

+ * )/8 /#%5!9%0*#%"#08 $ *! "8 *#%5+

"=.#$##%! 4 !+ 7 ) %8 0$ !.%! *$ "#% " ' + 0 @.*+ $!#$".$$ !#%!

#8 88+ $0 "$% " $$ */ %!* 8 7 %

* #% *0* #%5 $ "#% :; " '6 +9 7 *6 * + 0.*0$ ! "#!#%5+ 4 + %!6+ * * %" + "%"8.!#%50 * 5* 0+$ A.!54 %9.8!) $.

#" * * 0*!." !+ * #%) 89&1 B, !"

# $#$" %

! "

" ! "

! &' !

)

! & " % ) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

" "

# $#)$! "

! & "

! ) & , % -. "

#$ ) %

)-. -. , ! "/ "( "

#$ ! "

! & 0

"% "

! !! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0"

) %'" ) 0'"

) ' ! "

) ' ) 0

, * 1 1 ! "

#$ ! "

! & "

! "

" ,"/"!2

#$" ) % "

3 ! (

)!"# %$ ! !" !

"/ "

! "

) "

"""% ! "

! &" ) ( "

& ! 4"/ "

)! !

' "

& ! "

" ) ( 52 !"

# " $

! "/ "("!2 % "

3 ! ( ! ! '"

! & ) 6 %6 ! !" ! "/ "

! "

7 "

)

& # $! "

' "

#$ 2 2 !"

" ,) ( "

) ( "

& # $ 4 % % ! ""

% ( !" ! ( "

' " "

"/ "( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! & ) ! "

#$ ! "

# $#)$

8 , ! 0( "

#$)%(! / 9 :"%) 0( "

! "

( "

#$ ! "

! &' " ) 0 "

#$ + , ! "

#$ ( ! ! "(

") " ! "

! ! )! "

! &" !"' "(!

"/ ( % ""

, !) "! )" )*"

#$! "

! & ( % " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( !!" ! "

! &''

2) "

% % / ( ! ! 0(

"( ! ! "

!" "/ ; ' + @0$##% 4 ! )/ + 0 @ .* "

% ) $.44 *#C ! #% +

889#%5 4 %% * * 4* "8 *#/ % + 0*#%"#08 $ 8 #! !9% )/ + %$#.#% %"+&1 :

;

% 88+$ "

$ $9+ * #%+ "=.#$##%0*" $$+ !) %#%## ! ).+ *!+ $%) % %%.%" !.%! *$ "#% + "

6 % + !

"44 %" 4 % + " ' # 6 + * #$ % 8 0$ 0*" !#%5$ %! + $ 4 9#88 "%#%. 6+9 7 *69#++ *#! *+ + "40 %$ #%+ $) ! *4#% ! .%! * + 0*7#$#%$ " ' 88 +$ "

$ $ 9+ * #%+ *!.%! *$ "#% + " >

+ $) %

%%.%" ! 0*#* "44 %" 4 % + " '6 + 0*7#$#%$ + " '9.8!+ 7 %) *#%5* 008#"

%!+ 0*" !#%5$9#88"%#%. #%* $0 " +$ "

$ $6 $# 6 + " >

+ $%) %* 0 8 ! :);

+ 9*!D*?.$ !#%) 9 %+ )++ "%#%5 %"# $ $ "#% + " '#$) * ! $-.* $-.9+#"+ %$+ $ 38 0$#%5 "=.#$##%0*" !#%5$)++ "%#%5 %"# $ 4.$ ) .8 #88 ! 2 %#%5 + * )/6 + # + 0$$ $$#%+ !) % 3 %).+ "40 %$ #%9 $%* " #7 !6 + * 9.8! ) % 8 0$ (#4#8 *8/6 # "40 %$ #% + $ ) %

"" 0 !).+ 0$$ $$#%+ $%) % 3 %6+ * 9.8!) % 0$#%5#!"

