High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25867/2014dismissed

Harvinder Kaur v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2017-12-22Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan7 pages

!"!#$!%&'()*)* * +,!&-!./"/&'(* * * +#$/'%!#0+1# !,/,/&'!# 2!#"1"

3,+,!&- 1'4+5+'%&,6!#"

!"7&'%!',"

#!"!',( #*+#/'%!#36+#8+9%$&.+,!-&#,6!7!,/,/&'!#* #** *3*6+:;+9***9 1'4+5* <<<

!,/,/&'!# #+/"!" + .6+;;!'=! ,& ,6! &#%!#%+,!% )*

* >

7+""!%5@,6!3!.#!,+#@,&3,+,!&- 1'4+59!7+#,8!',&- %1.+,/&' +'% :6!#!5@ .;+/8 &- ,6! 7!,/,/&'!# "!!A/'= #!,#&"7!.,/$! 7#&8&,/&',&,6!7&",&-B!.,1#!#:*!*-*,6!@!+# 96+"5!!'#!4!.,!%* #/!--+.,"8+@5!'&,/.!%*

!,/,/&'!#5!;&'=",&,6!#!"!#$!%.+,!=&#@&-3.6!%1;!%+",! +'% .+8! ,& 5! +77&/',!% +" + 1'4+5/ /",#!"" /' ,6! %1.+,/&'

!7+#,8!',93,+,!&- 1'4+5&'*>* )) *',6!@!+#,6!%1.+,/&'

!7+#,8!', #!C1/"/,/&'!% .+"!" -#&8 !;/=/5;! +",!#"D/",#!""!" -&# .&'"/%!#+,/&'-&#7#&8&,/&'+"B!.,1#!#"/'%/--!#!',"154!.,"* !,/,/&'!# "!',6!#.+"!-&#7#&8&,/&'+"B!.,1#!#/' 1'4+5/,6#&1=67#&7!#.6+''!;

&'*)** 77+#!',;@9,6!.+"!-&#7#&8&,/&'&-,6!7!,/,/&'!#+'% #!"7&'%!', '&* 6!#!/'9 :6& +;"& 5!;&'=" ,& ,6! #!"!#$!% .+,!=&#@ &- 3.6!%1;!%+",!9:+"%1;@.&'"/%!#!%* #&8&,/&'&#%!#%+,!%** :+"

/""1!%/'-+$&1#&-#!"7&'%!','&*+'%+'&#%!#%+,!%* :+"/""1!% /'-+$&1#&-,6!7!,/,/&'!#7#&8&,/'=6!#,&,6!7&",&-B!.,1#!#+=+/'",,6!

#!"!#$!%.+,!=&#@*,6+"5!!'+$!##!%/',6!7!,/,/&',6+,#!"7&'%!','&* 6+%4&/'!%"!#$/.!+"+/",#!""&' *>* )) /*!*"15"!C1!',/'7&/',&- ,/8!,&,6!7!,/,/&'!#+'%+""1.69/',6!.+%#!&-/",#!"""6!:+"41'/&#,& ,6!7!,/,/&'!#* +"!"!,17&'5!6+;-&-,6!7!,/,/&'!#/",6+,+,,6!,/8!&- /""1+'.! &- ,6! 7#&8&,/&' &#%!# ,& ,6! 7&", &- B!.,1#!#9 "6! :+" &' 8+,!#'/,@;!+$!-#&8>** ,&!.!85!#9 +'%/,/"%1#/'="1.6 7!#/&% /,"!;-,6+, ,6!7!,/,/&'!#:+" ,#+'"-!##!% -#&8%/",#/., +,/+;+,& %/",#/.,B1%6/+'+5@$/#,1!&-&#%!#%+,!%** 7+""!%5@,6!/#!.,&#

15;/.'",#1.,/&'" 3* 9 1'4+5+'%!'%&#"!%5@,6!/",#/.,%1.+,/&'

--/.!# 3* 9 +,/+;+&'** *,/""158/,,!%,6+,7!,/,/&'!#"158/,,!% 6!#-&#8+;4&/'/'=+,,6!7;+.!&-7&",/'=/'%/",#/.,B1%6/+'+51,,6!' .&',/'1!%,&+$+/;&-6!#8+,!#'/,@;!+$!*"7!#7!,/,/&'!#,6!&#%!#"&- 7#&8&,/&'%+,!%* :!#!'!$!#.&881'/.+,!%,&6!#+'%+""1.6"6! .&1;% '&, 4&/' ,6! 7#&8&,/&'+; 7&", &- B!.,1#!#* 6!#!+-,!#9 /, /" &' >**,6+,,6!7!,/,/&'!#:+"7#&8&,!%+"B!.,1#!#/' 1'4+5/+'%/'

