Mohinder Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

 











 




 

   


 !"#$% &#'% ($ #%% )#'

 # + ! &$#'

,# -




 
 
 

   '# .

'/%&$*0&12 #


  
 




!"

--"%2 %  ""4#& -' 5#& ' 


$

!"

$%  --"%2 % %"#& '-" 2% '#2'&2''#2 '

" % 

*'#.6 --"%2 %  ""4#& &2''#2'

" % 

*'#.6  7# '#2'& % 

!"

$$

!"

$#-' 5#'% '8* '&#'

& #&



*'#.6 &:

;

*'# .;0 4$#'#!50$#-#%%

#& #'1%2# *'$#'-' 5#'

$ !## 9 &#!5$#-#%% '$% '#%

 #9# #'1%2#&*'%

 -# 25 $#4'%-#%% <'%# "50$# $#2 # 9 &#*% '#$ $#-#%%  --% #&

 !"#

= &4

- #&  '%

6 -#' ""#( %

04$%"#$#-#%%

&*50$#2

*9#&"%8*' & !* #&$#'-"%2#

%2% "

 ># "

'# #&-#'

'9$#&*5

%( #&$%9  $#-#%%

*#& 2$ '(# $##

6 &$#'

#''#(*" '% 8*%'54 2 &*2#& ( %

$%9!5 +%$ $#% 8*%'5'#-'4 -'# '# # %'*-#'% "%2#0 +%$ 04$#1#

*#& $42 *

%2#$#-#%% #',#-"5 %& $42 * # %2#4 *!9%#&!5 $#-#%% ($# 9#!#*

2'50$#%9-*(

" #'1%2#4

(('%#1#&!5 %& '&#'0$#-#%% %"#&&#- '9#  " --# "#-*5

-#2'?# #' "

"%2#0<'&#', (#09'% '04$%2$4 &%

; '&#'

& #&

&:

; '# *!+#29 #'

2$ ""# (#% /# '

#&2*

$ $#%9-*( '&#'

$ 1#!##

1%" % -'% 2%-"# *' "+* %2# *--"%#&2-%# $#&2*9#

'#"%#&*- &*'% 8*%'5/# '

#&2*

*'$#' $ $#-* ( *$'%54$%"# -

('&#'

"$  --"%#&% 9% &04$#'# 0$#29-"% 2# ,*"# ;:= + !"%2#,*"# 9 & '5 .29-"%

%&,*"#9 7# 8*%'5 *"" &1%&/# '

#&2*

#" "

$ $#-* $9#

" #'1%2#% !# 4 '&#&% 2 #

(' 1#   2  '  9% &*2  !*  $% 2  $   !##   7#  %

%&#' % % $# '(*9# "# '

#&2*

#"$ $# --#"" #

: *$'%5$  7# 2

%&#' % $#('* &  --# "

($  $## &0"# '

#& 2*

$ $#-* $9#

" #'1%2#7##-% (% 1%#4$# 2$ '(# ( %

#'% $#$%($#' %&# &-* $9# "#

%&#2*"&$ 1#!##  4 '&#& ># '&  $#  '(*9#

 &1 2#&  !5  "# '

#&  2*

#"  '  $# #'  &  $ 1#  "

  ( #  $'*($  $#  %9-*( #& '&#'

&  $#'

&2*9#

 1 %" !"# $# %"# $# '#( '&% ( --% 9#

 !"#

= &$% - ( &%

#'# -" 2#

2$ '(# $##0  %"% (    '#-"5    $#  2$ '(# $##0  2 &*2% (    '#(*" '

8*%'50*"%9 #"5&%

" #'1%2#0'#+#2%

--# " 4#""!5$# --#"" # *$'%5 '# &% -*#& $#-#%%

*#&2$ '(# $##

6

%&#'% (  '#-"5    $#  2$ '(# $##0  '#(*" '  &#- '9#   % 8*%'5  4

&*2#& ( %

#'!50 +%$ $#% 8*%'5'#-'

-'# '# +%$ 04$%

*#& $42 * # %2#$# #' ,#-"5 $42 * # %2#4 *!9%#&!5$#-#%% % ('#-"5$# $42 * # %2#!#*

2'50$#%9-*( '&#'

" #'1%2#4

(('%#1#&!5 %& '&#'0$#-#%% %"#&&#- '9#  " --# "#-*5

-#2'?# #' "

"%2#0<'&#', (#09'% '04$%2$4 &%

; $#%9-*( #&'&#'

"$ 2$ ""# (#& "5

$#('* &$ $#'#"#1 &2*9#

4#'# *--"%#&  &#8* # --'* %54 ('

#&$#-#%% #'!# '#-

" *2$$#-* $9# $#$%($#' %&#7##-% (%

6 1%#4$# ""#( %

"#1#""#& ( %

$%9 *'% ( '(*9#

0 8*#''54 -*"# '

#&2*

'$# #'# -" % $#&#" 5 #&'&#'

"4

&#1# $# --# "4

;$#-'#

%"#&2$ ""# (#!$$# '# %&'&#'

#' &#" 5

9'#$ /# '