&&#$! 3( :";

$ + $0 " "40 %$ * + 8 "=.#* ! #$ "%" *% !6 + %?)8 (.0* 4 .* %!# + $ "

5*#"

88/ )$ *7 !+ + @0* $$#%0 #!#%+ 4 #%0 * $ "#% :; + " '! $%#%"8.! ! 0$# "40 %$ #%#% ".* + #$ * =.#* ! ) 0*7 ! #$ + + "40 %$

4.%9 $ %! * !9+#"++ $) % @08 #% !#% &+ %! *#%5 + 4.% 9.8! 4 % + + 4.% #$ 4 !

#8 )8 + 8 %!9% * %! + 9.8! ) !#$"+ *5 +

)8#5 #% 4 3 + 0 /4 % %! #% + 7 % $."+ 0 *$% "

%%) 0 % 8#C ! *+ !

.8#%4 3#%5+ 0 /4 %+#8 * **#%5 $ "#% ':;6 ':;6 '

+ " >

"40 *#%5+ 49#++ 0 * 4 *# 0*7#$#%$# $ "#% > + " '6+ %?)8 0 @.*+ $"8 *# # !+ %8/"%$ =. %" %%10 /4 % "40 %$ #%#$4 3 + /4 % #% * $ $0 *$ "#%'

+ " >

7 %+ %?)8 (.0* 4 .*+ .*+ *"8 *# # !+ %" + 0 /4 % "40 %$ #%+ $) %

* !E %! * !.%! *$ "#%':;6+

"=.#*#%5 .+*#/ "

%% ) 0 % 8#C ! * %%10 /4 % $ +

4.% + $ * 4 #% .%0 #! !. * .$ 8 "" 0 )/ + %!9% * "8 *# / # .*+ *6 + %?)8 (.0* 4 .* +

.*+ * )$ *7 ! + # 8 %!9% * + #8 ! + * * %" * +#5+ * "40 %$ #% + "

%% "8 #4 + + 9 $ % 0 #! +

4.% :!;

+#8 * !#%5+ 0*7#$$ "#%) 0 * $ "#% " '6+ %?)8 (.0* 4 .*+ $"8 *# # !+ #%"

$ 6 +

*0 /4 %+ $) %4 ! ).%! 0$# !68# )#8#/ / 4.% 8%5 9#+ #% * $ $.)$#$ %! # % ! 0$# ! * A*#/ +8!#%5$ * #7 / *$*4* 6"40 %$ #%.%! *+ " ' + $ ) 0 #! + 8 %!9% *$ $ % + !

%# #"

*8 "=.#$##%.%! *$ "#% + " >

5 *!#%5 + ! 0$#6 # + $ ) % "8 *# # ! #% + A.!54 % + * + +#5+ * "40 %$ #% 8896 + 4% / $+.8!%+ 7 ) %! 0$# !9#++ < %!"=.#$##%88 "*

*#%+ * $.*/*#%+ .*9#+* $0 "4 A*#/ 8 +8!#%5$64 %#%5+ * )/# #9 $! 0$# !#% %/ + +* 4! $ 9#+ * $0 " 4 A*#/ +8!#%5$6 + +#5+ * "40 %$ #%9#88% 8896).#% * $.%! *$ "#%'

" >

9.8!) + "%$ =. %" : ;

$ * 5 *!$ + 4! 3#%5 0$$ $$#%6 + %?)8 (.0* 4 .* + ! "8 *# # ! + !* 9#%5 #%=. $ * 0*E 4 4* %!.4 9.8!4 %+ 0+/$#"

80$$ $$#%+ $) % 3 %+ 8 99#+ * 5 *!7 $#%5 8 %!+ $%" #%) * # * !+8!+ %" + 0$$ $$#%+ $) % 3 %.%! *$ "#%F + " >

6+ 8 %!7 $#%+ ( %!+ * "

%%) %/!#7 $#%5* 0$#%5 :

;

+#8 "40.#%5+ 5 00 *#! #7 / *$) 9 %+ !