71#"1+'.!,&:6/.6"6!4&/'!%,6!7#&8&,/&'+;7&",&'*** !,/,/&'!# ",+,!",6+,"6!5!.+8!+:+#!&-,6!7#&8&,/&'&#%!#%+,!%* &';@ &'*>*

+'%:6!#!17&'#!7!+,!%#!7#!"!',+,/&'":!#!"158/,,!%,& =#+',,&6!#,6!5!'!-/,&-,6!7#&8&,/&'+;7&",:*!*-** * !,/,/&'!# ,6!'7#!-!##!% &*&- >"!!A/'=/""1+'.!&-%/#!.,/&'",&,6!

#!"7&'%!',+1,6&#/,/!",&.&'"/%!#6!#.+"!-&#7#&8&,/&'+"B!.,1#!#/'

1'4+5/#!,#&"7!.,/$!;@*31.6:#/,7!,/,/&':+"%/"7&"!%&-5@,6/"&1#,&' ** > :/,6 ,6!%/#!.,/&'" ,& ,6! -/#",#!"7&'%!', ,& .&'"/%!#+'%%!./%!+;!=+;'&,/.!,6+,6+%5!!'"!#$!%5@,6!7!,/,/&'!# :/,6/'+7!#/&%&-,:&8&',6"+'%5@7+""/'=+"7!+A/'=&#%!#*

> ,/"/'71#7&#,!%.&87;/+'.!&-,6!%/#!.,/&'"/""1!%5@,6/" &1#,,6+,,6!/871='!%&#%!#%+,!%)*

* > 6+"5!!'

7+""!%%!.;/'/'=,6!.;+/8&-,6!7!,/,/&'!#-&##!,#&"7!.,/$!7#&8&,/&'&' ,6!=#&1'%,6+,"1.6.;+/8/"5+##!%5@;+.6!"* ,/"+=+/'","1.65#/!-5+.A%#&7,6+,,6!/'",+',7!,/,/&'6+" 5!!'-/;!%"!!A/'=C1+"6/'=&-/871='!%&#%!#%+,!%)*

* > ''!?1#!

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

+'%1'%!#"1.6./#.18",+'.!"/,:+"'&,&7!'-&#,6!-/#", #!"7&'%!',,&6+$!#!4!.,!%,6!.;+/8&-,6!7!,/,/&'!#&',6!=#&1'%&- %!;+@+'%;+.6!"*6!7;!+&-%/".#/8/'+,/&'+'%$/&;+,/&'&-#,/.;!"

+'% &-,6!&'",/,1,/&'&-'%/+6+"+;"&5!!'#+/"!%5@.&',!'%/'=,6+, #!"7&'%!','&*9:6&6+%4&/'!%"!#$/.!/',6!+",!#.+%#!&' *>* ))

:+"41'/&#,&,6!7!,/,/&'!#+'%/'"7/,!,6!#!&-6+"5!!'=#+',!%5!'!-/,&-

7#&8&,/&'-#&8+'!+#;/!#%+,!/*!*** *6!"!'/&#/*!*,6!7!,/,/&'!#9 +""1.69.+''&,5!%!'/!%,6!"+8!5!'!-/,*

!#.&',#+9;!+#'!%3,+,!.&1'"!;6+"41",/-/!%,6!7+""/'=&-,6! /871='!%&#%!#%+,!%)*

* > /',!#8"&-,6!#!+"&'"

+""/='!%,6!#!/'*,/"+#=1!%,6+,,6!7!,/,/&'!#6+"5!!'";!!7/'=&$!#6!# #/=6,"9 /- +'@9 +'% .+''&, 5! 7!#8/,,!% ,& #+/"! + .;+/8 +" #!=+#%" #!,#&"7!.,/$!7#&8&,/&':*!*-,6!@!+# 5@-/;/'=+:#/,7!,/,/&'/',6!

@!+#

* '+7#!$/&1"%+,!&-6!+#/'=+'/""1!+#&"!+",&:6!,6!#/,/" ,6!3,+,!&$,*/,"!;-,&5;+8!+"#!=+#%",6!7!,/,/&'!#6+$/'='&,4&/'!%,6! 7#&8&,/&'+;7&",&-B!.,1#!#/'71#"1+'.!,&,6!7#&8&,/&'&#%!#%+,!% * &#/,:+"+%!;/5!#+,!+.,&-,6!7!,/,/&'!#,&+$&/%,6!'!:7;+.! &-7&",/'=5@+,,!87,/'=,&-&#!=&7#&8&,/&'* ..&#%/'=;@9$/%!&#%!#%+,!%* * 7+""!%5@,6/"&1#,9+ %/#!.,/&':+"/""1!%,&,6!* * 3* 9 1'4+5,&7!#"&'+;;@.&'%1.,+7#&5!