#&2*

!##  !"# (%1#  5 

2'5  #  # 2#-  $#   "5 

 $   $#  4 '# !*-

04$%2$% 22#- !"#  "5$#'&#'4 $#-#%% #'!*$#4

2% #&% 8*%'5-'2##&% 4#""( %

'&#'

"0

--# "4 %"#&!5$#-#%% #' $# '(*9#

' % '#$# -* ( *$'%5 $# --#"" # *$'%54#'# "

$# 9# $  &#8* #--'* %5 $# '% (4 (%1# &2-%# &2*9#

4#'# *--"%#&$%9 2 #('%2 ($ '#2'&#&% %9-*( #&'&#'

"$ $#2-%#  ""$#&2*9#

7#&

'4#'#&#"%1#'#&$#-#%% #'#1# !5$#% 8*%'5

%2#' & &#8* # --'* %54 -'&*2#$% &# 2#!*$# %"#&& 4

$#"&% 8*%'5$ $#-#%% #'4$%"# &*52

*9#&"%8*' & !* #&$% %'

%2#'

$# ""#( %

"#1#""#& ( %

$%94#'#-'1#&

'9$#  #9#

$#4%

%9%" '"5$# --#"" # *$'%5$

"

(%1#   ($ $#-#%%  &#8* #--'* %5 &  $%9 &  $#  #

#2%1#"5  2'

.# #&  $#  4%

  $# (%1# --'* %5"# &$% &# 2#% 4$%2$$#

*!9%#&"% 4%

($ $#4% $#&# #$#4%

9# $# --"%2 %  >#&%& 4 -'&*2# 54%

*99 #&# '"%#'""$#4%

4#'##

  &$#4 (%1# --'* %52'

.# #$#4%

$ !## $#"&$ $#&#- '9#  "% 8*%'54 2 &*2#& '%2"5%

22'& 2#4%$,*"# ;6 + !"%2#,*"# '#1#'0 #'%*

""#( %

9% &*24#'#"#1#""#& ( %

$#4 "5 * &!#%  &'* 7# 2 &%% !* !* #&$# %'

%2#'

4#"">#4 - #'''%

'%27#  '# 04$%2$4 $#9 1% "

&*5!*$#'# #&-#'

'9$# 9# $# 7% %'

%2#' -# '9$% &*50  "5$#9% !#$ 1#&!* !* #&$%9 &9 (#& 2 -#!5'%&%  -'%1 # 2#' & $#'# #'2*"& !# ( 9#&%2 ""5  # #&  $#  %9-*( #&  '&#'    &%

"  4  -

#&  

&$#'# #' --# "4

;$#-'#

%"#& #' &#" 5 9'#$ #%$#'% 1#'9#

 9 &#  %  $#  -#%% '  &*'% (  '(*9#

0 

2'5 2 & #$#&#" 5$#-#%% #'$%9

22#-#&$#'&#'-

#&!5$#-* ( *$'%5 !5$# --#"" # *$'%5 &%4 2$ ""# (#&#1# 4%$% $#'# !"# %9#  $#  %9-*( #&  '&#'

'9  &#" 5  &  " 2$# & 

2'5# 29# '4 '& $ $#"&% 1 '%* +*&(9#

$ $#
*'$  &*5 -'#2$#'%($ $#2%%@#

!* %9*"

#* "5%% 7##-%

"%1#$#-'%9 '5-'% 2%-"#$ 4$#  (('%#1#&-#'

04%$* &#8* #'# 0 --' 2$# $#
*' $% 4 "#% *'#'-"# *'#0$#
*'4*"&!#* &#'"#( "!"%( %  2'*% %@#4$#$#'%%   !#" #&

 (# &% !## #' % #&'  $#-#%%  --' 2$#&$%

*' #' &#" 5 9'#$ &9'#

2'5  $  !##  (%1#   '#1#'0 4$%"# # #'2% (  -4#' * &#'

; '%2"# ;    $# 


%*%     &% 0  $# 
*'  %    ##  $   $# 2'#% 9* !# # #'2% #&+*&%2%* "5 &'# !"5$#-#%%

  !#  ""4#&     7#  * '# !"5  " (  %9#    2$ ""# (#  $# %9-*( %# #'&#" 5 9'#$ $# $%9 1%(%"

 !*$% '%($ 0$#&% 2'#% '5'#"%# * &#''%2"# ; $#


%*%  &% 2

!#('

#&&*!$#-4#'


*'* &#''%2"#;

%*%  &% % 2'#% '5!*%%

!## #'2%  +*&%2%* &'# !"#9

 2 #0$#'#% &#" 5 9'#$

*2$$#2" %9 #'% $-#"#

"5%9#! ''#& $#$ "#-1#'

$#9 #' '5# '

(#$#'# 04$ #1#'0$

$4$#&#" 5 (#$#'2 !#2 & #&%9-"5!5 5% $ $#-#%%  4 '# !*-

$#'&#'

%2%#

2 & #$#&#" 5 $#4

2% #&% 8*%'5 &4

&#8* #--'* %%#  ""$#22

 22'&% ("50$#-'#

9#'% 4#""

&#" 5 &" 2$#  1#9!#' 0  &
  '

-+   $#$#' -# 7% (A'# B#

$#$#''#-' !"# B#