*! %! "44 %" 4 % + " '6 %/ #% *#4 *! * $.)$#$#%5#$) @"8.! !9+#"+4 %$+

* @"8.!#%5+ #% *#4*! *6+ 0* 1* =.#$# 5 00 *#! / *$#$%+ * 6 + 0*7#$#%$ $ "#% :;"

%%) #%73 ! :5;

+ %?)8 .* + .*+ * "8 *# # ! + # + "=.#$##% %! + ! *8# * ) % "+ 88 %5 ! %! + "=.#$##% 9 $ .0+ 8!6 9+#"+ 4 %$ + 0*" !#%5 $! "%"8.! !6 + .4)* 88 0* "#% $ "#% + " '"

%%) #%73 $# ! $%* 7#7 $ 8 %!#4 ) ** !"8 #4$ :+;

%0 * ''6+ %?)8 .*+ $4 ! #"8 *+ + 0*7#$#% $ "#% + " '#$4 %) #%73 !)/+ ) % #"# *# $# 8 %!9% *$9+9 * * "*! !$ + #4

#$$.

%" %# #"

#% .%! * $ "#% + " >

%/ $.)$ =. %0.*"+ $ *6+8! **+ *9#$ 6"

%%#%73 + 0*7#$#%$ $ "#% + " '

$ 0 * + "

$ 0. *+ )/ + 0 ##% *$6 + / * 9% *$ #% 0$$ $$#% + 8 %!"40*#$ !#%G+ $* % 6'6'6'>6'

$#.

! #% -#88 5 C#* ) !6 +$#8 #$*#" .*5 % + 0 ##% *$ 7 $ !+ 4$ 87 $8 %!) 9% *+ @ % H$+ * + $ #!8 "=.#* !)/+ ( */ % 7#! %# #"

#%$!

! F ' F #$$. !.%! *$ "#% %!$ "#%F + < %!"=.#$##%"6 >

6 889 ! )/ *! !

! * + 0.)8#" 0.*0$ % 4 8/6 ! 7 804 % %! .#8#C #% 8 * $#! %# 86 44 *"# 8 %$#.#% 8( "* .*.5* 4#$+ "

$ + 0 ##% *$+ ! $0# 7#%5 "=.#* !+ 8 %!#%=. $#%6+ ( +

#8 ! 3 0$$ $$#% + 8 %!#88!

+ 0 ##% *$ * #% ".

80+/$#"

80$$ $$#% + 8 #% =. $#% .*+ * # + $ ) % "% %! ! + 7 % + 4.% "40 %$ #%+ $% #+ *) %0 #!%*+ $) %! 0$# !9#++ * %" .* +.$6 0* / * + $ ) % 4 ! ! "8 * + "=.#$##% 0*" !#%5$ 7#%5) %8 0$ !.%! *$ "#% " '

* "%* 6 2* %3.* 2# 86 8 *% ! !!##% 8 !7"

% * 8

*#%5 *+ ( */ % $.)4#$+ + "% %#% + 0 ##% *$ ) #%5#%+ 0$$ $$#% + 8 %!#%=. $#%#$9#+. %/4 *# $+ 0$$ $$#% + 8 %!9 3 % + #4 %%.%" 4 % *!#$ 8 )/ * "*!#%5 C% 4"+ %

! %! $ 4 9 %! !7 *+ ) % #"# */! 0 *4 %# (-.*+ *6+ "% %!$+ + "40 %$ * 8 %! #% =. $#% 9 $ !.8/ %! * ! # 6 9 $ 4 !

#8 )8 + 0 ##% *$ $ 9 88 $ + * 8 %! 9% *$ +9 7 *6 # #$ + 0 ##% *$ 9+ + 7 "+$ % % * " #7 + $ 4 %! $.)4#$ + +

4.% "40 %$ *+ 8 %!#%=. $#%+ 8* !/) %! 0$# ! 9#+ * %" .*7#! "+ =. %> >F!