:/,6&1,/'$&;$/'=,6!** " 3* 9B1%6/+'+&# +,/+;+* B/5!#,@:+"

=#+',!%,&* * 3* 9 1'4+5,&6&:!$!#,+A!+""/",+'.!-#&8,6!8-&# 71#7&"!&-#!.&#%&#&-6/"41'/&#"* ;+.!%&'#!.&#%/"+'+%%/,/&'+;

+--/%+$/,%+,!% >*>* +'%+77!'%!%+;&'=:/,6/"+ #&5! !7&#,%+,!% ** &-36*+;5/#3/'=69* * 3** 9 1'4+5* 6! #&5! !7&#,+,''!?1#! 6+"5!!'7!#1"!%* 6!

"+8!:&1;%#!$!+;,6+,",+,!8!',"&-$+#/&1"!87;&@!!":6&6+%5!!' 7#&8&,!%%1#/'=,6!@!+# +'%$/%!,6!"+8!7#&8&,/&'&#%!#%+,!% * 6+%5!!'#!.&#%!%+'%+-,!#&5,+/'/'=#!7&#,"&-,6!** "

3* 9 +,/+;++"+;"&B1%6/+'+9/,6+"5!!'&7/'!%,6+,&#%!#"&-7#&8&,/&' :!#!'&,%/#!.,;@-&#:+#%!%,&,6!!87;&@!!".&'.!#'!%&#,&,6!6!+%"&-

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

,6!7#&8&,/&'#!7&#,( F

6!$/!:,+A!'/',6! #&5! !7&#,+"#!=+#%".;+/8&-,6!

7!,/,/&'!#-&##!,#&"7!.,/$!7#&8&,/&',&5!'&,:!;;-&1'%!%9/"5+"!%&' .&=!',+'%$+;/%#!+"&'/'=*,/"'&,+.+"!:6!#!,6!7!,/,/&'!#/"+;;!=/'= 8+;+-/%!"+=+/'",+'@7+#,/.1;+#&--/./+;&-,6!#!"7&'%!',%!7+#,8!',*6! ",+'%,+A!'&'5!6+;-&-,6!7!,/,/&'!#,6+,"6!:+"'&,+:+#!&-+

7#&8&,/&'&#%!#7+""!%/'6!#-+$&1#/',6!@!+# ,/;;,6!@!+#

%&!"'&,/'"7/#!.&'-/%!'.!7+#,/.1;+#;@/',6!;/=6,&-,6!+%8/,,!%7&"/,/&' &--+.,,6+,"6!6!#"!;-6+%-&#:+#%!%6!#.+"!-&#7#&8&,/&'* $!' &,6!#:/"!9 + 5!;+,!% .;+/8 +" #!=+#%" #!,#&"7!.,/$! 7#&8&,/&':*!*-,6!@!+# /""&1=6,,&5!#+/"!%/',6!/'",+',7!,/,/&' ,6+,:+"-/;!%/',6!@!+#

*6!+"7!.,&-%!;+@/'8+,,!#"&-"!'/&#/,@ +'%7#&8&,/&'6+%5!!'%!+;,:/,65@,6!7!?&1#,/',6!.+"!&-

+'%/, :+"&5"!#$!%+"-&;;&:"( !

" #

% #$ !

& #

' $ # $ $( !

& $

# ) *

# % , # , #

, -

6/;!%!.;/'/'=,&/',!#-!#!/',6!7#!"!',7!,/,/&'9"1--/.!/,,& &5"!#$!,6+,!$!'/-,6/"&1#,/',6!7#!$/&1":#/,7!,/,/&'/*!* >6+%/""1!%%/#!.,/&'"&'** >,&.&'"/%!#+'%,+A!+%!./"/&'17&'

+ ;!=+; '&,/.! ,6+, ,6! 7!,/,/&'!# 6+% =&, "!#$!% 17&' ,6! #!"7&'%!', +1,6&#/,/!"9,6!"+8!.+''&,5!.&'",#1!%,&8!+',6+, ,6/"&1#,6+% .&'%&'!%,6!+"7!.,&-%!;+@*

&#,6!#!+"&'"#!.&#%!%+5&$!9'&8!#/,/"-&1'%/',6!/'",+', 7!,/,/&'+'%,6!"+8!/"9+..&#%/'=;@9%/"8/""!%*

;1.A@ 6!,6!#"7!+A/'=D#!+"&'!%( !"D& 6!,6!# !7&#,+5;!( !"D&