! F6+ * * 6+ $.)4#$$#% + 0 ##% *$+ % #+ *"40 %$ #%+ $) %0 #!%*#+ ) % ! 0$# ! #% + .* #$ 8# )8 ) * A " ! / * **#%5 + 0*#%"#08 $8 #!!9%#%%!* 7 804 %.+*#/?$"

$ :(.0* ;6+ + 0* / ! * !#$4#$$ 8 + #%$ % 0 ##% $ %% + "%#%5 %"# $ 0* $"*#) !#%( "#% :; + " '+ 7 ) % .8 #88 ! F * + 7#%5 0 *.$ ! + 08 !#%5$ )+ + "% $#%5 0 *# $ * "*!#%5+ #*"% %#%$69 + 7 %+ $# #%"%"8.! + + 4 %!#$$=.

* 8/"7 * !)/+ 0*#%"#08 $8 #!!9%)/+ %?)8 (.0* 4 .* %!# #% + "

$ %!* 7 804 % .+*#/ :$.0* ; %!+ 0* / * + 0 ##% *"8 #4#%58 0$#%5 "=.#$##%0*" !#%5$! $ *7 $ !#$4#$$ 8#%7# 9 889#%5* $%$&1

; +.5+ + 0 ##% *$ + 7 "% %! ! + ".

8 0+/$#"

8 0$$ $$#% + 8 %!#%=. $#%#$$#889#++ 4+9 7 *6+ $ #! 7 *4 % #$ % % )8 #% 7# 9 + #% *0* #% D0+/$#"

80$$ $$#%?4 ! )/+ %?)8 0 @.*#%%!*

7 804 % .+*#/ :$.0* ; 9+ * #% + %?)8 .* + "

5*#"

88/ + 8! + + 9*! 0$$ $$#% .$ ! #% + " >

+ $ $ 4 4 %#%5 $ + 0+/$#"

8 0$$ $$#% .$ ! #% ( "#% :; " ' + % + ( 7 *%4 %

"=.#* $ + 8 %! !* 9$ 4 4* %!.4 3#%50$$ $$#% 9+#"+#%+ 0* $ %"

$ #$)/* "*!#%5 C% 4"+ %

! 6 + 4.%$ 3#%5 + 0+/$#"

8 0$$ $$#% + 8 %!%" + 0$$ $$#%#$ 3 %6+ * #$

)$8. 7 $#%5 + 8 %! #%+ ( + *

* 7 %# %!9% ** #%$+ 0$$ $$#% + 8 %!6+ #$ * $0 $$ *6

%! $."+ 0$$ $$#% * $0 $$ * %.* $ *+#$ ) % # %!% ) + + 9% *# ( $)$ *7 ! )7 + 0$$ $$#% + 8 %! #% =. $#% $ %!$ 3 % )/ * "*!#%5 C% 4"+ %

! 6+ * * 6 ".

80+/$#"

8 0$$ $$#% + 8 %!#$9#+( %!8 %!#$!.8/7 $ !#%+ ( * *4 88 %".4)* %" $ + 08 + 0 ##% * ) #%5#%0+/$#"

80$$ $$#% + 8 %!#$+.$+ * )/* A " ! #++#$% + "%#%5 %"# $"8 #48 0$#%5 "=.#$##% 0*" !#%5$5 $ ); $

$+ $0 " "40 %$ #%#$"%" *% !6##$#40* % +#5+8#5++ * + + %?)8 0 @".*9+#8 #% *0* #%5 + 9*! D0 #!? "".**#%5 #% ( "#% :; %! + 9*! D! 0$# !?.$ !#%0*7#$( "#% :; '"+ $7 */ "

5*#"

88/)$ *7 !+ 4 %#%5

" )+)/+8!#%5 + 9*! D0 #!? ! $ % #%"8.! ! 0$# %! #% "

$ 6 +

4.%+ $) % %! * !6+ )8#5 #%0 /#$ .8 #88 !+ 9.8! "%$*. 4 % B

I + $ ) % @08 #% ! #% 0 * ' 4 % + + 4.% #$E9 $ 4 !

#8 )8 + 8 %!9% * %!+ 9.8!) !#$"+ *5 )8#5 #% 4 3 + 0 /4 % #$ + $0 "# #" $ %! + * $0%! %( + + "40 %$ 4.%9 $!.8/ %! * !

+ 8 %!9% *$ %! + "40 %$ 4.% * 8 %! #% =. $#%9 $! 0$# !9#++ * %" .*7#! "+ =. % > >F!

! F+.$6#%7# 9 $ 4 "% %#% 0 ##% *$+ % #+ *"40 %$ #%9 $0 #!%*9 $! 0$# ! #%+ * %" .*6#$8# )8 ) * A " !) #%5"%* !#"*/ )+8 9 $9 88

"$ $ 0$$ $$#% + 8 %! $ %!$ !.8/ 3 % %! + "40 %$ #% $ %!$ !.8/ %! * !6 %% + "%#%5 %"# $ 0* $"*#) ! #% $ "#% :; " ' #$ .8 #88 ! $ "%$ =. %" 6+ * + ! 4#%5 #"#% ( "#% " ' "

%% "4 #% 08 / %! +.$6 0* / * #% + 0 ##% $ 3#%58 0$#%5 "=.#$##%0*" !#%5$#$+ * )/* A " ! 2* %3.* 2# 8 % + $* %5+ +

"$ 08 ! ! #% + 9*# % $ 4 % + $7 + 4 %8/ "% %! ! + + ( "=.#* ! + 8 * + 0.)8#"0.*0$ 0.)8#"0.*0$ *.#8#C #% 8 ** $#! %# 86"44 *"# 8

%! #%$#.#% 8 ( "* .*.5* 4 $ 0 * + 08 % 0* 0 * ! .%! * + */ % *) % 7 804 % .+*#/ "6 + 0.)8#" 0.*0$ #$

"+# 7 ! )/ !* 9#%5E 00*7#%5 + 8 / . 08 % $ 0 * + 8 / . 08 % 0* 0 * ! * + "=.#$##% #% =. $#%6 + 8 %! #% =. $#% #$ 7 */ 4."+ $$ %# 8 "+# 7 + 0.)8#"0.*0$ %!#

"$+ 08 %%#%5 4 *8 086 %F4 *8 0860 *36>49#! * !6 4* ! %!$+00#%5" %* + 7 "%$#! * !+#$0 * *5.4 %* #$ )/+ * $0%! %$ %!9 * #%"408 5* 4 %9#++ $ 4 $+#$#$ %#40* %

"*) 3 0#% 4#%! 9+#8 !

8#%5 9#+ + "

$ *#$#%5 . + "=.#$##% 8 %!

"+# 7 + 0.)8#"0.*0$ %!##$+ $ E#$ .+*#/9+#$#%+ ) $

0$##%! "#! )..#8#C #% + 8 "=.#* !6

*#+ 7#%5) % 7 $ !#%( > $ $ =. 8 )7 !#$".$$#% %!#%7# 9 8 9$.44 *#C !#% * 'F' %!* 7 804 % .+*#/?$ "

$ :$.0* ;6 $0 "# #"

88/

7#%5* "*! !+ #%+ "

$ #%+ %!6+ 0+/$#"

80$$ $$#% + 8 %!#% =. $#%+ 7#%5) % 3 %6+ )8#5 *0 /4 % "40 %$ #%$ %!$ !#$"+ *5 ! 8$"%$#! *#%5+ + 8 %!#%=. $#%#$7 */4."+ $$ %# 8 "+# 7 + 0.)8#"0.*0$ 69 + 7 %+ $# #%+8!+ #%+ #%$ % "

$ 6+ $ + .88/!#$"+ *5 !#$)8#5 #%=.

)++ "%#%5 %"# $ "".**#%5 #% $ "#% :; ' " %! # ) #%5 $6 + 0* $ % 0 ##% 4 *#$!#$4#$$ 8 %!+ %" 6+ #%$ %0 ##%#$!#$4#$$ !

7#%5!#$4#$$ !+ 4 #%9*#0 ##%6 880 %!#%5 008#"

#%$6 # %/ 8$4 $+ $ 4

+ 9*#0 ##%#$!#$4#$$ !( .$=.# %/ $ %!$7 "

!!!! % + + *$0 3#%5E* $% !&

( + + * 0* )8 &